Skip to content
BookLens

Women in Love

D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)

Meanwhile the men stood in calm little groups, chatting, smoking, pretending to pay no heed to the rustling animation of the women’s world. But they could not really talk, because of the glassy ravel of women’s excited, cold laughter and running voices. They waited, uneasy, suspended, rather bored. But Gerald remained as if genial and happy, unaware that he was waiting or unoccupied, knowing himself the very pivot of the occasion. Suddenly Mrs Crich came noiselessly into the room, peering about with her strong, clear face. She was still wearing her hat, and her sac coat of blue silk. “What is it, mother?” said Gerald. “Nothing, nothing!” she answered vaguely. And she went straight towards Birkin, who was talking to a Crich brother-in-law. “How do you do, Mr Birkin,” she said, in her low voice, that seemed to take no count of her guests. She held out her hand to him. “Oh Mrs Crich,” replied Birkin, in his readily-changing voice, “I couldn’t come to you before.” “I don’t know half the people here,” she said, in her low voice. Her son-in-law moved uneasily away. “And you don’t like strangers?” laughed Birkin. “I myself can never see why one should take account of people, just because they happen to be in the room with one: why should I know they are there?”

“Why indeed, why indeed!” said Mrs Crich, in her low, tense voice. “Except that they are there. I don’t know people whom I find in the house. The children introduce them to me—‘Mother, this is Mr So-and-so.’ I am no further. What has Mr So-and-so to do with his own name?—and what have I to do with either him or his name?” She looked up at Birkin. She startled him. He was flattered too that she came to talk to him, for she took hardly any notice of anybody. He looked down at her tense clear face, with its heavy features, but he was afraid to look into her heavy-seeing blue eyes. He noticed instead how her hair looped in slack, slovenly strands over her rather beautiful ears, which were not quite clean. Neither was her neck perfectly clean. Even in that he seemed to belong to her, rather than to the rest of the company; though, he thought to himself, he was always well washed, at any rate at the neck and ears. He smiled faintly, thinking these things. Yet he was tense, feeling that he and the elderly, estranged woman were conferring together like traitors, like enemies within the camp of the other people. He resembled a deer, that throws one ear back upon the trail behind, and one ear forward, to know what is ahead. “People don’t really matter,” he said, rather unwilling to continue. The mother looked up at him with sudden, dark interrogation, as if doubting his sincerity.

“How do you mean, matter?” she asked sharply. “Not many people are anything at all,” he answered, forced to go deeper than he wanted to. “They jingle and giggle. It would be much better if they were just wiped out. Essentially, they don’t exist, they aren’t there.” She watched him steadily while he spoke. “But we didn’t imagine them,” she said sharply. “There’s nothing to imagine, that’s why they don’t exist.” “Well,” she said, “I would hardly go as far as that. There they are, whether they exist or no. It doesn’t rest with me to decide on their existence. I only know that I can’t be expected to take count of them all. You can’t expect me to know them, just because they happen to be there. As far as I go they might as well not be there.” “Exactly,” he replied. “Mightn’t they?” she asked again. “Just as well,” he repeated. And there was a little pause. “Except that they are there, and that’s a nuisance,” she said. “There are my sons-in-law,” she went on, in a sort of monologue. “Now Laura’s got married, there’s another. And I really don’t know John from James yet. They come up to me and call me mother. I know what they will say—‘how are you, mother?’ I ought to say, ‘I am not your mother, in any sense.’ But what is the use? There they are. I have had children of my own. I suppose I know them from another woman’s children.” “One would suppose so,” he said.

She looked at him, somewhat surprised, forgetting perhaps that she was talking to him. And she lost her thread. She looked round the room, vaguely. Birkin could not guess what she was looking for, nor what she was thinking. Evidently she noticed her sons. “Are my children all there?” she asked him abruptly. He laughed, startled, afraid perhaps. “I scarcely know them, except Gerald,” he replied. “Gerald!” she exclaimed. “He’s the most wanting of them all. You’d never think it, to look at him now, would you?” “No,” said Birkin. The mother looked across at her eldest son, stared at him heavily for some time. “Ay,” she said, in an incomprehensible monosyllable, that sounded profoundly cynical. Birkin felt afraid, as if he dared not realise. And Mrs Crich moved away, forgetting him. But she returned on her traces. “I should like him to have a friend,” she said. “He has never had a friend.” Birkin looked down into her eyes, which were blue, and watching heavily. He could not understand them. “Am I my brother’s keeper?” he said to himself, almost flippantly.

