Women in Love
D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)
“One wants a new space to be in, I quite agree,” she said. “But I think that a new world is a development from this world, and that to isolate oneself with one other person, isn’t to find a new world at all, but only to secure oneself in one’s illusions.” Ursula looked out of the window. In her soul she began to wrestle, and she was frightened. She was always frightened of words, because she knew that mere word-force could always make her believe what she did not believe. “Perhaps,” she said, full of mistrust, of herself and everybody. “But,” she added, “I do think that one can’t have anything new whilst one cares for the old—do you know what I mean?—even fighting the old is belonging to it. I know, one is tempted to stop with the world, just to fight it. But then it isn’t worth it.” Gudrun considered herself. “Yes,” she said. “In a way, one is of the world if one lives in it. But isn’t it really an illusion to think you can get out of it? After all, a cottage in the Abruzzi, or wherever it may be, isn’t a new world. No, the only thing to do with the world, is to see it through.” Ursula looked away. She was so frightened of argument.
“But there can be something else, can’t there?” she said. “One can see it through in one’s soul, long enough before it sees itself through in actuality. And then, when one has seen one’s soul, one is something else.” “Can one see it through in one’s soul?” asked Gudrun. “If you mean that you can see to the end of what will happen, I don’t agree. I really can’t agree. And anyhow, you can’t suddenly fly off on to a new planet, because you think you can see to the end of this.” Ursula suddenly straightened herself. “Yes,” she said. “Yes—one knows. One has no more connections here. One has a sort of other self, that belongs to a new planet, not to this. You’ve got to hop off.” Gudrun reflected for a few moments. Then a smile of ridicule, almost of contempt, came over her face. “And what will happen when you find yourself in space?” she cried in derision. “After all, the great ideas of the world are the same there. You above everybody can’t get away from the fact that love, for instance, is the supreme thing, in space as well as on earth.” “No,” said Ursula, “it isn’t. Love is too human and little. I believe in something inhuman, of which love is only a little part. I believe what we must fulfil comes out of the unknown to us, and it is something infinitely more than love. It isn’t so merely human.”
Gudrun looked at Ursula with steady, balancing eyes. She admired and despised her sister so much, both! Then, suddenly she averted her face, saying coldly, uglily: “Well, I’ve got no further than love, yet.” Over Ursula’s mind flashed the thought: “Because you never have loved, you can’t get beyond it.” Gudrun rose, came over to Ursula and put her arm round her neck. “Go and find your new world, dear,” she said, her voice clanging with false benignity. “After all, the happiest voyage is the quest of Rupert’s Blessed Isles.” Her arm rested round Ursula’s neck, her fingers on Ursula’s cheek for a few moments. Ursula was supremely uncomfortable meanwhile. There was an insult in Gudrun’s protective patronage that was really too hurting. Feeling her sister’s resistance, Gudrun drew awkwardly away, turned over the pillow, and disclosed the stockings again. “Ha—ha!” she laughed, rather hollowly. “How we do talk indeed—new worlds and old—!” And they passed to the familiar worldly subjects. Gerald and Birkin had walked on ahead, waiting for the sledge to overtake them, conveying the departing guests. “How much longer will you stay here?” asked Birkin, glancing up at Gerald’s very red, almost blank face. “Oh, I can’t say,” Gerald replied. “Till we get tired of it.” “You’re not afraid of the snow melting first?” asked Birkin. Gerald laughed. “Does it melt?” he said. “Things are all right with you then?” said Birkin. Gerald screwed up his eyes a little.
