Women in Love
D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)
“He has no pain, but he feels tired,” replied Winifred, the girl with the hair down her back. The wine was filled, and everybody was talking boisterously. At the far end of the table sat the mother, with her loosely-looped hair. She had Birkin for a neighbour. Sometimes she glanced fiercely down the rows of faces, bending forwards and staring unceremoniously. And she would say in a low voice to Birkin: “Who is that young man?” “I don’t know,” Birkin answered discreetly. “Have I seen him before?” she asked. “I don’t think so. I haven’t,” he replied. And she was satisfied. Her eyes closed wearily, a peace came over her face, she looked like a queen in repose. Then she started, a little social smile came on her face, for a moment she looked the pleasant hostess. For a moment she bent graciously, as if everyone were welcome and delightful. And then immediately the shadow came back, a sullen, eagle look was on her face, she glanced from under her brows like a sinister creature at bay, hating them all. “Mother,” called Diana, a handsome girl a little older than Winifred, “I may have wine, mayn’t I?” “Yes, you may have wine,” replied the mother automatically, for she was perfectly indifferent to the question. And Diana beckoned to the footman to fill her glass. “Gerald shouldn’t forbid me,” she said calmly, to the company at large. “All right, Di,” said her brother amiably. And she glanced challenge at him as she drank from her glass.
There was a strange freedom, that almost amounted to anarchy, in the house. It was rather a resistance to authority, than liberty. Gerald had some command, by mere force of personality, not because of any granted position. There was a quality in his voice, amiable but dominant, that cowed the others, who were all younger than he. Hermione was having a discussion with the bridegroom about nationality. “No,” she said, “I think that the appeal to patriotism is a mistake. It is like one house of business rivalling another house of business.” “Well you can hardly say that, can you?” exclaimed Gerald, who had a real passion for discussion. “You couldn’t call a race a business concern, could you?—and nationality roughly corresponds to race, I think. I think it is meant to.” There was a moment’s pause. Gerald and Hermione were always strangely but politely and evenly inimical. “Do you think race corresponds with nationality?” she asked musingly, with expressionless indecision. Birkin knew she was waiting for him to participate. And dutifully he spoke up. “I think Gerald is right—race is the essential element in nationality, in Europe at least,” he said. Again Hermione paused, as if to allow this statement to cool. Then she said with strange assumption of authority: “Yes, but even so, is the patriotic appeal an appeal to the racial instinct? Is it not rather an appeal to the proprietory instinct, the commercial instinct? And isn’t this what we mean by nationality?”
“Probably,” said Birkin, who felt that such a discussion was out of place and out of time. But Gerald was now on the scent of argument. “A race may have its commercial aspect,” he said. “In fact it must. It is like a family. You must make provision. And to make provision you have got to strive against other families, other nations. I don’t see why you shouldn’t.” Again Hermione made a pause, domineering and cold, before she replied: “Yes, I think it is always wrong to provoke a spirit of rivalry. It makes bad blood. And bad blood accumulates.” “But you can’t do away with the spirit of emulation altogether?” said Gerald. “It is one of the necessary incentives to production and improvement.” “Yes,” came Hermione’s sauntering response. “I think you can do away with it.” “I must say,” said Birkin, “I detest the spirit of emulation.” Hermione was biting a piece of bread, pulling it from between her teeth with her fingers, in a slow, slightly derisive movement. She turned to Birkin. “You do hate it, yes,” she said, intimate and gratified. “Detest it,” he repeated. “Yes,” she murmured, assured and satisfied. “But,” Gerald insisted, “you don’t allow one man to take away his neighbour’s living, so why should you allow one nation to take away the living from another nation?” There was a long slow murmur from Hermione before she broke into speech, saying with a laconic indifference: “It is not always a question of possessions, is it? It is not all a question of goods?”
Gerald was nettled by this implication of vulgar materialism. “Yes, more or less,” he retorted. “If I go and take a man’s hat from off his head, that hat becomes a symbol of that man’s liberty. When he fights me for his hat, he is fighting me for his liberty.” Hermione was nonplussed. “Yes,” she said, irritated. “But that way of arguing by imaginary instances is not supposed to be genuine, is it? A man does not come and take my hat from off my head, does he?” “Only because the law prevents him,” said Gerald. “Not only,” said Birkin. “Ninety-nine men out of a hundred don’t want my hat.” “That’s a matter of opinion,” said Gerald. “Or the hat,” laughed the bridegroom. “And if he does want my hat, such as it is,” said Birkin, “why, surely it is open to me to decide, which is a greater loss to me, my hat, or my liberty as a free and indifferent man. If I am compelled to offer fight, I lose the latter. It is a question which is worth more to me, my pleasant liberty of conduct, or my hat.” “Yes,” said Hermione, watching Birkin strangely. “Yes.” “But would you let somebody come and snatch your hat off your head?” the bride asked of Hermione. The face of the tall straight woman turned slowly and as if drugged to this new speaker. “No,” she replied, in a low inhuman tone, that seemed to contain a chuckle. “No, I shouldn’t let anybody take my hat off my head.”
