Women in Love
D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)
“And all sorts of marriage, also snub and otherwise?” he said. “That’s it.” “And you think if I marry, it will be snub?” asked Gerald quizzically, his head a little on one side. Birkin laughed quickly. “How do I know what it will be!” he said. “Don’t lambaste me with my own parallels—” Gerald pondered a while. “But I should like to know your opinion, exactly,” he said. “On your marriage?—or marrying? Why should you want my opinion? I’ve got no opinions. I’m not interested in legal marriage, one way or another. It’s a mere question of convenience.” Still Gerald watched him closely. “More than that, I think,” he said seriously. “However you may be bored by the ethics of marriage, yet really to marry, in one’s own personal case, is something critical, final—” “You mean there is something final in going to the registrar with a woman?” “If you’re coming back with her, I do,” said Gerald. “It is in some way irrevocable.” “Yes, I agree,” said Birkin. “No matter how one regards legal marriage, yet to enter into the married state, in one’s own personal instance, is final—” “I believe it is,” said Birkin, “somewhere.” “The question remains then, should one do it,” said Gerald. Birkin watched him narrowly, with amused eyes. “You are like Lord Bacon, Gerald,” he said. “You argue it like a lawyer—or like Hamlet’s to-be-or-not-to-be. If I were you I would not marry: but ask Gudrun, not me. You’re not marrying me, are you?” Gerald did not heed the latter part of this speech.
“Yes,” he said, “one must consider it coldly. It is something critical. One comes to the point where one must take a step in one direction or another. And marriage is one direction—” “And what is the other?” asked Birkin quickly. Gerald looked up at him with hot, strangely-conscious eyes, that the other man could not understand. “I can’t say,” he replied. “If I knew that—” He moved uneasily on his feet, and did not finish. “You mean if you knew the alternative?” asked Birkin. “And since you don’t know it, marriage is a pis aller.” Gerald looked up at Birkin with the same hot, constrained eyes. “One does have the feeling that marriage is a pis aller,” he admitted. “Then don’t do it,” said Birkin. “I tell you,” he went on, “the same as I’ve said before, marriage in the old sense seems to me repulsive. Égoïsme à deux is nothing to it. It’s a sort of tacit hunting in couples: the world all in couples, each couple in its own little house, watching its own little interests, and stewing in its own little privacy—it’s the most repulsive thing on earth.” “I quite agree,” said Gerald. “There’s something inferior about it. But as I say, what’s the alternative.” “One should avoid this home instinct. It’s not an instinct, it’s a habit of cowardliness. One should never have a home.” “I agree really,” said Gerald. “But there’s no alternative.”
“We’ve got to find one. I do believe in a permanent union between a man and a woman. Chopping about is merely an exhaustive process. But a permanent relation between a man and a woman isn’t the last word—it certainly isn’t.” “Quite,” said Gerald. “In fact,” said Birkin, “because the relation between man and woman is made the supreme and exclusive relationship, that’s where all the tightness and meanness and insufficiency comes in.” “Yes, I believe you,” said Gerald. “You’ve got to take down the love-and-marriage ideal from its pedestal. We want something broader. I believe in the additional perfect relationship between man and man—additional to marriage.” “I can never see how they can be the same,” said Gerald. “Not the same—but equally important, equally creative, equally sacred, if you like.” “I know,” said Gerald, “you believe something like that. Only I can’t feel it, you see.” He put his hand on Birkin’s arm, with a sort of deprecating affection. And he smiled as if triumphantly.
He was ready to be doomed. Marriage was like a doom to him. He was willing to condemn himself in marriage, to become like a convict condemned to the mines of the underworld, living no life in the sun, but having a dreadful subterranean activity. He was willing to accept this. And marriage was the seal of his condemnation. He was willing to be sealed thus in the underworld, like a soul damned but living forever in damnation. But he would not make any pure relationship with any other soul. He could not. Marriage was not the committing of himself into a relationship with Gudrun. It was a committing of himself in acceptance of the established world, he would accept the established order, in which he did not livingly believe, and then he would retreat to the underworld for his life. This he would do. The other way was to accept Rupert’s offer of alliance, to enter into the bond of pure trust and love with the other man, and then subsequently with the woman. If he pledged himself with the man he would later be able to pledge himself with the woman: not merely in legal marriage, but in absolute, mystic marriage. Yet he could not accept the offer. There was a numbness upon him, a numbness either of unborn, absent volition, or of atrophy. Perhaps it was the absence of volition. For he was strangely elated at Rupert’s offer. Yet he was still more glad to reject it, not to be committed.
