Skip to content
BookLens

Our Mutual Friend

Charles Dickens (1812–1870)

Now, too, was he cursed with a state of mind more wearing and more wearisome than remorse. He had no remorse; but the evildoer who can hold that avenger at bay, cannot escape the slower torture of incessantly doing the evil deed again and doing it more efficiently. In the defensive declarations and pretended confessions of murderers, the pursuing shadow of this torture may be traced through every lie they tell. If I had done it as alleged, is it conceivable that I would have made this and this mistake? If I had done it as alleged, should I have left that unguarded place which that false and wicked witness against me so infamously deposed to? The state of that wretch who continually finds the weak spots in his own crime, and strives to strengthen them when it is unchangeable, is a state that aggravates the offence by doing the deed a thousand times instead of once; but it is a state, too, that tauntingly visits the offence upon a sullen unrepentant nature with its heaviest punishment every time.

Bradley toiled on, chained heavily to the idea of his hatred and his vengeance, and thinking how he might have satiated both in many better ways than the way he had taken. The instrument might have been better, the spot and the hour might have been better chosen. To batter a man down from behind in the dark, on the brink of a river, was well enough, but he ought to have been instantly disabled, whereas he had turned and seized his assailant; and so, to end it before chance-help came, and to be rid of him, he had been hurriedly thrown backward into the river before the life was fully beaten out of him. Now if it could be done again, it must not be so done. Supposing his head had been held down under water for a while. Supposing the first blow had been truer. Supposing he had been shot. Supposing he had been strangled. Suppose this way, that way, the other way. Suppose anything but getting unchained from the one idea, for that was inexorably impossible.

The school reopened next day. The scholars saw little or no change in their master’s face, for it always wore its slowly labouring expression. But, as he heard his classes, he was always doing the deed and doing it better. As he paused with his piece of chalk at the black board before writing on it, he was thinking of the spot, and whether the water was not deeper and the fall straighter, a little higher up, or a little lower down. He had half a mind to draw a line or two upon the board, and show himself what he meant. He was doing it again and improving on the manner, at prayers, in his mental arithmetic, all through his questioning, all through the day. Charley Hexam was a master now, in another school, under another head. It was evening, and Bradley was walking in his garden observed from behind a blind by gentle little Miss Peecher, who contemplated offering him a loan of her smelling salts for headache, when Mary Anne, in faithful attendance, held up her arm. ‘Yes, Mary Anne?’ ‘Young Mr Hexam, if you please, ma’am, coming to see Mr Headstone.’ ‘Very good, Mary Anne.’ Again Mary Anne held up her arm. ‘You may speak, Mary Anne?’ ‘Mr Headstone has beckoned young Mr Hexam into his house, ma’am, and he has gone in himself without waiting for young Mr Hexam to come up, and now he has gone in too, ma’am, and has shut the door.’ ‘With all my heart, Mary Anne.’

Again Mary Anne’s telegraphic arm worked. ‘What more, Mary Anne?’ ‘They must find it rather dull and dark, Miss Peecher, for the parlour blind’s down, and neither of them pulls it up.’ ‘There is no accounting,’ said good Miss Peecher with a little sad sigh which she repressed by laying her hand on her neat methodical boddice, ‘there is no accounting for tastes, Mary Anne.’ Charley, entering the dark room, stopped short when he saw his old friend in its yellow shade. ‘Come in, Hexam, come in.’ Charley advanced to take the hand that was held out to him; but stopped again, short of it. The heavy, bloodshot eyes of the schoolmaster, rising to his face with an effort, met his look of scrutiny. ‘Mr Headstone, what’s the matter?’ ‘Matter? Where?’ ‘Mr Headstone, have you heard the news? This news about the fellow, Mr Eugene Wrayburn? That he is killed?’ ‘He is dead, then!’ exclaimed Bradley. Young Hexam standing looking at him, he moistened his lips with his tongue, looked about the room, glanced at his former pupil, and looked down. ‘I heard of the outrage,’ said Bradley, trying to constrain his working mouth, ‘but I had not heard the end of it.’ ‘Where were you,’ said the boy, advancing a step as he lowered his voice, ‘when it was done? Stop! I don’t ask that. Don’t tell me. If you force your confidence upon me, Mr Headstone, I’ll give up every word of it. Mind! Take notice. I’ll give up it, and I’ll give up you. I will!’