“How would you prevent it?” asked Gerald. “I don’t know,” replied Hermione slowly. “Probably I should kill him.” There was a strange chuckle in her tone, a dangerous and convincing humour in her bearing. “Of course,” said Gerald, “I can see Rupert’s point. It is a question to him whether his hat or his peace of mind is more important.” “Peace of body,” said Birkin. “Well, as you like there,” replied Gerald. “But how are you going to decide this for a nation?” “Heaven preserve me,” laughed Birkin. “Yes, but suppose you have to?” Gerald persisted. “Then it is the same. If the national crown-piece is an old hat, then the thieving gent may have it.” “But can the national or racial hat be an old hat?” insisted Gerald. “Pretty well bound to be, I believe,” said Birkin. “I’m not so sure,” said Gerald. “I don’t agree, Rupert,” said Hermione. “All right,” said Birkin. “I’m all for the old national hat,” laughed Gerald. “And a fool you look in it,” cried Diana, his pert sister who was just in her teens. “Oh, we’re quite out of our depths with these old hats,” cried Laura Crich. “Dry up now, Gerald. We’re going to drink toasts. Let us drink toasts. Toasts—glasses, glasses—now then, toasts! Speech! Speech!”
Passages expressing a similar idea
Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER II. SHORTLANDS
There was a strange freedom, that almost amounted to anarchy, in the house. It was rather a resistance to authority, than liberty. Gerald had some command, by mere force of personality, not because of any granted position. There was a quality in his voice, amiable but dominant, that cowed the others, who were all younger than he. Hermione was having a discussion with the bridegroom about nationality. “No,” she said, “I think that the appeal to patriotism is a mistake. It is like one house of business rivalling another house of business.” “Well you can hardly say that, can you?” exclaimed Gerald, who had a real passion for discussion. “You couldn’t call a race a business concern, could you?—and nationality roughly corresponds to race, I think. I think it is meant to.” There was a moment’s pause. Gerald and Hermione were always strangely but politely and evenly inimical. “Do you think race corresponds with nationality?” she asked musingly, with expressionless indecision. Birkin knew she was waiting for him to participate. And dutifully he spoke up. “I think Gerald is right—race is the essential element in nationality, in Europe at least,” he said. Again Hermione paused, as if to allow this statement to cool. Then she said with strange assumption of authority: “Yes, but even so, is the patriotic appeal an appeal to the racial instinct? Is it not rather an appeal to the proprietory instinct, the commercial instinct? And isn’t this what we mean by nationality?”
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER II. SHORTLANDS
Gerald was nettled by this implication of vulgar materialism. “Yes, more or less,” he retorted. “If I go and take a man’s hat from off his head, that hat becomes a symbol of that man’s liberty. When he fights me for his hat, he is fighting me for his liberty.” Hermione was nonplussed. “Yes,” she said, irritated. “But that way of arguing by imaginary instances is not supposed to be genuine, is it? A man does not come and take my hat from off my head, does he?” “Only because the law prevents him,” said Gerald. “Not only,” said Birkin. “Ninety-nine men out of a hundred don’t want my hat.” “That’s a matter of opinion,” said Gerald. “Or the hat,” laughed the bridegroom. “And if he does want my hat, such as it is,” said Birkin, “why, surely it is open to me to decide, which is a greater loss to me, my hat, or my liberty as a free and indifferent man. If I am compelled to offer fight, I lose the latter. It is a question which is worth more to me, my pleasant liberty of conduct, or my hat.” “Yes,” said Hermione, watching Birkin strangely. “Yes.” “But would you let somebody come and snatch your hat off your head?” the bride asked of Hermione. The face of the tall straight woman turned slowly and as if drugged to this new speaker. “No,” she replied, in a low inhuman tone, that seemed to contain a chuckle. “No, I shouldn’t let anybody take my hat off my head.”
