Sons and Lovers
D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)
Having finished, he strolled down the garden, leaving the two women to talk. It was a hazy, sunny afternoon, mild and soft. Clara glanced through the window after him as he loitered among the chrysanthemums. She felt as if something almost tangible fastened her to him; yet he seemed so easy in his graceful, indolent movement, so detached as he tied up the too-heavy flower branches to their stakes, that she wanted to shriek in her helplessness. Mrs. Morel rose. “You will let me help you wash up,” said Clara. “Eh, there are so few, it will only take a minute,” said the other. Clara, however, dried the tea-things, and was glad to be on such good terms with his mother; but it was torture not to be able to follow him down the garden. At last she allowed herself to go; she felt as if a rope were taken off her ankle. The afternoon was golden over the hills of Derbyshire. He stood across in the other garden, beside a bush of pale Michaelmas daisies, watching the last bees crawl into the hive. Hearing her coming, he turned to her with an easy motion, saying: “It’s the end of the run with these chaps.” Clara stood near him. Over the low red wall in front was the country and the far-off hills, all golden dim.
At that moment Miriam was entering through the garden-door. She saw Clara go up to him, saw him turn, and saw them come to rest together. Something in their perfect isolation together made her know that it was accomplished between them, that they were, as she put it, married. She walked very slowly down the cinder-track of the long garden. Clara had pulled a button from a hollyhock spire, and was breaking it to get the seeds. Above her bowed head the pink flowers stared, as if defending her. The last bees were falling down to the hive. “Count your money,” laughed Paul, as she broke the flat seeds one by one from the roll of coin. She looked at him. “I’m well off,” she said, smiling. “How much? Pf!” He snapped his fingers. “Can I turn them into gold?” “I’m afraid not,” she laughed. They looked into each other’s eyes, laughing. At that moment they became aware of Miriam. There was a click, and everything had altered. “Hello, Miriam!” he exclaimed. “You said you’d come!” “Yes. Had you forgotten?” She shook hands with Clara, saying: “It seems strange to see you here.” “Yes,” replied the other; “it seems strange to be here.” There was a hesitation. “This is pretty, isn’t it?” said Miriam. “I like it very much,” replied Clara. Then Miriam realised that Clara was accepted as she had never been. “Have you come down alone?” asked Paul.
“Yes; I went to Agatha’s to tea. We are going to chapel. I only called in for a moment to see Clara.” “You should have come in here to tea,” he said. Miriam laughed shortly, and Clara turned impatiently aside. “Do you like the chrysanthemums?” he asked. “Yes; they are very fine,” replied Miriam. “Which sort do you like best?” he asked. “I don’t know. The bronze, I think.” “I don’t think you’ve seen all the sorts. Come and look. Come and see which are your favourites, Clara.” He led the two women back to his own garden, where the towsled bushes of flowers of all colours stood raggedly along the path down to the field. The situation did not embarrass him, to his knowledge. “Look, Miriam; these are the white ones that came from your garden. They aren’t so fine here, are they?” “No,” said Miriam. “But they’re hardier. You’re so sheltered; things grow big and tender, and then die. These little yellow ones I like. Will you have some?” While they were out there the bells began to ring in the church, sounding loud across the town and the field. Miriam looked at the tower, proud among the clustering roofs, and remembered the sketches he had brought her. It had been different then, but he had not left her even yet. She asked him for a book to read. He ran indoors. “What! is that Miriam?” asked his mother coldly. “Yes; she said she’d call and see Clara.” “You told her, then?” came the sarcastic answer.
“Yes; why shouldn’t I?” “There’s certainly no reason why you shouldn’t,” said Mrs. Morel, and she returned to her book. He winced from his mother’s irony, frowned irritably, thinking: “Why can’t I do as I like?” “You’ve not seen Mrs. Morel before?” Miriam was saying to Clara. “No; but she’s so nice!” “Yes,” said Miriam, dropping her head; “in some ways she’s very fine.” “I should think so.” “Had Paul told you much about her?” “He had talked a good deal.” “Ha!” There was silence until he returned with the book. “When will you want it back?” Miriam asked. “When you like,” he answered. Clara turned to go indoors, whilst he accompanied Miriam to the gate. “When will you come up to Willey Farm?” the latter asked. “I couldn’t say,” replied Clara. “Mother asked me to say she’d be pleased to see you any time, if you cared to come.” “Thank you; I should like to, but I can’t say when.” “Oh, very well!” exclaimed Miriam rather bitterly, turning away. She went down the path with her mouth to the flowers he had given her. “You’re sure you won’t come in?” he said. “No, thanks.” “We are going to chapel.” “Ah, I shall see you, then!” Miriam was very bitter. “Yes.”