Then he remembered, with a slight shock, that that was Cain’s cry. And Gerald was Cain, if anybody. Not that he was Cain, either, although he had slain his brother. There was such a thing as pure accident, and the consequences did not attach to one, even though one had killed one’s brother in such wise. Gerald as a boy had accidentally killed his brother. What then? Why seek to draw a brand and a curse across the life that had caused the accident? A man can live by accident, and die by accident. Or can he not? Is every man’s life subject to pure accident, is it only the race, the genus, the species, that has a universal reference? Or is this not true, is there no such thing as pure accident? Has everything that happens a universal significance? Has it? Birkin, pondering as he stood there, had forgotten Mrs Crich, as she had forgotten him. He did not believe that there was any such thing as accident. It all hung together, in the deepest sense. Just as he had decided this, one of the Crich daughters came up, saying: “Won’t you come and take your hat off, mother dear? We shall be sitting down to eat in a minute, and it’s a formal occasion, darling, isn’t it?” She drew her arm through her mother’s, and they went away. Birkin immediately went to talk to the nearest man.

Passages expressing a similar idea

  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XIX. MOONY

    “Are they?” Brangwen caught himself up. “I’m not speaking of you in particular,” he said. “What I mean is that my children have been brought up to think and do according to the religion I was brought up in myself, and I don’t want to see them going away from that.” There was a dangerous pause. “And beyond that—?” asked Birkin. The father hesitated, he was in a nasty position. “Eh? What do you mean? All I want to say is that my daughter”—he tailed off into silence, overcome by futility. He knew that in some way he was off the track. “Of course,” said Birkin, “I don’t want to hurt anybody or influence anybody. Ursula does exactly as she pleases.” There was a complete silence, because of the utter failure in mutual understanding. Birkin felt bored. Her father was not a coherent human being, he was a roomful of old echoes. The eyes of the younger man rested on the face of the elder. Brangwen looked up, and saw Birkin looking at him. His face was covered with inarticulate anger and humiliation and sense of inferiority in strength. “And as for beliefs, that’s one thing,” he said. “But I’d rather see my daughters dead tomorrow than that they should be at the beck and call of the first man that likes to come and whistle for them.” A queer painful light came into Birkin’s eyes.

    Read in context
  • Women in Love · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XXIV. DEATH AND LOVE

    “How are you?” she muttered, in her strangely quiet voice, as if nobody should hear but him. “You’re not getting into a state, are you? You’re not letting it make you hysterical?” The curious challenge in the last words startled Gudrun. “I don’t think so, mother,” he answered, rather coldly cheery. “Somebody’s got to see it through, you know.” “Have they? Have they?” answered his mother rapidly. “Why should you take it on yourself? What have you got to do, seeing it through. It will see itself through. You are not needed.” “No, I don’t suppose I can do any good,” he answered. “It’s just how it affects us, you see.” “You like to be affected—don’t you? It’s quite nuts for you? You would have to be important. You have no need to stop at home. Why don’t you go away!” These sentences, evidently the ripened grain of many dark hours, took Gerald by surprise. “I don’t think it’s any good going away now, mother, at the last minute,” he said, coldly. “You take care,” replied his mother. “You mind yourself—that’s your business. You take too much on yourself. You mind yourself, or you’ll find yourself in Queer Street, that’s what will happen to you. You’re hysterical, always were.” “I’m all right, mother,” he said. “There’s no need to worry about me, I assure you.” “Let the dead bury their dead—don’t go and bury yourself along with them—that’s what I tell you. I know you well enough.”