There was a jumble market every Monday afternoon in the old market-place in town. Ursula and Birkin strayed down there one afternoon. They had been talking of furniture, and they wanted to see if there was any fragment they would like to buy, amid the heaps of rubbish collected on the cobble-stones. The old market-square was not very large, a mere bare patch of granite setts, usually with a few fruit-stalls under a wall. It was in a poor quarter of the town. Meagre houses stood down one side, there was a hosiery factory, a great blank with myriad oblong windows, at the end, a street of little shops with flagstone pavement down the other side, and, for a crowning monument, the public baths, of new red brick, with a clock-tower. The people who moved about seemed stumpy and sordid, the air seemed to smell rather dirty, there was a sense of many mean streets ramifying off into warrens of meanness. Now and again a great chocolate-and-yellow tramcar ground round a difficult bend under the hosiery factory. Ursula was superficially thrilled when she found herself out among the common people, in the jumbled place piled with old bedding, heaps of old iron, shabby crockery in pale lots, muffled lots of unthinkable clothing. She and Birkin went unwillingly down the narrow aisle between the rusty wares. He was looking at the goods, she at the people.
Passages expressing a similar idea
Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXV. MARRIAGE OR NOT
“And all sorts of marriage, also snub and otherwise?” he said. “That’s it.” “And you think if I marry, it will be snub?” asked Gerald quizzically, his head a little on one side. Birkin laughed quickly. “How do I know what it will be!” he said. “Don’t lambaste me with my own parallels—” Gerald pondered a while. “But I should like to know your opinion, exactly,” he said. “On your marriage?—or marrying? Why should you want my opinion? I’ve got no opinions. I’m not interested in legal marriage, one way or another. It’s a mere question of convenience.” Still Gerald watched him closely. “More than that, I think,” he said seriously. “However you may be bored by the ethics of marriage, yet really to marry, in one’s own personal case, is something critical, final—” “You mean there is something final in going to the registrar with a woman?” “If you’re coming back with her, I do,” said Gerald. “It is in some way irrevocable.” “Yes, I agree,” said Birkin. “No matter how one regards legal marriage, yet to enter into the married state, in one’s own personal instance, is final—” “I believe it is,” said Birkin, “somewhere.” “The question remains then, should one do it,” said Gerald. Birkin watched him narrowly, with amused eyes. “You are like Lord Bacon, Gerald,” he said. “You argue it like a lawyer—or like Hamlet’s to-be-or-not-to-be. If I were you I would not marry: but ask Gudrun, not me. You’re not marrying me, are you?” Gerald did not heed the latter part of this speech.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXV. MARRIAGE OR NOT
“Yes,” he said, “one must consider it coldly. It is something critical. One comes to the point where one must take a step in one direction or another. And marriage is one direction—” “And what is the other?” asked Birkin quickly. Gerald looked up at him with hot, strangely-conscious eyes, that the other man could not understand. “I can’t say,” he replied. “If I knew that—” He moved uneasily on his feet, and did not finish. “You mean if you knew the alternative?” asked Birkin. “And since you don’t know it, marriage is a pis aller.” Gerald looked up at Birkin with the same hot, constrained eyes. “One does have the feeling that marriage is a pis aller,” he admitted. “Then don’t do it,” said Birkin. “I tell you,” he went on, “the same as I’ve said before, marriage in the old sense seems to me repulsive. Égoïsme à deux is nothing to it. It’s a sort of tacit hunting in couples: the world all in couples, each couple in its own little house, watching its own little interests, and stewing in its own little privacy—it’s the most repulsive thing on earth.” “I quite agree,” said Gerald. “There’s something inferior about it. But as I say, what’s the alternative.” “One should avoid this home instinct. It’s not an instinct, it’s a habit of cowardliness. One should never have a home.” “I agree really,” said Gerald. “But there’s no alternative.”
