Skip to content
BookLens

Sons and Lovers

D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)

It was nearly five o’clock when he told her. They were sitting on the bank of a stream, where the lip of turf hung over a hollow bank of yellow earth, and he was hacking away with a stick, as he did when he was perturbed and cruel. “I have been thinking,” he said, “we ought to break off.” “Why?” she cried in surprise. “Because it’s no good going on.” “Why is it no good?” “It isn’t. I don’t want to marry. I don’t want ever to marry. And if we’re not going to marry, it’s no good going on.” “But why do you say this now?” “Because I’ve made up my mind.” “And what about these last months, and the things you told me then?” “I can’t help it! I don’t want to go on.” “You don’t want any more of me?” “I want us to break off—you be free of me, I free of you.” “And what about these last months?” “I don’t know. I’ve not told you anything but what I thought was true.” “Then why are you different now?” “I’m not—I’m the same—only I know it’s no good going on.” “You haven’t told me why it’s no good.” “Because I don’t want to go on—and I don’t want to marry.” “How many times have you offered to marry me, and I wouldn’t?” “I know; but I want us to break off.”

There was silence for a moment or two, while he dug viciously at the earth. She bent her head, pondering. He was an unreasonable child. He was like an infant which, when it has drunk its fill, throws away and smashes the cup. She looked at him, feeling she could get hold of him and wring some consistency out of him. But she was helpless. Then she cried: “I have said you were only fourteen—you are only four!” He still dug at the earth viciously. He heard. “You are a child of four,” she repeated in her anger. He did not answer, but said in his heart: “All right; if I’m a child of four, what do you want me for? I don’t want another mother.” But he said nothing to her, and there was silence. “And have you told your people?” she asked. “I have told my mother.” There was another long interval of silence. “Then what do you want?” she asked. “Why, I want us to separate. We have lived on each other all these years; now let us stop. I will go my own way without you, and you will go your way without me. You will have an independent life of your own then.”

There was in it some truth that, in spite of her bitterness, she could not help registering. She knew she felt in a sort of bondage to him, which she hated because she could not control it. She hated her love for him from the moment it grew too strong for her. And, deep down, she had hated him because she loved him and he dominated her. She had resisted his domination. She had fought to keep herself free of him in the last issue. And she was free of him, even more than he of her. “And,” he continued, “we shall always be more or less each other’s work. You have done a lot for me, I for you. Now let us start and live by ourselves.” “What do you want to do?” she asked. “Nothing—only to be free,” he answered. She, however, knew in her heart that Clara’s influence was over him to liberate him. But she said nothing. “And what have I to tell my mother?” she asked. “I told my mother,” he answered, “that I was breaking off—clean and altogether.” “I shall not tell them at home,” she said. Frowning, “You please yourself,” he said. He knew he had landed her in a nasty hole, and was leaving her in the lurch. It angered him. “Tell them you wouldn’t and won’t marry me, and have broken off,” he said. “It’s true enough.”

She bit her finger moodily. She thought over their whole affair. She had known it would come to this; she had seen it all along. It chimed with her bitter expectation. “Always—it has always been so!” she cried. “It has been one long battle between us—you fighting away from me.” It came from her unawares, like a flash of lightning. The man’s heart stood still. Was this how she saw it? “But we’ve had some perfect hours, some perfect times, when we were together!” he pleaded. “Never!” she cried; “never! It has always been you fighting me off.” “Not always—not at first!” he pleaded. “Always, from the very beginning—always the same!” She had finished, but she had done enough. He sat aghast. He had wanted to say: “It has been good, but it is at an end.” And she—she whose love he had believed in when he had despised himself—denied that their love had ever been love. “He had always fought away from her?” Then it had been monstrous. There had never been anything really between them; all the time he had been imagining something where there was nothing. And she had known. She had known so much, and had told him so little. She had known all the time. All the time this was at the bottom of her!

He sat silent in bitterness. At last the whole affair appeared in a cynical aspect to him. She had really played with him, not he with her. She had hidden all her condemnation from him, had flattered him, and despised him. She despised him now. He grew intellectual and cruel. “You ought to marry a man who worships you,” he said; “then you could do as you liked with him. Plenty of men will worship you, if you get on the private side of their natures. You ought to marry one such. They would never fight you off.” “Thank you!” she said. “But don’t advise me to marry someone else any more. You’ve done it before.” “Very well,” he said; “I will say no more.” He sat still, feeling as if he had had a blow, instead of giving one. Their eight years of friendship and love, the eight years of his life, were nullified. “When did you think of this?” she asked. “I thought definitely on Thursday night.” “I knew it was coming,” she said. That pleased him bitterly. “Oh, very well! If she knew then it doesn’t come as a surprise to her,” he thought. “And have you said anything to Clara?” she asked. “No; but I shall tell her now.” There was a silence. “Do you remember the things you said this time last year, in my grandmother’s house—nay last month even?” “Yes,” he said; “I do! And I meant them! I can’t help that it’s failed.” “It has failed because you want something else.”

