Women in Love
D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)
“You think Rupert is off his head a bit?” Gerald asked. Her eyes flashed with acknowledgment. “As regards a woman, yes,” she said, “I do. There is such a thing as two people being in love for the whole of their lives—perhaps. But marriage is neither here nor there, even then. If they are in love, well and good. If not—why break eggs about it!” “Yes,” said Gerald. “That’s how it strikes me. But what about Rupert?” “I can’t make out—neither can he nor anybody. He seems to think that if you marry you can get through marriage into a third heaven, or something—all very vague.” “Very! And who wants a third heaven? As a matter of fact, Rupert has a great yearning to be safe—to tie himself to the mast.” “Yes. It seems to me he’s mistaken there too,” said Gudrun. “I’m sure a mistress is more likely to be faithful than a wife—just because she is her own mistress. No—he says he believes that a man and wife can go further than any other two beings—but where, is not explained. They can know each other, heavenly and hellish, but particularly hellish, so perfectly that they go beyond heaven and hell—into—there it all breaks down—into nowhere.” “Into Paradise, he says,” laughed Gerald. Gudrun shrugged her shoulders. “Je m’en fiche of your Paradise!” she said. “Not being a Mohammedan,” said Gerald. Birkin sat motionless, driving the car, quite unconscious of what they said. And Gudrun, sitting immediately behind him, felt a sort of ironic pleasure in thus exposing him.
“He says,” she added, with a grimace of irony, “that you can find an eternal equilibrium in marriage, if you accept the unison, and still leave yourself separate, don’t try to fuse.” “Doesn’t inspire me,” said Gerald. “That’s just it,” said Gudrun. “I believe in love, in a real abandon, if you’re capable of it,” said Gerald. “So do I,” said she. “And so does Rupert, too—though he is always shouting.” “No,” said Gudrun. “He won’t abandon himself to the other person. You can’t be sure of him. That’s the trouble I think.” “Yet he wants marriage! Marriage—et puis?” “Le paradis!” mocked Gudrun. Birkin, as he drove, felt a creeping of the spine, as if somebody was threatening his neck. But he shrugged with indifference. It began to rain. Here was a change. He stopped the car and got down to put up the hood.
They came to the town, and left Gerald at the railway station. Gudrun and Winifred were to come to tea with Birkin, who expected Ursula also. In the afternoon, however, the first person to turn up was Hermione. Birkin was out, so she went in the drawing-room, looking at his books and papers, and playing on the piano. Then Ursula arrived. She was surprised, unpleasantly so, to see Hermione, of whom she had heard nothing for some time. “It is a surprise to see you,” she said. “Yes,” said Hermione—“I’ve been away at Aix—” “Oh, for your health?” “Yes.” The two women looked at each other. Ursula resented Hermione’s long, grave, downward-looking face. There was something of the stupidity and the unenlightened self-esteem of a horse in it. “She’s got a horse-face,” Ursula said to herself, “she runs between blinkers.” It did seem as if Hermione, like the moon, had only one side to her penny. There was no obverse. She stared out all the time on the narrow, but to her, complete world of the extant consciousness. In the darkness, she did not exist. Like the moon, one half of her was lost to life. Her self was all in her head, she did not know what it was spontaneously to run or move, like a fish in the water, or a weasel on the grass. She must always know.
But Ursula only suffered from Hermione’s one-sidedness. She only felt Hermione’s cool evidence, which seemed to put her down as nothing. Hermione, who brooded and brooded till she was exhausted with the ache of her effort at consciousness, spent and ashen in her body, who gained so slowly and with such effort her final and barren conclusions of knowledge, was apt, in the presence of other women, whom she thought simply female, to wear the conclusions of her bitter assurance like jewels which conferred on her an unquestionable distinction, established her in a higher order of life. She was apt, mentally, to condescend to women such as Ursula, whom she regarded as purely emotional. Poor Hermione, it was her one possession, this aching certainty of hers, it was her only justification. She must be confident here, for God knows, she felt rejected and deficient enough elsewhere. In the life of thought, of the spirit, she was one of the elect. And she wanted to be universal. But there was a devastating cynicism at the bottom of her. She did not believe in her own universals—they were sham. She did not believe in the inner life—it was a trick, not a reality. She did not believe in the spiritual world—it was an affectation. In the last resort, she believed in Mammon, the flesh, and the devil—these at least were not sham. She was a priestess without belief, without conviction, suckled in a creed outworn, and condemned to the reiteration of mysteries that were not divine to her. Yet there was no escape. She was a leaf upon a dying tree. What help was there then, but to fight still for the old, withered truths, to die for the old, outworn belief, to be a sacred and inviolate priestess of desecrated mysteries? The old great truths had been true. And she was a leaf of the old great tree of knowledge that was withering now. To the old and last truth then she must be faithful even though cynicism and mockery took place at the bottom of her soul.
