Skip to content
BookLens

Women in Love

D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)

Her limbs were young and tender. Her legs, scarcely formed yet, the legs of a maiden just passing towards cruel womanhood, dangled childishly over the side of the powerful horse, pathetically, the small feet folded one over the other, as if to hide. But there was no hiding. There she was exposed naked on the naked flank of the horse. The horse stood stock still, stretched in a kind of start. It was a massive, magnificent stallion, rigid with pent-up power. Its neck was arched and terrible, like a sickle, its flanks were pressed back, rigid with power. Gudrun went pale, and a darkness came over her eyes, like shame, she looked up with a certain supplication, almost slave-like. He glanced at her, and jerked his head a little. “How big is it?” she asked, in a toneless voice, persisting in appearing casual and unaffected. “How big?” he replied, glancing again at her. “Without pedestal—so high—” he measured with his hand—“with pedestal, so—” He looked at her steadily. There was a little brusque, turgid contempt for her in his swift gesture, and she seemed to cringe a little. “And what is it done in?” she asked, throwing back her head and looking at him with affected coldness. He still gazed at her steadily, and his dominance was not shaken. “Bronze—green bronze.” “Green bronze!” repeated Gudrun, coldly accepting his challenge. She was thinking of the slender, immature, tender limbs of the girl, smooth and cold in green bronze. “Yes, beautiful,” she murmured, looking up at him with a certain dark homage.

He closed his eyes and looked aside, triumphant. “Why,” said Ursula, “did you make the horse so stiff? It is as stiff as a block.” “Stiff?” he repeated, in arms at once. “Yes. Look how stock and stupid and brutal it is. Horses are sensitive, quite delicate and sensitive, really.” He raised his shoulders, spread his hands in a shrug of slow indifference, as much as to inform her she was an amateur and an impertinent nobody. “Wissen Sie,” he said, with an insulting patience and condescension in his voice, “that horse is a certain form, part of a whole form. It is part of a work of art, a piece of form. It is not a picture of a friendly horse to which you give a lump of sugar, do you see—it is part of a work of art, it has no relation to anything outside that work of art.” Ursula, angry at being treated quite so insultingly de haut en bas, from the height of esoteric art to the depth of general exoteric amateurism, replied, hotly, flushing and lifting her face. “But it is a picture of a horse, nevertheless.” He lifted his shoulders in another shrug. “As you like—it is not a picture of a cow, certainly.” Here Gudrun broke in, flushed and brilliant, anxious to avoid any more of this, any more of Ursula’s foolish persistence in giving herself away.

“What do you mean by ‘it is a picture of a horse?’” she cried at her sister. “What do you mean by a horse? You mean an idea you have in your head, and which you want to see represented. There is another idea altogether, quite another idea. Call it a horse if you like, or say it is not a horse. I have just as much right to say that your horse isn’t a horse, that it is a falsity of your own make-up.” Ursula wavered, baffled. Then her words came. “But why does he have this idea of a horse?” she said. “I know it is his idea. I know it is a picture of himself, really—” Loerke snorted with rage. “A picture of myself!” he repeated, in derision. “Wissen sie, gnädige Frau, that is a Kunstwerk, a work of art. It is a work of art, it is a picture of nothing, of absolutely nothing. It has nothing to do with anything but itself, it has no relation with the everyday world of this and other, there is no connection between them, absolutely none, they are two different and distinct planes of existence, and to translate one into the other is worse than foolish, it is a darkening of all counsel, a making confusion everywhere. Do you see, you must not confuse the relative work of action, with the absolute world of art. That you must not do.”

“That is quite true,” cried Gudrun, let loose in a sort of rhapsody. “The two things are quite and permanently apart, they have nothing to do with one another. I and my art, they have nothing to do with each other. My art stands in another world, I am in this world.” Her face was flushed and transfigured. Loerke who was sitting with his head ducked, like some creature at bay, looked up at her, swiftly, almost furtively, and murmured, “Ja—so ist es, so ist es.” Ursula was silent after this outburst. She was furious. She wanted to poke a hole into them both. “It isn’t a word of it true, of all this harangue you have made me,” she replied flatly. “The horse is a picture of your own stock, stupid brutality, and the girl was a girl you loved and tortured and then ignored.” He looked up at her with a small smile of contempt in his eyes. He would not trouble to answer this last charge. Gudrun too was silent in exasperated contempt. Ursula was such an insufferable outsider, rushing in where angels would fear to tread. But then—fools must be suffered, if not gladly. But Ursula was persistent too.

