Skip to content
BookLens

Women in Love

D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)

“It’s not a question of my right over you—though I have some right, remember. I want to know, I only want to know what it is that subjugates you to that little scum of a sculptor downstairs, what it is that brings you down like a humble maggot, in worship of him. I want to know what you creep after.” She stood over against the window, listening. Then she turned round. “Do you?” she said, in her most easy, most cutting voice. “Do you want to know what it is in him? It’s because he has some understanding of a woman, because he is not stupid. That’s why it is.” A queer, sinister, animal-like smile came over Gerald’s face. “But what understanding is it?” he said. “The understanding of a flea, a hopping flea with a proboscis. Why should you crawl abject before the understanding of a flea?” There passed through Gudrun’s mind Blake’s representation of the soul of a flea. She wanted to fit it to Loerke. Blake was a clown too. But it was necessary to answer Gerald. “Don’t you think the understanding of a flea is more interesting than the understanding of a fool?” she asked. “A fool!” he repeated. “A fool, a conceited fool—a Dummkopf,” she replied, adding the German word. “Do you call me a fool?” he replied. “Well, wouldn’t I rather be the fool I am, than that flea downstairs?” She looked at him. A certain blunt, blind stupidity in him palled on her soul, limiting her.

“You give yourself away by that last,” she said. He sat and wondered. “I shall go away soon,” he said. She turned on him. “Remember,” she said, “I am completely independent of you—completely. You make your arrangements, I make mine.” He pondered this. “You mean we are strangers from this minute?” he asked. She halted and flushed. He was putting her in a trap, forcing her hand. She turned round on him. “Strangers,” she said, “we can never be. But if you want to make any movement apart from me, then I wish you to know you are perfectly free to do so. Do not consider me in the slightest.” Even so slight an implication that she needed him and was depending on him still was sufficient to rouse his passion. As he sat a change came over his body, the hot, molten stream mounted involuntarily through his veins. He groaned inwardly, under its bondage, but he loved it. He looked at her with clear eyes, waiting for her. She knew at once, and was shaken with cold revulsion. How could he look at her with those clear, warm, waiting eyes, waiting for her, even now? What had been said between them, was it not enough to put them worlds asunder, to freeze them forever apart! And yet he was all transfused and roused, waiting for her. It confused her. Turning her head aside, she said: “I shall always tell you, whenever I am going to make any change—” And with this she moved out of the room.

He sat suspended in a fine recoil of disappointment, that seemed gradually to be destroying his understanding. But the unconscious state of patience persisted in him. He remained motionless, without thought or knowledge, for a long time. Then he rose, and went downstairs, to play at chess with one of the students. His face was open and clear, with a certain innocent laisser-aller that troubled Gudrun most, made her almost afraid of him, whilst she disliked him deeply for it. It was after this that Loerke, who had never yet spoken to her personally, began to ask her of her state. “You are not married at all, are you?” he asked. She looked full at him. “Not in the least,” she replied, in her measured way. Loerke laughed, wrinkling up his face oddly. There was a thin wisp of his hair straying on his forehead, she noticed that his skin was of a clear brown colour, his hands, his wrists. And his hands seemed closely prehensile. He seemed like topaz, so strangely brownish and pellucid. “Good,” he said. Still it needed some courage for him to go on. “Was Mrs Birkin your sister?” he asked. “Yes.” “And was she married?” “She was married.” “Have you parents, then?” “Yes,” said Gudrun, “we have parents.” And she told him, briefly, laconically, her position. He watched her closely, curiously all the while. “So!” he exclaimed, with some surprise. “And the Herr Crich, is he rich?” “Yes, he is rich, a coal owner.” “How long has your friendship with him lasted?” “Some months.”

There was a pause. “Yes, I am surprised,” he said at length. “The English, I thought they were so—cold. And what do you think to do when you leave here?” “What do I think to do?” she repeated. “Yes. You cannot go back to the teaching. No—” he shrugged his shoulders—“that is impossible. Leave that to the canaille who can do nothing else. You, for your part—you know, you are a remarkable woman, eine seltsame Frau. Why deny it—why make any question of it? You are an extraordinary woman, why should you follow the ordinary course, the ordinary life?” Gudrun sat looking at her hands, flushed. She was pleased that he said, so simply, that she was a remarkable woman. He would not say that to flatter her—he was far too self-opinionated and objective by nature. He said it as he would say a piece of sculpture was remarkable, because he knew it was so. And it gratified her to hear it from him. Other people had such a passion to make everything of one degree, of one pattern. In England it was chic to be perfectly ordinary. And it was a relief to her to be acknowledged extraordinary. Then she need not fret about the common standards. “You see,” she said, “I have no money whatsoever.” “Ach, money!” he cried, lifting his shoulders. “When one is grown up, money is lying about at one’s service. It is only when one is young that it is rare. Take no thought for money—that always lies to hand.”