“I am so glad to see you,” she said to Ursula, in her slow voice, that was like an incantation. “You and Rupert have become quite friends?” “Oh yes,” said Ursula. “He is always somewhere in the background.” Hermione paused before she answered. She saw perfectly well the other woman’s vaunt: it seemed truly vulgar. “Is he?” she said slowly, and with perfect equanimity. “And do you think you will marry?” The question was so calm and mild, so simple and bare and dispassionate that Ursula was somewhat taken aback, rather attracted. It pleased her almost like a wickedness. There was some delightful naked irony in Hermione. “Well,” replied Ursula, “He wants to, awfully, but I’m not so sure.” Hermione watched her with slow calm eyes. She noted this new expression of vaunting. How she envied Ursula a certain unconscious positivity! even her vulgarity! “Why aren’t you sure?” she asked, in her easy sing song. She was perfectly at her ease, perhaps even rather happy in this conversation. “You don’t really love him?” Ursula flushed a little at the mild impertinence of this question. And yet she could not definitely take offence. Hermione seemed so calmly and sanely candid. After all, it was rather great to be able to be so sane. “He says it isn’t love he wants,” she replied. “What is it then?” Hermione was slow and level. “He wants me really to accept him in marriage.” Hermione was silent for some time, watching Ursula with slow, pensive eyes.
Passages expressing a similar idea
Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XII. CARPETING
“I’m afraid I hoped so,” said Ursula. “I ran here for refuge, when I saw you down the lake, just putting off.” “Did you! And now we’ve run you to earth.” Hermione’s eyelids lifted with an uncanny movement, amused but overwrought. She had always her strange, rapt look, unnatural and irresponsible. “I was going on,” said Ursula. “Mr Birkin wanted me to see the rooms. Isn’t it delightful to live here? It is perfect.” “Yes,” said Hermione, abstractedly. Then she turned right away from Ursula, ceased to know her existence. “How do you feel, Rupert?” she sang in a new, affectionate tone, to Birkin. “Very well,” he replied. “Were you quite comfortable?” The curious, sinister, rapt look was on Hermione’s face, she shrugged her bosom in a convulsed movement, and seemed like one half in a trance. “Quite comfortable,” he replied. There was a long pause, whilst Hermione looked at him for a long time, from under her heavy, drugged eyelids. “And you think you’ll be happy here?” she said at last. “I’m sure I shall.” “I’m sure I shall do anything for him as I can,” said the labourer’s wife. “And I’m sure our master will; so I hope he’ll find himself comfortable.” Hermione turned and looked at her slowly. “Thank you so much,” she said, and then she turned completely away again. She recovered her position, and lifting her face towards him, and addressing him exclusively, she said: “Have you measured the rooms?” “No,” he said, “I’ve been mending the punt.”
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XII. CARPETING
The party watched her. Soon the cages were covered, they had a strange funereal look. But from under the towels odd defiant trills and bubblings still shook out. “Oh, they won’t go on,” said Mrs Salmon reassuringly. “They’ll go to sleep now.” “Really,” said Hermione, politely. “They will,” said Gerald. “They will go to sleep automatically, now the impression of evening is produced.” “Are they so easily deceived?” cried Ursula. “Oh, yes,” replied Gerald. “Don’t you know the story of Fabre, who, when he was a boy, put a hen’s head under her wing, and she straight away went to sleep? It’s quite true.” “And did that make him a naturalist?” asked Birkin. “Probably,” said Gerald. Meanwhile Ursula was peeping under one of the cloths. There sat the canary in a corner, bunched and fluffed up for sleep. “How ridiculous!” she cried. “It really thinks the night has come! How absurd! Really, how can one have any respect for a creature that is so easily taken in!” “Yes,” sang Hermione, coming also to look. She put her hand on Ursula’s arm and chuckled a low laugh. “Yes, doesn’t he look comical?” she chuckled. “Like a stupid husband.” Then, with her hand still on Ursula’s arm, she drew her away, saying, in her mild sing-song: “How did you come here? We saw Gudrun too.” “I came to look at the pond,” said Ursula, “and I found Mr Birkin there.” “Did you? This is quite a Brangwen land, isn’t it!”
