Skip to content
BookLens

Women in Love

D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)

“Do you know what it is to suffer when you are with a woman? She’s so beautiful, so perfect, you find her so good, it tears you like a silk, and every stroke and bit cuts hot—ha, that perfection, when you blast yourself, you blast yourself! And then—” he stopped on the snow and suddenly opened his clenched hands—“it’s nothing—your brain might have gone charred as rags—and—” he looked round into the air with a queer histrionic movement “it’s blasting—you understand what I mean—it is a great experience, something final—and then—you’re shrivelled as if struck by electricity.” He walked on in silence. It seemed like bragging, but like a man in extremity bragging truthfully. “Of course,” he resumed, “I wouldn’t not have had it! It’s a complete experience. And she’s a wonderful woman. But—how I hate her somewhere! It’s curious—” Birkin looked at him, at his strange, scarcely conscious face. Gerald seemed blank before his own words. “But you’ve had enough now?” said Birkin. “You have had your experience. Why work on an old wound?” “Oh,” said Gerald, “I don’t know. It’s not finished—” And the two walked on. “I’ve loved you, as well as Gudrun, don’t forget,” said Birkin bitterly. Gerald looked at him strangely, abstractedly. “Have you?” he said, with icy scepticism. “Or do you think you have?” He was hardly responsible for what he said. The sledge came. Gudrun dismounted and they all made their farewell. They wanted to go apart, all of them. Birkin took his place, and the sledge drove away leaving Gudrun and Gerald standing on the snow, waving. Something froze Birkin’s heart, seeing them standing there in the isolation of the snow, growing smaller and more isolated.

When Ursula and Birkin were gone, Gudrun felt herself free in her contest with Gerald. As they grew more used to each other, he seemed to press upon her more and more. At first she could manage him, so that her own will was always left free. But very soon, he began to ignore her female tactics, he dropped his respect for her whims and her privacies, he began to exert his own will blindly, without submitting to hers. Already a vital conflict had set in, which frightened them both. But he was alone, whilst already she had begun to cast round for external resource. When Ursula had gone, Gudrun felt her own existence had become stark and elemental. She went and crouched alone in her bedroom, looking out of the window at the big, flashing stars. In front was the faint shadow of the mountain-knot. That was the pivot. She felt strange and inevitable, as if she were centred upon the pivot of all existence, there was no further reality. Presently Gerald opened the door. She knew he would not be long before he came. She was rarely alone, he pressed upon her like a frost, deadening her. “Are you alone in the dark?” he said. And she could tell by his tone he resented it, he resented this isolation she had drawn round herself. Yet, feeling static and inevitable, she was kind towards him. “Would you like to light the candle?” she asked. He did not answer, but came and stood behind her, in the darkness.

“Look,” she said, “at that lovely star up there. Do you know its name?” He crouched beside her, to look through the low window. “No,” he said. “It is very fine.” “Isn’t it beautiful! Do you notice how it darts different coloured fires—it flashes really superbly—” They remained in silence. With a mute, heavy gesture she put her hand on his knee, and took his hand. “Are you regretting Ursula?” he asked. “No, not at all,” she said. Then, in a slow mood, she asked: “How much do you love me?” He stiffened himself further against her. “How much do you think I do?” he asked. “I don’t know,” she replied. “But what is your opinion?” he asked. There was a pause. At length, in the darkness, came her voice, hard and indifferent: “Very little indeed,” she said coldly, almost flippant. His heart went icy at the sound of her voice. “Why don’t I love you?” he asked, as if admitting the truth of her accusation, yet hating her for it. “I don’t know why you don’t—I’ve been good to you. You were in a fearful state when you came to me.” Her heart was beating to suffocate her, yet she was strong and unrelenting. “When was I in a fearful state?” he asked. “When you first came to me. I had to take pity on you. But it was never love.” It was that statement “It was never love,” which sounded in his ears with madness.

“Why must you repeat it so often, that there is no love?” he said in a voice strangled with rage. “Well you don’t think you love, do you?” she asked. He was silent with cold passion of anger. “You don’t think you can love me, do you?” she repeated almost with a sneer. “No,” he said. “You know you never have loved me, don’t you?” “I don’t know what you mean by the word “love,” he replied. “Yes, you do. You know all right that you have never loved me. Have you, do you think?” “No,” he said, prompted by some barren spirit of truthfulness and obstinacy. “And you never will love me,” she said finally, “will you?” There was a diabolic coldness in her, too much to bear. “No,” he said. “Then,” she replied, “what have you against me!” He was silent in cold, frightened rage and despair. “If only I could kill her,” his heart was whispering repeatedly. “If only I could kill her—I should be free.” It seemed to him that death was the only severing of this Gordian knot. “Why do you torture me?” he said. She flung her arms round his neck.

