Skip to content
BookLens

The three musketeers

Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870)

The abbess, who was the daughter of a noble house, took particular delight in stories of the court, which so seldom travel to the extremities of the kingdom, and which, above all, have so much difficulty in penetrating the walls of convents, at whose threshold the noise of the world dies away. Milady, on the contrary, was quite conversant with all aristocratic intrigues, amid which she had constantly lived for five or six years. She made it her business, therefore, to amuse the good abbess with the worldly practices of the court of France, mixed with the eccentric pursuits of the king; she made for her the scandalous chronicle of the lords and ladies of the court, whom the abbess knew perfectly by name, touched lightly on the amours of the queen and the Duke of Buckingham, talking a great deal to induce her auditor to talk a little. But the abbess contented herself with listening and smiling without replying a word. Milady, however, saw that this sort of narrative amused her very much, and kept at it; only she now let her conversation drift toward the cardinal. But she was greatly embarrassed. She did not know whether the abbess was a royalist or a cardinalist; she therefore confined herself to a prudent middle course. But the abbess, on her part, maintained a reserve still more prudent, contenting herself with making a profound inclination of the head every time the fair traveler pronounced the name of his Eminence.

Milady began to think she should soon grow weary of a convent life; she resolved, then, to risk something in order that she might know how to act afterward. Desirous of seeing how far the discretion of the good abbess would go, she began to tell a story, obscure at first, but very circumstantial afterward, about the cardinal, relating the amours of the minister with Mme. d’Aiguillon, Marion de Lorme, and several other gay women. The abbess listened more attentively, grew animated by degrees, and smiled. “Good,” thought Milady; “she takes a pleasure in my conversation. If she is a cardinalist, she has no fanaticism, at least.” She then went on to describe the persecutions exercised by the cardinal upon his enemies. The abbess only crossed herself, without approving or disapproving. This confirmed Milady in her opinion that the abbess was rather royalist than cardinalist. Milady therefore continued, coloring her narrations more and more. “I am very ignorant of these matters,” said the abbess, at length; “but however distant from the court we may be, however remote from the interests of the world we may be placed, we have very sad examples of what you have related. And one of our boarders has suffered much from the vengeance and persecution of the cardinal!” “One of your boarders?” said Milady; “oh, my God! Poor woman! I pity her, then.”

“And you have reason, for she is much to be pitied. Imprisonment, menaces, ill treatment—she has suffered everything. But after all,” resumed the abbess, “Monsieur Cardinal has perhaps plausible motives for acting thus; and though she has the look of an angel, we must not always judge people by the appearance.” “Good!” said Milady to herself; “who knows! I am about, perhaps, to discover something here; I am in the vein.” She tried to give her countenance an appearance of perfect candor. “Alas,” said Milady, “I know it is so. It is said that we must not trust to the face; but in what, then, shall we place confidence, if not in the most beautiful work of the Lord? As for me, I shall be deceived all my life perhaps, but I shall always have faith in a person whose countenance inspires me with sympathy.” “You would, then, be tempted to believe,” said the abbess, “that this young person is innocent?” “The cardinal pursues not only crimes,” said she: “there are certain virtues which he pursues more severely than certain offenses.” “Permit me, madame, to express my surprise,” said the abbess. “At what?” said Milady, with the utmost ingenuousness. “At the language you use.” “What do you find so astonishing in that language?” said Milady, smiling. “You are the friend of the cardinal, for he sends you hither, and yet—” “And yet I speak ill of him,” replied Milady, finishing the thought of the superior. “At least you don’t speak well of him.”

“That is because I am not his friend,” said she, sighing, “but his victim!” “But this letter in which he recommends you to me?” “Is an order for me to confine myself to a sort of prison, from which he will release me by one of his satellites.” “But why have you not fled?” “Whither should I go? Do you believe there is a spot on the earth which the cardinal cannot reach if he takes the trouble to stretch forth his hand? If I were a man, that would barely be possible; but what can a woman do? This young boarder of yours, has she tried to fly?” “No, that is true; but she—that is another thing; I believe she is detained in France by some love affair.” “Ah,” said Milady, with a sigh, “if she loves she is not altogether wretched.” “Then,” said the abbess, looking at Milady with increasing interest, “I behold another poor victim?” “Alas, yes,” said Milady. The abbess looked at her for an instant with uneasiness, as if a fresh thought suggested itself to her mind. “You are not an enemy of our holy faith?” said she, hesitatingly. “Who—I?” cried Milady; “I a Protestant? Oh, no! I call to witness the God who hears us, that on the contrary I am a fervent Catholic!”

