Skip to content
BookLens

Emile

Jean-Jacques Rousseau (1712–1778)

When you explain the Articles of Faith let it be by direct teaching, not by question and answer. Children should only answer what they think, not what has been drilled into them. All the answers in the catechism are the wrong way about; it is the scholar who instructs the teacher; in the child’s mouth they are a downright lie, since they explain what he does not understand, and affirm what he cannot believe. Find me, if you can, an intelligent man who could honestly say his catechism. The first question I find in our catechism is as follows: “Who created you and brought you into the world?” To which the girl, who thinks it was her mother, replies without hesitation, “It was God.” All she knows is that she is asked a question which she only half understands and she gives an answer she does not understand at all. I wish some one who really understands the development of children’s minds would write a catechism for them. It might be the most useful book ever written, and, in my opinion, it would do its author no little honour. This at least is certain—if it were a good book it would be very unlike our catechisms.

Such a catechism will not be satisfactory unless the child can answer the questions of its own accord without having to learn the answers; indeed the child will often ask the questions itself. An example is required to make my meaning plain and I feel how ill equipped I am to furnish such an example. I will try to give some sort of outline of my meaning. To get to the first question in our catechism I suppose we must begin somewhat after the following fashion. NURSE: Do you remember when your mother was a little girl? CHILD: No, nurse. NURSE: Why not, when you have such a good memory? CHILD: I was not alive. NURSE: Then you were not always alive! CHILD: No. NURSE: Will you live for ever! CHILD: Yes. NURSE: Are you young or old? CHILD: I am young. NURSE: Is your grandmamma old or young? CHILD: She is old. NURSE: Was she ever young? CHILD: Yes. NURSE: Why is she not young now? CHILD: She has grown old. NURSE: Will you grow old too? CHILD: I don’t know. NURSE: Where are your last year’s frocks? CHILD: They have been unpicked. NURSE: Why! CHILD: Because they were too small for me. NURSE: Why were they too small? CHILD: I have grown bigger. NURSE: Will you grow any more! CHILD: Oh, yes. NURSE: And what becomes of big girls? CHILD: They grow into women. NURSE: And what becomes of women! CHILD: They are mothers. NURSE: And what becomes of mothers? CHILD: They grow old.

NURSE: Will you grow old? CHILD: When I am a mother. NURSE: And what becomes of old people? CHILD: I don’t know. NURSE: What became of your grandfather? CHILD: He died. [Footnote: The child will say this because she has heard it said; but you must make sure she knows what death is, for the idea is not so simple and within the child’s grasp as people think. In that little poem “Abel” you will find an example of the way to teach them. This charming work breathes a delightful simplicity with which one should feed one’s own mind so as to talk with children.] NURSE: Why did he die? CHILD: Because he was so old. NURSE: What becomes of old people! CHILD: They die. NURSE: And when you are old——? CHILD: Oh nurse! I don’t want to die! NURSE: My dear, no one wants to die, and everybody dies. CHILD: Why, will mamma die too! NURSE: Yes, like everybody else. Women grow old as well as men, and old age ends in death. CHILD: What must I do to grow old very, very slowly? NURSE: Be good while you are little. CHILD: I will always be good, nurse. NURSE: So much the better. But do you suppose you will live for ever? CHILD: When I am very, very old—— NURSE: Well? CHILD: When we are so very old you say we must die? NURSE: You must die some day. CHILD: Oh dear! I suppose I must. NURSE: Who lived before you? CHILD: My father and mother.

NURSE: And before them? CHILD: Their father and mother. NURSE: Who will live after you? CHILD: My children. NURSE: Who will live after them? CHILD: Their children. In this way, by concrete examples, you will find a beginning and end for the human race like everything else—that is to say, a father and mother who never had a father and mother, and children who will never have children of their own. It is only after a long course of similar questions that we are ready for the first question in the catechism; then alone can we put the question and the child may be able to understand it. But what a gap there is between the first and the second question which is concerned with the definitions of the divine nature. When will this chasm be bridged? “God is a spirit.” “And what is a spirit?” Shall I start the child upon this difficult question of metaphysics which grown men find so hard to understand? These are no questions for a little girl to answer; if she asks them, it is as much or more than we can expect. In that case I should tell her quite simply, “You ask me what God is; it is not easy to say; we can neither hear nor see nor handle God; we can only know Him by His works. To learn what He is, you must wait till you know what He has done.”

If our dogmas are all equally true, they are not equally important. It makes little difference to the glory of God that we should perceive it everywhere, but it does make a difference to human society, and to every member of that society, that a man should know and do the duties which are laid upon him by the law of God, his duty to his neighbour and to himself. This is what we should always be teaching one another, and it is this which fathers and mothers are specially bound to teach their little ones. Whether a virgin became the mother of her Creator, whether she gave birth to God, or merely to a man into whom God has entered, whether the Father and the Son are of the same substance or of like substance only, whether the Spirit proceeded from one or both of these who are but one, or from both together, however important these questions may seem, I cannot see that it is any more necessary for the human race to come to a decision with regard to them than to know what day to keep Easter, or whether we should tell our beads, fast, and refuse to eat meat, speak Latin or French in church, adorn the walls with statues, hear or say mass, and have no wife of our own. Let each think as he pleases; I cannot see that it matters to any one but himself; for my own part it is no concern of mine.

Passages expressing a similar idea

  • The possessed: or, The devils · Fyodor Dostoyevsky (1821–1881) · CHAPTER II. PRINCE HARRY. MATCHMAKING.

