Women in Love
D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)
The Brangwen family was going to move from Beldover. It was necessary now for the father to be in town. Birkin had taken out a marriage licence, yet Ursula deferred from day to day. She would not fix any definite time—she still wavered. Her month’s notice to leave the Grammar School was in its third week. Christmas was not far off. Gerald waited for the Ursula-Birkin marriage. It was something crucial to him. “Shall we make it a double-barrelled affair?” he said to Birkin one day. “Who for the second shot?” asked Birkin. “Gudrun and me,” said Gerald, the venturesome twinkle in his eyes. Birkin looked at him steadily, as if somewhat taken aback. “Serious—or joking?” he asked. “Oh, serious. Shall I? Shall Gudrun and I rush in along with you?” “Do by all means,” said Birkin. “I didn’t know you’d got that length.” “What length?” said Gerald, looking at the other man, and laughing. “Oh yes, we’ve gone all the lengths.” “There remains to put it on a broad social basis, and to achieve a high moral purpose,” said Birkin. “Something like that: the length and breadth and height of it,” replied Gerald, smiling. “Oh well,” said Birkin, “it’s a very admirable step to take, I should say.” Gerald looked at him closely. “Why aren’t you enthusiastic?” he asked. “I thought you were such dead nuts on marriage.” Birkin lifted his shoulders. “One might as well be dead nuts on noses. There are all sorts of noses, snub and otherwise—” Gerald laughed.
“And all sorts of marriage, also snub and otherwise?” he said. “That’s it.” “And you think if I marry, it will be snub?” asked Gerald quizzically, his head a little on one side. Birkin laughed quickly. “How do I know what it will be!” he said. “Don’t lambaste me with my own parallels—” Gerald pondered a while. “But I should like to know your opinion, exactly,” he said. “On your marriage?—or marrying? Why should you want my opinion? I’ve got no opinions. I’m not interested in legal marriage, one way or another. It’s a mere question of convenience.” Still Gerald watched him closely. “More than that, I think,” he said seriously. “However you may be bored by the ethics of marriage, yet really to marry, in one’s own personal case, is something critical, final—” “You mean there is something final in going to the registrar with a woman?” “If you’re coming back with her, I do,” said Gerald. “It is in some way irrevocable.” “Yes, I agree,” said Birkin. “No matter how one regards legal marriage, yet to enter into the married state, in one’s own personal instance, is final—” “I believe it is,” said Birkin, “somewhere.” “The question remains then, should one do it,” said Gerald. Birkin watched him narrowly, with amused eyes. “You are like Lord Bacon, Gerald,” he said. “You argue it like a lawyer—or like Hamlet’s to-be-or-not-to-be. If I were you I would not marry: but ask Gudrun, not me. You’re not marrying me, are you?” Gerald did not heed the latter part of this speech.
“Yes,” he said, “one must consider it coldly. It is something critical. One comes to the point where one must take a step in one direction or another. And marriage is one direction—” “And what is the other?” asked Birkin quickly. Gerald looked up at him with hot, strangely-conscious eyes, that the other man could not understand. “I can’t say,” he replied. “If I knew that—” He moved uneasily on his feet, and did not finish. “You mean if you knew the alternative?” asked Birkin. “And since you don’t know it, marriage is a pis aller.” Gerald looked up at Birkin with the same hot, constrained eyes. “One does have the feeling that marriage is a pis aller,” he admitted. “Then don’t do it,” said Birkin. “I tell you,” he went on, “the same as I’ve said before, marriage in the old sense seems to me repulsive. Égoïsme à deux is nothing to it. It’s a sort of tacit hunting in couples: the world all in couples, each couple in its own little house, watching its own little interests, and stewing in its own little privacy—it’s the most repulsive thing on earth.” “I quite agree,” said Gerald. “There’s something inferior about it. But as I say, what’s the alternative.” “One should avoid this home instinct. It’s not an instinct, it’s a habit of cowardliness. One should never have a home.” “I agree really,” said Gerald. “But there’s no alternative.”
“We’ve got to find one. I do believe in a permanent union between a man and a woman. Chopping about is merely an exhaustive process. But a permanent relation between a man and a woman isn’t the last word—it certainly isn’t.” “Quite,” said Gerald. “In fact,” said Birkin, “because the relation between man and woman is made the supreme and exclusive relationship, that’s where all the tightness and meanness and insufficiency comes in.” “Yes, I believe you,” said Gerald. “You’ve got to take down the love-and-marriage ideal from its pedestal. We want something broader. I believe in the additional perfect relationship between man and man—additional to marriage.” “I can never see how they can be the same,” said Gerald. “Not the same—but equally important, equally creative, equally sacred, if you like.” “I know,” said Gerald, “you believe something like that. Only I can’t feel it, you see.” He put his hand on Birkin’s arm, with a sort of deprecating affection. And he smiled as if triumphantly.
