What Is Art?
Leo Tolstoy (1828–1910)
No. 1. The following verses are by Vielé-Griffin, from page 28 of a volume of his Poems:— OISEAU BLEU COULEUR DU TEMPS. 1. Sait-tu l’oubli D’un vain doux rêve, Oiseau moqueur De la forêt? Le jour pâlit, La nuit se lève, Et dans mon cœur L’ombre a pleuré; 2. O chante-moi Ta folle gamme, Car j’ai dormi Ce jour durant; Le lâche emoi Où fut mon âme Sanglote ennui Le jour mourant... 3. Sais-tu le chant De sa parole Et de sa voix, Toi qui redis Dans le couchant Ton air frivole Comme autrefois Sous les midis? 4. O chante alors La mélodie De son amour, Mon fol espoir, Parmi les ors Et l’incendie Du vain doux jour Qui meurt ce soir. Francis Vielé-Griffin. BLUE BIRD. 1. Canst thou forget, In dreams so vain, Oh, mocking bird Of forest deep? The day doth set, Night comes again, My heart has heard The shadows weep; 2. Thy tones let flow In maddening scale, For I have slept The livelong day; Emotions low In me now wail, My soul they’ve kept: Light dies away ... 3. That music sweet, Ah, do you know Her voice and speech? Your airs so light You who repeat In sunset’s glow, As you sang, each, At noonday’s height. 4. Of my desire, My hope so bold, Her love—up, sing, Sing ’neath this light, This flaming fire, And all the gold The eve doth bring Ere comes the night.
And here are some verses by the esteemed young poet Verhaeren, which I also take from page 28 of his Works:— ATTIRANCES. Lointainement, et si étrangement pareils, De grands masques d’argent que la brume recule, Vaguent, au jour tombant, autour des vieux soleils. Les doux lointaines!—et comme, au fond du crépuscule, Ils nous fixent le cœur, immensément le cœur, Avec les yeux défunts de leur visage d’âme. C’est toujours du silence, à moins, dans la pâleur Du soir, un jet de feu soudain, un cri de flamme, Un départ de lumière inattendu vers Dieu. On se laisse charmer et troubler de mystère, Et l’on dirait des morts qui taisent un adieu Trop mystique, pour être écouté par la terre! Sont-ils le souvenir matériel et clair Des éphèbes chrétiens couchés aux catacombes Parmi les lys? Sont-ils leur regard et leur chair? Ou seul, ce qui survit de merveilleux aux tombes De ceux qui sont partis, vers leurs rêves, un soir, Conquérir la folie à l’assaut des nuées? Lointainement, combien nous les sentons vouloir Un peu d’amour pour leurs œuvres destituées, Pour leur errance et leur tristesse aux horizons. Toujours! aux horizons du cœur et des pensées, Alors que les vieux soirs éclatent en blasons Soudains, pour les gloires noires et angoissées. Émile Verhaeren, Poèmes. ATTRACTIONS. Large masks of silver, by mists drawn away, So strangely alike, yet so far apart, Float round the old suns when faileth the day. They transfix our heart, so immensely our heart, Those distances mild, in the twilight deep,
Looking out of dead faces with their spirit eyes. All around is now silence, except when there leap In the pallor of evening, with fiery cries, Some fountains of flame that God-ward do fly. Mysterious trouble and charms us enfold. You might think that the dead spoke a silent good-bye, Oh! too mystical far on earth to be told! Are they the memories, material and bright, Of the Christian youths that in catacombs sleep ’Mid the lilies? Are they their flesh or their sight? Or the marvel alone that survives, in the deep, Of those that, one night, returned to their dream Of conquering folly by assaulting the skies? For their destitute works—we feel it seems, For a little love their longing cries From horizons far—for their errings and pain. In horizons ever of heart and thought, While the evenings old in bright blaze wane Suddenly, for black glories anguish fraught.
