Sons and Lovers
D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)
“Yes; I went to Agatha’s to tea. We are going to chapel. I only called in for a moment to see Clara.” “You should have come in here to tea,” he said. Miriam laughed shortly, and Clara turned impatiently aside. “Do you like the chrysanthemums?” he asked. “Yes; they are very fine,” replied Miriam. “Which sort do you like best?” he asked. “I don’t know. The bronze, I think.” “I don’t think you’ve seen all the sorts. Come and look. Come and see which are your favourites, Clara.” He led the two women back to his own garden, where the towsled bushes of flowers of all colours stood raggedly along the path down to the field. The situation did not embarrass him, to his knowledge. “Look, Miriam; these are the white ones that came from your garden. They aren’t so fine here, are they?” “No,” said Miriam. “But they’re hardier. You’re so sheltered; things grow big and tender, and then die. These little yellow ones I like. Will you have some?” While they were out there the bells began to ring in the church, sounding loud across the town and the field. Miriam looked at the tower, proud among the clustering roofs, and remembered the sketches he had brought her. It had been different then, but he had not left her even yet. She asked him for a book to read. He ran indoors. “What! is that Miriam?” asked his mother coldly. “Yes; she said she’d call and see Clara.” “You told her, then?” came the sarcastic answer.
“Yes; why shouldn’t I?” “There’s certainly no reason why you shouldn’t,” said Mrs. Morel, and she returned to her book. He winced from his mother’s irony, frowned irritably, thinking: “Why can’t I do as I like?” “You’ve not seen Mrs. Morel before?” Miriam was saying to Clara. “No; but she’s so nice!” “Yes,” said Miriam, dropping her head; “in some ways she’s very fine.” “I should think so.” “Had Paul told you much about her?” “He had talked a good deal.” “Ha!” There was silence until he returned with the book. “When will you want it back?” Miriam asked. “When you like,” he answered. Clara turned to go indoors, whilst he accompanied Miriam to the gate. “When will you come up to Willey Farm?” the latter asked. “I couldn’t say,” replied Clara. “Mother asked me to say she’d be pleased to see you any time, if you cared to come.” “Thank you; I should like to, but I can’t say when.” “Oh, very well!” exclaimed Miriam rather bitterly, turning away. She went down the path with her mouth to the flowers he had given her. “You’re sure you won’t come in?” he said. “No, thanks.” “We are going to chapel.” “Ah, I shall see you, then!” Miriam was very bitter. “Yes.”
They parted. He felt guilty towards her. She was bitter, and she scorned him. He still belonged to herself, she believed; yet he could have Clara, take her home, sit with her next his mother in chapel, give her the same hymn-book he had given herself years before. She heard him running quickly indoors. But he did not go straight in. Halting on the plot of grass, he heard his mother’s voice, then Clara’s answer: “What I hate is the bloodhound quality in Miriam.” “Yes,” said his mother quickly, “yes; doesn’t it make you hate her, now!” His heart went hot, and he was angry with them for talking about the girl. What right had they to say that? Something in the speech itself stung him into a flame of hate against Miriam. Then his own heart rebelled furiously at Clara’s taking the liberty of speaking so about Miriam. After all, the girl was the better woman of the two, he thought, if it came to goodness. He went indoors. His mother looked excited. She was beating with her hand rhythmically on the sofa-arm, as women do who are wearing out. He could never bear to see the movement. There was a silence; then he began to talk.
In chapel Miriam saw him find the place in the hymn-book for Clara, in exactly the same way as he used for herself. And during the sermon he could see the girl across the chapel, her hat throwing a dark shadow over her face. What did she think, seeing Clara with him? He did not stop to consider. He felt himself cruel towards Miriam. After chapel he went over Pentrich with Clara. It was a dark autumn night. They had said good-bye to Miriam, and his heart had smitten him as he left the girl alone. “But it serves her right,” he said inside himself, and it almost gave him pleasure to go off under her eyes with this other handsome woman. There was a scent of damp leaves in the darkness. Clara’s hand lay warm and inert in his own as they walked. He was full of conflict. The battle that raged inside him made him feel desperate. Up Pentrich Hill Clara leaned against him as he went. He slid his arm round her waist. Feeling the strong motion of her body under his arm as she walked, the tightness in his chest because of Miriam relaxed, and the hot blood bathed him. He held her closer and closer. Then: “You still keep on with Miriam,” she said quietly. “Only talk. There never was a great deal more than talk between us,” he said bitterly. “Your mother doesn’t care for her,” said Clara. “No, or I might have married her. But it’s all up really!”