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XIII BAXTER DAWES

    “I don’t care what her opinion of me is. She’s fearfully in love with me, but it’s not very deep.” “But quite as deep as your feeling for her.” He looked up at his mother curiously. “Yes,” he said. “You know, mother, I think there must be something the matter with me, that I can’t love. When she’s there, as a rule, I do love her. Sometimes, when I see her just as the woman, I love her, mother; but then, when she talks and criticises, I often don’t listen to her.” “Yet she’s as much sense as Miriam.” “Perhaps; and I love her better than Miriam. But why don’t they hold me?” The last question was almost a lamentation. His mother turned away her face, sat looking across the room, very quiet, grave, with something of renunciation. “But you wouldn’t want to marry Clara?” she said. “No; at first perhaps I would. But why—why don’t I want to marry her or anybody? I feel sometimes as if I wronged my women, mother.” “How wronged them, my son?” “I don’t know.” He went on painting rather despairingly; he had touched the quick of the trouble. “And as for wanting to marry,” said his mother, “there’s plenty of time yet.” “But no, mother. I even love Clara, and I did Miriam; but to give myself to them in marriage I couldn’t. I couldn’t belong to them. They seem to want me, and I can’t ever give it them.” “You haven’t met the right woman.”

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER IX DEFEAT OF MIRIAM

    “What’s a matter with her? Is she going dotty with being too lonely?” “Yes,” said Miriam. “It’s not the right sort of life for her. I think it’s cruel to bury her there. I really ought to go and see her more. But—she upsets me.” “She makes me feel sorry for her—yes, and she bothers me,” he said. “I suppose,” blurted Clara suddenly, “she wants a man.” The other two were silent for a few moments. “But it’s the loneliness sends her cracked,” said Paul. Clara did not answer, but strode on uphill. She was walking with her hand hanging, her legs swinging as she kicked through the dead thistles and the tussocky grass, her arms hanging loose. Rather than walking, her handsome body seemed to be blundering up the hill. A hot wave went over Paul. He was curious about her. Perhaps life had been cruel to her. He forgot Miriam, who was walking beside him talking to him. She glanced at him, finding he did not answer her. His eyes were fixed ahead on Clara. “Do you still think she is disagreeable?” she asked. He did not notice that the question was sudden. It ran with his thoughts. “Something’s the matter with her,” he said. “Yes,” answered Miriam.

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER X CLARA

    “Oh, do you!” replied his mother. “And do you call yours a divine discontent?” “Yes. I don’t care about its divinity. But damn your happiness! So long as life’s full, it doesn’t matter whether it’s happy or not. I’m afraid your happiness would bore me.” “You never give it a chance,” she said. Then suddenly all her passion of grief over him broke out. “But it does matter!” she cried. “And you ought to be happy, you ought to try to be happy, to live to be happy. How could I bear to think your life wouldn’t be a happy one!” “Your own’s been bad enough, mater, but it hasn’t left you so much worse off than the folk who’ve been happier. I reckon you’ve done well. And I am the same. Aren’t I well enough off?” “You’re not, my son. Battle—battle—and suffer. It’s about all you do, as far as I can see.” “But why not, my dear? I tell you it’s the best—” “It isn’t. And one ought to be happy, one ought.” By this time Mrs. Morel was trembling violently. Struggles of this kind often took place between her and her son, when she seemed to fight for his very life against his own will to die. He took her in his arms. She was ill and pitiful. “Never mind, Little,” he murmured. “So long as you don’t feel life’s paltry and a miserable business, the rest doesn’t matter, happiness or unhappiness.” She pressed him to her. “But I want you to be happy,” she said pathetically.

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XI THE TEST ON MIRIAM

    There was silence for a moment or two, while he dug viciously at the earth. She bent her head, pondering. He was an unreasonable child. He was like an infant which, when it has drunk its fill, throws away and smashes the cup. She looked at him, feeling she could get hold of him and wring some consistency out of him. But she was helpless. Then she cried: “I have said you were only fourteen—you are only four!” He still dug at the earth viciously. He heard. “You are a child of four,” she repeated in her anger. He did not answer, but said in his heart: “All right; if I’m a child of four, what do you want me for? I don’t want another mother.” But he said nothing to her, and there was silence. “And have you told your people?” she asked. “I have told my mother.” There was another long interval of silence. “Then what do you want?” she asked. “Why, I want us to separate. We have lived on each other all these years; now let us stop. I will go my own way without you, and you will go your way without me. You will have an independent life of your own then.”

    Read in context