And the following is a poem by Moréas, evidently an admirer of Greek beauty. It is from page 28 of a volume of his Poems:— ENONE AU CLAIR VISAGE. Enone, j’avais cru qu’en aimant ta beauté Où l’âme avec le corps trouvent leur unité, J’allais, m’affermissant et le cœur et l’esprit, Monter jusqu’à cela qui jamais ne périt, N’ayant été crée, qui n’est froideur ou feu, Qui n’est beau quelque part et laid en autre lieu; Et me flattais encor’ d’une belle harmonie Que j’eusse composé du meilleur et du pire, Ainsi que le chanteur qui chérit Polimnie, En accordant le grave avec l’aigu, retire Un son bien élevé sur les nerfs de sa lyre. Mais mon courage, hélas! se pâmant comme mort, M’enseigna que le trait qui m’avait fait amant Ne fut pas de cet arc que courbe sans effort La Vénus qui naquit du mâle seulement, Mais que j’avais souffert cette Vénus dernière, Qui a le cœur couard, né d’une faible mère. Et pourtant, ce mauvais garçon, chasseur habile, Qui charge son carquois de sagette subtile, Qui secoue en riant sa torche, pour un jour, Qui ne pose jamais que sur de tendres fleurs, C’est sur un teint charmant qu’il essuie les pleurs, Et c’est encore un Dieu, Enone, cet Amour. Mais, laisse, les oiseaux du printemps sont partis, Et je vois les rayons du soleil amortis. Enone, ma douleur, harmonieux visage, Superbe humilité, doux honnête langage, Hier me remirant dans cet étang glacé Qui au bout du jardin se couvre de feuillage,
Sur ma face je vis que les jours ont passé. Jean Moréas. ENONE. Enone, in loving thy beauty, I thought, Where the soul and the body to union are brought, That mounting by steadying my heart and my mind, In that which can’t perish, myself I should find. For it ne’er was created, is not ugly and fair; Is not coldness in one part, while on fire it is there. Yes, I flattered myself that a harmony fine I’d succeed to compose of the worst and the best, Like the bard who adores Polyhymnia divine, And mingling sounds different from the nerves of his lyre, From the grave and the smart draws melodies higher. But, alas! my courage, so faint and nigh spent, The dart that has struck me proves without fail Not to be from that bow which is easily bent By the Venus that’s born alone of the male. No, ’twas that other Venus that caused me to smart, Born of frail mother with cowardly heart. And yet that naughty lad, that little hunter bold, Who laughs and shakes his flowery torch just for a day, Who never rests but upon tender flowers and gay, On sweetest skin who dries the tears his eyes that fill, Yet oh, Enone mine, a God’s that Cupid still. Let it pass; for the birds of the Spring are away, And dying I see the sun’s lingering ray. Enone, my sorrow, oh, harmonious face, Humility grand, words of virtue and grace, I looked yestere’en in the pond frozen fast, Strewn with leaves at the end of the garden’s fair space, And I read in my face that those days are now past.
Passages expressing a similar idea
Childhood · Leo Tolstoy (1828–1910) · XV — CHILDHOOD
Do in after life the freshness and light-heartedness, the craving for love and for strength of faith, ever return which we experience in our childhood’s years? What better time is there in our lives than when the two best of virtues—innocent gaiety and a boundless yearning for affection—are our sole objects of pursuit? Where now are our ardent prayers? Where now are our best gifts—the pure tears of emotion which a guardian angel dries with a smile as he sheds upon us lovely dreams of ineffable childish joy? Can it be that life has left such heavy traces upon one’s heart that those tears and ecstasies are for ever vanished? Can it be that there remains to us only the recollection of them?
Read in contextChildhood · Leo Tolstoy (1828–1910) · XXVII — GRIEF
The door creaked as the chanter entered who was to relieve his predecessor. The noise awakened me, and my first thought was that, seeing me standing on the chair in a posture which had nothing touching in its aspect, he might take me for an unfeeling boy who had climbed on to the chair out of mere curiosity: wherefore I hastened to make the sign of the cross, to bend down my head, and to burst out crying. As I recall now my impressions of that episode I find that it was only during my moments of self-forgetfulness that my grief was wholehearted. True, both before and after the funeral I never ceased to cry and to look miserable, yet I feel conscience-stricken when I recall that grief of mine, seeing that always present in it there was an element of conceit—of a desire to show that I was more grieved than any one else, of an interest which I took in observing the effect, produced upon others by my tears, and of an idle curiosity leading me to remark Mimi’s bonnet and the faces of all present. The mere circumstance that I despised myself for not feeling grief to the exclusion of everything else, and that I endeavoured to conceal the fact, shows that my sadness was insincere and unnatural. I took a delight in feeling that I was unhappy, and in trying to feel more so. Consequently this egotistic consciousness completely annulled any element of sincerity in my woe.