They parted. He felt guilty towards her. She was bitter, and she scorned him. He still belonged to herself, she believed; yet he could have Clara, take her home, sit with her next his mother in chapel, give her the same hymn-book he had given herself years before. She heard him running quickly indoors. But he did not go straight in. Halting on the plot of grass, he heard his mother’s voice, then Clara’s answer: “What I hate is the bloodhound quality in Miriam.” “Yes,” said his mother quickly, “yes; doesn’t it make you hate her, now!” His heart went hot, and he was angry with them for talking about the girl. What right had they to say that? Something in the speech itself stung him into a flame of hate against Miriam. Then his own heart rebelled furiously at Clara’s taking the liberty of speaking so about Miriam. After all, the girl was the better woman of the two, he thought, if it came to goodness. He went indoors. His mother looked excited. She was beating with her hand rhythmically on the sofa-arm, as women do who are wearing out. He could never bear to see the movement. There was a silence; then he began to talk.
Passages expressing a similar idea
Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · PART TWO / CHAPTER VII LAD-AND-GIRL LOVE
They went into the garden. The sky behind the townlet and the church was orange-red; the flower-garden was flooded with a strange warm light that lifted every leaf into significance. Paul passed along a fine row of sweet-peas, gathering a blossom here and there, all cream and pale blue. Miriam followed, breathing the fragrance. To her, flowers appealed with such strength she felt she must make them part of herself. When she bent and breathed a flower, it was as if she and the flower were loving each other. Paul hated her for it. There seemed a sort of exposure about the action, something too intimate. When he had got a fair bunch, they returned to the house. He listened for a moment to his mother’s quiet movement upstairs, then he said: “Come here, and let me pin them in for you.” He arranged them two or three at a time in the bosom of her dress, stepping back now and then to see the effect. “You know,” he said, taking the pin out of his mouth, “a woman ought always to arrange her flowers before her glass.” Miriam laughed. She thought flowers ought to be pinned in one’s dress without any care. That Paul should take pains to fix her flowers for her was his whim. He was rather offended at her laughter. “Some women do—those who look decent,” he said.
Read in contextSons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XII PASSION
“Then I’ll bring her—shall I bring her here?” “You please yourself.” “Then I will bring her here—one Sunday—to tea. If you think a horrid thing about her, I shan’t forgive you.” His mother laughed. “As if it would make any difference!” she said. He knew he had won. “Oh, but it feels so fine, when she’s there! She’s such a queen in her way.” Occasionally he still walked a little way from chapel with Miriam and Edgar. He did not go up to the farm. She, however, was very much the same with him, and he did not feel embarrassed in her presence. One evening she was alone when he accompanied her. They began by talking books: it was their unfailing topic. Mrs. Morel had said that his and Miriam’s affair was like a fire fed on books—if there were no more volumes it would die out. Miriam, for her part, boasted that she could read him like a book, could place her finger any minute on the chapter and the line. He, easily taken in, believed that Miriam knew more about him than anyone else. So it pleased him to talk to her about himself, like the simplest egoist. Very soon the conversation drifted to his own doings. It flattered him immensely that he was of such supreme interest. “And what have you been doing lately?” “I—oh, not much! I made a sketch of Bestwood from the garden, that is nearly right at last. It’s the hundredth try.” So they went on. Then she said:
Read in contextSons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER VIII STRIFE IN LOVE
The stars on the lake seemed to leap like grasshoppers, silver upon the blackness, as he spun past. Then there was the long climb home. “See, mother!” he said, as he threw her the berries and leaves on to the table. “H’m!” she said, glancing at them, then away again. She sat reading, alone, as she always did. “Aren’t they pretty?” “Yes.” He knew she was cross with him. After a few minutes he said: “Edgar and Miriam are coming to tea to-morrow.” She did not answer. “You don’t mind?” Still she did not answer. “Do you?” he asked. “You know whether I mind or not.” “I don’t see why you should. I have plenty of meals there.” “You do.” “Then why do you begrudge them tea?” “I begrudge whom tea?” “What are you so horrid for?” “Oh, say no more! You’ve asked her to tea, it’s quite sufficient. She’ll come.” He was very angry with his mother. He knew it was merely Miriam she objected to. He flung off his boots and went to bed. Paul went to meet his friends the next afternoon. He was glad to see them coming. They arrived home at about four o’clock. Everywhere was clean and still for Sunday afternoon. Mrs. Morel sat in her black dress and black apron. She rose to meet the visitors. With Edgar she was cordial, but with Miriam cold and rather grudging. Yet Paul thought the girl looked so nice in her brown cashmere frock.
