Skip to content
BookLens

Women in Love

D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)

The two girls waited a while, to see if there were any hope. The moon shone clearly overhead, with almost impertinent brightness, the small dark boats clustered on the water, there were voices and subdued shouts. But it was all to no purpose. Gudrun went home when Birkin returned. He was commissioned to open the sluice that let out the water from the lake, which was pierced at one end, near the high-road, thus serving as a reservoir to supply with water the distant mines, in case of necessity. “Come with me,” he said to Ursula, “and then I will walk home with you, when I’ve done this.” He called at the water-keeper’s cottage and took the key of the sluice. They went through a little gate from the high-road, to the head of the water, where was a great stone basin which received the overflow, and a flight of stone steps descended into the depths of the water itself. At the head of the steps was the lock of the sluice-gate. The night was silver-grey and perfect, save for the scattered restless sound of voices. The grey sheen of the moonlight caught the stretch of water, dark boats plashed and moved. But Ursula’s mind ceased to be receptive, everything was unimportant and unreal.

Birkin fixed the iron handle of the sluice, and turned it with a wrench. The cogs began slowly to rise. He turned and turned, like a slave, his white figure became distinct. Ursula looked away. She could not bear to see him winding heavily and laboriously, bending and rising mechanically like a slave, turning the handle. Then, a real shock to her, there came a loud splashing of water from out of the dark, tree-filled hollow beyond the road, a splashing that deepened rapidly to a harsh roar, and then became a heavy, booming noise of a great body of water falling solidly all the time. It occupied the whole of the night, this great steady booming of water, everything was drowned within it, drowned and lost. Ursula seemed to have to struggle for her life. She put her hands over her ears, and looked at the high bland moon. “Can’t we go now?” she cried to Birkin, who was watching the water on the steps, to see if it would get any lower. It seemed to fascinate him. He looked at her and nodded. The little dark boats had moved nearer, people were crowding curiously along the hedge by the high-road, to see what was to be seen. Birkin and Ursula went to the cottage with the key, then turned their backs on the lake. She was in great haste. She could not bear the terrible crushing boom of the escaping water. “Do you think they are dead?” she cried in a high voice, to make herself heard.

“Yes,” he replied. “Isn’t it horrible!” He paid no heed. They walked up the hill, further and further away from the noise. “Do you mind very much?” she asked him. “I don’t mind about the dead,” he said, “once they are dead. The worst of it is, they cling on to the living, and won’t let go.” She pondered for a time. “Yes,” she said. “The fact of death doesn’t really seem to matter much, does it?” “No,” he said. “What does it matter if Diana Crich is alive or dead?” “Doesn’t it?” she said, shocked. “No, why should it? Better she were dead—she’ll be much more real. She’ll be positive in death. In life she was a fretting, negated thing.” “You are rather horrible,” murmured Ursula. “No! I’d rather Diana Crich were dead. Her living somehow, was all wrong. As for the young man, poor devil—he’ll find his way out quickly instead of slowly. Death is all right—nothing better.” “Yet you don’t want to die,” she challenged him. He was silent for a time. Then he said, in a voice that was frightening to her in its change: “I should like to be through with it—I should like to be through with the death process.” “And aren’t you?” asked Ursula nervously. They walked on for some way in silence, under the trees. Then he said, slowly, as if afraid:

“There is life which belongs to death, and there is life which isn’t death. One is tired of the life that belongs to death—our kind of life. But whether it is finished, God knows. I want love that is like sleep, like being born again, vulnerable as a baby that just comes into the world.” Ursula listened, half attentive, half avoiding what he said. She seemed to catch the drift of his statement, and then she drew away. She wanted to hear, but she did not want to be implicated. She was reluctant to yield there, where he wanted her, to yield as it were her very identity. “Why should love be like sleep?” she asked sadly. “I don’t know. So that it is like death—I do want to die from this life—and yet it is more than life itself. One is delivered over like a naked infant from the womb, all the old defences and the old body gone, and new air around one, that has never been breathed before.” She listened, making out what he said. She knew, as well as he knew, that words themselves do not convey meaning, that they are but a gesture we make, a dumb show like any other. And she seemed to feel his gesture through her blood, and she drew back, even though her desire sent her forward. “But,” she said gravely, “didn’t you say you wanted something that was not love—something beyond love?”

