Women in Love
D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)
“I can’t stand the crowd,” replied Gerald. “But third’ll be all right. There’s a restaurant car, we can have some tea.” The two men looked at the station clock, having nothing further to say. “What were you reading in the paper?” Birkin asked. Gerald looked at him quickly. “Isn’t it funny, what they do put in the newspapers,” he said. “Here are two leaders—” he held out his Daily Telegraph, “full of the ordinary newspaper cant—” he scanned the columns down—“and then there’s this little—I dunno what you’d call it, essay, almost—appearing with the leaders, and saying there must arise a man who will give new values to things, give us new truths, a new attitude to life, or else we shall be a crumbling nothingness in a few years, a country in ruin—” “I suppose that’s a bit of newspaper cant, as well,” said Birkin. “It sounds as if the man meant it, and quite genuinely,” said Gerald. “Give it to me,” said Birkin, holding out his hand for the paper. The train came, and they went on board, sitting on either side a little table, by the window, in the restaurant car. Birkin glanced over his paper, then looked up at Gerald, who was waiting for him. “I believe the man means it,” he said, “as far as he means anything.” “And do you think it’s true? Do you think we really want a new gospel?” asked Gerald. Birkin shrugged his shoulders.
“I think the people who say they want a new religion are the last to accept anything new. They want novelty right enough. But to stare straight at this life that we’ve brought upon ourselves, and reject it, absolutely smash up the old idols of ourselves, that we sh’ll never do. You’ve got very badly to want to get rid of the old, before anything new will appear—even in the self.” Gerald watched him closely. “You think we ought to break up this life, just start and let fly?” he asked. “This life. Yes I do. We’ve got to bust it completely, or shrivel inside it, as in a tight skin. For it won’t expand any more.” There was a queer little smile in Gerald’s eyes, a look of amusement, calm and curious. “And how do you propose to begin? I suppose you mean, reform the whole order of society?” he asked. Birkin had a slight, tense frown between the brows. He too was impatient of the conversation. “I don’t propose at all,” he replied. “When we really want to go for something better, we shall smash the old. Until then, any sort of proposal, or making proposals, is no more than a tiresome game for self-important people.” The little smile began to die out of Gerald’s eyes, and he said, looking with a cool stare at Birkin: “So you really think things are very bad?” “Completely bad.” The smile appeared again. “In what way?”
“Every way,” said Birkin. “We are such dreary liars. Our one idea is to lie to ourselves. We have an ideal of a perfect world, clean and straight and sufficient. So we cover the earth with foulness; life is a blotch of labour, like insects scurrying in filth, so that your collier can have a pianoforte in his parlour, and you can have a butler and a motor-car in your up-to-date house, and as a nation we can sport the Ritz, or the Empire, Gaby Deslys and the Sunday newspapers. It is very dreary.” Gerald took a little time to re-adjust himself after this tirade. “Would you have us live without houses—return to nature?” he asked. “I would have nothing at all. People only do what they want to do—and what they are capable of doing. If they were capable of anything else, there would be something else.” Again Gerald pondered. He was not going to take offence at Birkin. “Don’t you think the collier’s pianoforte, as you call it, is a symbol for something very real, a real desire for something higher, in the collier’s life?”
“Higher!” cried Birkin. “Yes. Amazing heights of upright grandeur. It makes him so much higher in his neighbouring collier’s eyes. He sees himself reflected in the neighbouring opinion, like in a Brocken mist, several feet taller on the strength of the pianoforte, and he is satisfied. He lives for the sake of that Brocken spectre, the reflection of himself in the human opinion. You do the same. If you are of high importance to humanity you are of high importance to yourself. That is why you work so hard at the mines. If you can produce coal to cook five thousand dinners a day, you are five thousand times more important than if you cooked only your own dinner.” “I suppose I am,” laughed Gerald. “Can’t you see,” said Birkin, “that to help my neighbour to eat is no more than eating myself. ‘I eat, thou eatest, he eats, we eat, you eat, they eat’—and what then? Why should every man decline the whole verb. First person singular is enough for me.” “You’ve got to start with material things,” said Gerald. Which statement Birkin ignored. “And we’ve got to live for something, we’re not just cattle that can graze and have done with it,” said Gerald. “Tell me,” said Birkin. “What do you live for?” Gerald’s face went baffled. “What do I live for?” he repeated. “I suppose I live to work, to produce something, in so far as I am a purposive being. Apart from that, I live because I am living.”