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER V. IN THE TRAIN
“And do you want to?” said Birkin. Gerald looked with a long, twinkling, almost sardonic look into the eyes of the other man. “I don’t know,” he said. “I do—I want to love,” said Birkin. “You do?” “Yes. I want the finality of love.” “The finality of love,” repeated Gerald. And he waited for a moment. “Just one woman?” he added. The evening light, flooding yellow along the fields, lit up Birkin’s face with a tense, abstract steadfastness. Gerald still could not make it out. “Yes, one woman,” said Birkin. But to Gerald it sounded as if he were insistent rather than confident. “I don’t believe a woman, and nothing but a woman, will ever make my life,” said Gerald. “Not the centre and core of it—the love between you and a woman?” asked Birkin. Gerald’s eyes narrowed with a queer dangerous smile as he watched the other man. “I never quite feel it that way,” he said. “You don’t? Then wherein does life centre, for you?” “I don’t know—that’s what I want somebody to tell me. As far as I can make out, it doesn’t centre at all. It is artificially held together by the social mechanism.” Birkin pondered as if he would crack something. “I know,” he said, “it just doesn’t centre. The old ideals are dead as nails—nothing there. It seems to me there remains only this perfect union with a woman—sort of ultimate marriage—and there isn’t anything else.” “And you mean if there isn’t the woman, there’s nothing?” said Gerald. “Pretty well that—seeing there’s no God.”
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXI. THRESHOLD
“You think Rupert is off his head a bit?” Gerald asked. Her eyes flashed with acknowledgment. “As regards a woman, yes,” she said, “I do. There is such a thing as two people being in love for the whole of their lives—perhaps. But marriage is neither here nor there, even then. If they are in love, well and good. If not—why break eggs about it!” “Yes,” said Gerald. “That’s how it strikes me. But what about Rupert?” “I can’t make out—neither can he nor anybody. He seems to think that if you marry you can get through marriage into a third heaven, or something—all very vague.” “Very! And who wants a third heaven? As a matter of fact, Rupert has a great yearning to be safe—to tie himself to the mast.” “Yes. It seems to me he’s mistaken there too,” said Gudrun. “I’m sure a mistress is more likely to be faithful than a wife—just because she is her own mistress. No—he says he believes that a man and wife can go further than any other two beings—but where, is not explained. They can know each other, heavenly and hellish, but particularly hellish, so perfectly that they go beyond heaven and hell—into—there it all breaks down—into nowhere.” “Into Paradise, he says,” laughed Gerald. Gudrun shrugged her shoulders. “Je m’en fiche of your Paradise!” she said. “Not being a Mohammedan,” said Gerald. Birkin sat motionless, driving the car, quite unconscious of what they said. And Gudrun, sitting immediately behind him, felt a sort of ironic pleasure in thus exposing him.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XVI. MAN TO MAN
Quite other things were going through Birkin’s mind. Suddenly he saw himself confronted with another problem—the problem of love and eternal conjunction between two men. Of course this was necessary—it had been a necessity inside himself all his life—to love a man purely and fully. Of course he had been loving Gerald all along, and all along denying it. He lay in the bed and wondered, whilst his friend sat beside him, lost in brooding. Each man was gone in his own thoughts. “You know how the old German knights used to swear a Blutbruderschaft,” he said to Gerald, with quite a new happy activity in his eyes. “Make a little wound in their arms, and rub each other’s blood into the cut?” said Gerald. “Yes—and swear to be true to each other, of one blood, all their lives. That is what we ought to do. No wounds, that is obsolete. But we ought to swear to love each other, you and I, implicitly, and perfectly, finally, without any possibility of going back on it.” He looked at Gerald with clear, happy eyes of discovery. Gerald looked down at him, attracted, so deeply bondaged in fascinated attraction, that he was mistrustful, resenting the bondage, hating the attraction. “We will swear to each other, one day, shall we?” pleaded Birkin. “We will swear to stand by each other—be true to each other—ultimately—infallibly—given to each other, organically—without possibility of taking back.”
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XVI. MAN TO MAN
“Yet you are so banal as to consider me chiefly a freak,” said Birkin pointedly. “A freak!” exclaimed Gerald, startled. And his face opened suddenly, as if lighted with simplicity, as when a flower opens out of the cunning bud. “No—I never consider you a freak.” And he watched the other man with strange eyes, that Birkin could not understand. “I feel,” Gerald continued, “that there is always an element of uncertainty about you—perhaps you are uncertain about yourself. But I’m never sure of you. You can go away and change as easily as if you had no soul.” He looked at Birkin with penetrating eyes. Birkin was amazed. He thought he had all the soul in the world. He stared in amazement. And Gerald, watching, saw the amazing attractive goodliness of his eyes, a young, spontaneous goodness that attracted the other man infinitely, yet filled him with bitter chagrin, because he mistrusted it so much. He knew Birkin could do without him—could forget, and not suffer. This was always present in Gerald’s consciousness, filling him with bitter unbelief: this consciousness of the young, animal-like spontaneity of detachment. It seemed almost like hypocrisy and lying, sometimes, oh, often, on Birkin’s part, to talk so deeply and importantly.
Read in context