The Count of Monte Cristo
Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870)
“That just shows the meanness of this slander. They have allowed all this time to elapse, and then all of a sudden rake up events which have been forgotten to furnish materials for scandal, in order to tarnish the lustre of our high position. I inherit my father’s name, and I do not choose that the shadow of disgrace should darken it. I am going to Beauchamp, in whose journal this paragraph appears, and I shall insist on his retracting the assertion before two witnesses.” “Beauchamp will never retract.” “Then we must fight.” “No you will not, for he will tell you, what is very true, that perhaps there were fifty officers in the Greek army bearing the same name.” “We will fight, nevertheless. I will efface that blot on my father’s character. My father, who was such a brave soldier, whose career was so brilliant——” “Oh, well, he will add, ‘We are warranted in believing that this Fernand is not the illustrious Count of Morcerf, who also bears the same Christian name.’” “I am determined not to be content with anything short of an entire retractation.” “And you intend to make him do it in the presence of two witnesses, do you?” “Yes.” “You do wrong.” “Which means, I suppose, that you refuse the service which I asked of you?” “You know my theory regarding duels; I told you my opinion on that subject, if you remember, when we were at Rome.”
“Nevertheless, my dear count, I found you this morning engaged in an occupation but little consistent with the notions you profess to entertain.” “Because, my dear fellow, you understand one must never be eccentric. If one’s lot is cast among fools, it is necessary to study folly. I shall perhaps find myself one day called out by some harebrained scamp, who has no more real cause of quarrel with me than you have with Beauchamp; he may take me to task for some foolish trifle or other, he will bring his witnesses, or will insult me in some public place, and I am expected to kill him for all that.” “You admit that you would fight, then? Well, if so, why do you object to my doing so?” “I do not say that you ought not to fight, I only say that a duel is a serious thing, and ought not to be undertaken without due reflection.” “Did he reflect before he insulted my father?” “If he spoke hastily, and owns that he did so, you ought to be satisfied.” “Ah, my dear count, you are far too indulgent.” “And you are far too exacting. Supposing, for instance, and do not be angry at what I am going to say——” “Well.” “Supposing the assertion to be really true?” “A son ought not to submit to such a stain on his father’s honor.” “Ma foi! we live in times when there is much to which we must submit.” “That is precisely the fault of the age.”
“And do you undertake to reform it?” “Yes, as far as I am personally concerned.” “Well, you are indeed exacting, my dear fellow!” “Yes, I own it.” “Are you quite impervious to good advice?” “Not when it comes from a friend.” “And do you account me that title?” “Certainly I do.” “Well, then, before going to Beauchamp with your witnesses, seek further information on the subject.” “From whom?” “From Haydée.” “Why, what can be the use of mixing a woman up in the affair?—what can she do in it?” “She can declare to you, for example, that your father had no hand whatever in the defeat and death of the vizier; or if by chance he had, indeed, the misfortune to——” “I have told you, my dear count, that I would not for one moment admit of such a proposition.” “You reject this means of information, then?” “I do—most decidedly.” “Then let me offer one more word of advice.” “Do so, then, but let it be the last.” “You do not wish to hear it, perhaps?” “On the contrary, I request it.” “Do not take any witnesses with you when you go to Beauchamp—visit him alone.” “That would be contrary to all custom.” “Your case is not an ordinary one.” “And what is your reason for advising me to go alone?” “Because then the affair will rest between you and Beauchamp.” “Explain yourself.”
“I will do so. If Beauchamp be disposed to retract, you ought at least to give him the opportunity of doing it of his own free will,—the satisfaction to you will be the same. If, on the contrary, he refuses to do so, it will then be quite time enough to admit two strangers into your secret.” “They will not be strangers, they will be friends.” “Ah, but the friends of today are the enemies of tomorrow; Beauchamp, for instance.” “So you recommend——” “I recommend you to be prudent.” “Then you advise me to go alone to Beauchamp?” “I do, and I will tell you why. When you wish to obtain some concession from a man’s self-love, you must avoid even the appearance of wishing to wound it.” “I believe you are right.” “I am glad of it.” “Then I will go alone.” “Go; but you would do better still by not going at all.” “That is impossible.” “Do so, then; it will be a wiser plan than the first which you proposed.” “But if, in spite of all my precautions, I am at last obliged to fight, will you not be my second?” “My dear viscount,” said Monte Cristo gravely, “you must have seen before today that at all times and in all places I have been at your disposal, but the service which you have just demanded of me is one which it is out of my power to render you.” “Why?”