“Does it?” she said, laughing. “Always. The Gerald will give you a sum, if you ask him for it—” She flushed deeply. “I will ask anybody else,” she said, with some difficulty—“but not him.” Loerke looked closely at her. “Good,” he said. “Then let it be somebody else. Only don’t go back to that England, that school. No, that is stupid.” Again there was a pause. He was afraid to ask her outright to go with him, he was not even quite sure he wanted her; and she was afraid to be asked. He begrudged his own isolation, was very chary of sharing his life, even for a day. “The only other place I know is Paris,” she said, “and I can’t stand that.” She looked with her wide, steady eyes full at Loerke. He lowered his head and averted his face. “Paris, no!” he said. “Between the réligion d’amour, and the latest ’ism, and the new turning to Jesus, one had better ride on a carrousel all day. But come to Dresden. I have a studio there—I can give you work,—oh, that would be easy enough. I haven’t seen any of your things, but I believe in you. Come to Dresden—that is a fine town to be in, and as good a life as you can expect of a town. You have everything there, without the foolishness of Paris or the beer of Munich.”

Passages expressing a similar idea

  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXIX. CONTINENTAL

    Already they were rarely together. Leitner ran attaching himself to somebody or other, always deferring, Loerke was a good deal alone. Out of doors he wore a Westphalian cap, a close brown-velvet head with big brown velvet flaps down over his ears, so that he looked like a lop-eared rabbit, or a troll. His face was brown-red, with a dry, bright skin, that seemed to crinkle with his mobile expressions. His eyes were arresting—brown, full, like a rabbit’s, or like a troll’s, or like the eyes of a lost being, having a strange, dumb, depraved look of knowledge, and a quick spark of uncanny fire. Whenever Gudrun had tried to talk to him he had shied away unresponsive, looking at her with his watchful dark eyes, but entering into no relation with her. He had made her feel that her slow French and her slower German, were hateful to him. As for his own inadequate English, he was much too awkward to try it at all. But he understood a good deal of what was said, nevertheless. And Gudrun, piqued, left him alone. This afternoon, however, she came into the lounge as he was talking to Ursula. His fine, black hair somehow reminded her of a bat, thin as it was on his full, sensitive-looking head, and worn away at the temples. He sat hunched up, as if his spirit were bat-like. And Gudrun could see he was making some slow confidence to Ursula, unwilling, a slow, grudging, scanty self-revelation. She went and sat by her sister.

    Read in context
  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXIX. CONTINENTAL

    “Your husband,” said Ursula, with a certain irony. “I haven’t got a husband,” said Gudrun in English. In German she answered, “He is thirty-one.” But Loerke was watching closely, with his uncanny, full, suspicious eyes. Something in Gudrun seemed to accord with him. He was really like one of the “little people’ who have no soul, who has found his mate in a human being. But he suffered in his discovery. She too was fascinated by him, fascinated, as if some strange creature, a rabbit or a bat, or a brown seal, had begun to talk to her. But also, she knew what he was unconscious of, his tremendous power of understanding, of apprehending her living motion. He did not know his own power. He did not know how, with his full, submerged, watchful eyes, he could look into her and see her, what she was, see her secrets. He would only want her to be herself—he knew her verily, with a subconscious, sinister knowledge, devoid of illusions and hopes. To Gudrun, there was in Loerke the rock-bottom of all life. Everybody else had their illusion, must have their illusion, their before and after. But he, with a perfect stoicism, did without any before and after, dispensed with all illusion. He did not deceive himself in the last issue. In the last issue he cared about nothing, he was troubled about nothing, he made not the slightest attempt to be at one with anything. He existed a pure, unconnected will, stoical and momentaneous. There was only his work.

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XI THE TEST ON MIRIAM

    He sat silent in bitterness. At last the whole affair appeared in a cynical aspect to him. She had really played with him, not he with her. She had hidden all her condemnation from him, had flattered him, and despised him. She despised him now. He grew intellectual and cruel. “You ought to marry a man who worships you,” he said; “then you could do as you liked with him. Plenty of men will worship you, if you get on the private side of their natures. You ought to marry one such. They would never fight you off.” “Thank you!” she said. “But don’t advise me to marry someone else any more. You’ve done it before.” “Very well,” he said; “I will say no more.” He sat still, feeling as if he had had a blow, instead of giving one. Their eight years of friendship and love, the eight years of his life, were nullified. “When did you think of this?” she asked. “I thought definitely on Thursday night.” “I knew it was coming,” she said. That pleased him bitterly. “Oh, very well! If she knew then it doesn’t come as a surprise to her,” he thought. “And have you said anything to Clara?” she asked. “No; but I shall tell her now.” There was a silence. “Do you remember the things you said this time last year, in my grandmother’s house—nay last month even?” “Yes,” he said; “I do! And I meant them! I can’t help that it’s failed.” “It has failed because you want something else.”

