Howards End
E. M. (Edward Morgan) Forster (1879–1970)
“If he sublets, I shan’t have the same control. In theory there should be no more damage done at Howards End; in practice there will be. Things may be done for which no money can compensate. For instance, I shouldn’t want that fine wych-elm spoilt. It hangs—Margaret, we must go and see the old place some time. It’s pretty in its way. We’ll motor down and have lunch with Charles.” “I should enjoy that,” said Margaret bravely. “What about next Wednesday?” “Wednesday? No, I couldn’t well do that. Aunt Juley expects us to stop here another week at least.” “But you can give that up now.” “Er—no,” said Margaret, after a moment’s thought. “Oh, that’ll be all right. I’ll speak to her.” “This visit is a high solemnity. My aunt counts on it year after year. She turns the house upside down for us; she invites our special friends—she scarcely knows Frieda, and we can’t leave her on her hands. I missed one day, and she would be so hurt if I didn’t stay the full ten.” “But I’ll say a word to her. Don’t you bother.” “Henry, I won’t go. Don’t bully me.” “You want to see the house, though?” “Very much—I’ve heard so much about it, one way or the other. Aren’t there pigs’ teeth in the wych-elm?” “Pigs’ teeth?” “And you chew the bark for toothache.” “What a rum notion! Of course not!” “Perhaps I have confused it with some other tree. There are still a great number of sacred trees in England, it seems.”
But he left her to intercept Mrs. Munt, whose voice could be heard in the distance: to be intercepted himself by Helen. “Oh, Mr. Wilcox, about the Porphyrion—” she began, and went scarlet all over her face. “It’s all right,” called Margaret, catching them up. “Dempster’s Bank’s better.” “But I think you told us the Porphyrion was bad, and would smash before Christmas.” “Did I? It was still outside the Tariff Ring, and had to take rotten policies. Lately it came in—safe as houses now.” “In other words, Mr. Bast need never have left it.” “No, the fellow needn’t.” “—and needn’t have started life elsewhere at a greatly reduced salary.” “He only says ‘reduced,’” corrected Margaret, seeing trouble ahead. “With a man so poor, every reduction must be great. I consider it a deplorable misfortune.” Mr. Wilcox, intent on his business with Mrs. Munt, was going steadily on, but the last remark made him say: “What? What’s that? Do you mean that I’m responsible?” “You’re ridiculous, Helen.” “You seem to think—” He looked at his watch. “Let me explain the point to you. It is like this. You seem to assume, when a business concern is conducting a delicate negotiation, it ought to keep the public informed stage by stage. The Porphyrion, according to you, was bound to say, ‘I am trying all I can to get into the Tariff Ring. I am not sure that I shall succeed, but it is the only thing that will save me from insolvency, and I am trying.’ My dear Helen—”
“Is that your point? A man who had little money has less—that’s mine.” “I am grieved for your clerk. But it is all in the day’s work. It’s part of the battle of life.” “A man who had little money,” she repeated, “has less, owing to us. Under these circumstances I do not consider ‘the battle of life’ a happy expression.” “Oh come, come!” he protested pleasantly. “You’re not to blame. No one’s to blame.” “Is no one to blame for anything?” “I wouldn’t say that, but you’re taking it far too seriously. Who is this fellow?” “We have told you about the fellow twice already,” said Helen. “You have even met the fellow. He is very poor and his wife is an extravagant imbecile. He is capable of better things. We—we, the upper classes—thought we would help him from the height of our superior knowledge—and here’s the result!” He raised his finger. “Now, a word of advice.” “I require no more advice.” “A word of advice. Don’t take up that sentimental attitude over the poor. See that she doesn’t, Margaret. The poor are poor, and one’s sorry for them, but there it is. As civilization moves forward, the shoe is bound to pinch in places, and it’s absurd to pretend that anyone is responsible personally. Neither you, nor I, nor my informant, nor the man who informed him, nor the directors of the Porphyrion, are to blame for this clerk’s loss of salary. It’s just the shoe pinching—no one can help it; and it might easily have been worse.”
Helen quivered with indignation. “By all means subscribe to charities—subscribe to them largely—but don’t get carried away by absurd schemes of Social Reform. I see a good deal behind the scenes, and you can take it from me that there is no Social Question—except for a few journalists who try to get a living out of the phrase. There are just rich and poor, as there always have been and always will be. Point me out a time when men have been equal—” “I didn’t say—” “Point me out a time when desire for equality has made them happier. No, no. You can’t. There always have been rich and poor. I’m no fatalist. Heaven forbid! But our civilization is moulded by great impersonal forces” (his voice grew complacent; it always did when he eliminated the personal), “and there always will be rich and poor. You can’t deny it” (and now it was a respectful voice)—“and you can’t deny that, in spite of all, the tendency of civilization has on the whole been upward.” “Owing to God, I suppose,” flashed Helen. He stared at her. “You grab the dollars. God does the rest.” It was no good instructing the girl if she was going to talk about God in that neurotic modern way. Fraternal to the last, he left her for the quieter company of Mrs. Munt. He thought, “She rather reminds me of Dolly.” Helen looked out at the sea. “Don’t even discuss political economy with Henry,” advised her sister. “It’ll only end in a cry.”