He was ready to be doomed. Marriage was like a doom to him. He was willing to condemn himself in marriage, to become like a convict condemned to the mines of the underworld, living no life in the sun, but having a dreadful subterranean activity. He was willing to accept this. And marriage was the seal of his condemnation. He was willing to be sealed thus in the underworld, like a soul damned but living forever in damnation. But he would not make any pure relationship with any other soul. He could not. Marriage was not the committing of himself into a relationship with Gudrun. It was a committing of himself in acceptance of the established world, he would accept the established order, in which he did not livingly believe, and then he would retreat to the underworld for his life. This he would do. The other way was to accept Rupert’s offer of alliance, to enter into the bond of pure trust and love with the other man, and then subsequently with the woman. If he pledged himself with the man he would later be able to pledge himself with the woman: not merely in legal marriage, but in absolute, mystic marriage. Yet he could not accept the offer. There was a numbness upon him, a numbness either of unborn, absent volition, or of atrophy. Perhaps it was the absence of volition. For he was strangely elated at Rupert’s offer. Yet he was still more glad to reject it, not to be committed.
Passages expressing a similar idea
Howards End · E. M. (Edward Morgan) Forster (1879–1970) · Chapter 19
“That’s foolish. In the first place, I disagree about the outer life. Well, we’ve often argued that. The real point is that there is the widest gulf between my love-making and yours. Yours—was romance; mine will be prose. I’m not running it down—a very good kind of prose, but well considered, well thought out. For instance, I know all Mr. Wilcox’s faults. He’s afraid of emotion. He cares too much about success, too little about the past. His sympathy lacks poetry, and so isn’t sympathy really. I’d even say”—she looked at the shining lagoons—“that, spiritually, he’s not as honest as I am. Doesn’t that satisfy you?” “No, it doesn’t,” said Helen. “It makes me feel worse and worse. You must be mad.” Margaret made a movement of irritation. “I don’t intend him, or any man or any woman, to be all my life—good heavens, no! There are heaps of things in me that he doesn’t, and shall never, understand.” Thus she spoke before the wedding ceremony and the physical union, before the astonishing glass shade had fallen that interposes between married couples and the world. She was to keep her independence more than do most women as yet. Marriage was to alter her fortunes rather than her character, and she was not far wrong in boasting that she understood her future husband. Yet he did alter her character—a little. There was an unforeseen surprise, a cessation of the winds and odours of life, a social pressure that would have her think conjugally.
Read in contextJane Eyre: An Autobiography · Charlotte Brontë (1816–1855) · CHAPTER XXXIV
“It is what I want,” he said, speaking to himself; “it is just what I want. And there are obstacles in the way: they must be hewn down. Jane, you would not repent marrying me—be certain of that; we must be married. I repeat it: there is no other way; and undoubtedly enough of love would follow upon marriage to render the union right even in your eyes.” “I scorn your idea of love,” I could not help saying, as I rose up and stood before him, leaning my back against the rock. “I scorn the counterfeit sentiment you offer: yes, St. John, and I scorn you when you offer it.” He looked at me fixedly, compressing his well-cut lips while he did so. Whether he was incensed or surprised, or what, it was not easy to tell: he could command his countenance thoroughly. “I scarcely expected to hear that expression from you,” he said: “I think I have done and uttered nothing to deserve scorn.” I was touched by his gentle tone, and overawed by his high, calm mien. “Forgive me the words, St. John; but it is your own fault that I have been roused to speak so unguardedly. You have introduced a topic on which our natures are at variance—a topic we should never discuss: the very name of love is an apple of discord between us. If the reality were required, what should we do? How should we feel? My dear cousin, abandon your scheme of marriage—forget it.”