The wretched creature seemed to suffer acutely under this renunciation. A desolate air of utter and complete loneliness fell upon him, like a visible shade. ‘It’s for me to speak, not you,’ said the boy. ‘If you do, you’ll do it at your peril. I am going to put your selfishness before you, Mr Headstone—your passionate, violent, and ungovernable selfishness—to show you why I can, and why I will, have nothing more to do with you.’ He looked at young Hexam as if he were waiting for a scholar to go on with a lesson that he knew by heart and was deadly tired of. But he had said his last word to him.

Passages expressing a similar idea

  • Our Mutual Friend · Charles Dickens (1812–1870) · Chapter 7 / BETTER TO BE ABEL THAN CAIN

    Again Mary Anne’s telegraphic arm worked. ‘What more, Mary Anne?’ ‘They must find it rather dull and dark, Miss Peecher, for the parlour blind’s down, and neither of them pulls it up.’ ‘There is no accounting,’ said good Miss Peecher with a little sad sigh which she repressed by laying her hand on her neat methodical boddice, ‘there is no accounting for tastes, Mary Anne.’ Charley, entering the dark room, stopped short when he saw his old friend in its yellow shade. ‘Come in, Hexam, come in.’ Charley advanced to take the hand that was held out to him; but stopped again, short of it. The heavy, bloodshot eyes of the schoolmaster, rising to his face with an effort, met his look of scrutiny. ‘Mr Headstone, what’s the matter?’ ‘Matter? Where?’ ‘Mr Headstone, have you heard the news? This news about the fellow, Mr Eugene Wrayburn? That he is killed?’ ‘He is dead, then!’ exclaimed Bradley. Young Hexam standing looking at him, he moistened his lips with his tongue, looked about the room, glanced at his former pupil, and looked down. ‘I heard of the outrage,’ said Bradley, trying to constrain his working mouth, ‘but I had not heard the end of it.’ ‘Where were you,’ said the boy, advancing a step as he lowered his voice, ‘when it was done? Stop! I don’t ask that. Don’t tell me. If you force your confidence upon me, Mr Headstone, I’ll give up every word of it. Mind! Take notice. I’ll give up it, and I’ll give up you. I will!’

    Read in context
  • Our Mutual Friend · Charles Dickens (1812–1870) · Chapter 11 / SOME AFFAIRS OF THE HEART

    ‘Mr Headstone coming across the garden!’ exclaimed Miss Peecher, with a flushed glance at the looking-glass. ‘You have answered very well, Mary Anne. You are forming an excellent habit of arranging your thoughts clearly. That will do.’ The discreet Mary Anne resumed her seat and her silence, and stitched, and stitched, and was stitching when the schoolmaster’s shadow came in before him, announcing that he might be instantly expected. ‘Good evening, Miss Peecher,’ he said, pursuing the shadow, and taking its place. ‘Good evening, Mr Headstone. Mary Anne, a chair.’ ‘Thank you,’ said Bradley, seating himself in his constrained manner. ‘This is but a flying visit. I have looked in, on my way, to ask a kindness of you as a neighbour.’ ‘Did you say on your way, Mr Headstone?’ asked Miss Peecher. ‘On my way to—where I am going.’ ‘Church Street, Smith Square, by Mill Bank,’ repeated Miss Peecher, in her own thoughts. ‘Charley Hexam has gone to get a book or two he wants, and will probably be back before me. As we leave my house empty, I took the liberty of telling him I would leave the key here. Would you kindly allow me to do so?’ ‘Certainly, Mr Headstone. Going for an evening walk, sir?’ ‘Partly for a walk, and partly for—on business.’ ‘Business in Church Street, Smith Square, by Mill Bank,’ repeated Miss Peecher to herself. ‘Having said which,’ pursued Bradley, laying his door-key on the table, ‘I must be already going. There is nothing I can do for you, Miss Peecher?’

    Read in context
  • Our Mutual Friend · Charles Dickens (1812–1870) · Chapter 11 / EFFECT IS GIVEN TO THE DOLLS’ DRESSMAKER’S DISCOVERY

    ‘I will endeavour to take care, sir. Might I beg leave to speak to you, outside, a moment?’ ‘By all means.’ It was evening, and the office was well lighted. The schoolmaster, who had never remitted his watch on Lightwood’s door, now moved by another door to a corner without, where there was more shadow than light; and said, plucking at his gloves: ‘One of your ladies, sir, mentioned within my hearing a name that I am acquainted with; I may say, well acquainted with. The name of the sister of an old pupil of mine. He was my pupil for a long time, and has got on and gone upward rapidly. The name of Hexam. The name of Lizzie Hexam.’ He seemed to be a shy man, struggling against nervousness, and spoke in a very constrained way. The break he set between his last two sentences was quite embarrassing to his hearer. ‘Yes,’ replied Mr Milvey. ‘We are going down to see her.’ ‘I gathered as much, sir. I hope there is nothing amiss with the sister of my old pupil? I hope no bereavement has befallen her. I hope she is in no affliction? Has lost no—relation?’ Mr Milvey thought this a man with a very odd manner, and a dark downward look; but he answered in his usual open way. ‘I am glad to tell you, Mr Headstone, that the sister of your old pupil has not sustained any such loss. You thought I might be going down to bury some one?’