Suddenly his voice went passionate with hate. “If I was with her now, we should be jawing about the ‘Christian Mystery’, or some such tack. Thank God, I’m not!” They walked on in silence for some time. “But you can’t really give her up,” said Clara. “I don’t give her up, because there’s nothing to give,” he said. “There is for her.” “I don’t know why she and I shouldn’t be friends as long as we live,” he said. “But it’ll only be friends.” Clara drew away from him, leaning away from contact with him. “What are you drawing away for?” he asked. She did not answer, but drew farther from him. “Why do you want to walk alone?” he asked. Still there was no answer. She walked resentfully, hanging her head. “Because I said I would be friends with Miriam!” he exclaimed. She would not answer him anything. “I tell you it’s only words that go between us,” he persisted, trying to take her again. She resisted. Suddenly he strode across in front of her, barring her way. “Damn it!” he said. “What do you want now?” “You’d better run after Miriam,” mocked Clara.
Passages expressing a similar idea
Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XI THE TEST ON MIRIAM
Frequently he hated Miriam. He hated her as she bent forward and pored over his things. He hated her way of patiently casting him up, as if he were an endless psychological account. When he was with her, he hated her for having got him, and yet not got him, and he tortured her. She took all and gave nothing, he said. At least, she gave no living warmth. She was never alive, and giving off life. Looking for her was like looking for something which did not exist. She was only his conscience, not his mate. He hated her violently, and was more cruel to her. They dragged on till the next summer. He saw more and more of Clara. At last he spoke. He had been sitting working at home one evening. There was between him and his mother a peculiar condition of people frankly finding fault with each other. Mrs. Morel was strong on her feet again. He was not going to stick to Miriam. Very well; then she would stand aloof till he said something. It had been coming a long time, this bursting of the storm in him, when he would come back to her. This evening there was between them a peculiar condition of suspense. He worked feverishly and mechanically, so that he could escape from himself. It grew late. Through the open door, stealthily, came the scent of madonna lilies, almost as if it were prowling abroad. Suddenly he got up and went out of doors.
Read in contextSons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER VIII STRIFE IN LOVE
And he, coming home from his walks with Miriam, was wild with torture. He walked biting his lips and with clenched fists, going at a great rate. Then, brought up against a stile, he stood for some minutes, and did not move. There was a great hollow of darkness fronting him, and on the black upslopes patches of tiny lights, and in the lowest trough of the night, a flare of the pit. It was all weird and dreadful. Why was he torn so, almost bewildered, and unable to move? Why did his mother sit at home and suffer? He knew she suffered badly. But why should she? And why did he hate Miriam, and feel so cruel towards her, at the thought of his mother. If Miriam caused his mother suffering, then he hated her—and he easily hated her. Why did she make him feel as if he were uncertain of himself, insecure, an indefinite thing, as if he had not sufficient sheathing to prevent the night and the space breaking into him? How he hated her! And then, what a rush of tenderness and humility! Suddenly he plunged on again, running home. His mother saw on him the marks of some agony, and she said nothing. But he had to make her talk to him. Then she was angry with him for going so far with Miriam. “Why don’t you like her, mother?” he cried in despair.