“Ah, I don’t want to torture you,” she said pityingly, as if she were comforting a child. The impertinence made his veins go cold, he was insensible. She held her arms round his neck, in a triumph of pity. And her pity for him was as cold as stone, its deepest motive was hate of him, and fear of his power over her, which she must always counterfoil. “Say you love me,” she pleaded. “Say you will love me for ever—won’t you—won’t you?” But it was her voice only that coaxed him. Her senses were entirely apart from him, cold and destructive of him. It was her overbearing will that insisted. “Won’t you say you’ll love me always?” she coaxed. “Say it, even if it isn’t true—say it Gerald, do.” “I will love you always,” he repeated, in real agony, forcing the words out. She gave him a quick kiss. “Fancy your actually having said it,” she said with a touch of raillery. He stood as if he had been beaten. “Try to love me a little more, and to want me a little less,” she said, in a half contemptuous, half coaxing tone. The darkness seemed to be swaying in waves across his mind, great waves of darkness plunging across his mind. It seemed to him he was degraded at the very quick, made of no account. “You mean you don’t want me?” he said.

Passages expressing a similar idea

  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XI THE TEST ON MIRIAM

    “I love you an awful lot—then there is something short.” “Where?” she answered, looking at him. “Oh, in me! It is I who ought to be ashamed—like a spiritual cripple. And I am ashamed. It is misery. Why is it?” “I don’t know,” replied Miriam. “And I don’t know,” he repeated. “Don’t you think we have been too fierce in our what they call purity? Don’t you think that to be so much afraid and averse is a sort of dirtiness?” She looked at him with startled dark eyes. “You recoiled away from anything of the sort, and I took the motion from you, and recoiled also, perhaps worse.” There was silence in the room for some time. “Yes,” she said, “it is so.” “There is between us,” he said, “all these years of intimacy. I feel naked enough before you. Do you understand?” “I think so,” she answered. “And you love me?” She laughed. “Don’t be bitter,” he pleaded. She looked at him and was sorry for him; his eyes were dark with torture. She was sorry for him; it was worse for him to have this deflated love than for herself, who could never be properly mated. He was restless, for ever urging forward and trying to find a way out. He might do as he liked, and have what he liked of her. “Nay,” she said softly, “I am not bitter.”

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · PART TWO / CHAPTER VII LAD-AND-GIRL LOVE

    He turned and looked at her. She stood beside him, for ever in shadow. Her face, covered with the darkness of her hat, was watching him unseen. But she was brooding. She was slightly afraid—deeply moved and religious. That was her best state. He was impotent against it. His blood was concentrated like a flame in his chest. But he could not get across to her. There were flashes in his blood. But somehow she ignored them. She was expecting some religious state in him. Still yearning, she was half aware of his passion, and gazed at him, troubled. “What is it?” she murmured again. “It’s the moon,” he answered, frowning. “Yes,” she assented. “Isn’t it wonderful?” She was curious about him. The crisis was past. He did not know himself what was the matter. He was naturally so young, and their intimacy was so abstract, he did not know he wanted to crush her on to his breast to ease the ache there. He was afraid of her. The fact that he might want her as a man wants a woman had in him been suppressed into a shame. When she shrank in her convulsed, coiled torture from the thought of such a thing, he had winced to the depths of his soul. And now this “purity” prevented even their first love-kiss. It was as if she could scarcely stand the shock of physical love, even a passionate kiss, and then he was too shrinking and sensitive to give it.

    Read in context
  • The Rainbow · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · Chapter IV. GIRLHOOD OF ANNA BRANGWEN

    He was afraid. His heart quivered and broke. He was stopped. “Anna,” he said, as if he answered her from a distance, unsure. “My love.” And he drew near, and she drew near. “Anna,” he said, in wonder and the birthpain of love. “My love,” she said, her voice growing rapturous. And they kissed on the mouth, in rapture and surprise, long, real kisses. The kiss lasted, there among the moonlight. He kissed her again, and she kissed him. And again they were kissing together. Till something happened in him, he was strange. He wanted her. He wanted her exceedingly. She was something new. They stood there folded, suspended in the night. And his whole being quivered with surprise, as from a blow. He wanted her, and he wanted to tell her so. But the shock was too great to him. He had never realized before. He trembled with irritation and unusedness, he did not know what to do. He held her more gently, gently, much more gently. The conflict was gone by. And he was glad, and breathless, and almost in tears. But he knew he wanted her. Something fixed in him for ever. He was hers. And he was very glad and afraid. He did not know what to do, as they stood there in the open, moonlit field. He looked through her hair at the moon, which seemed to swim liquid-bright.