“And what’s your work? Getting so many more thousands of tons of coal out of the earth every day. And when we’ve got all the coal we want, and all the plush furniture, and pianofortes, and the rabbits are all stewed and eaten, and we’re all warm and our bellies are filled and we’re listening to the young lady performing on the pianoforte—what then? What then, when you’ve made a real fair start with your material things?” Gerald sat laughing at the words and the mocking humour of the other man. But he was cogitating too. “We haven’t got there yet,” he replied. “A good many people are still waiting for the rabbit and the fire to cook it.” “So while you get the coal I must chase the rabbit?” said Birkin, mocking at Gerald. “Something like that,” said Gerald. Birkin watched him narrowly. He saw the perfect good-humoured callousness, even strange, glistening malice, in Gerald, glistening through the plausible ethics of productivity. “Gerald,” he said, “I rather hate you.” “I know you do,” said Gerald. “Why do you?” Birkin mused inscrutably for some minutes. “I should like to know if you are conscious of hating me,” he said at last. “Do you ever consciously detest me—hate me with mystic hate? There are odd moments when I hate you starrily.” Gerald was rather taken aback, even a little disconcerted. He did not quite know what to say. “I may, of course, hate you sometimes,” he said. “But I’m not aware of it—never acutely aware of it, that is.”
Passages expressing a similar idea
Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XVI. MAN TO MAN
Gerald’s eyes narrowed uglily. School had been torture to him. Yet he had not questioned whether one should go through this torture. He seemed to believe in education through subjection and torment. “I hated it at the time, but I can see it was necessary,” he said. “It brought me into line a bit—and you can’t live unless you do come into line somewhere.” “Well,” said Birkin, “I begin to think that you can’t live unless you keep entirely out of the line. It’s no good trying to toe the line, when your one impulse is to smash up the line. Winnie is a special nature, and for special natures you must give a special world.” “Yes, but where’s your special world?” said Gerald. “Make it. Instead of chopping yourself down to fit the world, chop the world down to fit yourself. As a matter of fact, two exceptional people make another world. You and I, we make another, separate world. You don’t want a world same as your brothers-in-law. It’s just the special quality you value. Do you want to be normal or ordinary! It’s a lie. You want to be free and extraordinary, in an extraordinary world of liberty.” Gerald looked at Birkin with subtle eyes of knowledge. But he would never openly admit what he felt. He knew more than Birkin, in one direction—much more. And this gave him his gentle love for the other man, as if Birkin were in some way young, innocent, child-like: so amazingly clever, but incurably innocent.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER V. IN THE TRAIN
“I think the people who say they want a new religion are the last to accept anything new. They want novelty right enough. But to stare straight at this life that we’ve brought upon ourselves, and reject it, absolutely smash up the old idols of ourselves, that we sh’ll never do. You’ve got very badly to want to get rid of the old, before anything new will appear—even in the self.” Gerald watched him closely. “You think we ought to break up this life, just start and let fly?” he asked. “This life. Yes I do. We’ve got to bust it completely, or shrivel inside it, as in a tight skin. For it won’t expand any more.” There was a queer little smile in Gerald’s eyes, a look of amusement, calm and curious. “And how do you propose to begin? I suppose you mean, reform the whole order of society?” he asked. Birkin had a slight, tense frown between the brows. He too was impatient of the conversation. “I don’t propose at all,” he replied. “When we really want to go for something better, we shall smash the old. Until then, any sort of proposal, or making proposals, is no more than a tiresome game for self-important people.” The little smile began to die out of Gerald’s eyes, and he said, looking with a cool stare at Birkin: “So you really think things are very bad?” “Completely bad.” The smile appeared again. “In what way?”
