Women in Love
D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)
“It was once,” said Birkin, “gilded—and it had a cane seat. Somebody has nailed this wooden seat in. Look, here is a trifle of the red that underlay the gilt. The rest is all black, except where the wood is worn pure and glossy. It is the fine unity of the lines that is so attractive. Look, how they run and meet and counteract. But of course the wooden seat is wrong—it destroys the perfect lightness and unity in tension the cane gave. I like it though—” “Ah yes,” said Ursula, “so do I.” “How much is it?” Birkin asked the man. “Ten shillings.” “And you will send it—?” It was bought. “So beautiful, so pure!” Birkin said. “It almost breaks my heart.” They walked along between the heaps of rubbish. “My beloved country—it had something to express even when it made that chair.” “And hasn’t it now?” asked Ursula. She was always angry when he took this tone. “No, it hasn’t. When I see that clear, beautiful chair, and I think of England, even Jane Austen’s England—it had living thoughts to unfold even then, and pure happiness in unfolding them. And now, we can only fish among the rubbish heaps for the remnants of their old expression. There is no production in us now, only sordid and foul mechanicalness.” “It isn’t true,” cried Ursula. “Why must you always praise the past, at the expense of the present? Really, I don’t think so much of Jane Austen’s England. It was materialistic enough, if you like—”
“It could afford to be materialistic,” said Birkin, “because it had the power to be something other—which we haven’t. We are materialistic because we haven’t the power to be anything else—try as we may, we can’t bring off anything but materialism: mechanism, the very soul of materialism.” Ursula was subdued into angry silence. She did not heed what he said. She was rebelling against something else. “And I hate your past. I’m sick of it,” she cried. “I believe I even hate that old chair, though it is beautiful. It isn’t my sort of beauty. I wish it had been smashed up when its day was over, not left to preach the beloved past to us. I’m sick of the beloved past.” “Not so sick as I am of the accursed present,” he said. “Yes, just the same. I hate the present—but I don’t want the past to take its place—I don’t want that old chair.” He was rather angry for a moment. Then he looked at the sky shining beyond the tower of the public baths, and he seemed to get over it all. He laughed. “All right,” he said, “then let us not have it. I’m sick of it all, too. At any rate one can’t go on living on the old bones of beauty.” “One can’t,” she cried. “I don’t want old things.” “The truth is, we don’t want things at all,” he replied. “The thought of a house and furniture of my own is hateful to me.” This startled her for a moment. Then she replied:
“So it is to me. But one must live somewhere.” “Not somewhere—anywhere,” he said. “One should just live anywhere—not have a definite place. I don’t want a definite place. As soon as you get a room, and it is complete, you want to run from it. Now my rooms at the Mill are quite complete, I want them at the bottom of the sea. It is a horrible tyranny of a fixed milieu, where each piece of furniture is a commandment-stone.” She clung to his arm as they walked away from the market. “But what are we going to do?” she said. “We must live somehow. And I do want some beauty in my surroundings. I want a sort of natural grandeur even, splendour.” “You’ll never get it in houses and furniture—or even clothes. Houses and furniture and clothes, they are all terms of an old base world, a detestable society of man. And if you have a Tudor house and old, beautiful furniture, it is only the past perpetuated on top of you, horrible. And if you have a perfect modern house done for you by Poiret, it is something else perpetuated on top of you. It is all horrible. It is all possessions, possessions, bullying you and turning you into a generalisation. You have to be like Rodin, Michelangelo, and leave a piece of raw rock unfinished to your figure. You must leave your surroundings sketchy, unfinished, so that you are never contained, never confined, never dominated from the outside.” She stood in the street contemplating.
“And we are never to have a complete place of our own—never a home?” she said. “Pray God, in this world, no,” he answered. “But there’s only this world,” she objected. He spread out his hands with a gesture of indifference. “Meanwhile, then, we’ll avoid having things of our own,” he said. “But you’ve just bought a chair,” she said. “I can tell the man I don’t want it,” he replied. She pondered again. Then a queer little movement twitched her face. “No,” she said, “we don’t want it. I’m sick of old things.” “New ones as well,” he said. They retraced their steps. There—in front of some furniture, stood the young couple, the woman who was going to have a baby, and the narrow-faced youth. She was fair, rather short, stout. He was of medium height, attractively built. His dark hair fell sideways over his brow, from under his cap, he stood strangely aloof, like one of the damned. “Let us give it to them,” whispered Ursula. “Look they are getting a home together.” “I won’t aid abet them in it,” he said petulantly, instantly sympathising with the aloof, furtive youth, against the active, procreant female. “Oh yes,” cried Ursula. “It’s right for them—there’s nothing else for them.” “Very well,” said Birkin, “you offer it to them. I’ll watch.” Ursula went rather nervously to the young couple, who were discussing an iron washstand—or rather, the man was glancing furtively and wonderingly, like a prisoner, at the abominable article, whilst the woman was arguing.
