Skip to content
BookLens

Our Mutual Friend

Charles Dickens (1812–1870)

The late John Harmon, looking at the proud face with the down-cast eyes, and at the quick breathing as it stirred the fall of bright brown hair over the beautiful neck, would probably have remained silent. ‘I wish to speak to you, sir,’ said Bella, ‘once for all, and I don’t know how to do it. I have sat here all this evening, wishing to speak to you, and determining to speak to you, and feeling that I must. I beg for a moment’s time.’ He remained silent, and she remained with her face averted, sometimes making a slight movement as if she would turn and speak. At length she did so. ‘You know how I am situated here, sir, and you know how I am situated at home. I must speak to you for myself, since there is no one about me whom I could ask to do so. It is not generous in you, it is not honourable in you, to conduct yourself towards me as you do.’ ‘Is it ungenerous or dishonourable to be devoted to you; fascinated by you?’ ‘Preposterous!’ said Bella. The late John Harmon might have thought it rather a contemptuous and lofty word of repudiation. ‘I now feel obliged to go on,’ pursued the Secretary, ‘though it were only in self-explanation and self-defence. I hope, Miss Wilfer, that it is not unpardonable—even in me—to make an honest declaration of an honest devotion to you.’ ‘An honest declaration!’ repeated Bella, with emphasis. ‘Is it otherwise?’

‘I must request, sir,’ said Bella, taking refuge in a touch of timely resentment, ‘that I may not be questioned. You must excuse me if I decline to be cross-examined.’ ‘Oh, Miss Wilfer, this is hardly charitable. I ask you nothing but what your own emphasis suggests. However, I waive even that question. But what I have declared, I take my stand by. I cannot recall the avowal of my earnest and deep attachment to you, and I do not recall it.’ ‘I reject it, sir,’ said Bella. ‘I should be blind and deaf if I were not prepared for the reply. Forgive my offence, for it carries its punishment with it.’ ‘What punishment?’ asked Bella. ‘Is my present endurance none? But excuse me; I did not mean to cross-examine you again.’ ‘You take advantage of a hasty word of mine,’ said Bella with a little sting of self-reproach, ‘to make me seem—I don’t know what. I spoke without consideration when I used it. If that was bad, I am sorry; but you repeat it after consideration, and that seems to me to be at least no better. For the rest, I beg it may be understood, Mr Rokesmith, that there is an end of this between us, now and for ever.’ ‘Now and for ever,’ he repeated.

‘Yes. I appeal to you, sir,’ proceeded Bella with increasing spirit, ‘not to pursue me. I appeal to you not to take advantage of your position in this house to make my position in it distressing and disagreeable. I appeal to you to discontinue your habit of making your misplaced attentions as plain to Mrs Boffin as to me.’ ‘Have I done so?’ ‘I should think you have,’ replied Bella. ‘In any case it is not your fault if you have not, Mr Rokesmith.’ ‘I hope you are wrong in that impression. I should be very sorry to have justified it. I think I have not. For the future there is no apprehension. It is all over.’ ‘I am much relieved to hear it,’ said Bella. ‘I have far other views in life, and why should you waste your own?’ ‘Mine!’ said the Secretary. ‘My life!’ His curious tone caused Bella to glance at the curious smile with which he said it. It was gone as he glanced back. ‘Pardon me, Miss Wilfer,’ he proceeded, when their eyes met; ‘you have used some hard words, for which I do not doubt you have a justification in your mind, that I do not understand. Ungenerous and dishonourable. In what?’ ‘I would rather not be asked,’ said Bella, haughtily looking down. ‘I would rather not ask, but the question is imposed upon me. Kindly explain; or if not kindly, justly.’

‘Oh, sir!’ said Bella, raising her eyes to his, after a little struggle to forbear, ‘is it generous and honourable to use the power here which your favour with Mr and Mrs Boffin and your ability in your place give you, against me?’ ‘Against you?’ ‘Is it generous and honourable to form a plan for gradually bringing their influence to bear upon a suit which I have shown you that I do not like, and which I tell you that I utterly reject?’ The late John Harmon could have borne a good deal, but he would have been cut to the heart by such a suspicion as this. ‘Would it be generous and honourable to step into your place—if you did so, for I don’t know that you did, and I hope you did not—anticipating, or knowing beforehand, that I should come here, and designing to take me at this disadvantage?’ ‘This mean and cruel disadvantage,’ said the Secretary. ‘Yes,’ assented Bella. The Secretary kept silence for a little while; then merely said, ‘You are wholly mistaken, Miss Wilfer; wonderfully mistaken. I cannot say, however, that it is your fault. If I deserve better things of you, you do not know it.’