    Read in context
  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XIII. MINO

    “How nice the fuchsias are!” she said, to break the silence. “Aren’t they! Did you think I had forgotten what I said?” A swoon went over Ursula’s mind. “I don’t want you to remember it—if you don’t want to,” she struggled to say, through the dark mist that covered her. There was silence for some moments. “No,” he said. “It isn’t that. Only—if we are going to know each other, we must pledge ourselves for ever. If we are going to make a relationship, even of friendship, there must be something final and infallible about it.” There was a clang of mistrust and almost anger in his voice. She did not answer. Her heart was too much contracted. She could not have spoken. Seeing she was not going to reply, he continued, almost bitterly, giving himself away: “I can’t say it is love I have to offer—and it isn’t love I want. It is something much more impersonal and harder—and rarer.” There was a silence, out of which she said: “You mean you don’t love me?” She suffered furiously, saying that. “Yes, if you like to put it like that. Though perhaps that isn’t true. I don’t know. At any rate, I don’t feel the emotion of love for you—no, and I don’t want to. Because it gives out in the last issues.” “Love gives out in the last issues?” she asked, feeling numb to the lips.

    Read in context
  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XIX. MOONY

    The amount of truth that was in this made him stiff and unheeding of her. “I don’t mean let yourself go in the Dionysic ecstatic way,” he said. “I know you can do that. But I hate ecstasy, Dionysic or any other. It’s like going round in a squirrel cage. I want you not to care about yourself, just to be there and not to care about yourself, not to insist—be glad and sure and indifferent.” “Who insists?” she mocked. “Who is it that keeps on insisting? It isn’t me!” There was a weary, mocking bitterness in her voice. He was silent for some time. “I know,” he said. “While ever either of us insists to the other, we are all wrong. But there we are, the accord doesn’t come.” They sat in stillness under the shadow of the trees by the bank. The night was white around them, they were in the darkness, barely conscious. Gradually, the stillness and peace came over them. She put her hand tentatively on his. Their hands clasped softly and silently, in peace. “Do you really love me?” she said. He laughed. “I call that your war-cry,” he replied, amused. “Why!” she cried, amused and really wondering. “Your insistence—Your war-cry—“A Brangwen, A Brangwen”—an old battle-cry. Yours is, ‘Do you love me? Yield knave, or die.’” “No,” she said, pleading, “not like that. Not like that. But I must know that you love me, mustn’t I?” “Well then, know it and have done with it.” “But do you?”

    Read in context
  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XIII. MINO

    “We have all suffered so much,” he mocked, ironically. She looked up at him, and a flash of wild gaiety went over her face, a strange flash of yellow light coming from her eyes. “Haven’t we!” she cried, in a high, reckless cry. “It is almost absurd, isn’t it?” “Quite absurd,” he said. “Suffering bores me, any more.” “So it does me.” He was almost afraid of the mocking recklessness of her splendid face. Here was one who would go to the whole lengths of heaven or hell, whichever she had to go. And he mistrusted her, he was afraid of a woman capable of such abandon, such dangerous thoroughness of destructivity. Yet he chuckled within himself also. She came over to him and put her hand on his shoulder, looking down at him with strange golden-lighted eyes, very tender, but with a curious devilish look lurking underneath. “Say you love me, say ‘my love’ to me,” she pleaded. He looked back into her eyes, and saw. His face flickered with sardonic comprehension. “I love you right enough,” he said, grimly. “But I want it to be something else.” “But why? But why?” she insisted, bending her wonderful luminous face to him. “Why isn’t it enough?” “Because we can go one better,” he said, putting his arms round her. “No, we can’t,” she said, in a strong, voluptuous voice of yielding. “We can only love each other. Say ‘my love’ to me, say it, say it.” She put her arms round his neck. He enfolded her, and kissed her subtly, murmuring in a subtle voice of love, and irony, and submission: “Yes,—my love, yes,—my love. Let love be enough then. I love you then—I love you. I’m bored by the rest.” “Yes,” she murmured, nestling very sweet and close to him.

    Read in context