Women in Love
D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)
In the new, superfine bliss, a peace superseding knowledge, there was no I and you, there was only the third, unrealised wonder, the wonder of existing not as oneself, but in a consummation of my being and of her being in a new one, a new, paradisal unit regained from the duality. Nor can I say “I love you,” when I have ceased to be, and you have ceased to be: we are both caught up and transcended into a new oneness where everything is silent, because there is nothing to answer, all is perfect and at one. Speech travels between the separate parts. But in the perfect One there is perfect silence of bliss. They were married by law on the next day, and she did as he bade her, she wrote to her father and mother. Her mother replied, not her father. She did not go back to school. She stayed with Birkin in his rooms, or at the Mill, moving with him as he moved. But she did not see anybody, save Gudrun and Gerald. She was all strange and wondering as yet, but relieved as by dawn. Gerald sat talking to her one afternoon in the warm study down at the Mill. Rupert had not yet come home. “You are happy?” Gerald asked her, with a smile. “Very happy!” she cried, shrinking a little in her brightness. “Yes, one can see it.” “Can one?” cried Ursula in surprise. He looked up at her with a communicative smile. “Oh yes, plainly.”
She was pleased. She meditated a moment. “And can you see that Rupert is happy as well?” He lowered his eyelids, and looked aside. “Oh yes,” he said. “Really!” “Oh yes.” He was very quiet, as if it were something not to be talked about by him. He seemed sad. She was very sensitive to suggestion. She asked the question he wanted her to ask. “Why don’t you be happy as well?” she said. “You could be just the same.” He paused a moment. “With Gudrun?” he asked. “Yes!” she cried, her eyes glowing. But there was a strange tension, an emphasis, as if they were asserting their wishes, against the truth. “You think Gudrun would have me, and we should be happy?” he said. “Yes, I’m sure!” she cried. Her eyes were round with delight. Yet underneath she was constrained, she knew her own insistence. “Oh, I’m so glad,” she added. He smiled. “What makes you glad?” he said. “For her sake,” she replied. “I’m sure you’d—you’re the right man for her.” “You are?” he said. “And do you think she would agree with you?” “Oh yes!” she exclaimed hastily. Then, upon reconsideration, very uneasy: “Though Gudrun isn’t so very simple, is she? One doesn’t know her in five minutes, does one? She’s not like me in that.” She laughed at him with her strange, open, dazzled face. “You think she’s not much like you?” Gerald asked. She knitted her brows. “Oh, in many ways she is. But I never know what she will do when anything new comes.”
“You don’t?” said Gerald. He was silent for some moments. Then he moved tentatively. “I was going to ask her, in any case, to go away with me at Christmas,” he said, in a very small, cautious voice. “Go away with you? For a time, you mean?” “As long as she likes,” he said, with a deprecating movement. They were both silent for some minutes. “Of course,” said Ursula at last, “she might just be willing to rush into marriage. You can see.” “Yes,” smiled Gerald. “I can see. But in case she won’t—do you think she would go abroad with me for a few days—or for a fortnight?” “Oh yes,” said Ursula. “I’d ask her.” “Do you think we might all go together?” “All of us?” Again Ursula’s face lighted up. “It would be rather fun, don’t you think?” “Great fun,” he said. “And then you could see,” said Ursula. “What?” “How things went. I think it is best to take the honeymoon before the wedding—don’t you?” She was pleased with this mot. He laughed. “In certain cases,” he said. “I’d rather it were so in my own case.” “Would you!” exclaimed Ursula. Then doubtingly, “Yes, perhaps you’re right. One should please oneself.” Birkin came in a little later, and Ursula told him what had been said. “Gudrun!” exclaimed Birkin. “She’s a born mistress, just as Gerald is a born lover—amant en titre. If as somebody says all women are either wives or mistresses, then Gudrun is a mistress.”
“And all men either lovers or husbands,” cried Ursula. “But why not both?” “The one excludes the other,” he laughed. “Then I want a lover,” cried Ursula. “No you don’t,” he said. “But I do,” she wailed. He kissed her, and laughed. It was two days after this that Ursula was to go to fetch her things from the house in Beldover. The removal had taken place, the family had gone. Gudrun had rooms in Willey Green. Ursula had not seen her parents since her marriage. She wept over the rupture, yet what was the good of making it up! Good or not good, she could not go to them. So her things had been left behind and she and Gudrun were to walk over for them, in the afternoon. It was a wintry afternoon, with red in the sky, when they arrived at the house. The windows were dark and blank, already the place was frightening. A stark, void entrance-hall struck a chill to the hearts of the girls. “I don’t believe I dare have come in alone,” said Ursula. “It frightens me.” “Ursula!” cried Gudrun. “Isn’t it amazing! Can you believe you lived in this place and never felt it? How I lived here a day without dying of terror, I cannot conceive!” They looked in the big dining-room. It was a good-sized room, but now a cell would have been lovelier. The large bay windows were naked, the floor was stripped, and a border of dark polish went round the tract of pale boarding.
