Skip to content
BookLens

Resurrection

Leo Tolstoy (1828–1910)

“I do not agree with you. In the first place, I cannot admit that the criminals classed as political are punished because they are above the average. In most cases they are the refuse of society, just as much perverted, though in a different way, as the criminal types whom you consider below the average.” “But I happen to know men who are morally far above their judges; all the sectarians are moral, from—” But Rogozhinsky, a man not accustomed to be interrupted when he spoke, did not listen to Nekhludoff, but went on talking at the same time, thereby irritating him still more. “Nor can I admit that the object of the law is the upholding of the present state of things. The law aims at reforming—” “A nice kind of reform, in a prison!” Nekhludoff put in. “Or removing,” Rogozhinsky went on, persistently, “the perverted and brutalised persons that threaten society.” “That’s just what it doesn’t do. Society has not the means of doing either the one thing or the other.” “How is that? I don’t understand,” said Rogozhinsky with a forced smile. “I mean that only two reasonable kinds of punishment exist. Those used in the old days: corporal and capital punishment, which, as human nature gradually softens, come more and more into disuse,” said Nekhludoff. “There, now, this is quite new and very strange to hear from your lips.”

“Yes, it is reasonable to hurt a man so that he should not do in future what he is hurt for doing, and it is also quite reasonable to cut a man’s head off when he is injurious or dangerous to society. These punishments have a reasonable meaning. But what sense is there in locking up in a prison a man perverted by want of occupation and bad example; to place him in a position where he is provided for, where laziness is imposed on him, and where he is in company with the most perverted of men? What reason is there to take a man at public cost (it comes to more than 500 roubles per head) from the Toula to the Irkoatsk government, or from Koursk—” “Yes, but all the same, people are afraid of those journeys at public cost, and if it were not for such journeys and the prisons, you and I would not be sitting here as we are.” “The prisons cannot insure our safety, because these people do not stay there for ever, but are set free again. On the contrary, in those establishments men are brought to the greatest vice and degradation, so that the danger is increased.” “You mean to say that the penitentiary system should be improved.” “It cannot be improved. Improved prisons would cost more than all that is being now spent on the people’s education, and would lay a still heavier burden on the people.”

“The shortcomings of the penitentiary system in nowise invalidate the law itself,” Rogozhinsky continued again, without heeding his brother-in-law. “There is no remedy for these shortcomings,” said Nekhludoff, raising his voice. “What of that? Shall we therefore go and kill, or, as a certain statesman proposed, go putting out people’s eyes?” Rogozhinsky remarked. “Yes; that would be cruel, but it would be effective. What is done now is cruel, and not only ineffective, but so stupid that one cannot understand how people in their senses can take part in so absurd and cruel a business as criminal law.” “But I happen to take part in it,” said Rogozhinsky, growing pale. “That is your business. But to me it is incomprehensible.” “I think there are a good many things incomprehensible to you,” said Rogozhinsky, with a trembling voice. “I have seen how one public prosecutor did his very best to get an unfortunate boy condemned, who could have evoked nothing but sympathy in an unperverted mind. I know how another cross-examined a sectarian and put down the reading of the Gospels as a criminal offence; in fact, the whole business of the Law Courts consists in senseless and cruel actions of that sort.” “I should not serve if I thought so,” said Rogozhinsky, rising. Nekhludoff noticed a peculiar glitter under his brother-in-law’s spectacles. “Can it be tears?” he thought. And they were really tears of injured pride. Rogozhinsky went up to the window, got out his handkerchief, coughed and rubbed his spectacles, took them off, and wiped his eyes.

When he returned to the sofa he lit a cigar, and did not speak any more. Nekhludoff felt pained and ashamed of having offended his brother-in-law and his sister to such a degree, especially as he was going away the next day. He parted with them in confusion, and drove home. “All I have said may be true—anyhow he did not reply. But it was not said in the right way. How little I must have changed if I could be carried away by ill-feeling to such an extent as to hurt and wound poor Nathalie in such a way!” he thought.

The gang of prisoners, among whom was Maslova, was to leave Moscow by rail at 3 p.m.; therefore, in order to see the gang start, and walk to the station with the prisoners Nekhludoff meant to reach the prison before 12 o’clock.

Passages expressing a similar idea

  • Resurrection · Leo Tolstoy (1828–1910) · CHAPTER XXXIII. THE AIM OF THE LAW.

    “I do not agree with you. In the first place, I cannot admit that the criminals classed as political are punished because they are above the average. In most cases they are the refuse of society, just as much perverted, though in a different way, as the criminal types whom you consider below the average.” “But I happen to know men who are morally far above their judges; all the sectarians are moral, from—” But Rogozhinsky, a man not accustomed to be interrupted when he spoke, did not listen to Nekhludoff, but went on talking at the same time, thereby irritating him still more. “Nor can I admit that the object of the law is the upholding of the present state of things. The law aims at reforming—” “A nice kind of reform, in a prison!” Nekhludoff put in. “Or removing,” Rogozhinsky went on, persistently, “the perverted and brutalised persons that threaten society.” “That’s just what it doesn’t do. Society has not the means of doing either the one thing or the other.” “How is that? I don’t understand,” said Rogozhinsky with a forced smile. “I mean that only two reasonable kinds of punishment exist. Those used in the old days: corporal and capital punishment, which, as human nature gradually softens, come more and more into disuse,” said Nekhludoff. “There, now, this is quite new and very strange to hear from your lips.”

    Read in context
  • Resurrection · Leo Tolstoy (1828–1910) · CHAPTER XXXIII. THE AIM OF THE LAW.

