Sons and Lovers
D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)
“Because Dr. Ansell said you didn’t know anybody here. Do you?” “I know nobody nowhere,” said Dawes. “Well,” said Paul, “it’s because you don’t choose to, then.” There was another silence. “We s’ll be taking my mother home as soon as we can,” said Paul. “What’s a-matter with her?” asked Dawes, with a sick man’s interest in illness. “She’s got a cancer.” There was another silence. “But we want to get her home,” said Paul. “We s’ll have to get a motor-car.” Dawes lay thinking. “Why don’t you ask Thomas Jordan to lend you his?” said Dawes. “It’s not big enough,” Morel answered. Dawes blinked his dark eyes as he lay thinking. “Then ask Jack Pilkington; he’d lend it you. You know him.” “I think I s’ll hire one,” said Paul. “You’re a fool if you do,” said Dawes. The sick man was gaunt and handsome again. Paul was sorry for him because his eyes looked so tired. “Did you get a job here?” he asked. “I was only here a day or two before I was taken bad,” Dawes replied. “You want to get in a convalescent home,” said Paul. The other’s face clouded again. “I’m goin’ in no convalescent home,” he said. “My father’s been in the one at Seathorpe, an’ he liked it. Dr. Ansell would get you a recommend.” Dawes lay thinking. It was evident he dared not face the world again. “The seaside would be all right just now,” Morel said. “Sun on those sandhills, and the waves not far out.”
The other did not answer. “By Gad!” Paul concluded, too miserable to bother much; “it’s all right when you know you’re going to walk again, and swim!” Dawes glanced at him quickly. The man’s dark eyes were afraid to meet any other eyes in the world. But the real misery and helplessness in Paul’s tone gave him a feeling of relief. “Is she far gone?” he asked. “She’s going like wax,” Paul answered; “but cheerful—lively!” He bit his lip. After a minute he rose. “Well, I’ll be going,” he said. “I’ll leave you this half-crown.” “I don’t want it,” Dawes muttered. Morel did not answer, but left the coin on the table. “Well,” he said, “I’ll try and run in when I’m back in Sheffield. Happen you might like to see my brother-in-law? He works in Pyecrofts.” “I don’t know him,” said Dawes. “He’s all right. Should I tell him to come? He might bring you some papers to look at.” The other man did not answer. Paul went. The strong emotion that Dawes aroused in him, repressed, made him shiver. He did not tell his mother, but next day he spoke to Clara about this interview. It was in the dinner-hour. The two did not often go out together now, but this day he asked her to go with him to the Castle grounds. There they sat while the scarlet geraniums and the yellow calceolarias blazed in the sunlight. She was now always rather protective, and rather resentful towards him.
“Did you know Baxter was in Sheffield Hospital with typhoid?” he asked. She looked at him with startled grey eyes, and her face went pale. “No,” she said, frightened. “He’s getting better. I went to see him yesterday—the doctor told me.” Clara seemed stricken by the news. “Is he very bad?” she asked guiltily. “He has been. He’s mending now.” “What did he say to you?” “Oh, nothing! He seems to be sulking.” There was a distance between the two of them. He gave her more information. She went about shut up and silent. The next time they took a walk together, she disengaged herself from his arm, and walked at a distance from him. He was wanting her comfort badly. “Won’t you be nice with me?” he asked. She did not answer. “What’s the matter?” he said, putting his arm across her shoulder. “Don’t!” she said, disengaging herself. He left her alone, and returned to his own brooding. “Is it Baxter that upsets you?” he asked at length. “I have been vile to him!” she said. “I’ve said many a time you haven’t treated him well,” he replied. And there was a hostility between them. Each pursued his own train of thought. “I’ve treated him—no, I’ve treated him badly,” she said. “And now you treat me badly. It serves me right.” “How do I treat you badly?” he said.
“It serves me right,” she repeated. “I never considered him worth having, and now you don’t consider me. But it serves me right. He loved me a thousand times better than you ever did.” “He didn’t!” protested Paul. “He did! At any rate, he did respect me, and that’s what you don’t do.” “It looked as if he respected you!” he said. “He did! And I made him horrid—I know I did! You’ve taught me that. And he loved me a thousand times better than ever you do.” “All right,” said Paul. He only wanted to be left alone now. He had his own trouble, which was almost too much to bear. Clara only tormented him and made him tired. He was not sorry when he left her.