“We bought a chair,” said Ursula, “and we don’t want it. Would you have it? We should be glad if you would.” The young couple looked round at her, not believing that she could be addressing them. “Would you care for it?” repeated Ursula. “It’s really very pretty—but—but—” she smiled rather dazzlingly. The young couple only stared at her, and looked significantly at each other, to know what to do. And the man curiously obliterated himself, as if he could make himself invisible, as a rat can. “We wanted to give it to you,” explained Ursula, now overcome with confusion and dread of them. She was attracted by the young man. He was a still, mindless creature, hardly a man at all, a creature that the towns have produced, strangely pure-bred and fine in one sense, furtive, quick, subtle. His lashes were dark and long and fine over his eyes, that had no mind in them, only a dreadful kind of subject, inward consciousness, glazed and dark. His dark brows and all his lines, were finely drawn. He would be a dreadful, but wonderful lover to a woman, so marvellously contributed. His legs would be marvellously subtle and alive, under the shapeless, trousers, he had some of the fineness and stillness and silkiness of a dark-eyed, silent rat. Ursula had apprehended him with a fine frisson of attraction. The full-built woman was staring offensively. Again Ursula forgot him. “Won’t you have the chair?” she said.
Passages expressing a similar idea
Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXVI. A CHAIR
“It could afford to be materialistic,” said Birkin, “because it had the power to be something other—which we haven’t. We are materialistic because we haven’t the power to be anything else—try as we may, we can’t bring off anything but materialism: mechanism, the very soul of materialism.” Ursula was subdued into angry silence. She did not heed what he said. She was rebelling against something else. “And I hate your past. I’m sick of it,” she cried. “I believe I even hate that old chair, though it is beautiful. It isn’t my sort of beauty. I wish it had been smashed up when its day was over, not left to preach the beloved past to us. I’m sick of the beloved past.” “Not so sick as I am of the accursed present,” he said. “Yes, just the same. I hate the present—but I don’t want the past to take its place—I don’t want that old chair.” He was rather angry for a moment. Then he looked at the sky shining beyond the tower of the public baths, and he seemed to get over it all. He laughed. “All right,” he said, “then let us not have it. I’m sick of it all, too. At any rate one can’t go on living on the old bones of beauty.” “One can’t,” she cried. “I don’t want old things.” “The truth is, we don’t want things at all,” he replied. “The thought of a house and furniture of my own is hateful to me.” This startled her for a moment. Then she replied:
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXIX. CONTINENTAL
“One wants a new space to be in, I quite agree,” she said. “But I think that a new world is a development from this world, and that to isolate oneself with one other person, isn’t to find a new world at all, but only to secure oneself in one’s illusions.” Ursula looked out of the window. In her soul she began to wrestle, and she was frightened. She was always frightened of words, because she knew that mere word-force could always make her believe what she did not believe. “Perhaps,” she said, full of mistrust, of herself and everybody. “But,” she added, “I do think that one can’t have anything new whilst one cares for the old—do you know what I mean?—even fighting the old is belonging to it. I know, one is tempted to stop with the world, just to fight it. But then it isn’t worth it.” Gudrun considered herself. “Yes,” she said. “In a way, one is of the world if one lives in it. But isn’t it really an illusion to think you can get out of it? After all, a cottage in the Abruzzi, or wherever it may be, isn’t a new world. No, the only thing to do with the world, is to see it through.” Ursula looked away. She was so frightened of argument.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXVI. A CHAIR
“And we are never to have a complete place of our own—never a home?” she said. “Pray God, in this world, no,” he answered. “But there’s only this world,” she objected. He spread out his hands with a gesture of indifference. “Meanwhile, then, we’ll avoid having things of our own,” he said. “But you’ve just bought a chair,” she said. “I can tell the man I don’t want it,” he replied. She pondered again. Then a queer little movement twitched her face. “No,” she said, “we don’t want it. I’m sick of old things.” “New ones as well,” he said. They retraced their steps. There—in front of some furniture, stood the young couple, the woman who was going to have a baby, and the narrow-faced youth. She was fair, rather short, stout. He was of medium height, attractively built. His dark hair fell sideways over his brow, from under his cap, he stood strangely aloof, like one of the damned. “Let us give it to them,” whispered Ursula. “Look they are getting a home together.” “I won’t aid abet them in it,” he said petulantly, instantly sympathising with the aloof, furtive youth, against the active, procreant female. “Oh yes,” cried Ursula. “It’s right for them—there’s nothing else for them.” “Very well,” said Birkin, “you offer it to them. I’ll watch.” Ursula went rather nervously to the young couple, who were discussing an iron washstand—or rather, the man was glancing furtively and wonderingly, like a prisoner, at the abominable article, whilst the woman was arguing.