    Nekhludoff, on the other hand, felt provoked by his brother-in-law’s interference in his affairs concerning the land. And knowing in his heart of hearts that his sister, her husband, and their children, as his heirs, had a right to do so, was indignant that this narrow-minded man persisted with calm assurance to regard as just and lawful what Nekhludoff no longer doubted was folly and crime. This man’s arrogance annoyed Nekhludoff. “What could the law do?” he asked. “It could sentence one of the two duellists to the mines like an ordinary murderer.” Nekhludoff’s hands grew cold. “Well, and what good would that be?” he asked, hotly. “It would be just.” “As if justice were the aim of the law,” said Nekhludoff. “What else?” “The upholding of class interests! I think the law is only an instrument for upholding the existing order of things beneficial to our class.” “This is a perfectly new view,” said Rogozhinsky with a quiet smile; “the law is generally supposed to have a totally different aim.” “Yes, so it has in theory but not in practice, as I have found out. The law aims only at preserving the present state of things, and therefore it persecutes and executes those who stand above the ordinary level and wish to raise it—the so-called political prisoners, as well as those who are below the average—the so-called criminal types.”

    Read in context
  • Resurrection · Leo Tolstoy (1828–1910) · CHAPTER XI. AN ADVOCATE’S VIEWS ON JUDGES AND PROSECUTORS.

    “No, but this is a striking case,” said Nekhludoff, and gave a brief outline of the case of a peasant who began to read the Gospels to the peasants in the village, and to discuss them with his friends. The priests regarded this as a crime and informed the authorities. The magistrate examined him and the public prosecutor drew up an act of indictment, and the law courts committed him for trial. “This is really too terrible,” Nekhludoff said. “Can it be true?” “What are you surprised at?” “Why, everything. I can understand the police-officer, who simply obeys orders, but the prosecutor drawing up an act of that kind. An educated man . . .” “That is where the mistake lies, that we are in the habit of considering that the prosecutors and the judges in general are some kind of liberal persons. There was a time when they were such, but now it is quite different. They are just officials, only troubled about pay-day. They receive their salaries and want them increased, and there their principles end. They will accuse, judge, and sentence any one you like.” “Yes; but do laws really exist that can condemn a man to Siberia for reading the Bible with his friends?”

    Read in context
  • Resurrection · Leo Tolstoy (1828–1910) · CHAPTER XXXII. NEKHLUDOFF’S ANARCHISM.

    “My motives are that this woman—that this woman’s first step on her way to degradation—” Nekhludoff got angry with himself, and was unable to find the right expression. “My motives are that I am the guilty one, and she gets the punishment.” “If she is being punished she cannot be innocent, either.” “She is quite innocent.” And Nekhludoff related the whole incident with unnecessary warmth. “Yes, that was a case of carelessness on the part of the president, the result of which was a thoughtless answer on the part of the jury; but there is the Senate for cases like that.” “The Senate has rejected the appeal.” “Well, if the Senate has rejected it, there cannot have been sufficient reasons for an appeal,” said Rogozhinsky, evidently sharing the prevailing opinion that truth is the product of judicial decrees. “The Senate cannot enter into the question on its merits. If there is a real mistake, the Emperor should be petitioned.” “That has been done, but there is no probability of success. They will apply to the Department of the Ministry, the Department will consult the Senate, the Senate will repeat its decision, and, as usual, the innocent will get punished.”

    Read in context
  • Resurrection · Leo Tolstoy (1828–1910) · CHAPTER XXXII. NEKHLUDOFF’S ANARCHISM.

    “In the first place, the Department of the Ministry won’t consult the Senate,” said Rogozhinsky, with a condescending smile; “it will give orders for the original deeds to be sent from the Law Court, and if it discovers a mistake it will decide accordingly. And, secondly, the innocent are never punished, or at least in very rare, exceptional cases. It is the guilty who are punished,” Rogozhinsky said deliberately, and smiled self-complacently. “And I have become fully convinced that most of those condemned by law are innocent.” “How’s that?” “Innocent in the literal sense. Just as this woman is innocent of poisoning any one; as innocent as a peasant I have just come to know, of the murder he never committed; as a mother and son who were on the point of being condemned for incendiarism, which was committed by the owner of the house that was set on fire.” “Well, of course there always have been and always will be judicial errors. Human institutions cannot be perfect.” “And, besides, there are a great many people convicted who are innocent of doing anything considered wrong by the society they have grown up in.” “Excuse me, this is not so; every thief knows that stealing is wrong, and that we should not steal; that it is immoral,” said Rogozhinsky, with his quiet, self-assured, slightly contemptuous smile, which specially irritated Nekhludoff.

    Read in context
  • Resurrection · Leo Tolstoy (1828–1910) · CHAPTER LIII. VICTIMS OF GOVERNMENT.

    “Yes, we must admit it. Still, the people are fearfully spoilt. There are such types—desperate fellows, with whom one has to look sharp. To-day two of that sort had to be punished.” “Punished? How?” “Flogged with a birch-rod, by order.” “But corporal punishment is abolished.” “Not for such as are deprived of their rights. They are still liable to it.” Nekhludoff thought of what he had seen the day before while waiting in the hall, and now understood that the punishment was then being inflicted, and the mixed feeling of curiosity, depression, perplexity, and moral nausea, that grew into physical sickness, took hold of him more strongly than ever before. Without listening to the inspector’s assistant, or looking round, he hurriedly left the corridor, and went to the office. The inspector was in the office, occupied with other business, and had forgotten to send for Doukhova. He only remembered his promise to have her called when Nekhludoff entered the office. “Sit down, please. I’ll send for her at once,” said the inspector.

    Read in context