“All right?” he said. “I never know what those common words mean. All right and all wrong, don’t they become synonymous, somewhere?” “Yes, I suppose. How about going back?” asked Birkin. “Oh, I don’t know. We may never get back. I don’t look before and after,” said Gerald. “Nor pine for what is not,” said Birkin. Gerald looked into the distance, with the small-pupilled, abstract eyes of a hawk. “No. There’s something final about this. And Gudrun seems like the end, to me. I don’t know—but she seems so soft, her skin like silk, her arms heavy and soft. And it withers my consciousness, somehow, it burns the pith of my mind.” He went on a few paces, staring ahead, his eyes fixed, looking like a mask used in ghastly religions of the barbarians. “It blasts your soul’s eye,” he said, “and leaves you sightless. Yet you want to be sightless, you want to be blasted, you don’t want it any different.” He was speaking as if in a trance, verbal and blank. Then suddenly he braced himself up with a kind of rhapsody, and looked at Birkin with vindictive, cowed eyes, saying:
“Do you know what it is to suffer when you are with a woman? She’s so beautiful, so perfect, you find her so good, it tears you like a silk, and every stroke and bit cuts hot—ha, that perfection, when you blast yourself, you blast yourself! And then—” he stopped on the snow and suddenly opened his clenched hands—“it’s nothing—your brain might have gone charred as rags—and—” he looked round into the air with a queer histrionic movement “it’s blasting—you understand what I mean—it is a great experience, something final—and then—you’re shrivelled as if struck by electricity.” He walked on in silence. It seemed like bragging, but like a man in extremity bragging truthfully. “Of course,” he resumed, “I wouldn’t not have had it! It’s a complete experience. And she’s a wonderful woman. But—how I hate her somewhere! It’s curious—” Birkin looked at him, at his strange, scarcely conscious face. Gerald seemed blank before his own words. “But you’ve had enough now?” said Birkin. “You have had your experience. Why work on an old wound?” “Oh,” said Gerald, “I don’t know. It’s not finished—” And the two walked on. “I’ve loved you, as well as Gudrun, don’t forget,” said Birkin bitterly. Gerald looked at him strangely, abstractedly. “Have you?” he said, with icy scepticism. “Or do you think you have?” He was hardly responsible for what he said. The sledge came. Gudrun dismounted and they all made their farewell. They wanted to go apart, all of them. Birkin took his place, and the sledge drove away leaving Gudrun and Gerald standing on the snow, waving. Something froze Birkin’s heart, seeing them standing there in the isolation of the snow, growing smaller and more isolated.
Passages expressing a similar idea
Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXVII. FLITTING
“What did Rupert say—do you know?” she asked. “He said it would be most awfully jolly,” said Ursula. Again Gudrun looked down, and was silent. “Don’t you think it would?” said Ursula, tentatively. She was never quite sure how many defences Gudrun was having round herself. Gudrun raised her face with difficulty and held it averted. “I think it might be awfully jolly, as you say,” she replied. “But don’t you think it was an unpardonable liberty to take—to talk of such things to Rupert—who after all—you see what I mean, Ursula—they might have been two men arranging an outing with some little type they’d picked up. Oh, I think it’s unforgivable, quite!” She used the French word “type.” Her eyes flashed, her soft face was flushed and sullen. Ursula looked on, rather frightened, frightened most of all because she thought Gudrun seemed rather common, really like a little type. But she had not the courage quite to think this—not right out. “Oh no,” she cried, stammering. “Oh no—not at all like that—oh no! No, I think it’s rather beautiful, the friendship between Rupert and Gerald. They just are simple—they say anything to each other, like brothers.” Gudrun flushed deeper. She could not bear it that Gerald gave her away—even to Birkin. “But do you think even brothers have any right to exchange confidences of that sort?” she asked, with deep anger.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XIV. WATER-PARTY
When they had finished tea, the two girls sat on, silent and serene. Then Ursula, who had a beautiful strong voice, began to sing to herself, softly: “Ännchen von Tharau.” Gudrun listened, as she sat beneath the trees, and the yearning came into her heart. Ursula seemed so peaceful and sufficient unto herself, sitting there unconsciously crooning her song, strong and unquestioned at the centre of her own universe. And Gudrun felt herself outside. Always this desolating, agonised feeling, that she was outside of life, an onlooker, whilst Ursula was a partaker, caused Gudrun to suffer from a sense of her own negation, and made her, that she must always demand the other to be aware of her, to be in connection with her. “Do you mind if I do Dalcroze to that tune, Hurtler?” she asked in a curious muted tone, scarce moving her lips. “What did you say?” asked Ursula, looking up in peaceful surprise. “Will you sing while I do Dalcroze?” said Gudrun, suffering at having to repeat herself. Ursula thought a moment, gathering her straying wits together. “While you do—?” she asked vaguely. “Dalcroze movements,” said Gudrun, suffering tortures of self-consciousness, even because of her sister. “Oh Dalcroze! I couldn’t catch the name. Do—I should love to see you,” cried Ursula, with childish surprised brightness. “What shall I sing?” “Sing anything you like, and I’ll take the rhythm from it.” But Ursula could not for her life think of anything to sing. However, she suddenly began, in a laughing, teasing voice: “My love—is a high-born lady—”