“But he must be one of those men who have reconciled science with religion,” said Helen slowly. “I don’t like those men. They are scientific themselves, and talk of the survival of the fittest, and cut down the salaries of their clerks, and stunt the independence of all who may menace their comfort, but yet they believe that somehow good—and it is always that sloppy ‘somehow’—will be the outcome, and that in some mystical way the Mr. Basts of the future will benefit because the Mr. Basts of today are in pain.” “He is such a man in theory. But oh, Helen, in theory!” “But oh, Meg, what a theory!” “Why should you put things so bitterly, dearie?” “Because I’m an old maid,” said Helen, biting her lip. “I can’t think why I go on like this myself.” She shook off her sister’s hand and went into the house. Margaret, distressed at the day’s beginning, followed the Bournemouth steamer with her eyes. She saw that Helen’s nerves were exasperated by the unlucky Bast business beyond the bounds of politeness. There might at any minute be a real explosion, which even Henry would notice. Henry must be removed. “Margaret!” her aunt called. “Magsy! It isn’t true, surely, what Mr. Wilcox says, that you want to go away early next week?” “Not ‘want,’” was Margaret’s prompt reply; “but there is so much to be settled, and I do want to see the Charles’.”
Passages expressing a similar idea
Howards End · E. M. (Edward Morgan) Forster (1879–1970) · Chapter 20
“Poor fellow!” murmured Margaret, looking out to sea, and not understanding. “Charles being the elder son, some day Charles will have Howards End; but I am anxious, in my own happiness, not to be unjust to others.” “Of course not,” she began, and then gave a little cry. “You mean money. How stupid I am! Of course not!” Oddly enough, he winced a little at the word. “Yes. Money, since you put it so frankly. I am determined to be just to all—just to you, just to them. I am determined that my children shall have no case against me.” “Be generous to them,” she said sharply. “Bother justice!” “I am determined—and have already written to Charles to that effect—” “But how much have you got?” “What?” “How much have you a year? I’ve six hundred.” “My income?” “Yes. We must begin with how much you have, before we can settle how much you can give Charles. Justice, and even generosity, depend on that.” “I must say you’re a downright young woman,” he observed, patting her arm and laughing a little. “What a question to spring on a fellow!” “Don’t you know your income? Or don’t you want to tell it me?” “I—” “That’s all right”—now she patted him—“don’t tell me. I don’t want to know. I can do the sum just as well by proportion. Divide your income into ten parts. How many parts would you give to Evie, how many to Charles, how many to Paul?”
Read in contextHowards End · E. M. (Edward Morgan) Forster (1879–1970) · Chapter 17
“That’s his lookout. I don’t believe in suiting my conversation to my company. One can doubtless hit upon some medium of exchange that seems to do well enough, but it’s no more like the real thing than money is like food. There’s no nourishment in it. You pass it to the lower classes, and they pass it back to you, and this you call ‘social intercourse’ or ‘mutual endeavour,’ when it’s mutual priggishness if it’s anything. Our friends at Chelsea don’t see this. They say one ought to be at all costs intelligible, and sacrifice—” “Lower classes,” interrupted Mr. Wilcox, as it were thrusting his hand into her speech. “Well, you do admit that there are rich and poor. That’s something.” Margaret could not reply. Was he incredibly stupid, or did he understand her better than she understood herself? “You do admit that, if wealth was divided up equally, in a few years there would be rich and poor again just the same. The hard-working man would come to the top, the wastrel sink to the bottom.” “Every one admits that.” “Your Socialists don’t.” “My Socialists do. Yours mayn’t; but I strongly suspect yours of being not Socialists, but ninepins, which you have constructed for your own amusement. I can’t imagine any living creature who would bowl over quite so easily.”