    Read in context
  • Our Mutual Friend · Charles Dickens (1812–1870) · BOOK THE SECOND — BIRDS OF A FEATHER / Chapter 1 / OF AN EDUCATIONAL CHARACTER

    ‘Hexam and I are going to take a long walk.’ ‘Charming weather,’ remarked Miss Peecher, ‘for a long walk.’ ‘Ours is rather on business than mere pleasure,’ said the Master. Miss Peecher inverting her watering-pot, and very carefully shaking out the few last drops over a flower, as if there were some special virtue in them which would make it a Jack’s beanstalk before morning, called for replenishment to her pupil, who had been speaking to the boy. ‘Good-night, Miss Peecher,’ said the Master. ‘Good-night, Mr Headstone,’ said the Mistress. The pupil had been, in her state of pupilage, so imbued with the class-custom of stretching out an arm, as if to hail a cab or omnibus, whenever she found she had an observation on hand to offer to Miss Peecher, that she often did it in their domestic relations; and she did it now. ‘Well, Mary Anne?’ said Miss Peecher. ‘If you please, ma’am, Hexam said they were going to see his sister.’ ‘But that can’t be, I think,’ returned Miss Peecher: ‘because Mr Headstone can have no business with her.’ Mary Anne again hailed. ‘Well, Mary Anne?’ ‘If you please, ma’am, perhaps it’s Hexam’s business?’ ‘That may be,’ said Miss Peecher. ‘I didn’t think of that. Not that it matters at all.’ Mary Anne again hailed. ‘Well, Mary Anne?’ ‘They say she’s very handsome.’

    Read in context
  • Our Mutual Friend · Charles Dickens (1812–1870) · Chapter 11 / SOME AFFAIRS OF THE HEART

    The schoolmaster went his way, brooding and brooding, and a sense of being vanquished in a struggle might have been pieced out of his worried face. Truly, in his breast there lingered a resentful shame to find himself defeated by this passion for Charley Hexam’s sister, though in the very self-same moments he was concentrating himself upon the object of bringing the passion to a successful issue. He appeared before the dolls’ dressmaker, sitting alone at her work. ‘Oho!’ thought that sharp young personage, ‘it’s you, is it? I know your tricks and your manners, my friend!’ ‘Hexam’s sister,’ said Bradley Headstone, ‘is not come home yet?’ ‘You are quite a conjuror,’ returned Miss Wren. ‘I will wait, if you please, for I want to speak to her.’ ‘Do you?’ returned Miss Wren. ‘Sit down. I hope it’s mutual.’ Bradley glanced distrustfully at the shrewd face again bending over the work, and said, trying to conquer doubt and hesitation: ‘I hope you don’t imply that my visit will be unacceptable to Hexam’s sister?’ ‘There! Don’t call her that. I can’t bear you to call her that,’ returned Miss Wren, snapping her fingers in a volley of impatient snaps, ‘for I don’t like Hexam.’ ‘Indeed?’ ‘No.’ Miss Wren wrinkled her nose, to express dislike. ‘Selfish. Thinks only of himself. The way with all of you.’ ‘The way with all of us? Then you don’t like me?’ ‘So-so,’ replied Miss Wren, with a shrug and a laugh. ‘Don’t know much about you.’

    Read in context
  • David Copperfield · Charles Dickens (1812–1870) · CHAPTER 7. MY ‘FIRST HALF’ AT SALEM HOUSE

    School began in earnest next day. A profound impression was made upon me, I remember, by the roar of voices in the schoolroom suddenly becoming hushed as death when Mr. Creakle entered after breakfast, and stood in the doorway looking round upon us like a giant in a story-book surveying his captives. Tungay stood at Mr. Creakle’s elbow. He had no occasion, I thought, to cry out ‘Silence!’ so ferociously, for the boys were all struck speechless and motionless. Mr. Creakle was seen to speak, and Tungay was heard, to this effect. ‘Now, boys, this is a new half. Take care what you’re about, in this new half. Come fresh up to the lessons, I advise you, for I come fresh up to the punishment. I won’t flinch. It will be of no use your rubbing yourselves; you won’t rub the marks out that I shall give you. Now get to work, every boy!’

    Read in context