He turned in confusion. There was always confusion in speech. Yet it must be spoken. Whichever way one moved, if one were to move forwards, one must break a way through. And to know, to give utterance, was to break a way through the walls of the prison as the infant in labour strives through the walls of the womb. There is no new movement now, without the breaking through of the old body, deliberately, in knowledge, in the struggle to get out. “I don’t want love,” he said. “I don’t want to know you. I want to be gone out of myself, and you to be lost to yourself, so we are found different. One shouldn’t talk when one is tired and wretched. One Hamletises, and it seems a lie. Only believe me when I show you a bit of healthy pride and insouciance. I hate myself serious.” “Why shouldn’t you be serious?” she said. He thought for a minute, then he said, sulkily: “I don’t know.” Then they walked on in silence, at outs. He was vague and lost. “Isn’t it strange,” she said, suddenly putting her hand on his arm, with a loving impulse, “how we always talk like this! I suppose we do love each other, in some way.” “Oh yes,” he said; “too much.” She laughed almost gaily. “You’d have to have it your own way, wouldn’t you?” she teased. “You could never take it on trust.” He changed, laughed softly, and turned and took her in his arms, in the middle of the road.

Passages expressing a similar idea

  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER IV. DIVER

    “Frightful!” cried Gudrun. “And isn’t it horrible too to think of such a thing happening to one, when one was a child, and having to carry the responsibility of it all through one’s life. Imagine it, two boys playing together—then this comes upon them, for no reason whatever—out of the air. Ursula, it’s very frightening! Oh, it’s one of the things I can’t bear. Murder, that is thinkable, because there’s a will behind it. But a thing like that to happen to one—” “Perhaps there was an unconscious will behind it,” said Ursula. “This playing at killing has some primitive desire for killing in it, don’t you think?” “Desire!” said Gudrun, coldly, stiffening a little. “I can’t see that they were even playing at killing. I suppose one boy said to the other, ‘You look down the barrel while I pull the trigger, and see what happens.’ It seems to me the purest form of accident.” “No,” said Ursula. “I couldn’t pull the trigger of the emptiest gun in the world, not if some-one were looking down the barrel. One instinctively doesn’t do it—one can’t.” Gudrun was silent for some moments, in sharp disagreement. “Of course,” she said coldly. “If one is a woman, and grown up, one’s instinct prevents one. But I cannot see how that applies to a couple of boys playing together.” Her voice was cold and angry. “Yes,” persisted Ursula. At that moment they heard a woman’s voice a few yards off say loudly:

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER IX DEFEAT OF MIRIAM

    “I don’t believe in it. They look better growing.” “But you’d like some?” “They want to be left.” “I don’t believe they do.” “I don’t want the corpses of flowers about me,” she said. “That’s a stiff, artificial notion,” he said. “They don’t die any quicker in water than on their roots. And besides, they look nice in a bowl—they look jolly. And you only call a thing a corpse because it looks corpse-like.” “Whether it is one or not?” she argued. “It isn’t one to me. A dead flower isn’t a corpse of a flower.” Clara now ignored him. “And even so—what right have you to pull them?” she asked. “Because I like them, and want them—and there’s plenty of them.” “And that is sufficient?” “Yes. Why not? I’m sure they’d smell nice in your room in Nottingham.” “And I should have the pleasure of watching them die.” “But then—it does not matter if they do die.” Whereupon he left her, and went stooping over the clumps of tangled flowers which thickly sprinkled the field like pale, luminous foam-clots. Miriam had come close. Clara was kneeling, breathing some scent from the cowslips. “I think,” said Miriam, “if you treat them with reverence you don’t do them any harm. It is the spirit you pluck them in that matters.” “Yes,” he said. “But no, you get ’em because you want ’em, and that’s all.” He held out his bunch. Miriam was silent. He picked some more.

    Read in context
  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER III. CLASS-ROOM

    “Do you really think, Rupert,” she asked, as if Ursula were not present, “do you really think it is worth while? Do you really think the children are better for being roused to consciousness?” A dark flash went over his face, a silent fury. He was hollow-cheeked and pale, almost unearthly. And the woman, with her serious, conscience-harrowing question tortured him on the quick. “They are not roused to consciousness,” he said. “Consciousness comes to them, willy-nilly.” “But do you think they are better for having it quickened, stimulated? Isn’t it better that they should remain unconscious of the hazel, isn’t it better that they should see as a whole, without all this pulling to pieces, all this knowledge?” “Would you rather, for yourself, know or not know, that the little red flowers are there, putting out for the pollen?” he asked harshly. His voice was brutal, scornful, cruel. Hermione remained with her face lifted up, abstracted. He hung silent in irritation. “I don’t know,” she replied, balancing mildly. “I don’t know.” “But knowing is everything to you, it is all your life,” he broke out. She slowly looked at him. “Is it?” she said. “To know, that is your all, that is your life—you have only this, this knowledge,” he cried. “There is only one tree, there is only one fruit, in your mouth.” Again she was some time silent. “Is there?” she said at last, with the same untouched calm. And then in a tone of whimsical inquisitiveness: “What fruit, Rupert?”

