Skip to content
BookLens

Sons and Lovers

D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)

They went on with the meal. When they were going away, the old lady came timidly with three tiny dahlias in full blow, neat as bees, and speckled scarlet and white. She stood before Clara, pleased with herself, saying: “I don’t know whether—” and holding the flowers forward in her old hand. “Oh, how pretty!” cried Clara, accepting the flowers. “Shall she have them all?” asked Paul reproachfully of the old woman. “Yes, she shall have them all,” she replied, beaming with joy. “You have got enough for your share.” “Ah, but I shall ask her to give me one!” he teased. “Then she does as she pleases,” said the old lady, smiling. And she bobbed a little curtsey of delight. Clara was rather quiet and uncomfortable. As they walked along, he said: “You don’t feel criminal, do you?” She looked at him with startled grey eyes. “Criminal!” she said. “No.” “But you seem to feel you have done a wrong?” “No,” she said. “I only think, ‘If they knew!’” “If they knew, they’d cease to understand. As it is, they do understand, and they like it. What do they matter? Here, with only the trees and me, you don’t feel not the least bit wrong, do you?” He took her by the arm, held her facing him, holding her eyes with his. Something fretted him. “Not sinners, are we?” he said, with an uneasy little frown. “No,” she replied. He kissed her, laughing.

“You like your little bit of guiltiness, I believe,” he said. “I believe Eve enjoyed it, when she went cowering out of Paradise.” But there was a certain glow and quietness about her that made him glad. When he was alone in the railway-carriage, he found himself tumultuously happy, and the people exceedingly nice, and the night lovely, and everything good. Mrs. Morel was sitting reading when he got home. Her health was not good now, and there had come that ivory pallor into her face which he never noticed, and which afterwards he never forgot. She did not mention her own ill-health to him. After all, she thought, it was not much. “You are late!” she said, looking at him. His eyes were shining; his face seemed to glow. He smiled to her. “Yes; I’ve been down Clifton Grove with Clara.” His mother looked at him again. “But won’t people talk?” she said. “Why? They know she’s a suffragette, and so on. And what if they do talk!” “Of course, there may be nothing wrong in it,” said his mother. “But you know what folks are, and if once she gets talked about—” “Well, I can’t help it. Their jaw isn’t so almighty important, after all.” “I think you ought to consider her.” “So I do! What can people say?—that we take a walk together. I believe you’re jealous.” “You know I should be glad if she weren’t a married woman.”

“Well, my dear, she lives separate from her husband, and talks on platforms; so she’s already singled out from the sheep, and, as far as I can see, hasn’t much to lose. No; her life’s nothing to her, so what’s the worth of nothing? She goes with me—it becomes something. Then she must pay—we both must pay! Folk are so frightened of paying; they’d rather starve and die.” “Very well, my son. We’ll see how it will end.” “Very well, my mother. I’ll abide by the end.” “We’ll see!” “And she’s—she’s awfully nice, mother; she is really! You don’t know!” “That’s not the same as marrying her.” “It’s perhaps better.” There was silence for a while. He wanted to ask his mother something, but was afraid. “Should you like to know her?” He hesitated. “Yes,” said Mrs. Morel coolly. “I should like to know what she’s like.” “But she’s nice, mother, she is! And not a bit common!” “I never suggested she was.” “But you seem to think she’s—not as good as—She’s better than ninety-nine folk out of a hundred, I tell you! She’s better, she is! She’s fair, she’s honest, she’s straight! There isn’t anything underhand or superior about her. Don’t be mean about her!” Mrs. Morel flushed. “I am sure I am not mean about her. She may be quite as you say, but—” “You don’t approve,” he finished. “And do you expect me to?” she answered coldly. “Yes!—yes!—if you’d anything about you, you’d be glad! Do you want to see her?” “I said I did.”

“Then I’ll bring her—shall I bring her here?” “You please yourself.” “Then I will bring her here—one Sunday—to tea. If you think a horrid thing about her, I shan’t forgive you.” His mother laughed. “As if it would make any difference!” she said. He knew he had won. “Oh, but it feels so fine, when she’s there! She’s such a queen in her way.” Occasionally he still walked a little way from chapel with Miriam and Edgar. He did not go up to the farm. She, however, was very much the same with him, and he did not feel embarrassed in her presence. One evening she was alone when he accompanied her. They began by talking books: it was their unfailing topic. Mrs. Morel had said that his and Miriam’s affair was like a fire fed on books—if there were no more volumes it would die out. Miriam, for her part, boasted that she could read him like a book, could place her finger any minute on the chapter and the line. He, easily taken in, believed that Miriam knew more about him than anyone else. So it pleased him to talk to her about himself, like the simplest egoist. Very soon the conversation drifted to his own doings. It flattered him immensely that he was of such supreme interest. “And what have you been doing lately?” “I—oh, not much! I made a sketch of Bestwood from the garden, that is nearly right at last. It’s the hundredth try.” So they went on. Then she said:

