Skip to content
BookLens

The Count of Monte Cristo

Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870)

“A correspondent at Yanina informs us of a fact of which until now we had remained in ignorance. The castle which formed the protection of the town was given up to the Turks by a French officer named Fernand, in whom the grand vizier, Ali Tepelini, had reposed the greatest confidence.” “Well,” said Monte Cristo, “what do you see in that to annoy you?” “What do I see in it?” “Yes; what does it signify to you if the castle of Yanina was given up by a French officer?” “It signifies to my father, the Count of Morcerf, whose Christian name is Fernand!” “Did your father serve under Ali Pasha?” “Yes; that is to say, he fought for the independence of the Greeks, and hence arises the calumny.” “Oh, my dear viscount, do talk reason!” “I do not desire to do otherwise.” “Now, just tell me who the devil should know in France that the officer Fernand and the Count of Morcerf are one and the same person? and who cares now about Yanina, which was taken as long ago as the year 1822 or 1823?”

“That just shows the meanness of this slander. They have allowed all this time to elapse, and then all of a sudden rake up events which have been forgotten to furnish materials for scandal, in order to tarnish the lustre of our high position. I inherit my father’s name, and I do not choose that the shadow of disgrace should darken it. I am going to Beauchamp, in whose journal this paragraph appears, and I shall insist on his retracting the assertion before two witnesses.” “Beauchamp will never retract.” “Then we must fight.” “No you will not, for he will tell you, what is very true, that perhaps there were fifty officers in the Greek army bearing the same name.” “We will fight, nevertheless. I will efface that blot on my father’s character. My father, who was such a brave soldier, whose career was so brilliant——” “Oh, well, he will add, ‘We are warranted in believing that this Fernand is not the illustrious Count of Morcerf, who also bears the same Christian name.’” “I am determined not to be content with anything short of an entire retractation.” “And you intend to make him do it in the presence of two witnesses, do you?” “Yes.” “You do wrong.” “Which means, I suppose, that you refuse the service which I asked of you?” “You know my theory regarding duels; I told you my opinion on that subject, if you remember, when we were at Rome.”

“Nevertheless, my dear count, I found you this morning engaged in an occupation but little consistent with the notions you profess to entertain.” “Because, my dear fellow, you understand one must never be eccentric. If one’s lot is cast among fools, it is necessary to study folly. I shall perhaps find myself one day called out by some harebrained scamp, who has no more real cause of quarrel with me than you have with Beauchamp; he may take me to task for some foolish trifle or other, he will bring his witnesses, or will insult me in some public place, and I am expected to kill him for all that.” “You admit that you would fight, then? Well, if so, why do you object to my doing so?” “I do not say that you ought not to fight, I only say that a duel is a serious thing, and ought not to be undertaken without due reflection.” “Did he reflect before he insulted my father?” “If he spoke hastily, and owns that he did so, you ought to be satisfied.” “Ah, my dear count, you are far too indulgent.” “And you are far too exacting. Supposing, for instance, and do not be angry at what I am going to say——” “Well.” “Supposing the assertion to be really true?” “A son ought not to submit to such a stain on his father’s honor.” “Ma foi! we live in times when there is much to which we must submit.” “That is precisely the fault of the age.”

“And do you undertake to reform it?” “Yes, as far as I am personally concerned.” “Well, you are indeed exacting, my dear fellow!” “Yes, I own it.” “Are you quite impervious to good advice?” “Not when it comes from a friend.” “And do you account me that title?” “Certainly I do.” “Well, then, before going to Beauchamp with your witnesses, seek further information on the subject.” “From whom?” “From Haydée.” “Why, what can be the use of mixing a woman up in the affair?—what can she do in it?” “She can declare to you, for example, that your father had no hand whatever in the defeat and death of the vizier; or if by chance he had, indeed, the misfortune to——” “I have told you, my dear count, that I would not for one moment admit of such a proposition.” “You reject this means of information, then?” “I do—most decidedly.” “Then let me offer one more word of advice.” “Do so, then, but let it be the last.” “You do not wish to hear it, perhaps?” “On the contrary, I request it.” “Do not take any witnesses with you when you go to Beauchamp—visit him alone.” “That would be contrary to all custom.” “Your case is not an ordinary one.” “And what is your reason for advising me to go alone?” “Because then the affair will rest between you and Beauchamp.” “Explain yourself.”