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER I. SISTERS
Gudrun’s face hardened. “Do you really want children, Ursula?” she asked coldly. A dazzled, baffled look came on Ursula’s face. “One feels it is still beyond one,” she said. “Do you feel like that?” asked Gudrun. “I get no feeling whatever from the thought of bearing children.” Gudrun looked at Ursula with a masklike, expressionless face. Ursula knitted her brows. “Perhaps it isn’t genuine,” she faltered. “Perhaps one doesn’t really want them, in one’s soul—only superficially.” A hardness came over Gudrun’s face. She did not want to be too definite. “When one thinks of other people’s children—” said Ursula. Again Gudrun looked at her sister, almost hostile. “Exactly,” she said, to close the conversation. The two sisters worked on in silence, Ursula having always that strange brightness of an essential flame that is caught, meshed, contravened. She lived a good deal by herself, to herself, working, passing on from day to day, and always thinking, trying to lay hold on life, to grasp it in her own understanding. Her active living was suspended, but underneath, in the darkness, something was coming to pass. If only she could break through the last integuments! She seemed to try and put her hands out, like an infant in the womb, and she could not, not yet. Still she had a strange prescience, an intimation of something yet to come.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXI. THRESHOLD
“Yes,” Gerald looked at Gudrun, who sat by his side, and he said, his eyes narrowly laughing, “I want to know whether I ought to congratulate him, but I can’t get anything definite out of him.” Gudrun flushed deeply. “Congratulate him on what?” she asked. “There was some mention of an engagement—at least, he said something to me about it.” Gudrun flushed darkly. “You mean with Ursula?” she said, in challenge. “Yes. That is so, isn’t it?” “I don’t think there’s any engagement,” said Gudrun, coldly. “That so? Still no developments, Rupert?” he called. “Where? Matrimonial? No.” “How’s that?” called Gudrun. Birkin glanced quickly round. There was irritation in his eyes also. “Why?” he replied. “What do you think of it, Gudrun?” “Oh,” she cried, determined to fling her stone also into the pool, since they had begun, “I don’t think she wants an engagement. Naturally, she’s a bird that prefers the bush.” Gudrun’s voice was clear and gong-like. It reminded Rupert of her father’s, so strong and vibrant. “And I,” said Birkin, his face playful but yet determined, “I want a binding contract, and am not keen on love, particularly free love.” They were both amused. Why this public avowal? Gerald seemed suspended a moment, in amusement. “Love isn’t good enough for you?” he called. “No!” shouted Birkin. “Ha, well that’s being over-refined,” said Gerald, and the car ran through the mud. “What’s the matter, really?” said Gerald, turning to Gudrun.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER VIII. BREADALBY
There was Gerald, an amused look on his face; the game pleased him. There was Gudrun, watching with steady, large, hostile eyes; the game fascinated her, and she loathed it. There was Ursula, with a slightly startled look on her face, as if she were hurt, and the pain were just outside her consciousness. Suddenly Birkin got up and went out. “That’s enough,” he said to himself involuntarily. Hermione knew his motion, though not in her consciousness. She lifted her heavy eyes and saw him lapse suddenly away, on a sudden, unknown tide, and the waves broke over her. Only her indomitable will remained static and mechanical, she sat at the table making her musing, stray remarks. But the darkness had covered her, she was like a ship that has gone down. It was finished for her too, she was wrecked in the darkness. Yet the unfailing mechanism of her will worked on, she had that activity. “Shall we bathe this morning?” she said, suddenly looking at them all. “Splendid,” said Joshua. “It is a perfect morning.” “Oh, it is beautiful,” said Fräulein. “Yes, let us bathe,” said the Italian woman. “We have no bathing suits,” said Gerald. “Have mine,” said Alexander. “I must go to church and read the lessons. They expect me.” “Are you a Christian?” asked the Italian Countess, with sudden interest. “No,” said Alexander. “I’m not. But I believe in keeping up the old institutions.” “They are so beautiful,” said Fräulein daintily. “Oh, they are,” cried Miss Bradley.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER I. SISTERS
Gudrun went on her way half dazed. If this were human life, if these were human beings, living in a complete world, then what was her own world, outside? She was aware of her grass-green stockings, her large grass-green velour hat, her full soft coat, of a strong blue colour. And she felt as if she were treading in the air, quite unstable, her heart was contracted, as if at any minute she might be precipitated to the ground. She was afraid. She clung to Ursula, who, through long usage was inured to this violation of a dark, uncreated, hostile world. But all the time her heart was crying, as if in the midst of some ordeal: “I want to go back, I want to go away, I want not to know it, not to know that this exists.” Yet she must go forward. Ursula could feel her suffering. “You hate this, don’t you?” she asked. “It bewilders me,” stammered Gudrun. “You won’t stay long,” replied Ursula. And Gudrun went along, grasping at release.
Read in context