“Then, madame,” said the abbess, smiling, “be reassured; the house in which you are shall not be a very hard prison, and we will do all in our power to make you cherish your captivity. You will find here, moreover, the young woman of whom I spoke, who is persecuted, no doubt, in consequence of some court intrigue. She is amiable and well-behaved.” “What is her name?” “She was sent to me by someone of high rank, under the name of Kitty. I have not tried to discover her other name.” “Kitty!” cried Milady. “What? Are you sure?” “That she is called so? Yes, madame. Do you know her?” Milady smiled to herself at the idea which had occurred to her that this might be her old chambermaid. There was connected with the remembrance of this girl a remembrance of anger; and a desire of vengeance disordered the features of Milady, which, however, immediately recovered the calm and benevolent expression which this woman of a hundred faces had for a moment allowed them to lose. “And when can I see this young lady, for whom I already feel so great a sympathy?” asked Milady. “Why, this evening,” said the abbess; “today even. But you have been traveling these four days, as you told me yourself. This morning you rose at five o’clock; you must stand in need of repose. Go to bed and sleep; at dinnertime we will rouse you.”

Passages expressing a similar idea

  • The three musketeers · Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870) · Chapter LXI. THE CARMELITE CONVENT AT BÉTHUNE

    Milady began to think she should soon grow weary of a convent life; she resolved, then, to risk something in order that she might know how to act afterward. Desirous of seeing how far the discretion of the good abbess would go, she began to tell a story, obscure at first, but very circumstantial afterward, about the cardinal, relating the amours of the minister with Mme. d’Aiguillon, Marion de Lorme, and several other gay women. The abbess listened more attentively, grew animated by degrees, and smiled. “Good,” thought Milady; “she takes a pleasure in my conversation. If she is a cardinalist, she has no fanaticism, at least.” She then went on to describe the persecutions exercised by the cardinal upon his enemies. The abbess only crossed herself, without approving or disapproving. This confirmed Milady in her opinion that the abbess was rather royalist than cardinalist. Milady therefore continued, coloring her narrations more and more. “I am very ignorant of these matters,” said the abbess, at length; “but however distant from the court we may be, however remote from the interests of the world we may be placed, we have very sad examples of what you have related. And one of our boarders has suffered much from the vengeance and persecution of the cardinal!” “One of your boarders?” said Milady; “oh, my God! Poor woman! I pity her, then.”

    Read in context
  • The three musketeers · Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870) · Chapter LXI. THE CARMELITE CONVENT AT BÉTHUNE

    “That is because I am not his friend,” said she, sighing, “but his victim!” “But this letter in which he recommends you to me?” “Is an order for me to confine myself to a sort of prison, from which he will release me by one of his satellites.” “But why have you not fled?” “Whither should I go? Do you believe there is a spot on the earth which the cardinal cannot reach if he takes the trouble to stretch forth his hand? If I were a man, that would barely be possible; but what can a woman do? This young boarder of yours, has she tried to fly?” “No, that is true; but she—that is another thing; I believe she is detained in France by some love affair.” “Ah,” said Milady, with a sigh, “if she loves she is not altogether wretched.” “Then,” said the abbess, looking at Milady with increasing interest, “I behold another poor victim?” “Alas, yes,” said Milady. The abbess looked at her for an instant with uneasiness, as if a fresh thought suggested itself to her mind. “You are not an enemy of our holy faith?” said she, hesitatingly. “Who—I?” cried Milady; “I a Protestant? Oh, no! I call to witness the God who hears us, that on the contrary I am a fervent Catholic!”

    Read in context
  • The three musketeers · Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870) · Chapter LXI. THE CARMELITE CONVENT AT BÉTHUNE

    “Oh, you beautiful, good little creature!” said Milady. “How delighted I am to have found you! Let me look at you!” and while saying these words, she absolutely devoured her by her looks. “Oh, yes it is you indeed! From what he has told me, I know you now. I recognize you perfectly.” The poor young woman could not possibly suspect what frightful cruelty was behind the rampart of that pure brow, behind those brilliant eyes in which she read nothing but interest and compassion. “Then you know what I have suffered,” said Mme. Bonacieux, “since he has told you what he has suffered; but to suffer for him is happiness.” Milady replied mechanically, “Yes, that is happiness.” She was thinking of something else. “And then,” continued Mme. Bonacieux, “my punishment is drawing to a close. Tomorrow, this evening, perhaps, I shall see him again; and then the past will no longer exist.” “This evening?” asked Milady, roused from her reverie by these words. “What do you mean? Do you expect news from him?” “I expect himself.” “Himself? D’Artagnan here?” “Himself!” “But that’s impossible! He is at the siege of La Rochelle with the cardinal. He will not return till after the taking of the city.” “Ah, you fancy so! But is there anything impossible for my D’Artagnan, the noble and loyal gentleman?” “Oh, I cannot believe you!” “Well, read, then!” said the unhappy young woman, in the excess of her pride and joy, presenting a letter to Milady.