In the faded wallpaper were dark patches where furniture had stood, where pictures had hung. The sense of walls, dry, thin, flimsy-seeming walls, and a flimsy flooring, pale with its artificial black edges, was neutralising to the mind. Everything was null to the senses, there was enclosure without substance, for the walls were dry and papery. Where were they standing, on earth, or suspended in some cardboard box? In the hearth was burnt paper, and scraps of half-burnt paper. “Imagine that we passed our days here!” said Ursula. “I know,” cried Gudrun. “It is too appalling. What must we be like, if we are the contents of this!” “Vile!” said Ursula. “It really is.” And she recognised half-burnt covers of “Vogue”—half-burnt representations of women in gowns—lying under the grate. They went to the drawing-room. Another piece of shut-in air; without weight or substance, only a sense of intolerable papery imprisonment in nothingness. The kitchen did look more substantial, because of the red-tiled floor and the stove, but it was cold and horrid. The two girls tramped hollowly up the bare stairs. Every sound re-echoed under their hearts. They tramped down the bare corridor. Against the wall of Ursula’s bedroom were her things—a trunk, a work-basket, some books, loose coats, a hat-box, standing desolate in the universal emptiness of the dusk. “A cheerful sight, aren’t they?” said Ursula, looking down at her forsaken possessions. “Very cheerful,” said Gudrun.
Passages expressing a similar idea
Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXVII. FLITTING
“Oh yes,” said Ursula. “There’s never anything said that isn’t perfectly straightforward. No, the thing that’s amazed me most in Gerald—how perfectly simple and direct he can be! And you know, it takes rather a big man. Most of them must be indirect, they are such cowards.” But Gudrun was still silent with anger. She wanted the absolute secrecy kept, with regard to her movements. “Won’t you go?” said Ursula. “Do, we might all be so happy! There is something I love about Gerald—he’s much more lovable than I thought him. He’s free, Gudrun, he really is.” Gudrun’s mouth was still closed, sullen and ugly. She opened it at length. “Do you know where he proposes to go?” she asked. “Yes—to the Tyrol, where he used to go when he was in Germany—a lovely place where students go, small and rough and lovely, for winter sport!” Through Gudrun’s mind went the angry thought—“they know everything.” “Yes,” she said aloud, “about forty kilometres from Innsbruck, isn’t it?” “I don’t know exactly where—but it would be lovely, don’t you think, high in the perfect snow—?” “Very lovely!” said Gudrun, sarcastically. Ursula was put out. “Of course,” she said, “I think Gerald spoke to Rupert so that it shouldn’t seem like an outing with a type—” “I know, of course,” said Gudrun, “that he quite commonly does take up with that sort.” “Does he!” said Ursula. “Why how do you know?” “I know of a model in Chelsea,” said Gudrun coldly. Now Ursula was silent. “Well,” she said at last, with a doubtful laugh, “I hope he has a good time with her.” At which Gudrun looked more glum.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXV. MARRIAGE OR NOT
The Brangwen family was going to move from Beldover. It was necessary now for the father to be in town. Birkin had taken out a marriage licence, yet Ursula deferred from day to day. She would not fix any definite time—she still wavered. Her month’s notice to leave the Grammar School was in its third week. Christmas was not far off. Gerald waited for the Ursula-Birkin marriage. It was something crucial to him. “Shall we make it a double-barrelled affair?” he said to Birkin one day. “Who for the second shot?” asked Birkin. “Gudrun and me,” said Gerald, the venturesome twinkle in his eyes. Birkin looked at him steadily, as if somewhat taken aback. “Serious—or joking?” he asked. “Oh, serious. Shall I? Shall Gudrun and I rush in along with you?” “Do by all means,” said Birkin. “I didn’t know you’d got that length.” “What length?” said Gerald, looking at the other man, and laughing. “Oh yes, we’ve gone all the lengths.” “There remains to put it on a broad social basis, and to achieve a high moral purpose,” said Birkin. “Something like that: the length and breadth and height of it,” replied Gerald, smiling. “Oh well,” said Birkin, “it’s a very admirable step to take, I should say.” Gerald looked at him closely. “Why aren’t you enthusiastic?” he asked. “I thought you were such dead nuts on marriage.” Birkin lifted his shoulders. “One might as well be dead nuts on noses. There are all sorts of noses, snub and otherwise—” Gerald laughed.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXI. THRESHOLD