Read in contextChildhood · Leo Tolstoy (1828–1910) · XXVII — GRIEF
Somehow, as I gazed, an irrepressible, incomprehensible power seemed to compel me to keep my eyes fixed upon that lifeless face. I could not turn away, and my imagination began to picture before me scenes of her active life and happiness. I forgot that the corpse lying before me now—the THING at which I was gazing unconsciously as at an object which had nothing in common with my dreams—was SHE. I fancied I could see her—now here, now there, alive, happy, and smiling. Then some well-known feature in the face at which I was gazing would suddenly arrest my attention, and in a flash I would recall the terrible reality and shudder-though still unable to turn my eyes away. Then again the dreams would replace reality—then again the reality put to flight the dreams. At last the consciousness of both left me, and for a while I became insensible. How long I remained in that condition I do not know, nor yet how it occurred. I only know that for a time I lost all sense of existence, and experienced a kind of vague blissfulness which though grand and sweet, was also sad. It may be that, as it ascended to a better world, her beautiful soul had looked down with longing at the world in which she had left us—that it had seen my sorrow, and, pitying me, had returned to earth on the wings of love to console and bless me with a heavenly smile of compassion.
Read in contextChildhood · Leo Tolstoy (1828–1910) · XV — CHILDHOOD
HAPPY, happy, never-returning time of childhood! How can we help loving and dwelling upon its recollections? They cheer and elevate the soul, and become to one a source of higher joys. Sometimes, when dreaming of bygone days, I fancy that, tired out with running about, I have sat down, as of old, in my high arm-chair by the tea-table. It is late, and I have long since drunk my cup of milk. My eyes are heavy with sleep as I sit there and listen. How could I not listen, seeing that Mamma is speaking to somebody, and that the sound of her voice is so melodious and kind? How much its echoes recall to my heart! With my eyes veiled with drowsiness I gaze at her wistfully. Suddenly she seems to grow smaller and smaller, and her face vanishes to a point; yet I can still see it—can still see her as she looks at me and smiles. Somehow it pleases me to see her grown so small. I blink and blink, yet she looks no larger than a boy reflected in the pupil of an eye. Then I rouse myself, and the picture fades. Once more I half-close my eyes, and cast about to try and recall the dream, but it has gone. I rise to my feet, only to fall back comfortably into the armchair. “There! You are failing asleep again, little Nicolas,” says Mamma. “You had better go to by-by.”
Read in contextWhat Is Art? · Leo Tolstoy (1828–1910) · CHAPTER XIX
To people of our circle who do not know, and cannot or will not understand the feelings which will form the subject-matter of the art of the future, such subject-matter appears very poor in comparison with those subtleties of exclusive art with which they are now occupied. “What is there fresh to be said in the sphere of the Christian feeling of love of one’s fellow-man? The feelings common to everyone are so insignificant and monotonous,” think they. And yet, in our time, the really fresh feelings can only be religious, Christian feelings, and such as are open, accessible, to all. The feelings flowing from the religious perception of our times, Christian feelings, are infinitely new and varied, only not in the sense some people imagine,—not that they can be evoked by the depiction of Christ and of Gospel episodes, or by repeating in new forms the Christian truths of unity, brotherhood, equality, and love,—but in that all the oldest, commonest, and most hackneyed phenomena of life evoke the newest, most unexpected and touching emotions as soon as a man regards them from the Christian point of view. What can be older than the relations between married couples, of parents to children, of children to parents; the relations of men to their fellow-countrymen and to foreigners, to an invasion, to defence, to property, to the land, or to animals? But as soon as a man regards these matters from the Christian point of view, endlessly varied, fresh, complex, and strong emotions immediately arise.
Read in contextChildhood · Leo Tolstoy (1828–1910) · XV — CHILDHOOD
After saying my prayers I would wrap myself up in the bedclothes. My heart would feel light, peaceful, and happy, and one dream would follow another. Dreams of what? They were all of them vague, but all of them full of pure love and of a sort of expectation of happiness. I remember, too, that I used to think about Karl Ivanitch and his sad lot. He was the only unhappy being whom I knew, and so sorry would I feel for him, and so much did I love him, that tears would fall from my eyes as I thought, “May God give him happiness, and enable me to help him and to lessen his sorrow. I could make any sacrifice for him!” Usually, also, there would be some favourite toy—a china dog or hare—stuck into the bed-corner behind the pillow, and it would please me to think how warm and comfortable and well cared-for it was there. Also, I would pray God to make every one happy, so that every one might be contented, and also to send fine weather to-morrow for our walk. Then I would turn myself over on to the other side, and thoughts and dreams would become jumbled and entangled together until at last I slept soundly and peacefully, though with a face wet with tears.
Read in context