She went on the first opportunity to Sheffield to see her husband. The meeting was not a success. But she left him roses and fruit and money. She wanted to make restitution. It was not that she loved him. As she looked at him lying there her heart did not warm with love. Only she wanted to humble herself to him, to kneel before him. She wanted now to be self-sacrificial. After all, she had failed to make Morel really love her. She was morally frightened. She wanted to do penance. So she kneeled to Dawes, and it gave him a subtle pleasure. But the distance between them was still very great—too great. It frightened the man. It almost pleased the woman. She liked to feel she was serving him across an insuperable distance. She was proud now. Morel went to see Dawes once or twice. There was a sort of friendship between the two men, who were all the while deadly rivals. But they never mentioned the woman who was between them. Mrs. Morel got gradually worse. At first they used to carry her downstairs, sometimes even into the garden. She sat propped in her chair, smiling, and so pretty. The gold wedding-ring shone on her white hand; her hair was carefully brushed. And she watched the tangled sunflowers dying, the chrysanthemums coming out, and the dahlias.
Passages expressing a similar idea
Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XIV THE RELEASE
“Oh, how horrible!” said Clara, too frightened to speak. “And she looks at me, and she wants to stay with me,” he went on monotonously. “She’s got such a will, it seems as if she would never go—never!” “Don’t think of it!” cried Clara. “And she was religious—she is religious now—but it is no good. She simply won’t give in. And do you know, I said to her on Thursday: ‘Mother, if I had to die, I’d die. I’d will to die.’ And she said to me, sharp: ‘Do you think I haven’t? Do you think you can die when you like?’” His voice ceased. He did not cry, only went on speaking monotonously. Clara wanted to run. She looked round. There was the black, re-echoing shore, the dark sky down on her. She got up terrified. She wanted to be where there was light, where there were other people. She wanted to be away from him. He sat with his head dropped, not moving a muscle. “And I don’t want her to eat,” he said, “and she knows it. When I ask her: ‘Shall you have anything’ she’s almost afraid to say ‘Yes.’ ‘I’ll have a cup of Benger’s,’ she says. ‘It’ll only keep your strength up,’ I said to her. ‘Yes’—and she almost cried—‘but there’s such a gnawing when I eat nothing, I can’t bear it.’ So I went and made her the food. It’s the cancer that gnaws like that at her. I wish she’d die!” “Come!” said Clara roughly. “I’m going.”
Read in contextSons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XIII BAXTER DAWES
“Thank you!” he said. “I’m sorry Mrs. Morel is so ill. But we must see what we can do.” “There can’t be an operation?” said Paul. The doctor shook his head. “No,” he said; “and even if there could, her heart wouldn’t stand it.” “Is her heart risky?” asked Paul. “Yes; you must be careful with her.” “Very risky?” “No—er—no, no! Just take care.” And the doctor was gone. Then Paul carried his mother downstairs. She lay simply, like a child. But when he was on the stairs, she put her arms round his neck, clinging. “I’m so frightened of these beastly stairs,” she said. And he was frightened, too. He would let Leonard do it another time. He felt he could not carry her. “He thinks it’s only a tumour!” cried Annie to her mother. “And he can sweal it away.” “I knew he could,” protested Mrs. Morel scornfully. She pretended not to notice that Paul had gone out of the room. He sat in the kitchen, smoking. Then he tried to brush some grey ash off his coat. He looked again. It was one of his mother’s grey hairs. It was so long! He held it up, and it drifted into the chimney. He let go. The long grey hair floated and was gone in the blackness of the chimney. The next day he kissed her before going back to work. It was very early in the morning, and they were alone. “You won’t fret, my boy!” she said. “No, mother.”