    “A child who is twenty years old, thank God. Please don’t roll your eyes, I entreat you, you’re not on the stage. You’re very clever and learned, but you know nothing at all about life. You will always want a nurse to look after you. I shall die, and what will become of you? She will be a good nurse to you; she’s a modest girl, strong-willed, reasonable; besides, I shall be here too, I shan’t die directly. She’s fond of home, she’s an angel of gentleness. This happy thought came to me in Switzerland. Do you understand if I tell you myself that she is an angel of gentleness!” she screamed with sudden fury. “Your house is dirty, she will bring in order, cleanliness. Everything will shine like a mirror. Good gracious, do you expect me to go on my knees to you with such a treasure, to enumerate all the advantages, to court you! Why, you ought to be on your knees.… Oh, you shallow, shallow, faint-hearted man!” “But … I’m an old man!”

    Read in context
  • A Sportsman's Sketches Works of Ivan Turgenev, Volume I · Ivan Sergeevich Turgenev (1818–1883) · IV

    Suddenly the old mother comes unexpectedly into the room. I had already the evening before told her—the mother—there was little hope, and it would be well to send for a priest. When the sick girl saw her mother she said: "It's very well you have come; look at us, we love one another—we have given each other our word." "What does she say, doctor? what does she say?" I turned livid. "She is wandering," I say; "the fever." But she: "Hush, hush; you told me something quite different just now, and have taken my ring. Why do you pretend? My mother is good—she will forgive—she will understand—and I am dying…. I have no need to tell lies; give me your hand." I jumped up and ran out of the room. The old lady, of course, guessed how it was. 'I will not, however, weary you any longer, and to me too, of course, it's painful to recall all this. My patient passed away the next day. God rest her soul!' the doctor added, speaking quickly and with a sigh. 'Before her death she asked her family to go out and leave me alone with her.' '"Forgive me," she said; "I am perhaps to blame towards you … my illness … but believe me, I have loved no one more than you … do not forget me … keep my ring."' The doctor turned away; I took his hand.

    Read in context
  • Notes from the Underground · Fyodor Dostoyevsky (1821–1881) · VI

    “A wench would have died in hospital ...” (She knows all about it already: she said “wench,” not “girl.”) “She was in debt to her madam,” I retorted, more and more provoked by the discussion; “and went on earning money for her up to the end, though she was in consumption. Some sledge-drivers standing by were talking about her to some soldiers and telling them so. No doubt they knew her. They were laughing. They were going to meet in a pot-house to drink to her memory.” A great deal of this was my invention. Silence followed, profound silence. She did not stir. “And is it better to die in a hospital?” “Isn’t it just the same? Besides, why should I die?” she added irritably. “If not now, a little later.” “Why a little later?” “Why, indeed? Now you are young, pretty, fresh, you fetch a high price. But after another year of this life you will be very different—you will go off.” “In a year?”

    Read in context
  • White nights, and other stories · Fyodor Dostoyevsky (1821–1881) · Section 11

    "A wench would have died in hospital...." (She knows all about it already: she said "wench," not "girl.") "She was in debt to her madam," I retorted, more and more provoked by the discussion; "and went on earning money for her up to the end, though she was in consumption. Some sledge-drivers standing by were talking about her to some soldiers and telling them so. No doubt they knew her. They were laughing. They were going to meet in a pot-house to drink to her memory." A great deal of this was my invention. Silence followed, profound silence. She did not stir. "And is it better to die in a hospital?" "Isn't it just the same? Besides, why should I die?" she added irritably. "If not now, a little later." "Why a little later?" "Why, indeed? Now you are young, pretty, fresh, you fetch a high price. But after another year of this life you will be very different—you will go off." "In a year?"

    Read in context
  • Sense and Sensibility · Jane Austen (1775–1817) · CHAPTER VIII.

    “Infirmity!” said Elinor, “do you call Colonel Brandon infirm? I can easily suppose that his age may appear much greater to you than to my mother; but you can hardly deceive yourself as to his having the use of his limbs!” “Did not you hear him complain of the rheumatism? and is not that the commonest infirmity of declining life?” “My dearest child,” said her mother, laughing, “at this rate you must be in continual terror of my decay; and it must seem to you a miracle that my life has been extended to the advanced age of forty.” “Mama, you are not doing me justice. I know very well that Colonel Brandon is not old enough to make his friends yet apprehensive of losing him in the course of nature. He may live twenty years longer. But thirty-five has nothing to do with matrimony.” “Perhaps,” said Elinor, “thirty-five and seventeen had better not have any thing to do with matrimony together. But if there should by any chance happen to be a woman who is single at seven and twenty, I should not think Colonel Brandon’s being thirty-five any objection to his marrying her.”

    Read in context
  • Jane Eyre: An Autobiography · Charlotte Brontë (1816–1855) · CHAPTER XXXVII

    “Yes—but you understand one thing by staying with me; and I understand another. You, perhaps, could make up your mind to be about my hand and chair—to wait on me as a kind little nurse (for you have an affectionate heart and a generous spirit, which prompt you to make sacrifices for those you pity), and that ought to suffice for me no doubt. I suppose I should now entertain none but fatherly feelings for you: do you think so? Come—tell me.” “I will think what you like, sir: I am content to be only your nurse, if you think it better.” “But you cannot always be my nurse, Janet: you are young—you must marry one day.” “I don’t care about being married.” “You should care, Janet: if I were what I once was, I would try to make you care—but—a sightless block!” He relapsed again into gloom. I, on the contrary, became more cheerful, and took fresh courage: these last words gave me an insight as to where the difficulty lay; and as it was no difficulty with me, I felt quite relieved from my previous embarrassment. I resumed a livelier vein of conversation.

    Read in context