Read in contextSons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XII PASSION
In chapel Miriam saw him find the place in the hymn-book for Clara, in exactly the same way as he used for herself. And during the sermon he could see the girl across the chapel, her hat throwing a dark shadow over her face. What did she think, seeing Clara with him? He did not stop to consider. He felt himself cruel towards Miriam. After chapel he went over Pentrich with Clara. It was a dark autumn night. They had said good-bye to Miriam, and his heart had smitten him as he left the girl alone. “But it serves her right,” he said inside himself, and it almost gave him pleasure to go off under her eyes with this other handsome woman. There was a scent of damp leaves in the darkness. Clara’s hand lay warm and inert in his own as they walked. He was full of conflict. The battle that raged inside him made him feel desperate. Up Pentrich Hill Clara leaned against him as he went. He slid his arm round her waist. Feeling the strong motion of her body under his arm as she walked, the tightness in his chest because of Miriam relaxed, and the hot blood bathed him. He held her closer and closer. Then: “You still keep on with Miriam,” she said quietly. “Only talk. There never was a great deal more than talk between us,” he said bitterly. “Your mother doesn’t care for her,” said Clara. “No, or I might have married her. But it’s all up really!”
Read in contextSons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER X CLARA
Now she began to combat him in his restless fretting. He still kept up his connection with Miriam, could neither break free nor go the whole length of engagement. And this indecision seemed to bleed him of his energy. Moreover, his mother suspected him of an unrecognised leaning towards Clara, and, since the latter was a married woman, she wished he would fall in love with one of the girls in a better station of life. But he was stupid, and would refuse to love or even to admire a girl much, just because she was his social superior. “My boy,” said his mother to him, “all your cleverness, your breaking away from old things, and taking life in your own hands, doesn’t seem to bring you much happiness.” “What is happiness!” he cried. “It’s nothing to me! How am I to be happy?” The plump question disturbed her. “That’s for you to judge, my lad. But if you could meet some good woman who would make you happy—and you began to think of settling your life—when you have the means—so that you could work without all this fretting—it would be much better for you.” He frowned. His mother caught him on the raw of his wound of Miriam. He pushed the tumbled hair off his forehead, his eyes full of pain and fire. “You mean easy, mother,” he cried. “That’s a woman’s whole doctrine for life—ease of soul and physical comfort. And I do despise it.”
Read in contextSons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XI THE TEST ON MIRIAM
He went back to her. Something in her, when he looked at her, brought the tears almost to his eyes. One day he stood behind her as she sang. Annie was playing a song on the piano. As Miriam sang her mouth seemed hopeless. She sang like a nun singing to heaven. It reminded him so much of the mouth and eyes of one who sings beside a Botticelli Madonna, so spiritual. Again, hot as steel, came up the pain in him. Why must he ask her for the other thing? Why was there his blood battling with her? If only he could have been always gentle, tender with her, breathing with her the atmosphere of reverie and religious dreams, he would give his right hand. It was not fair to hurt her. There seemed an eternal maidenhood about her; and when he thought of her mother, he saw the great brown eyes of a maiden who was nearly scared and shocked out of her virgin maidenhood, but not quite, in spite of her seven children. They had been born almost leaving her out of count, not of her, but upon her. So she could never let them go, because she never had possessed them. Mrs. Morel saw him going again frequently to Miriam, and was astonished. He said nothing to his mother. He did not explain nor excuse himself. If he came home late, and she reproached him, he frowned and turned on her in an overbearing way:
Read in contextSons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · PART TWO / CHAPTER VII LAD-AND-GIRL LOVE
As they walked along the dark fen-meadow he watched the moon and did not speak. She plodded beside him. He hated her, for she seemed in some way to make him despise himself. Looking ahead—he saw the one light in the darkness, the window of their lamp-lit cottage. He loved to think of his mother, and the other jolly people. “Well, everybody else has been in long ago!” said his mother as they entered. “What does that matter!” he cried irritably. “I can go a walk if I like, can’t I?” “And I should have thought you could get in to supper with the rest,” said Mrs. Morel. “I shall please myself,” he retorted. “It’s not late. I shall do as I like.” “Very well,” said his mother cuttingly, “then do as you like.” And she took no further notice of him that evening. Which he pretended neither to notice nor to care about, but sat reading. Miriam read also, obliterating herself. Mrs. Morel hated her for making her son like this. She watched Paul growing irritable, priggish, and melancholic. For this she put the blame on Miriam. Annie and all her friends joined against the girl. Miriam had no friend of her own, only Paul. But she did not suffer so much, because she despised the triviality of these other people. And Paul hated her because, somehow, she spoilt his ease and naturalness. And he writhed himself with a feeling of humiliation.
Read in context