“Perhaps you may know at some future period, and in the mean time I request you to excuse my declining to put you in possession of my reasons.” “Well, I will have Franz and Château-Renaud; they will be the very men for it.” “Do so, then.” “But if I do fight, you will surely not object to giving me a lesson or two in shooting and fencing?” “That, too, is impossible.” “What a singular being you are!—you will not interfere in anything.” “You are right—that is the principle on which I wish to act.” “We will say no more about it, then. Good-bye, count.” Morcerf took his hat, and left the room. He found his carriage at the door, and doing his utmost to restrain his anger he went at once to find Beauchamp, who was in his office. It was a gloomy, dusty-looking apartment, such as journalists’ offices have always been from time immemorial. The servant announced M. Albert de Morcerf. Beauchamp repeated the name to himself, as though he could scarcely believe that he had heard aright, and then gave orders for him to be admitted. Albert entered. Beauchamp uttered an exclamation of surprise on seeing his friend leap over and trample under foot all the newspapers which were strewed about the room.
Passages expressing a similar idea
The Count of Monte Cristo · Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870) · Chapter 78. We hear From Yanina
“I will do so. If Beauchamp be disposed to retract, you ought at least to give him the opportunity of doing it of his own free will,—the satisfaction to you will be the same. If, on the contrary, he refuses to do so, it will then be quite time enough to admit two strangers into your secret.” “They will not be strangers, they will be friends.” “Ah, but the friends of today are the enemies of tomorrow; Beauchamp, for instance.” “So you recommend——” “I recommend you to be prudent.” “Then you advise me to go alone to Beauchamp?” “I do, and I will tell you why. When you wish to obtain some concession from a man’s self-love, you must avoid even the appearance of wishing to wound it.” “I believe you are right.” “I am glad of it.” “Then I will go alone.” “Go; but you would do better still by not going at all.” “That is impossible.” “Do so, then; it will be a wiser plan than the first which you proposed.” “But if, in spite of all my precautions, I am at last obliged to fight, will you not be my second?” “My dear viscount,” said Monte Cristo gravely, “you must have seen before today that at all times and in all places I have been at your disposal, but the service which you have just demanded of me is one which it is out of my power to render you.” “Why?”
Read in contextThe Count of Monte Cristo · Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870) · Chapter 59. The Will
“You will, of course, dispose of it in some way or other?” “Yes.” “In favor of some member of your family?” “No.” “Do you intend devoting it to charitable purposes, then?” pursued the notary. “Yes.” “But,” said the notary, “you are aware that the law does not allow a son to be entirely deprived of his patrimony?” “Yes.” “You only intend, then, to dispose of that part of your fortune which the law allows you to subtract from the inheritance of your son?” Noirtier made no answer. “Do you still wish to dispose of all?” “Yes.” “But they will contest the will after your death?” “No.” “My father knows me,” replied Villefort; “he is quite sure that his wishes will be held sacred by me; besides, he understands that in my position I cannot plead against the poor.” The eye of Noirtier beamed with triumph. “What do you decide on, sir?” asked the notary of Villefort. “Nothing, sir; it is a resolution which my father has taken and I know he never alters his mind. I am quite resigned. These 900,000 francs will go out of the family in order to enrich some hospital; but it is ridiculous thus to yield to the caprices of an old man, and I shall, therefore, act according to my conscience.” Having said this, Villefort quitted the room with his wife, leaving his father at liberty to do as he pleased. The same day the will was made, the witnesses were brought, it was approved by the old man, sealed in the presence of all and given in charge to M. Deschamps, the family notary.
Read in contextThe three musketeers · Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870) · Chapter XI. IN WHICH THE PLOT THICKENS
“No; you are, on the contrary, adorable.” “Give me your arm, then.” “Most willingly. And now?” “Now escort me.” “Where?” “Where I am going.” “But where are you going?” “You will see, because you will leave me at the door.” “Shall I wait for you?” “That will be useless.” “You will return alone, then?” “Perhaps yes, perhaps no.” “But will the person who shall accompany you afterward be a man or a woman?” “I don’t know yet.” “But I will know it!” “How so?” “I will wait until you come out.” “In that case, adieu.” “Why so?” “I do not want you.” “But you have claimed—” “The aid of a gentleman, not the watchfulness of a spy.” “The word is rather hard.” “How are they called who follow others in spite of them?” “They are indiscreet.” “The word is too mild.” “Well, madame, I perceive I must do as you wish.” “Why did you deprive yourself of the merit of doing so at once?” “Is there no merit in repentance?” “And do you really repent?” “I know nothing about it myself. But what I know is that I promise to do all you wish if you allow me to accompany you where you are going.” “And you will leave me then?” “Yes.” “Without waiting for my coming out again?” “Yes.” “Word of honor?” “By the faith of a gentleman. Take my arm, and let us go.”