This was an assumption of a sort of intimacy that irritated Gudrun almost like an affront. It seemed to her that Gerald was deliberately insulting her, and infringing on the decent privacy of them all. “What is it?” she said, in her high, repellent voice. “Don’t ask me!—I know nothing about ultimate marriage, I assure you: or even penultimate.” “Only the ordinary unwarrantable brand!” replied Gerald. “Just so—same here. I am no expert on marriage, and degrees of ultimateness. It seems to be a bee that buzzes loudly in Rupert’s bonnet.” “Exactly! But that is his trouble, exactly! Instead of wanting a woman for herself, he wants his ideas fulfilled. Which, when it comes to actual practice, is not good enough.” “Oh no. Best go slap for what’s womanly in woman, like a bull at a gate.” Then he seemed to glimmer in himself. “You think love is the ticket, do you?” he asked. “Certainly, while it lasts—you only can’t insist on permanency,” came Gudrun’s voice, strident above the noise. “Marriage or no marriage, ultimate or penultimate or just so-so?—take the love as you find it.” “As you please, or as you don’t please,” she echoed. “Marriage is a social arrangement, I take it, and has nothing to do with the question of love.” His eyes were flickering on her all the time. She felt as is he were kissing her freely and malevolently. It made the colour burn in her cheeks, but her heart was quite firm and unfailing.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXI. THRESHOLD
“You think Rupert is off his head a bit?” Gerald asked. Her eyes flashed with acknowledgment. “As regards a woman, yes,” she said, “I do. There is such a thing as two people being in love for the whole of their lives—perhaps. But marriage is neither here nor there, even then. If they are in love, well and good. If not—why break eggs about it!” “Yes,” said Gerald. “That’s how it strikes me. But what about Rupert?” “I can’t make out—neither can he nor anybody. He seems to think that if you marry you can get through marriage into a third heaven, or something—all very vague.” “Very! And who wants a third heaven? As a matter of fact, Rupert has a great yearning to be safe—to tie himself to the mast.” “Yes. It seems to me he’s mistaken there too,” said Gudrun. “I’m sure a mistress is more likely to be faithful than a wife—just because she is her own mistress. No—he says he believes that a man and wife can go further than any other two beings—but where, is not explained. They can know each other, heavenly and hellish, but particularly hellish, so perfectly that they go beyond heaven and hell—into—there it all breaks down—into nowhere.” “Into Paradise, he says,” laughed Gerald. Gudrun shrugged her shoulders. “Je m’en fiche of your Paradise!” she said. “Not being a Mohammedan,” said Gerald. Birkin sat motionless, driving the car, quite unconscious of what they said. And Gudrun, sitting immediately behind him, felt a sort of ironic pleasure in thus exposing him.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXI. THRESHOLD
“Yes,” Gerald looked at Gudrun, who sat by his side, and he said, his eyes narrowly laughing, “I want to know whether I ought to congratulate him, but I can’t get anything definite out of him.” Gudrun flushed deeply. “Congratulate him on what?” she asked. “There was some mention of an engagement—at least, he said something to me about it.” Gudrun flushed darkly. “You mean with Ursula?” she said, in challenge. “Yes. That is so, isn’t it?” “I don’t think there’s any engagement,” said Gudrun, coldly. “That so? Still no developments, Rupert?” he called. “Where? Matrimonial? No.” “How’s that?” called Gudrun. Birkin glanced quickly round. There was irritation in his eyes also. “Why?” he replied. “What do you think of it, Gudrun?” “Oh,” she cried, determined to fling her stone also into the pool, since they had begun, “I don’t think she wants an engagement. Naturally, she’s a bird that prefers the bush.” Gudrun’s voice was clear and gong-like. It reminded Rupert of her father’s, so strong and vibrant. “And I,” said Birkin, his face playful but yet determined, “I want a binding contract, and am not keen on love, particularly free love.” They were both amused. Why this public avowal? Gerald seemed suspended a moment, in amusement. “Love isn’t good enough for you?” he called. “No!” shouted Birkin. “Ha, well that’s being over-refined,” said Gerald, and the car ran through the mud. “What’s the matter, really?” said Gerald, turning to Gudrun.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXVIII. GUDRUN IN THE POMPADOUR
“Oh, only tonight. Are you coming over to speak to Julius?” “Not tonight.” “Oh very well. I’ll tell him then.” Then came her touch of diablerie. “You’re looking awf’lly fit.” “Yes—I feel it.” Gerald was quite calm and easy, a spark of satiric amusement in his eye. “Are you having a good time?” This was a direct blow for Gudrun, spoken in a level, toneless voice of callous ease. “Yes,” he replied, quite colourlessly. “I’m awf’lly sorry you aren’t coming round to the flat. You aren’t very faithful to your fwiends.” “Not very,” he said. She nodded them both “Good-night’, and went back slowly to her own set. Gudrun watched her curious walk, stiff and jerking at the loins. They heard her level, toneless voice distinctly. “He won’t come over;—he is otherwise engaged,” it said. There was more laughter and lowered voices and mockery at the table. “Is she a friend of yours?” said Gudrun, looking calmly at Gerald. “I’ve stayed at Halliday’s flat with Birkin,” he said, meeting her slow, calm eyes. And she knew that the Pussum was one of his mistresses—and he knew she knew. She looked round, and called for the waiter. She wanted an iced cocktail, of all things. This amused Gerald—he wondered what was up. The Halliday party was tipsy, and malicious. They were talking out loudly about Birkin, ridiculing him on every point, particularly on his marriage.
Read in context