“As for your world of art and your world of reality,” she replied, “you have to separate the two, because you can’t bear to know what you are. You can’t bear to realise what a stock, stiff, hide-bound brutality you are really, so you say ‘it’s the world of art.’ The world of art is only the truth about the real world, that’s all—but you are too far gone to see it.” She was white and trembling, intent. Gudrun and Loerke sat in stiff dislike of her. Gerald too, who had come up in the beginning of the speech, stood looking at her in complete disapproval and opposition. He felt she was undignified, she put a sort of vulgarity over the esotericism which gave man his last distinction. He joined his forces with the other two. They all three wanted her to go away. But she sat on in silence, her soul weeping, throbbing violently, her fingers twisting her handkerchief. The others maintained a dead silence, letting the display of Ursula’s obtrusiveness pass by. Then Gudrun asked, in a voice that was quite cool and casual, as if resuming a casual conversation: “Was the girl a model?” “Nein, sie war kein Modell. Sie war eine kleine Malschülerin.” “An art-student!” replied Gudrun.

Passages expressing a similar idea

  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXIX. CONTINENTAL

    He closed his eyes and looked aside, triumphant. “Why,” said Ursula, “did you make the horse so stiff? It is as stiff as a block.” “Stiff?” he repeated, in arms at once. “Yes. Look how stock and stupid and brutal it is. Horses are sensitive, quite delicate and sensitive, really.” He raised his shoulders, spread his hands in a shrug of slow indifference, as much as to inform her she was an amateur and an impertinent nobody. “Wissen Sie,” he said, with an insulting patience and condescension in his voice, “that horse is a certain form, part of a whole form. It is part of a work of art, a piece of form. It is not a picture of a friendly horse to which you give a lump of sugar, do you see—it is part of a work of art, it has no relation to anything outside that work of art.” Ursula, angry at being treated quite so insultingly de haut en bas, from the height of esoteric art to the depth of general exoteric amateurism, replied, hotly, flushing and lifting her face. “But it is a picture of a horse, nevertheless.” He lifted his shoulders in another shrug. “As you like—it is not a picture of a cow, certainly.” Here Gudrun broke in, flushed and brilliant, anxious to avoid any more of this, any more of Ursula’s foolish persistence in giving herself away.

    Read in context
  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXIX. CONTINENTAL

    “That is quite true,” cried Gudrun, let loose in a sort of rhapsody. “The two things are quite and permanently apart, they have nothing to do with one another. I and my art, they have nothing to do with each other. My art stands in another world, I am in this world.” Her face was flushed and transfigured. Loerke who was sitting with his head ducked, like some creature at bay, looked up at her, swiftly, almost furtively, and murmured, “Ja—so ist es, so ist es.” Ursula was silent after this outburst. She was furious. She wanted to poke a hole into them both. “It isn’t a word of it true, of all this harangue you have made me,” she replied flatly. “The horse is a picture of your own stock, stupid brutality, and the girl was a girl you loved and tortured and then ignored.” He looked up at her with a small smile of contempt in his eyes. He would not trouble to answer this last charge. Gudrun too was silent in exasperated contempt. Ursula was such an insufferable outsider, rushing in where angels would fear to tread. But then—fools must be suffered, if not gladly. But Ursula was persistent too.

    Read in context
  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XII. CARPETING

    “I do think—I do really think we must have the courage to use the lower animal life for our needs. I do think there is something wrong, when we look on every living creature as if it were ourselves. I do feel, that it is false to project our own feelings on every animate creature. It is a lack of discrimination, a lack of criticism.” “Quite,” said Birkin sharply. “Nothing is so detestable as the maudlin attributing of human feelings and consciousness to animals.” “Yes,” said Hermione, wearily, “we must really take a position. Either we are going to use the animals, or they will use us.” “That’s a fact,” said Gerald. “A horse has got a will like a man, though it has no mind strictly. And if your will isn’t master, then the horse is master of you. And this is a thing I can’t help. I can’t help being master of the horse.” “If only we could learn how to use our will,” said Hermione, “we could do anything. The will can cure anything, and put anything right. That I am convinced of—if only we use the will properly, intelligibly.” “What do you mean by using the will properly?” said Birkin. “A very great doctor taught me,” she said, addressing Ursula and Gerald vaguely. “He told me for instance, that to cure oneself of a bad habit, one should force oneself to do it, when one would not do it—make oneself do it—and then the habit would disappear.” “How do you mean?” said Gerald.