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XIV. WATER-PARTY
“Is there any need for you to be working?” said Birkin. “Wouldn’t it be much better if you went to bed?” “To bed! Good God, do you think I should sleep? We’ll find ’em, before I go away from here.” “But the men would find them just the same without you—why should you insist?” Gerald looked up at him. Then he put his hand affectionately on Birkin’s shoulder, saying: “Don’t you bother about me, Rupert. If there’s anybody’s health to think about, it’s yours, not mine. How do you feel yourself?” “Very well. But you, you spoil your own chance of life—you waste your best self.” Gerald was silent for a moment. Then he said: “Waste it? What else is there to do with it?” “But leave this, won’t you? You force yourself into horrors, and put a mill-stone of beastly memories round your neck. Come away now.” “A mill-stone of beastly memories!” Gerald repeated. Then he put his hand again affectionately on Birkin’s shoulder. “God, you’ve got such a telling way of putting things, Rupert, you have.” Birkin’s heart sank. He was irritated and weary of having a telling way of putting things. “Won’t you leave it? Come over to my place”—he urged as one urges a drunken man.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XVI. MAN TO MAN
“Yet you are so banal as to consider me chiefly a freak,” said Birkin pointedly. “A freak!” exclaimed Gerald, startled. And his face opened suddenly, as if lighted with simplicity, as when a flower opens out of the cunning bud. “No—I never consider you a freak.” And he watched the other man with strange eyes, that Birkin could not understand. “I feel,” Gerald continued, “that there is always an element of uncertainty about you—perhaps you are uncertain about yourself. But I’m never sure of you. You can go away and change as easily as if you had no soul.” He looked at Birkin with penetrating eyes. Birkin was amazed. He thought he had all the soul in the world. He stared in amazement. And Gerald, watching, saw the amazing attractive goodliness of his eyes, a young, spontaneous goodness that attracted the other man infinitely, yet filled him with bitter chagrin, because he mistrusted it so much. He knew Birkin could do without him—could forget, and not suffer. This was always present in Gerald’s consciousness, filling him with bitter unbelief: this consciousness of the young, animal-like spontaneity of detachment. It seemed almost like hypocrisy and lying, sometimes, oh, often, on Birkin’s part, to talk so deeply and importantly.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER V. IN THE TRAIN
“Art—music—London Bohemia—the most pettifogging calculating Bohemia that ever reckoned its pennies. But there are a few decent people, decent in some respects. They are really very thorough rejecters of the world—perhaps they live only in the gesture of rejection and negation—but negatively something, at any rate.” “What are they?—painters, musicians?” “Painters, musicians, writers—hangers-on, models, advanced young people, anybody who is openly at outs with the conventions, and belongs to nowhere particularly. They are often young fellows down from the University, and girls who are living their own lives, as they say.” “All loose?” said Gerald. Birkin could see his curiosity roused. “In one way. Most bound, in another. For all their shockingness, all on one note.” He looked at Gerald, and saw how his blue eyes were lit up with a little flame of curious desire. He saw too how good-looking he was. Gerald was attractive, his blood seemed fluid and electric. His blue eyes burned with a keen, yet cold light, there was a certain beauty, a beautiful passivity in all his body, his moulding. “We might see something of each other—I am in London for two or three days,” said Gerald. “Yes,” said Birkin, “I don’t want to go to the theatre, or the music hall—you’d better come round to the flat, and see what you can make of Halliday and his crowd.” “Thanks—I should like to,” laughed Gerald. “What are you doing tonight?” “I promised to meet Halliday at the Pompadour. It’s a bad place, but there is nowhere else.” “Where is it?” asked Gerald. “Piccadilly Circus.”
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XVI. MAN TO MAN
Birkin sought hard to express himself. But Gerald hardly listened. His face shone with a certain luminous pleasure. He was pleased. But he kept his reserve. He held himself back. “Shall we swear to each other, one day?” said Birkin, putting out his hand towards Gerald. Gerald just touched the extended fine, living hand, as if withheld and afraid. “We’ll leave it till I understand it better,” he said, in a voice of excuse. Birkin watched him. A little sharp disappointment, perhaps a touch of contempt came into his heart. “Yes,” he said. “You must tell me what you think, later. You know what I mean? Not sloppy emotionalism. An impersonal union that leaves one free.” They lapsed both into silence. Birkin was looking at Gerald all the time. He seemed now to see, not the physical, animal man, which he usually saw in Gerald, and which usually he liked so much, but the man himself, complete, and as if fated, doomed, limited. This strange sense of fatality in Gerald, as if he were limited to one form of existence, one knowledge, one activity, a sort of fatal halfness, which to himself seemed wholeness, always overcame Birkin after their moments of passionate approach, and filled him with a sort of contempt, or boredom. It was the insistence on the limitation which so bored Birkin in Gerald. Gerald could never fly away from himself, in real indifferent gaiety. He had a clog, a sort of monomania.
Read in context