    Read in context
  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXX. SNOWED UP

    She saw, by the dawning look on Loerke’s face, that he had understood. She was not Mrs Crich! So-o-, that explained a great deal. “Soll ich Fräulein sagen?” he asked, malevolently. “I am not married,” she said, with some hauteur. Her heart was fluttering now, beating like a bewildered bird. She knew she had dealt a cruel wound, and she could not bear it. Gerald sat erect, perfectly still, his face pale and calm, like the face of a statue. He was unaware of her, or of Loerke or anybody. He sat perfectly still, in an unalterable calm. Loerke, meanwhile, was crouching and glancing up from under his ducked head. Gudrun was tortured for something to say, to relieve the suspense. She twisted her face in a smile, and glanced knowingly, almost sneering, at Gerald. “Truth is best,” she said to him, with a grimace. But now again she was under his domination; now, because she had dealt him this blow; because she had destroyed him, and she did not know how he had taken it. She watched him. He was interesting to her. She had lost her interest in Loerke. Gerald rose at length, and went over in a leisurely still movement, to the Professor. The two began a conversation on Goethe. She was rather piqued by the simplicity of Gerald’s demeanour this evening. He did not seem angry or disgusted, only he looked curiously innocent and pure, really beautiful. Sometimes it came upon him, this look of clear distance, and it always fascinated her.

    Read in context
  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXX. SNOWED UP

    And all the while they two were hovering, hesitating round the flame of some invisible declaration. He wanted it, but was held back by some inevitable reluctance. She wanted it also, but she wanted to put it off, to put it off indefinitely, she still had some pity for Gerald, some connection with him. And the most fatal of all, she had the reminiscent sentimental compassion for herself in connection with him. Because of what had been, she felt herself held to him by immortal, invisible threads—because of what had been, because of his coming to her that first night, into her own house, in his extremity, because— Gerald was gradually overcome with a revulsion of loathing for Loerke. He did not take the man seriously, he despised him merely, except as he felt in Gudrun’s veins the influence of the little creature. It was this that drove Gerald wild, the feeling in Gudrun’s veins of Loerke’s presence, Loerke’s being, flowing dominant through her. “What makes you so smitten with that little vermin?” he asked, really puzzled. For he, man-like, could not see anything attractive or important at all in Loerke. Gerald expected to find some handsomeness or nobleness, to account for a woman’s subjection. But he saw none here, only an insect-like repulsiveness. Gudrun flushed deeply. It was these attacks she would never forgive. “What do you mean?” she replied. “My God, what a mercy I am not married to you!” Her voice of flouting and contempt scotched him. He was brought up short. But he recovered himself.

    Read in context
  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXIX. CONTINENTAL

    “Of course,” she said, turning to tease Loerke now, “you understood your little Malschülerin.” He raised his eyebrows and his shoulders in a complacent shrug. “The little girl?” asked Gerald, pointing to the figure. Gudrun was sitting with the picture in her lap. She looked up at Gerald, full into his eyes, so that he seemed to be blinded. “Didn’t he understand her!” she said to Gerald, in a slightly mocking, humorous playfulness. “You’ve only to look at the feet—aren’t they darling, so pretty and tender—oh, they’re really wonderful, they are really—” She lifted her eyes slowly, with a hot, flaming look into Loerke’s eyes. His soul was filled with her burning recognition, he seemed to grow more uppish and lordly. Gerald looked at the small, sculptured feet. They were turned together, half covering each other in pathetic shyness and fear. He looked at them a long time, fascinated. Then, in some pain, he put the picture away from him. He felt full of barrenness. “What was her name?” Gudrun asked Loerke. “Annette von Weck,” Loerke replied reminiscent. “Ja, sie war hübsch. She was pretty—but she was tiresome. She was a nuisance,—not for a minute would she keep still—not until I’d slapped her hard and made her cry—then she’d sit for five minutes.” He was thinking over the work, his work, the all important to him. “Did you really slap her?” asked Gudrun, coolly. He glanced back at her, reading her challenge.

    Read in context