Read in contextThe three musketeers · Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870) · Chapter VI. HIS MAJESTY KING LOUIS XIII.
“You mean to say that he deceives me; you mean to say that he betrays me? You accuse him, then? Come, speak; avow freely that you accuse him!” “No, sire, but I say that he deceives himself. I say that he is ill-informed. I say that he has hastily accused your Majesty’s Musketeers, toward whom he is unjust, and that he has not obtained his information from good sources.” “The accusation comes from Monsieur de la Trémouille, from the duke himself. What do you say to that?” “I might answer, sire, that he is too deeply interested in the question to be a very impartial witness; but so far from that, sire, I know the duke to be a royal gentleman, and I refer the matter to him—but upon one condition, sire.” “What?” “It is that your Majesty will make him come here, will interrogate him yourself, tête-à-tête, without witnesses, and that I shall see your Majesty as soon as you have seen the duke.” “What, then! You will bind yourself,” cried the king, “by what Monsieur de la Trémouille shall say?” “Yes, sire.” “You will accept his judgment?” “Undoubtedly.” “And you will submit to the reparation he may require?” “Certainly.” “La Chesnaye,” said the king. “La Chesnaye!” Louis XIII.’s confidential valet, who never left the door, entered in reply to the call. “La Chesnaye,” said the king, “let someone go instantly and find Monsieur de la Trémouille; I wish to speak with him this evening.”
Read in contextThe Count of Monte Cristo · Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870) · Chapter 78. We hear From Yanina
“Yes,” said Albert, blushing. “Well, what do you wish me to do for you?” said Beauchamp mildly. “My dear Beauchamp, I wish you to contradict this statement.” Beauchamp looked at Albert with a benevolent expression. “Come,” said he, “this matter will want a good deal of talking over; a retractation is always a serious thing, you know. Sit down, and I will read it again.” Albert resumed his seat, and Beauchamp read, with more attention than at first, the lines denounced by his friend. “Well,” said Albert in a determined tone, “you see that your paper has insulted a member of my family, and I insist on a retractation being made.” “You insist?” “Yes, I insist.” “Permit me to remind you that you are not in the Chamber, my dear viscount.” “Nor do I wish to be there,” replied the young man, rising. “I repeat that I am determined to have the announcement of yesterday contradicted. You have known me long enough,” continued Albert, biting his lips convulsively, for he saw that Beauchamp’s anger was beginning to rise,—“you have been my friend, and therefore sufficiently intimate with me to be aware that I am likely to maintain my resolution on this point.” “If I have been your friend, Morcerf, your present manner of speaking would almost lead me to forget that I ever bore that title. But wait a moment, do not let us get angry, or at least not yet. You are irritated and vexed—tell me how this Fernand is related to you?”
Read in contextThe three musketeers · Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870) · Chapter XVII. BONACIEUX AT HOME
“And you responded to his bidding, you imprudent man?” “Well, I can’t say I had much choice of going or not going, for I was taken to him between two guards. It is true also, that as I did not then know his Eminence, if I had been able to dispense with the visit, I should have been enchanted.” “He ill-treated you, then; he threatened you?” “He gave me his hand, and called me his friend. His friend! Do you hear that, madame? I am the friend of the great cardinal!” “Of the great cardinal!” “Perhaps you would contest his right to that title, madame?” “I would contest nothing; but I tell you that the favor of a minister is ephemeral, and that a man must be mad to attach himself to a minister. There are powers above his which do not depend upon a man or the issue of an event; it is to these powers we should rally.” “I am sorry for it, madame, but I acknowledge no other power but that of the great man whom I have the honor to serve.” “You serve the cardinal?” “Yes, madame; and as his servant, I will not allow you to be concerned in plots against the safety of the state, or to serve the intrigues of a woman who is not French and who has a Spanish heart. Fortunately we have the great cardinal; his vigilant eye watches over and penetrates to the bottom of the heart.”
Read in context