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XII. CARPETING
“All right,” said Birkin. “But can’t we wait for you while you dress?” persisted Hermione. “If you like.” He rose to go indoors. Ursula said she would take her leave. “Only,” she said, turning to Gerald, “I must say that, however man is lord of the beast and the fowl, I still don’t think he has any right to violate the feelings of the inferior creation. I still think it would have been much more sensible and nice of you if you’d trotted back up the road while the train went by, and been considerate.” “I see,” said Gerald, smiling, but somewhat annoyed. “I must remember another time.” “They all think I’m an interfering female,” thought Ursula to herself, as she went away. But she was in arms against them. She ran home plunged in thought. She had been very much moved by Hermione, she had really come into contact with her, so that there was a sort of league between the two women. And yet she could not bear her. But she put the thought away. “She’s really good,” she said to herself. “She really wants what is right.” And she tried to feel at one with Hermione, and to shut off from Birkin. She was strictly hostile to him. But she was held to him by some bond, some deep principle. This at once irritated her and saved her. Only now and again, violent little shudders would come over her, out of her subconsciousness, and she knew it was the fact that she had stated her challenge to Birkin, and he had, consciously or unconsciously, accepted. It was a fight to the death between them—or to new life: though in what the conflict lay, no one could say.
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXII. WOMAN TO WOMAN
“No indeed,” said Hermione. “No, indeed! But I think you are vital and young—it isn’t a question of years, or even of experience—it is almost a question of race. Rupert is race-old, he comes of an old race—and you seem to me so young, you come of a young, inexperienced race.” “Do I!” said Ursula. “But I think he is awfully young, on one side.” “Yes, perhaps childish in many respects. Nevertheless—” They both lapsed into silence. Ursula was filled with deep resentment and a touch of hopelessness. “It isn’t true,” she said to herself, silently addressing her adversary. “It isn’t true. And it is you who want a physically strong, bullying man, not I. It is you who want an unsensitive man, not I. You don’t know anything about Rupert, not really, in spite of the years you have had with him. You don’t give him a woman’s love, you give him an ideal love, and that is why he reacts away from you. You don’t know. You only know the dead things. Any kitchen maid would know something about him, you don’t know. What do you think your knowledge is but dead understanding, that doesn’t mean a thing. You are so false, and untrue, how could you know anything? What is the good of your talking about love—you untrue spectre of a woman! How can you know anything, when you don’t believe? You don’t believe in yourself and your own womanhood, so what good is your conceited, shallow cleverness—!”
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER II. SHORTLANDS
“How would you prevent it?” asked Gerald. “I don’t know,” replied Hermione slowly. “Probably I should kill him.” There was a strange chuckle in her tone, a dangerous and convincing humour in her bearing. “Of course,” said Gerald, “I can see Rupert’s point. It is a question to him whether his hat or his peace of mind is more important.” “Peace of body,” said Birkin. “Well, as you like there,” replied Gerald. “But how are you going to decide this for a nation?” “Heaven preserve me,” laughed Birkin. “Yes, but suppose you have to?” Gerald persisted. “Then it is the same. If the national crown-piece is an old hat, then the thieving gent may have it.” “But can the national or racial hat be an old hat?” insisted Gerald. “Pretty well bound to be, I believe,” said Birkin. “I’m not so sure,” said Gerald. “I don’t agree, Rupert,” said Hermione. “All right,” said Birkin. “I’m all for the old national hat,” laughed Gerald. “And a fool you look in it,” cried Diana, his pert sister who was just in her teens. “Oh, we’re quite out of our depths with these old hats,” cried Laura Crich. “Dry up now, Gerald. We’re going to drink toasts. Let us drink toasts. Toasts—glasses, glasses—now then, toasts! Speech! Speech!”
Read in contextWomen in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XVI. MAN TO MAN
“I don’t know. Gudrun is rather self-opinionated. She won’t go cheap anywhere. Or if she does, she’ll pretty soon take herself back. So whether she would condescend to do private teaching, particularly here, in Beldover, I don’t know. But it would be just the thing. Winifred has got a special nature. And if you can put into her way the means of being self-sufficient, that is the best thing possible. She’ll never get on with the ordinary life. You find it difficult enough yourself, and she is several skins thinner than you are. It is awful to think what her life will be like unless she does find a means of expression, some way of fulfilment. You can see what mere leaving it to fate brings. You can see how much marriage is to be trusted to—look at your own mother.” “Do you think mother is abnormal?” “No! I think she only wanted something more, or other than the common run of life. And not getting it, she has gone wrong perhaps.” “After producing a brood of wrong children,” said Gerald gloomily. “No more wrong than any of the rest of us,” Birkin replied. “The most normal people have the worst subterranean selves, take them one by one.” “Sometimes I think it is a curse to be alive,” said Gerald with sudden impotent anger. “Well,” said Birkin, “why not! Let it be a curse sometimes to be alive—at other times it is anything but a curse. You’ve got plenty of zest in it really.”
Read in context