Read in contextSons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XII PASSION
In chapel Miriam saw him find the place in the hymn-book for Clara, in exactly the same way as he used for herself. And during the sermon he could see the girl across the chapel, her hat throwing a dark shadow over her face. What did she think, seeing Clara with him? He did not stop to consider. He felt himself cruel towards Miriam. After chapel he went over Pentrich with Clara. It was a dark autumn night. They had said good-bye to Miriam, and his heart had smitten him as he left the girl alone. “But it serves her right,” he said inside himself, and it almost gave him pleasure to go off under her eyes with this other handsome woman. There was a scent of damp leaves in the darkness. Clara’s hand lay warm and inert in his own as they walked. He was full of conflict. The battle that raged inside him made him feel desperate. Up Pentrich Hill Clara leaned against him as he went. He slid his arm round her waist. Feeling the strong motion of her body under his arm as she walked, the tightness in his chest because of Miriam relaxed, and the hot blood bathed him. He held her closer and closer. Then: “You still keep on with Miriam,” she said quietly. “Only talk. There never was a great deal more than talk between us,” he said bitterly. “Your mother doesn’t care for her,” said Clara. “No, or I might have married her. But it’s all up really!”
Read in contextSons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XII PASSION
“You’ve not been out, then, lately?” “Yes; I went up Clifton Grove on Monday afternoon with Clara.” “It was not very nice weather,” said Miriam, “was it?” “But I wanted to go out, and it was all right. The Trent is full.” “And did you go to Barton?” she asked. “No; we had tea in Clifton.” “Did you! That would be nice.” “It was! The jolliest old woman! She gave us several pom-pom dahlias, as pretty as you like.” Miriam bowed her head and brooded. He was quite unconscious of concealing anything from her. “What made her give them you?” she asked. He laughed. “Because she liked us—because we were jolly, I should think.” Miriam put her finger in her mouth. “Were you late home?” she asked. At last he resented her tone. “I caught the seven-thirty.” “Ha!” They walked on in silence, and he was angry. “And how is Clara?” asked Miriam. “Quite all right, I think.” “That’s good!” she said, with a tinge of irony. “By the way, what of her husband? One never hears anything of him.” “He’s got some other woman, and is also quite all right,” he replied. “At least, so I think.” “I see—you don’t know for certain. Don’t you think a position like that is hard on a woman?” “Rottenly hard!” “It’s so unjust!” said Miriam. “The man does as he likes—” “Then let the woman also,” he said. “How can she? And if she does, look at her position!” “What of it?” “Why, it’s impossible! You don’t understand what a woman forfeits—”
Read in contextSons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XII PASSION
At that moment Miriam was entering through the garden-door. She saw Clara go up to him, saw him turn, and saw them come to rest together. Something in their perfect isolation together made her know that it was accomplished between them, that they were, as she put it, married. She walked very slowly down the cinder-track of the long garden. Clara had pulled a button from a hollyhock spire, and was breaking it to get the seeds. Above her bowed head the pink flowers stared, as if defending her. The last bees were falling down to the hive. “Count your money,” laughed Paul, as she broke the flat seeds one by one from the roll of coin. She looked at him. “I’m well off,” she said, smiling. “How much? Pf!” He snapped his fingers. “Can I turn them into gold?” “I’m afraid not,” she laughed. They looked into each other’s eyes, laughing. At that moment they became aware of Miriam. There was a click, and everything had altered. “Hello, Miriam!” he exclaimed. “You said you’d come!” “Yes. Had you forgotten?” She shook hands with Clara, saying: “It seems strange to see you here.” “Yes,” replied the other; “it seems strange to be here.” There was a hesitation. “This is pretty, isn’t it?” said Miriam. “I like it very much,” replied Clara. Then Miriam realised that Clara was accepted as she had never been. “Have you come down alone?” asked Paul.
Read in context