‘At least, sir,’ retorted Bella, with her old indignation rising, ‘you know the history of my being here at all. I have heard Mr Boffin say that you are master of every line and word of that will, as you are master of all his affairs. And was it not enough that I should have been willed away, like a horse, or a dog, or a bird; but must you too begin to dispose of me in your mind, and speculate in me, as soon as I had ceased to be the talk and the laugh of the town? Am I for ever to be made the property of strangers?’ ‘Believe me,’ returned the Secretary, ‘you are wonderfully mistaken.’ ‘I should be glad to know it,’ answered Bella. ‘I doubt if you ever will. Good-night. Of course I shall be careful to conceal any traces of this interview from Mr and Mrs Boffin, as long as I remain here. Trust me, what you have complained of is at an end for ever.’ ‘I am glad I have spoken, then, Mr Rokesmith. It has been painful and difficult, but it is done. If I have hurt you, I hope you will forgive me. I am inexperienced and impetuous, and I have been a little spoilt; but I really am not so bad as I dare say I appear, or as you think me.’

Passages expressing a similar idea

  • Our Mutual Friend · Charles Dickens (1812–1870) · Chapter 9 / SOMEBODY BECOMES THE SUBJECT OF A PREDICTION

    ‘I have very strong reasons, Miss Wilfer, for bearing with the drawbacks of my position in the house we both inhabit. Believe that they are not all mercenary, although I have, through a series of strange fatalities, faded out of my place in life. If what you see with such a gracious and good sympathy is calculated to rouse my pride, there are other considerations (and those you do not see) urging me to quiet endurance. The latter are by far the stronger.’ ‘I think I have noticed, Mr Rokesmith,’ said Bella, looking at him with curiosity, as not quite making him out, ‘that you repress yourself, and force yourself, to act a passive part.’ ‘You are right. I repress myself and force myself to act a part. It is not in tameness of spirit that I submit. I have a settled purpose.’ ‘And a good one, I hope,’ said Bella. ‘And a good one, I hope,’ he answered, looking steadily at her. ‘Sometimes I have fancied, sir,’ said Bella, turning away her eyes, ‘that your great regard for Mrs Boffin is a very powerful motive with you.’ ‘You are right again; it is. I would do anything for her, bear anything for her. There are no words to express how I esteem that good, good woman.’ ‘As I do too! May I ask you one thing more, Mr Rokesmith?’ ‘Anything more.’ ‘Of course you see that she really suffers, when Mr Boffin shows how he is changing?’

    Read in context
  • Our Mutual Friend · Charles Dickens (1812–1870) · Chapter 8 / IN WHICH AN INNOCENT ELOPEMENT OCCURS

    ‘I should beg you not to do so, but that it shows you to such admirable advantage,’ he replied with earnestness. ‘Forgive me; I could not help saying that. To return to what I have digressed from, let me add that perhaps they think I report them to you, deliver little messages, and the like. But I forbear to trouble you, as you never ask me.’ ‘I am going, sir,’ said Bella, looking at him as if he had reproved her, ‘to see them tomorrow.’ ‘Is that,’ he asked, hesitating, ‘said to me, or to them?’ ‘To which you please.’ ‘To both? Shall I make it a message?’ ‘You can if you like, Mr Rokesmith. Message or no message, I am going to see them tomorrow.’ ‘Then I will tell them so.’ He lingered a moment, as though to give her the opportunity of prolonging the conversation if she wished. As she remained silent, he left her. Two incidents of the little interview were felt by Miss Bella herself, when alone again, to be very curious. The first was, that he unquestionably left her with a penitent air upon her, and a penitent feeling in her heart. The second was, that she had not an intention or a thought of going home, until she had announced it to him as a settled design.