    Read in context
  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XII. CARPETING

    “Why should a horse want to put itself in the human power?” asked Ursula. “That is quite incomprehensible to me. I don’t believe it ever wanted it.” “Yes it did. It’s the last, perhaps highest, love-impulse: resign your will to the higher being,” said Birkin. “What curious notions you have of love,” jeered Ursula. “And woman is the same as horses: two wills act in opposition inside her. With one will, she wants to subject herself utterly. With the other she wants to bolt, and pitch her rider to perdition.” “Then I’m a bolter,” said Ursula, with a burst of laughter. “It’s a dangerous thing to domesticate even horses, let alone women,” said Birkin. “The dominant principle has some rare antagonists.” “Good thing too,” said Ursula. “Quite,” said Gerald, with a faint smile. “There’s more fun.” Hermione could bear no more. She rose, saying in her easy sing-song: “Isn’t the evening beautiful! I get filled sometimes with such a great sense of beauty, that I feel I can hardly bear it.” Ursula, to whom she had appealed, rose with her, moved to the last impersonal depths. And Birkin seemed to her almost a monster of hateful arrogance. She went with Hermione along the bank of the pond, talking of beautiful, soothing things, picking the gentle cowslips. “Wouldn’t you like a dress,” said Ursula to Hermione, “of this yellow spotted with orange—a cotton dress?” “Yes,” said Hermione, stopping and looking at the flower, letting the thought come home to her and soothe her. “Wouldn’t it be pretty? I should love it.”

    Read in context
  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXIX. CONTINENTAL

    “What does he say?” she asked Ursula. And Ursula translated, stammering and brief. Loerke watched Gudrun’s face, to see her judgment. “And do you think then,” said Gudrun, “that art should serve industry?” “Art should interpret industry, as art once interpreted religion,” he said. “But does your fair interpret industry?” she asked him. “Certainly. What is man doing, when he is at a fair like this? He is fulfilling the counterpart of labour—the machine works him, instead of he the machine. He enjoys the mechanical motion, in his own body.” “But is there nothing but work—mechanical work?” said Gudrun. “Nothing but work!” he repeated, leaning forward, his eyes two darknesses, with needle-points of light. “No, it is nothing but this, serving a machine, or enjoying the motion of a machine—motion, that is all. You have never worked for hunger, or you would know what god governs us.” Gudrun quivered and flushed. For some reason she was almost in tears. “No, I have not worked for hunger,” she replied, “but I have worked!” “Travaillé—lavorato?” he asked. “E che lavoro—che lavoro? Quel travail est-ce que vous avez fait?” He broke into a mixture of Italian and French, instinctively using a foreign language when he spoke to her. “You have never worked as the world works,” he said to her, with sarcasm. “Yes,” she said. “I have. And I do—I work now for my daily bread.” He paused, looked at her steadily, then dropped the subject entirely. She seemed to him to be trifling.

    Read in context
  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XII. CARPETING

    “I’m sure it isn’t,” she said at length. There always seemed an interval, a strange split between what she seemed to feel and experience, and what she actually said and thought. She seemed to catch her thoughts at length from off the surface of a maelstrom of chaotic black emotions and reactions, and Birkin was always filled with repulsion, she caught so infallibly, her will never failed her. Her voice was always dispassionate and tense, and perfectly confident. Yet she shuddered with a sense of nausea, a sort of seasickness that always threatened to overwhelm her mind. But her mind remained unbroken, her will was still perfect. It almost sent Birkin mad. But he would never, never dare to break her will, and let loose the maelstrom of her subconsciousness, and see her in her ultimate madness. Yet he was always striking at her. “And of course,” he said to Gerald, “horses haven’t got a complete will, like human beings. A horse has no one will. Every horse, strictly, has two wills. With one will, it wants to put itself in the human power completely—and with the other, it wants to be free, wild. The two wills sometimes lock—you know that, if ever you’ve felt a horse bolt, while you’ve been driving it.” “I have felt a horse bolt while I was driving it,” said Gerald, “but it didn’t make me know it had two wills. I only knew it was frightened.” Hermione had ceased to listen. She simply became oblivious when these subjects were started.

    Read in context