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER VIII. BREADALBY
There was Gerald, an amused look on his face; the game pleased him. There was Gudrun, watching with steady, large, hostile eyes; the game fascinated her, and she loathed it. There was Ursula, with a slightly startled look on her face, as if she were hurt, and the pain were just outside her consciousness. Suddenly Birkin got up and went out. “That’s enough,” he said to himself involuntarily. Hermione knew his motion, though not in her consciousness. She lifted her heavy eyes and saw him lapse suddenly away, on a sudden, unknown tide, and the waves broke over her. Only her indomitable will remained static and mechanical, she sat at the table making her musing, stray remarks. But the darkness had covered her, she was like a ship that has gone down. It was finished for her too, she was wrecked in the darkness. Yet the unfailing mechanism of her will worked on, she had that activity. “Shall we bathe this morning?” she said, suddenly looking at them all. “Splendid,” said Joshua. “It is a perfect morning.” “Oh, it is beautiful,” said Fräulein. “Yes, let us bathe,” said the Italian woman. “We have no bathing suits,” said Gerald. “Have mine,” said Alexander. “I must go to church and read the lessons. They expect me.” “Are you a Christian?” asked the Italian Countess, with sudden interest. “No,” said Alexander. “I’m not. But I believe in keeping up the old institutions.” “They are so beautiful,” said Fräulein daintily. “Oh, they are,” cried Miss Bradley.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XII. CARPETING
“All right,” said Birkin. “But can’t we wait for you while you dress?” persisted Hermione. “If you like.” He rose to go indoors. Ursula said she would take her leave. “Only,” she said, turning to Gerald, “I must say that, however man is lord of the beast and the fowl, I still don’t think he has any right to violate the feelings of the inferior creation. I still think it would have been much more sensible and nice of you if you’d trotted back up the road while the train went by, and been considerate.” “I see,” said Gerald, smiling, but somewhat annoyed. “I must remember another time.” “They all think I’m an interfering female,” thought Ursula to herself, as she went away. But she was in arms against them. She ran home plunged in thought. She had been very much moved by Hermione, she had really come into contact with her, so that there was a sort of league between the two women. And yet she could not bear her. But she put the thought away. “She’s really good,” she said to herself. “She really wants what is right.” And she tried to feel at one with Hermione, and to shut off from Birkin. She was strictly hostile to him. But she was held to him by some bond, some deep principle. This at once irritated her and saved her. Only now and again, violent little shudders would come over her, out of her subconsciousness, and she knew it was the fact that she had stated her challenge to Birkin, and he had, consciously or unconsciously, accepted. It was a fight to the death between them—or to new life: though in what the conflict lay, no one could say.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER VIII. BREADALBY
“Isn’t it wonderful—who would dare to put those two strong colours together—” Then Hermione’s maid entered silently and Ursula, overcome with dread, escaped, carried away by powerful impulse. Birkin went straight to bed. He was feeling happy, and sleepy. Since he had danced he was happy. But Gerald would talk to him. Gerald, in evening dress, sat on Birkin’s bed when the other lay down, and must talk. “Who are those two Brangwens?” Gerald asked. “They live in Beldover.” “In Beldover! Who are they then?” “Teachers in the Grammar School.” There was a pause. “They are!” exclaimed Gerald at length. “I thought I had seen them before.” “It disappoints you?” said Birkin. “Disappoints me! No—but how is it Hermione has them here?” “She knew Gudrun in London—that’s the younger one, the one with the darker hair—she’s an artist—does sculpture and modelling.” “She’s not a teacher in the Grammar School, then—only the other?” “Both—Gudrun art mistress, Ursula a class mistress.” “And what’s the father?” “Handicraft instructor in the schools.” “Really!” “Class-barriers are breaking down!” Gerald was always uneasy under the slightly jeering tone of the other. “That their father is handicraft instructor in a school! What does it matter to me?” Birkin laughed. Gerald looked at his face, as it lay there laughing and bitter and indifferent on the pillow, and he could not go away. “I don’t suppose you will see very much more of Gudrun, at least. She is a restless bird, she’ll be gone in a week or two,” said Birkin. “Where will she go?”
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XIX. MOONY
They heard her go into the dining-room, and drop her armful of books on the table. “Did you bring me that Girl’s Own?” cried Rosalind. “Yes, I brought it. But I forgot which one it was you wanted.” “You would,” cried Rosalind angrily. “It’s right for a wonder.” Then they heard her say something in a lowered tone. “Where?” cried Ursula. Again her sister’s voice was muffled. Brangwen opened the door, and called, in his strong, brazen voice: “Ursula.” She appeared in a moment, wearing her hat. “Oh how do you do!” she cried, seeing Birkin, and all dazzled as if taken by surprise. He wondered at her, knowing she was aware of his presence. She had her queer, radiant, breathless manner, as if confused by the actual world, unreal to it, having a complete bright world of her self alone. “Have I interrupted a conversation?” she asked. “No, only a complete silence,” said Birkin. “Oh,” said Ursula, vaguely, absent. Their presence was not vital to her, she was withheld, she did not take them in. It was a subtle insult that never failed to exasperate her father. “Mr Birkin came to speak to you, not to me,” said her father. “Oh, did he!” she exclaimed vaguely, as if it did not concern her. Then, recollecting herself, she turned to him rather radiantly, but still quite superficially, and said: “Was it anything special?” “I hope so,” he said, ironically. “—To propose to you, according to all accounts,” said her father. “Oh,” said Ursula.
Read in context