Read in contextNight and Day · Virginia Woolf (1882–1941) · CHAPTER XVI
“To begin with, I’m very fond of William. You can’t deny that. I know him better than any one, almost. But why I’m marrying him is, partly, I admit—I’m being quite honest with you, and you mustn’t tell any one—partly because I want to get married. I want to have a house of my own. It isn’t possible at home. It’s all very well for you, Henry; you can go your own way. I have to be there always. Besides, you know what our house is. You wouldn’t be happy either, if you didn’t do something. It isn’t that I haven’t the time at home—it’s the atmosphere.” Here, presumably, she imagined that her cousin, who had listened with his usual intelligent sympathy, raised his eyebrows a little, and interposed: “Well, but what do you want to do?” Even in this purely imaginary dialogue, Katharine found it difficult to confide her ambition to an imaginary companion. “I should like,” she began, and hesitated quite a long time before she forced herself to add, with a change of voice, “to study mathematics—to know about the stars.” Henry was clearly amazed, but too kind to express all his doubts; he only said something about the difficulties of mathematics, and remarked that very little was known about the stars. Katharine thereupon went on with the statement of her case.
Read in contextThe Rainbow · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · Chapter XV. THE BITTERNESS OF ECSTASY
“I suppose we ought to get married,” he said, rather wistfully. It was so magnificently free and in a deeper world, as it was. To make public their connection would be to put it in range with all the things which nullified him, and from which he was for the moment entirely dissociated. If he married he would have to assume his social self. And the thought of assuming his social self made him at once diffident and abstract. If she were his social wife, if she were part of that complication of dead reality, then what had his under-life to do with her? One’s social wife was almost a material symbol. Whereas now she was something more vivid to him than anything in conventional life could be. She gave the complete lie to all conventional life, he and she stood together, dark, fluid, infinitely potent, giving the living lie to the dead whole which contained them. He watched her pensive, puzzled face. “I don’t think I want to marry you,” she said, her brow clouded. It piqued him rather. “Why not?” he asked. “Let’s think about it afterwards, shall we?” she said. He was crossed, yet he loved her violently. “You’ve got a museau, not a face,” he said. “Have I?” she cried, her face lighting up like a pure flame. She thought she had escaped. Yet he returned—he was not satisfied. “Why?” he asked, “why don’t you want to marry me?”
Read in contextSense and Sensibility · Jane Austen (1775–1817) · CHAPTER XLVII.
“You consider the matter,” said Elinor, “exactly as a good mind and a sound understanding must consider it; and I dare say you perceive, as well as myself, not only in this, but in many other circumstances, reason enough to be convinced that your marriage must have involved you in many certain troubles and disappointments, in which you would have been poorly supported by an affection, on his side, much less certain. Had you married, you must have been always poor. His expensiveness is acknowledged even by himself, and his whole conduct declares that self-denial is a word hardly understood by him. His demands and your inexperience together, on a small, very small income, must have brought on distresses which would not be the less grievous to you, from having been entirely unknown and unthought of before. Your sense of honour and honesty would have led you, I know, when aware of your situation, to attempt all the economy that would appear to you possible: and, perhaps, as long as your frugality retrenched only on your own comfort, you might have been suffered to practice it, but beyond that—and how little could the utmost of your single management do to stop the ruin which had begun before your marriage? Beyond that, had you endeavoured, however reasonably, to abridge his enjoyments, is it not to be feared, that instead of prevailing on feelings so selfish to consent to it, you would have lessened your own influence on his heart, and made him regret the connection which had involved him in such difficulties?”
Read in contextWashington Square · Henry James (1843–1916) · XXI
“You think too much.” “I suppose I do; but I can’t help it, my mind is so terribly active. When I give myself, I give myself. I pay the penalty in my headaches, my famous headaches—a perfect circlet of pain! But I carry it as a queen carries her crown. Would you believe that I have one now? I wouldn’t, however, have missed our rendezvous for anything. I have something very important to tell you.” “Well, let’s have it,” said Morris. “I was perhaps a little headlong the other day in advising you to marry immediately. I have been thinking it over, and now I see it just a little differently.” “You seem to have a great many different ways of seeing the same object.” “Their number is infinite!” said Mrs. Penniman, in a tone which seemed to suggest that this convenient faculty was one of her brightest attributes. “I recommend you to take one way and stick to it,” Morris replied. “Ah! but it isn’t easy to choose. My imagination is never quiet, never satisfied. It makes me a bad adviser, perhaps; but it makes me a capital friend!” “A capital friend who gives bad advice!” said Morris. “Not intentionally—and who hurries off, at every risk, to make the most humble excuses!” “Well, what do you advise me now?” “To be very patient; to watch and wait.” “And is that bad advice or good?” “That is not for me to say,” Mrs. Penniman rejoined, with some dignity. “I only pretend it’s sincere.”
Read in context