“I will do so. If Beauchamp be disposed to retract, you ought at least to give him the opportunity of doing it of his own free will,—the satisfaction to you will be the same. If, on the contrary, he refuses to do so, it will then be quite time enough to admit two strangers into your secret.” “They will not be strangers, they will be friends.” “Ah, but the friends of today are the enemies of tomorrow; Beauchamp, for instance.” “So you recommend——” “I recommend you to be prudent.” “Then you advise me to go alone to Beauchamp?” “I do, and I will tell you why. When you wish to obtain some concession from a man’s self-love, you must avoid even the appearance of wishing to wound it.” “I believe you are right.” “I am glad of it.” “Then I will go alone.” “Go; but you would do better still by not going at all.” “That is impossible.” “Do so, then; it will be a wiser plan than the first which you proposed.” “But if, in spite of all my precautions, I am at last obliged to fight, will you not be my second?” “My dear viscount,” said Monte Cristo gravely, “you must have seen before today that at all times and in all places I have been at your disposal, but the service which you have just demanded of me is one which it is out of my power to render you.” “Why?”

Passages expressing a similar idea

  • The Count of Monte Cristo · Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870) · Chapter 78. We hear From Yanina

    “He is merely my father,” said Albert—“M. Fernand Mondego, Count of Morcerf, an old soldier who has fought in twenty battles and whose honorable scars they would denounce as badges of disgrace.” “Is it your father?” said Beauchamp; “that is quite another thing. Then I can well understand your indignation, my dear Albert. I will look at it again;” and he read the paragraph for the third time, laying a stress on each word as he proceeded. “But the paper nowhere identifies this Fernand with your father.” 40100m “No; but the connection will be seen by others, and therefore I will have the article contradicted.” At the words I will, Beauchamp steadily raised his eyes to Albert’s countenance, and then as gradually lowering them, he remained thoughtful for a few moments. “You will retract this assertion, will you not, Beauchamp?” said Albert with increased though stifled anger. “Yes,” replied Beauchamp. “Immediately?” said Albert. “When I am convinced that the statement is false.” “What?” “The thing is worth looking into, and I will take pains to investigate the matter thoroughly.” “But what is there to investigate, sir?” said Albert, enraged beyond measure at Beauchamp’s last remark. “If you do not believe that it is my father, say so immediately; and if, on the contrary, you believe it to be him, state your reasons for doing so.” Beauchamp looked at Albert with the smile which was so peculiar to him, and which in its numerous modifications served to express every varied emotion of his mind.

    Read in context
  • The Count of Monte Cristo · Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870) · Chapter 35. La Mazzolata

    “Oh, yes,” replied the count; “understand me, I would fight a duel for a trifle, for an insult, for a blow; and the more so that, thanks to my skill in all bodily exercises, and the indifference to danger I have gradually acquired, I should be almost certain to kill my man. Oh, I would fight for such a cause; but in return for a slow, profound, eternal torture, I would give back the same, were it possible; an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth, as the Orientalists say,—our masters in everything,—those favored creatures who have formed for themselves a life of dreams and a paradise of realities.” “But,” said Franz to the count, “with this theory, which renders you at once judge and executioner of your own cause, it would be difficult to adopt a course that would forever prevent your falling under the power of the law. Hatred is blind, rage carries you away; and he who pours out vengeance runs the risk of tasting a bitter draught.”

    Read in context
  • The Count of Monte Cristo · Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870) · Chapter 90. The Meeting

    “Now, sir,” said Albert, “if you think my apology sufficient, pray give me your hand. Next to the merit of infallibility which you appear to possess, I rank that of candidly acknowledging a fault. But this confession concerns me only. I acted well as a man, but you have acted better than man. An angel alone could have saved one of us from death—that angel came from heaven, if not to make us friends (which, alas, fatality renders impossible), at least to make us esteem each other.” Monte Cristo, with moistened eye, heaving breast, and lips half open, extended to Albert a hand which the latter pressed with a sentiment resembling respectful fear. “Gentlemen,” said he, “M. de Monte Cristo receives my apology. I had acted hastily towards him. Hasty actions are generally bad ones. Now my fault is repaired. I hope the world will not call me cowardly for acting as my conscience dictated. But if anyone should entertain a false opinion of me,” added he, drawing himself up as if he would challenge both friends and enemies, “I shall endeavor to correct his mistake.” “What happened during the night?” asked Beauchamp of Château-Renaud; “we appear to make a very sorry figure here.” “In truth, what Albert has just done is either very despicable or very noble,” replied the baron. “What can it mean?” said Debray to Franz.