“You’ve not been out, then, lately?” “Yes; I went up Clifton Grove on Monday afternoon with Clara.” “It was not very nice weather,” said Miriam, “was it?” “But I wanted to go out, and it was all right. The Trent is full.” “And did you go to Barton?” she asked. “No; we had tea in Clifton.” “Did you! That would be nice.” “It was! The jolliest old woman! She gave us several pom-pom dahlias, as pretty as you like.” Miriam bowed her head and brooded. He was quite unconscious of concealing anything from her. “What made her give them you?” she asked. He laughed. “Because she liked us—because we were jolly, I should think.” Miriam put her finger in her mouth. “Were you late home?” she asked. At last he resented her tone. “I caught the seven-thirty.” “Ha!” They walked on in silence, and he was angry. “And how is Clara?” asked Miriam. “Quite all right, I think.” “That’s good!” she said, with a tinge of irony. “By the way, what of her husband? One never hears anything of him.” “He’s got some other woman, and is also quite all right,” he replied. “At least, so I think.” “I see—you don’t know for certain. Don’t you think a position like that is hard on a woman?” “Rottenly hard!” “It’s so unjust!” said Miriam. “The man does as he likes—” “Then let the woman also,” he said. “How can she? And if she does, look at her position!” “What of it?” “Why, it’s impossible! You don’t understand what a woman forfeits—”

Passages expressing a similar idea

  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XII PASSION

    “No, I don’t. But if a woman’s got nothing but her fair fame to feed on, why, it’s thin tack, and a donkey would die of it!” So she understood his moral attitude, at least, and she knew he would act accordingly. She never asked him anything direct, but she got to know enough. Another day, when he saw Miriam, the conversation turned to marriage, then to Clara’s marriage with Dawes. “You see,” he said, “she never knew the fearful importance of marriage. She thought it was all in the day’s march—it would have to come—and Dawes—well, a good many women would have given their souls to get him; so why not him? Then she developed into the femme incomprise, and treated him badly, I’ll bet my boots.” “And she left him because he didn’t understand her?” “I suppose so. I suppose she had to. It isn’t altogether a question of understanding; it’s a question of living. With him, she was only half-alive; the rest was dormant, deadened. And the dormant woman was the femme incomprise, and she had to be awakened.” “And what about him.” “I don’t know. I rather think he loves her as much as he can, but he’s a fool.” “It was something like your mother and father,” said Miriam. “Yes; but my mother, I believe, got real joy and satisfaction out of my father at first. I believe she had a passion for him; that’s why she stayed with him. After all, they were bound to each other.” “Yes,” said Miriam.

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER IX DEFEAT OF MIRIAM

    “But I shan’t marry, mother. I shall live with you, and we’ll have a servant.” “Ay, my lad, it’s easy to talk. We’ll see when the time comes.” “What time? I’m nearly twenty-three.” “Yes, you’re not one that would marry young. But in three years’ time—” “I shall be with you just the same.” “We’ll see, my boy, we’ll see.” “But you don’t want me to marry?” “I shouldn’t like to think of you going through your life without anybody to care for you and do—no.” “And you think I ought to marry?” “Sooner or later every man ought.” “But you’d rather it were later.” “It would be hard—and very hard. It’s as they say: “‘A son’s my son till he takes him a wife, But my daughter’s my daughter the whole of her life.’” “And you think I’d let a wife take me from you?” “Well, you wouldn’t ask her to marry your mother as well as you,” Mrs. Morel smiled. “She could do what she liked; she wouldn’t have to interfere.” “She wouldn’t—till she’d got you—and then you’d see.” “I never will see. I’ll never marry while I’ve got you—I won’t.” “But I shouldn’t like to leave you with nobody, my boy,” she cried. “You’re not going to leave me. What are you? Fifty-three! I’ll give you till seventy-five. There you are, I’m fat and forty-four. Then I’ll marry a staid body. See!” His mother sat and laughed. “Go to bed,” she said—“go to bed.”