Read in contextSons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XIII BAXTER DAWES
“I did!” she cried. “But how was I to know?” “I think he might have been rather nice,” he said. “You think I made him what he is!” she exclaimed. “Oh no! he made himself. But there’s something about him—” Clara looked at her lover closely. There was something in him she hated, a sort of detached criticism of herself, a coldness which made her woman’s soul harden against him. “And what are you going to do?” she asked. “How?” “About Baxter.” “There’s nothing to do, is there?” he replied. “You can fight him if you have to, I suppose?” she said. “No; I haven’t the least sense of the ‘fist’. It’s funny. With most men there’s the instinct to clench the fist and hit. It’s not so with me. I should want a knife or a pistol or something to fight with.” “Then you’d better carry something,” she said. “Nay,” he laughed; “I’m not daggeroso.” “But he’ll do something to you. You don’t know him.” “All right,” he said, “we’ll see.” “And you’ll let him?” “Perhaps, if I can’t help it.” “And if he kills you?” she said. “I should be sorry, for his sake and mine.” Clara was silent for a moment. “You do make me angry!” she exclaimed. “That’s nothing afresh,” he laughed. “But why are you so silly? You don’t know him.” “And don’t want.” “Yes, but you’re not going to let a man do as he likes with you?” “What must I do?” he replied, laughing.
Read in contextSons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XIII BAXTER DAWES
“Did you know Baxter as well as you know me?” he asked. “He wouldn’t let me,” she said. “And I have let you know me?” “It’s what men won’t let you do. They won’t let you get really near to them,” she said. “And haven’t I let you?” “Yes,” she answered slowly; “but you’ve never come near to me. You can’t come out of yourself, you can’t. Baxter could do that better than you.” He walked on pondering. He was angry with her for preferring Baxter to him. “You begin to value Baxter now you’ve not got him,” he said. “No; I can only see where he was different from you.” But he felt she had a grudge against him. One evening, as they were coming home over the fields, she startled him by asking: “Do you think it’s worth it—the—the sex part?” “The act of loving, itself?” “Yes; is it worth anything to you?” “But how can you separate it?” he said. “It’s the culmination of everything. All our intimacy culminates then.” “Not for me,” she said. He was silent. A flash of hate for her came up. After all, she was dissatisfied with him, even there, where he thought they fulfilled each other. But he believed her too implicitly. “I feel,” she continued slowly, “as if I hadn’t got you, as if all of you weren’t there, and as if it weren’t me you were taking—” “Who, then?”
Read in contextSons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XI THE TEST ON MIRIAM
“I love you an awful lot—then there is something short.” “Where?” she answered, looking at him. “Oh, in me! It is I who ought to be ashamed—like a spiritual cripple. And I am ashamed. It is misery. Why is it?” “I don’t know,” replied Miriam. “And I don’t know,” he repeated. “Don’t you think we have been too fierce in our what they call purity? Don’t you think that to be so much afraid and averse is a sort of dirtiness?” She looked at him with startled dark eyes. “You recoiled away from anything of the sort, and I took the motion from you, and recoiled also, perhaps worse.” There was silence in the room for some time. “Yes,” she said, “it is so.” “There is between us,” he said, “all these years of intimacy. I feel naked enough before you. Do you understand?” “I think so,” she answered. “And you love me?” She laughed. “Don’t be bitter,” he pleaded. She looked at him and was sorry for him; his eyes were dark with torture. She was sorry for him; it was worse for him to have this deflated love than for herself, who could never be properly mated. He was restless, for ever urging forward and trying to find a way out. He might do as he liked, and have what he liked of her. “Nay,” she said softly, “I am not bitter.”
Read in contextSons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER X CLARA
“But why did you leave him? Was he horrid to you?” She shuddered lightly. “He—he sort of degraded me. He wanted to bully me because he hadn’t got me. And then I felt as if I wanted to run, as if I was fastened and bound up. And he seemed dirty.” “I see.” He did not at all see. “And was he always dirty?” he asked. “A bit,” she replied slowly. “And then he seemed as if he couldn’t get at me, really. And then he got brutal—he was brutal!” “And why did you leave him finally?” “Because—because he was unfaithful to me—” They were both silent for some time. Her hand lay on the gate-post as she balanced. He put his own over it. His heart beat quickly. “But did you—were you ever—did you ever give him a chance?” “Chance? How?” “To come near to you.” “I married him—and I was willing—” They both strove to keep their voices steady. “I believe he loves you,” he said. “It looks like it,” she replied. He wanted to take his hand away, and could not. She saved him by removing her own. After a silence, he began again: “Did you leave him out of count all along?” “He left me,” she said. “And I suppose he couldn’t make himself mean everything to you?” “He tried to bully me into it.” But the conversation had got them both out of their depth. Suddenly Paul jumped down. “Come on,” he said. “Let’s go and get some tea.”
Read in context