    Read in context
  • The Count of Monte Cristo · Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870) · Chapter 88. The Insult

    “It is quite immaterial to me,” said Monte Cristo, “and it was very unnecessary to disturb me at the Opera for such a trifle. In France people fight with the sword or pistol, in the colonies with the carbine, in Arabia with the dagger. Tell your client that, although I am the insulted party, in order to carry out my eccentricity, I leave him the choice of arms, and will accept without discussion, without dispute, anything, even combat by drawing lots, which is always stupid, but with me different from other people, as I am sure to gain.” “Sure to gain!” repeated Beauchamp, looking with amazement at the count. “Certainly,” said Monte Cristo, slightly shrugging his shoulders; “otherwise I would not fight with M. de Morcerf. I shall kill him—I cannot help it. Only by a single line this evening at my house let me know the arms and the hour; I do not like to be kept waiting.” “Pistols, then, at eight o’clock, in the Bois de Vincennes,” said Beauchamp, quite disconcerted, not knowing if he was dealing with an arrogant braggadocio or a supernatural being. “Very well, sir,” said Monte Cristo. “Now all that is settled, do let me see the performance, and tell your friend Albert not to come any more this evening; he will hurt himself with all his ill-chosen barbarisms: let him go home and go to sleep.” Beauchamp left the box, perfectly amazed. “Now,” said Monte Cristo, turning towards Morrel, “I may depend upon you, may I not?”

    Read in context
  • The Count of Monte Cristo · Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870) · Chapter 35. La Mazzolata

    “Ah, duelling,” cried the count; “a pleasant manner, upon my soul, of arriving at your end when that end is vengeance! A man has carried off your mistress, a man has seduced your wife, a man has dishonored your daughter; he has rendered the whole life of one who had the right to expect from Heaven that portion of happiness God has promised to everyone of his creatures, an existence of misery and infamy; and you think you are avenged because you send a ball through the head, or pass a sword through the breast, of that man who has planted madness in your brain, and despair in your heart. And remember, moreover, that it is often he who comes off victorious from the strife, absolved of all crime in the eyes of the world. No, no,” continued the count, “had I to avenge myself, it is not thus I would take revenge.” “Then you disapprove of duelling? You would not fight a duel?” asked Albert in his turn, astonished at this strange theory.

    Read in context
  • The Count of Monte Cristo · Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870) · Chapter 78. We hear From Yanina

    “Nothing of the kind, sir,” replied Danglars: “if such had been the case, I only should have been to blame, inasmuch as I was aware of all these things when I made the engagement. No, do not seek any longer to discover the reason. I really am quite ashamed to have been the cause of your undergoing such severe self-examination; let us drop the subject, and adopt the middle course of delay, which implies neither a rupture nor an engagement. Ma foi, there is no hurry. My daughter is only seventeen years old, and your son twenty-one. While we wait, time will be progressing, events will succeed each other; things which in the evening look dark and obscure, appear but too clearly in the light of morning, and sometimes the utterance of one word, or the lapse of a single day, will reveal the most cruel calumnies.” “Calumnies, did you say, sir?” cried Morcerf, turning livid with rage. “Does anyone dare to slander me?” “Monsieur, I told you that I considered it best to avoid all explanation.” “Then, sir, I am patiently to submit to your refusal?” “Yes, sir, although I assure you the refusal is as painful for me to give as it is for you to receive, for I had reckoned on the honor of your alliance, and the breaking off of a marriage contract always injures the lady more than the gentleman.” “Enough, sir,” said Morcerf, “we will speak no more on the subject.”

    Read in context