    Read in context
  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XIX. MOONY

    “Yes, it was horrible, really. Why should you hate the moon? It hasn’t done you any harm, has it?” “Was it hate?” he said. And they were silent for a few minutes. “When did you come back?” she said. “Today.” “Why did you never write?” “I could find nothing to say.” “Why was there nothing to say?” “I don’t know. Why are there no daffodils now?” “No.” Again there was a space of silence. Ursula looked at the moon. It had gathered itself together, and was quivering slightly. “Was it good for you, to be alone?” she asked. “Perhaps. Not that I know much. But I got over a good deal. Did you do anything important?” “No. I looked at England, and thought I’d done with it.” “Why England?” he asked in surprise. “I don’t know, it came like that.” “It isn’t a question of nations,” he said. “France is far worse.” “Yes, I know. I felt I’d done with it all.” They went and sat down on the roots of the trees, in the shadow. And being silent, he remembered the beauty of her eyes, which were sometimes filled with light, like spring, suffused with wonderful promise. So he said to her, slowly, with difficulty: “There is a golden light in you, which I wish you would give me.” It was as if he had been thinking of this for some time. She was startled, she seemed to leap clear of him. Yet also she was pleased. “What kind of a light,” she asked.

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XIV THE RELEASE

    “Oh, how horrible!” said Clara, too frightened to speak. “And she looks at me, and she wants to stay with me,” he went on monotonously. “She’s got such a will, it seems as if she would never go—never!” “Don’t think of it!” cried Clara. “And she was religious—she is religious now—but it is no good. She simply won’t give in. And do you know, I said to her on Thursday: ‘Mother, if I had to die, I’d die. I’d will to die.’ And she said to me, sharp: ‘Do you think I haven’t? Do you think you can die when you like?’” His voice ceased. He did not cry, only went on speaking monotonously. Clara wanted to run. She looked round. There was the black, re-echoing shore, the dark sky down on her. She got up terrified. She wanted to be where there was light, where there were other people. She wanted to be away from him. He sat with his head dropped, not moving a muscle. “And I don’t want her to eat,” he said, “and she knows it. When I ask her: ‘Shall you have anything’ she’s almost afraid to say ‘Yes.’ ‘I’ll have a cup of Benger’s,’ she says. ‘It’ll only keep your strength up,’ I said to her. ‘Yes’—and she almost cried—‘but there’s such a gnawing when I eat nothing, I can’t bear it.’ So I went and made her the food. It’s the cancer that gnaws like that at her. I wish she’d die!” “Come!” said Clara roughly. “I’m going.”

    Read in context
  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXI. THRESHOLD

    He was still so strong and living! But the nausea of death began to creep back on him, in reaction. Gudrun went away, back to Winifred. Mademoiselle had left, Gudrun stayed a good deal at Shortlands, and a tutor came in to carry on Winifred’s education. But he did not live in the house, he was connected with the Grammar School. One day, Gudrun was to drive with Winifred and Gerald and Birkin to town, in the car. It was a dark, showery day. Winifred and Gudrun were ready and waiting at the door. Winifred was very quiet, but Gudrun had not noticed. Suddenly the child asked, in a voice of unconcern: “Do you think my father’s going to die, Miss Brangwen?” Gudrun started. “I don’t know,” she replied. “Don’t you truly?” “Nobody knows for certain. He may die, of course.” The child pondered a few moments, then she asked: “But do you think he will die?” It was put almost like a question in geography or science, insistent, as if she would force an admission from the adult. The watchful, slightly triumphant child was almost diabolical. “Do I think he will die?” repeated Gudrun. “Yes, I do.” But Winifred’s large eyes were fixed on her, and the girl did not move. “He is very ill,” said Gudrun. A small smile came over Winifred’s face, subtle and sceptical.

    Read in context