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER V. IN THE TRAIN
Birkin looked at the land, at the evening, and was thinking: “Well, if mankind is destroyed, if our race is destroyed like Sodom, and there is this beautiful evening with the luminous land and trees, I am satisfied. That which informs it all is there, and can never be lost. After all, what is mankind but just one expression of the incomprehensible. And if mankind passes away, it will only mean that this particular expression is completed and done. That which is expressed, and that which is to be expressed, cannot be diminished. There it is, in the shining evening. Let mankind pass away—time it did. The creative utterances will not cease, they will only be there. Humanity doesn’t embody the utterance of the incomprehensible any more. Humanity is a dead letter. There will be a new embodiment, in a new way. Let humanity disappear as quick as possible.” Gerald interrupted him by asking, “Where are you staying in London?” Birkin looked up. “With a man in Soho. I pay part of the rent of a flat, and stop there when I like.” “Good idea—have a place more or less your own,” said Gerald. “Yes. But I don’t care for it much. I’m tired of the people I am bound to find there.” “What kind of people?”
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXIX. CONTINENTAL
“Sculpture and architecture must go together. The day for irrelevant statues, as for wall pictures, is over. As a matter of fact sculpture is always part of an architectural conception. And since churches are all museum stuff, since industry is our business, now, then let us make our places of industry our art—our factory-area our Parthenon, ecco!” Ursula pondered. “I suppose,” she said, “there is no need for our great works to be so hideous.” Instantly he broke into motion. “There you are!” he cried, “there you are! There is not only no need for our places of work to be ugly, but their ugliness ruins the work, in the end. Men will not go on submitting to such intolerable ugliness. In the end it will hurt too much, and they will wither because of it. And this will wither the work as well. They will think the work itself is ugly: the machines, the very act of labour. Whereas the machinery and the acts of labour are extremely, maddeningly beautiful. But this will be the end of our civilisation, when people will not work because work has become so intolerable to their senses, it nauseates them too much, they would rather starve. Then we shall see the hammer used only for smashing, then we shall see it. Yet here we are—we have the opportunity to make beautiful factories, beautiful machine-houses—we have the opportunity—” Gudrun could only partly understand. She could have cried with vexation.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXIII. EXCURSE
“I don’t know. I feel as if I would just meet you and we’d set off—just towards the distance.” “But where can one go?” she asked anxiously. “After all, there is only the world, and none of it is very distant.” “Still,” he said, “I should like to go with you—nowhere. It would be rather wandering just to nowhere. That’s the place to get to—nowhere. One wants to wander away from the world’s somewheres, into our own nowhere.” Still she meditated. “You see, my love,” she said, “I’m so afraid that while we are only people, we’ve got to take the world that’s given—because there isn’t any other.” “Yes there is,” he said. “There’s somewhere where we can be free—somewhere where one needn’t wear much clothes—none even—where one meets a few people who have gone through enough, and can take things for granted—where you be yourself, without bothering. There is somewhere—there are one or two people—” “But where—?” she sighed. “Somewhere—anywhere. Let’s wander off. That’s the thing to do—let’s wander off.” “Yes—” she said, thrilled at the thought of travel. But to her it was only travel. “To be free,” he said. “To be free, in a free place, with a few other people!” “Yes,” she said wistfully. Those “few other people” depressed her. “It isn’t really a locality, though,” he said. “It’s a perfected relation between you and me, and others—the perfect relation—so that we are free together.”
Read in context