    Read in context
  • The three musketeers · Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870) · Chapter XLIV. THE UTILITY OF STOVEPIPES

    “Oh, your Eminence knows him well,” cried Milady, carried away by her anger. “He is the evil genius of both of us. It is he who in an encounter with your Eminence’s Guards decided the victory in favor of the king’s Musketeers; it is he who gave three desperate wounds to De Wardes, your emissary, and who caused the affair of the diamond studs to fail; it is he who, knowing it was I who had Madame Bonacieux carried off, has sworn my death.” “Ah, ah!” said the cardinal, “I know of whom you speak.” “I mean that miserable D’Artagnan.” “He is a bold fellow,” said the cardinal. “And it is exactly because he is a bold fellow that he is the more to be feared.” “I must have,” said the duke, “a proof of his connection with Buckingham.” “A proof?” cried Milady; “I will have ten.” “Well, then, it becomes the simplest thing in the world; get me that proof, and I will send him to the Bastille.” “So far good, monseigneur; but afterwards?” “When once in the Bastille, there is no afterward!” said the cardinal, in a low voice. “Ah, pardieu!” continued he, “if it were as easy for me to get rid of my enemy as it is easy to get rid of yours, and if it were against such people you require impunity—” “Monseigneur,” replied Milady, “a fair exchange. Life for life, man for man; give me one, I will give you the other.”

    Read in context
  • The three musketeers · Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870) · Chapter LXI. THE CARMELITE CONVENT AT BÉTHUNE

    “Then, madame,” said the abbess, smiling, “be reassured; the house in which you are shall not be a very hard prison, and we will do all in our power to make you cherish your captivity. You will find here, moreover, the young woman of whom I spoke, who is persecuted, no doubt, in consequence of some court intrigue. She is amiable and well-behaved.” “What is her name?” “She was sent to me by someone of high rank, under the name of Kitty. I have not tried to discover her other name.” “Kitty!” cried Milady. “What? Are you sure?” “That she is called so? Yes, madame. Do you know her?” Milady smiled to herself at the idea which had occurred to her that this might be her old chambermaid. There was connected with the remembrance of this girl a remembrance of anger; and a desire of vengeance disordered the features of Milady, which, however, immediately recovered the calm and benevolent expression which this woman of a hundred faces had for a moment allowed them to lose. “And when can I see this young lady, for whom I already feel so great a sympathy?” asked Milady. “Why, this evening,” said the abbess; “today even. But you have been traveling these four days, as you told me yourself. This morning you rose at five o’clock; you must stand in need of repose. Go to bed and sleep; at dinnertime we will rouse you.”

    Read in context
  • The three musketeers · Alexandre Dumas (1802–1870) · Chapter LXVII. CONCLUSION

    “You are charged with having corresponded with the enemies of the kingdom; you are charged with having surprised state secrets; you are charged with having tried to thwart the plans of your general.” “And who charges me with this, monseigneur?” said D’Artagnan, who had no doubt the accusation came from Milady, “a woman branded by the justice of the country; a woman who has espoused one man in France and another in England; a woman who poisoned her second husband and who attempted both to poison and assassinate me!” “What do you say, monsieur?” cried the cardinal, astonished; “and of what woman are you speaking thus?” “Of Milady de Winter,” replied D’Artagnan, “yes, of Milady de Winter, of whose crimes your Eminence is doubtless ignorant, since you have honored her with your confidence.” “Monsieur,” said the cardinal, “if Milady de Winter has committed the crimes you lay to her charge, she shall be punished.” “She has been punished, monseigneur.” “And who has punished her?” “We.” “She is in prison?” “She is dead.” “Dead!” repeated the cardinal, who could not believe what he heard, “dead! Did you not say she was dead?” “Three times she attempted to kill me, and I pardoned her; but she murdered the woman I loved. Then my friends and I took her, tried her, and condemned her.” D’Artagnan then related the poisoning of Mme. Bonacieux in the convent of the Carmelites at Béthune, the trial in the isolated house, and the execution on the banks of the Lys.

    Read in context