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER IX DEFEAT OF MIRIAM

    “Mother—and the others. They say at this rate everybody will consider me engaged, and I ought to consider myself so, because it’s not fair to you. And I’ve tried to find out—and I don’t think I love you as a man ought to love his wife. What do you think about it?” Miriam bowed her head moodily. She was angry at having this struggle. People should leave him and her alone. “I don’t know,” she murmured. “Do you think we love each other enough to marry?” he asked definitely. It made her tremble. “No,” she answered truthfully. “I don’t think so—we’re too young.” “I thought perhaps,” he went on miserably, “that you, with your intensity in things, might have given me more—than I could ever make up to you. And even now—if you think it better—we’ll be engaged.” Now Miriam wanted to cry. And she was angry, too. He was always such a child for people to do as they liked with. “No, I don’t think so,” she said firmly. He pondered a minute. “You see,” he said, “with me—I don’t think one person would ever monopolise me—be everything to me—I think never.” This she did not consider. “No,” she murmured. Then, after a pause, she looked at him, and her dark eyes flashed. “This is your mother,” she said. “I know she never liked me.”

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XIII BAXTER DAWES

    “I don’t care what her opinion of me is. She’s fearfully in love with me, but it’s not very deep.” “But quite as deep as your feeling for her.” He looked up at his mother curiously. “Yes,” he said. “You know, mother, I think there must be something the matter with me, that I can’t love. When she’s there, as a rule, I do love her. Sometimes, when I see her just as the woman, I love her, mother; but then, when she talks and criticises, I often don’t listen to her.” “Yet she’s as much sense as Miriam.” “Perhaps; and I love her better than Miriam. But why don’t they hold me?” The last question was almost a lamentation. His mother turned away her face, sat looking across the room, very quiet, grave, with something of renunciation. “But you wouldn’t want to marry Clara?” she said. “No; at first perhaps I would. But why—why don’t I want to marry her or anybody? I feel sometimes as if I wronged my women, mother.” “How wronged them, my son?” “I don’t know.” He went on painting rather despairingly; he had touched the quick of the trouble. “And as for wanting to marry,” said his mother, “there’s plenty of time yet.” “But no, mother. I even love Clara, and I did Miriam; but to give myself to them in marriage I couldn’t. I couldn’t belong to them. They seem to want me, and I can’t ever give it them.” “You haven’t met the right woman.”

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER IX DEFEAT OF MIRIAM

    “I s’ll trust her to you, my lad, and hold you responsible for her.” “You can,” he said, nearly dead with the ordeal. And it was all over. When Morel and Arthur were in bed, Paul sat talking, as he often did, with his mother. “You’re not sorry she’s married, mother, are you?” he asked. “I’m not sorry she’s married—but—it seems strange that she should go from me. It even seems to me hard that she can prefer to go with her Leonard. That’s how mothers are—I know it’s silly.” “And shall you be miserable about her?” “When I think of my own wedding day,” his mother answered, “I can only hope her life will be different.” “But you can trust him to be good to her?” “Yes, yes. They say he’s not good enough for her. But I say if a man is genuine, as he is, and a girl is fond of him—then—it should be all right. He’s as good as she.” “So you don’t mind?” “I would never have let a daughter of mine marry a man I didn’t feel to be genuine through and through. And yet, there’s a gap now she’s gone.” They were both miserable, and wanted her back again. It seemed to Paul his mother looked lonely, in her new black silk blouse with its bit of white trimming. “At any rate, mother, I s’ll never marry,” he said. “Ay, they all say that, my lad. You’ve not met the one yet. Only wait a year or two.”

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER IX DEFEAT OF MIRIAM

    “And have they enough to keep them?” “I don’t think so. I think they do lace work.” “And wherein lies her charm, my boy?” “I don’t know that she’s charming, mother. But she’s nice. And she seems straight, you know—not a bit deep, not a bit.” “But she’s a good deal older than you.” “She’s thirty, I’m going on twenty-three.” “You haven’t told me what you like her for.” “Because I don’t know—a sort of defiant way she’s got—a sort of angry way.” Mrs. Morel considered. She would have been glad now for her son to fall in love with some woman who would—she did not know what. But he fretted so, got so furious suddenly, and again was melancholic. She wished he knew some nice woman—She did not know what she wished, but left it vague. At any rate, she was not hostile to the idea of Clara. Annie, too, was getting married. Leonard had gone away to work in Birmingham. One week-end when he was home she had said to him: “You don’t look very well, my lad.” “I dunno,” he said. “I feel anyhow or nohow, ma.” He called her “ma” already in his boyish fashion. “Are you sure they’re good lodgings?” she asked. “Yes—yes. Only—it’s a winder when you have to pour your own tea out—an’ nobody to grouse if you team it in your saucer and sup it up. It somehow takes a’ the taste out of it.” Mrs. Morel laughed. “And so it knocks you up?” she said.

    Read in context