Read in contextHowards End · E. M. (Edward Morgan) Forster (1879–1970) · Chapter 22
Helen quivered with indignation. “By all means subscribe to charities—subscribe to them largely—but don’t get carried away by absurd schemes of Social Reform. I see a good deal behind the scenes, and you can take it from me that there is no Social Question—except for a few journalists who try to get a living out of the phrase. There are just rich and poor, as there always have been and always will be. Point me out a time when men have been equal—” “I didn’t say—” “Point me out a time when desire for equality has made them happier. No, no. You can’t. There always have been rich and poor. I’m no fatalist. Heaven forbid! But our civilization is moulded by great impersonal forces” (his voice grew complacent; it always did when he eliminated the personal), “and there always will be rich and poor. You can’t deny it” (and now it was a respectful voice)—“and you can’t deny that, in spite of all, the tendency of civilization has on the whole been upward.” “Owing to God, I suppose,” flashed Helen. He stared at her. “You grab the dollars. God does the rest.” It was no good instructing the girl if she was going to talk about God in that neurotic modern way. Fraternal to the last, he left her for the quieter company of Mrs. Munt. He thought, “She rather reminds me of Dolly.” Helen looked out at the sea. “Don’t even discuss political economy with Henry,” advised her sister. “It’ll only end in a cry.”
Read in contextHowards End · E. M. (Edward Morgan) Forster (1879–1970) · Chapter 15
And here Margaret interrupted. “Order, order, Miss Schlegel!” said the reader of the paper. “You are here, I understand, to advise me in the interests of the Society for the Preservation of Places of Historic Interest or Natural Beauty. I cannot have you speaking out of your role. It makes my poor head go round, and I think you forget that I am very ill.” “Your head won’t go round if only you’ll listen to my argument,” said Margaret. “Why not give him the money itself. You’re supposed to have about thirty thousand a year.” “Have I? I thought I had a million.” “Wasn’t a million your capital? Dear me! we ought to have settled that. Still, it doesn’t matter. Whatever you’ve got, I order you to give as many poor men as you can three hundred a year each.” “But that would be pauperizing them,” said an earnest girl, who liked the Schlegels, but thought them a little unspiritual at times. “Not if you gave them so much. A big windfall would not pauperize a man. It is these little driblets, distributed among too many, that do the harm. Money’s educational. It’s far more educational than the things it buys.” There was a protest. “In a sense,” added Margaret, but the protest continued. “Well, isn’t the most civilized thing going, the man who has learnt to wear his income properly?” “Exactly what your Mr. Basts won’t do.”
Read in contextHowards End · E. M. (Edward Morgan) Forster (1879–1970) · Chapter 15
“Not at all. I don’t agree with your sister. There’s nothing like a debate to teach one quickness. I often wish I had gone in for them when I was a youngster. It would have helped me no end.” “Quickness—?” “Yes. Quickness in argument. Time after time I’ve missed scoring a point because the other man has had the gift of the gab and I haven’t. Oh, I believe in these discussions.” The patronizing tone thought Margaret, came well enough from a man who was old enough to be their father. She had always maintained that Mr. Wilcox had a charm. In times of sorrow or emotion his inadequacy had pained her, but it was pleasant to listen to him now, and to watch his thick brown moustache and high forehead confronting the stars. But Helen was nettled. The aim of their debates she implied was Truth. “Oh yes, it doesn’t much matter what subject you take,” said he. Margaret laughed and said, “But this is going to be far better than the debate itself.” Helen recovered herself and laughed too. “No, I won’t go on,” she declared. “I’ll just put our special case to Mr. Wilcox.” “About Mr. Bast? Yes, do. He’ll be more lenient to a special case. “But, Mr. Wilcox, do first light another cigarette. It’s this. We’ve just come across a young fellow, who’s evidently very poor, and who seems interest—” “What’s his profession?” “Clerk.” “What in?” “Do you remember, Margaret?” “Porphyrion Fire Insurance Company.”
Read in contextHowards End · E. M. (Edward Morgan) Forster (1879–1970) · Chapter 30
“This part is in confidence,” said Helen. “It has nothing to do with Meg, and do not mention it to her. The compensation—I do not see who is to pay it if I don’t, and I have already decided on the minimum sum. As soon as possible I am placing it to your account, and when I am in Germany you will pay it over for me. I shall never forget your kindness, Tibbikins, if you do this.” “What is the sum?” “Five thousand.” “Good God alive!” said Tibby, and went crimson. “Now, what is the good of driblets? To go through life having done one thing—to have raised one person from the abyss: not these puny gifts of shillings and blankets—making the grey more grey. No doubt people will think me extraordinary.” “I don’t care a damn what people think!” cried he, heated to unusual manliness of diction. “But it’s half what you have.” “Not nearly half.” She spread out her hands over her soiled skirt. “I have far too much, and we settled at Chelsea last spring that three hundred a year is necessary to set a man on his feet. What I give will bring in a hundred and fifty between two. It isn’t enough.”
Read in context