    Read in context
  • Our Mutual Friend · Charles Dickens (1812–1870) · Chapter 9 / SOMEBODY BECOMES THE SUBJECT OF A PREDICTION

    ‘But you once depreciated me, sir,’ thought Bella, pouting, ‘and I hope you may be satisfied with the consequences you brought upon your head!’ However, she said nothing to that purpose; she even said something to a different purpose. ‘Mr Rokesmith, it seems so long since we spoke together naturally, that I am embarrassed in approaching another subject. Mr Boffin. You know I am very grateful to him; don’t you? You know I feel a true respect for him, and am bound to him by the strong ties of his own generosity; now don’t you?’ ‘Unquestionably. And also that you are his favourite companion.’ ‘That makes it,’ said Bella, ‘so very difficult to speak of him. But—. Does he treat you well?’ ‘You see how he treats me,’ the Secretary answered, with a patient and yet proud air. ‘Yes, and I see it with pain,’ said Bella, very energetically. The Secretary gave her such a radiant look, that if he had thanked her a hundred times, he could not have said as much as the look said. ‘I see it with pain,’ repeated Bella, ‘and it often makes me miserable. Miserable, because I cannot bear to be supposed to approve of it, or have any indirect share in it. Miserable, because I cannot bear to be forced to admit to myself that Fortune is spoiling Mr Boffin.’

    Read in context
  • Our Mutual Friend · Charles Dickens (1812–1870) · Chapter 13 / A SOLO AND A DUETT

    ‘I must request, sir,’ said Bella, taking refuge in a touch of timely resentment, ‘that I may not be questioned. You must excuse me if I decline to be cross-examined.’ ‘Oh, Miss Wilfer, this is hardly charitable. I ask you nothing but what your own emphasis suggests. However, I waive even that question. But what I have declared, I take my stand by. I cannot recall the avowal of my earnest and deep attachment to you, and I do not recall it.’ ‘I reject it, sir,’ said Bella. ‘I should be blind and deaf if I were not prepared for the reply. Forgive my offence, for it carries its punishment with it.’ ‘What punishment?’ asked Bella. ‘Is my present endurance none? But excuse me; I did not mean to cross-examine you again.’ ‘You take advantage of a hasty word of mine,’ said Bella with a little sting of self-reproach, ‘to make me seem—I don’t know what. I spoke without consideration when I used it. If that was bad, I am sorry; but you repeat it after consideration, and that seems to me to be at least no better. For the rest, I beg it may be understood, Mr Rokesmith, that there is an end of this between us, now and for ever.’ ‘Now and for ever,’ he repeated.

    Read in context
  • Our Mutual Friend · Charles Dickens (1812–1870) · Chapter 13 / A SOLO AND A DUETT

    ‘At least, sir,’ retorted Bella, with her old indignation rising, ‘you know the history of my being here at all. I have heard Mr Boffin say that you are master of every line and word of that will, as you are master of all his affairs. And was it not enough that I should have been willed away, like a horse, or a dog, or a bird; but must you too begin to dispose of me in your mind, and speculate in me, as soon as I had ceased to be the talk and the laugh of the town? Am I for ever to be made the property of strangers?’ ‘Believe me,’ returned the Secretary, ‘you are wonderfully mistaken.’ ‘I should be glad to know it,’ answered Bella. ‘I doubt if you ever will. Good-night. Of course I shall be careful to conceal any traces of this interview from Mr and Mrs Boffin, as long as I remain here. Trust me, what you have complained of is at an end for ever.’ ‘I am glad I have spoken, then, Mr Rokesmith. It has been painful and difficult, but it is done. If I have hurt you, I hope you will forgive me. I am inexperienced and impetuous, and I have been a little spoilt; but I really am not so bad as I dare say I appear, or as you think me.’

    Read in context
  • Our Mutual Friend · Charles Dickens (1812–1870) · Chapter 13 / A SOLO AND A DUETT

    ‘Mr Rokesmith,’ said Bella, taking up her work, and inspecting it all round the corners, ‘I wanted to say something to you when I could have the opportunity, as an explanation why I was rude to you the other day. You have no right to think ill of me, sir.’ The sharp little way in which she darted a look at him, half sensitively injured, and half pettishly, would have been very much admired by the late John Harmon. ‘You don’t know how well I think of you, Miss Wilfer.’ ‘Truly, you must have a very high opinion of me, Mr Rokesmith, when you believe that in prosperity I neglect and forget my old home.’ ‘Do I believe so?’ ‘You did, sir, at any rate,’ returned Bella. ‘I took the liberty of reminding you of a little omission into which you had fallen—insensibly and naturally fallen. It was no more than that.’ ‘And I beg leave to ask you, Mr Rokesmith,’ said Bella, ‘why you took that liberty?—I hope there is no offence in the phrase; it is your own, remember.’ ‘Because I am truly, deeply, profoundly interested in you, Miss Wilfer. Because I wish to see you always at your best. Because I—shall I go on?’ ‘No, sir,’ returned Bella, with a burning face, ‘you have said more than enough. I beg that you will not go on. If you have any generosity, any honour, you will say no more.’

    Read in context