Passages expressing a similar idea

  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XII PASSION

    They parted. He felt guilty towards her. She was bitter, and she scorned him. He still belonged to herself, she believed; yet he could have Clara, take her home, sit with her next his mother in chapel, give her the same hymn-book he had given herself years before. She heard him running quickly indoors. But he did not go straight in. Halting on the plot of grass, he heard his mother’s voice, then Clara’s answer: “What I hate is the bloodhound quality in Miriam.” “Yes,” said his mother quickly, “yes; doesn’t it make you hate her, now!” His heart went hot, and he was angry with them for talking about the girl. What right had they to say that? Something in the speech itself stung him into a flame of hate against Miriam. Then his own heart rebelled furiously at Clara’s taking the liberty of speaking so about Miriam. After all, the girl was the better woman of the two, he thought, if it came to goodness. He went indoors. His mother looked excited. She was beating with her hand rhythmically on the sofa-arm, as women do who are wearing out. He could never bear to see the movement. There was a silence; then he began to talk.

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER X CLARA

    Now she began to combat him in his restless fretting. He still kept up his connection with Miriam, could neither break free nor go the whole length of engagement. And this indecision seemed to bleed him of his energy. Moreover, his mother suspected him of an unrecognised leaning towards Clara, and, since the latter was a married woman, she wished he would fall in love with one of the girls in a better station of life. But he was stupid, and would refuse to love or even to admire a girl much, just because she was his social superior. “My boy,” said his mother to him, “all your cleverness, your breaking away from old things, and taking life in your own hands, doesn’t seem to bring you much happiness.” “What is happiness!” he cried. “It’s nothing to me! How am I to be happy?” The plump question disturbed her. “That’s for you to judge, my lad. But if you could meet some good woman who would make you happy—and you began to think of settling your life—when you have the means—so that you could work without all this fretting—it would be much better for you.” He frowned. His mother caught him on the raw of his wound of Miriam. He pushed the tumbled hair off his forehead, his eyes full of pain and fire. “You mean easy, mother,” he cried. “That’s a woman’s whole doctrine for life—ease of soul and physical comfort. And I do despise it.”

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XI THE TEST ON MIRIAM

    He sat silent in bitterness. At last the whole affair appeared in a cynical aspect to him. She had really played with him, not he with her. She had hidden all her condemnation from him, had flattered him, and despised him. She despised him now. He grew intellectual and cruel. “You ought to marry a man who worships you,” he said; “then you could do as you liked with him. Plenty of men will worship you, if you get on the private side of their natures. You ought to marry one such. They would never fight you off.” “Thank you!” she said. “But don’t advise me to marry someone else any more. You’ve done it before.” “Very well,” he said; “I will say no more.” He sat still, feeling as if he had had a blow, instead of giving one. Their eight years of friendship and love, the eight years of his life, were nullified. “When did you think of this?” she asked. “I thought definitely on Thursday night.” “I knew it was coming,” she said. That pleased him bitterly. “Oh, very well! If she knew then it doesn’t come as a surprise to her,” he thought. “And have you said anything to Clara?” she asked. “No; but I shall tell her now.” There was a silence. “Do you remember the things you said this time last year, in my grandmother’s house—nay last month even?” “Yes,” he said; “I do! And I meant them! I can’t help that it’s failed.” “It has failed because you want something else.”

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XIII BAXTER DAWES

    Paul would have died rather than his mother should get to know of this affair. He suffered tortures of humiliation and self-consciousness. There was now a good deal of his life of which necessarily he could not speak to his mother. He had a life apart from her—his sexual life. The rest she still kept. But he felt he had to conceal something from her, and it irked him. There was a certain silence between them, and he felt he had, in that silence, to defend himself against her; he felt condemned by her. Then sometimes he hated her, and pulled at her bondage. His life wanted to free itself of her. It was like a circle where life turned back on itself, and got no farther. She bore him, loved him, kept him, and his love turned back into her, so that he could not be free to go forward with his own life, really love another woman. At this period, unknowingly, he resisted his mother’s influence. He did not tell her things; there was a distance between them. Clara was happy, almost sure of him. She felt she had at last got him for herself; and then again came the uncertainty. He told her jestingly of the affair with her husband. Her colour came up, her grey eyes flashed. “That’s him to a ‘T’,” she cried—“like a navvy! He’s not fit for mixing with decent folk.” “Yet you married him,” he said. It made her furious that he reminded her.

    Read in context
  • The Rainbow · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · Chapter III. CHILDHOOD OF ANNA LENSKY

    So he had to begin the bitter lesson, to abate himself, to take less than he wanted. For she was Woman to him, all other women were her shadows. For she had satisfied him. And he wanted it to go on. And it could not. However he raged, and, filled with suppression that became hot and bitter, hated her in his soul that she did not want him, however he had mad outbursts, and drank and made ugly scenes, still he knew, he was only kicking against the pricks. It was not, he had to learn, that she would not want him enough, as much as he demanded that she should want him. It was that she could not. She could only want him in her own way, and to her own measure. And she had spent much life before he found her as she was, the woman who could take him and give him fulfilment. She had taken him and given him fulfilment. She still could do so, in her own times and ways. But he must control himself, measure himself to her. He wanted to give her all his love, all his passion, all his essential energy. But it could not be. He must find other things than her, other centres of living. She sat close and impregnable with the child. And he was jealous of the child.

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XI THE TEST ON MIRIAM

    Miriam plunged home over the meadows. She was not afraid of people, what they might say; but she dreaded the issue with him. Yes, she would let him have her if he insisted; and then, when she thought of it afterwards, her heart went down. He would be disappointed, he would find no satisfaction, and then he would go away. Yet he was so insistent; and over this, which did not seem so all-important to her, was their love to break down. After all, he was only like other men, seeking his satisfaction. Oh, but there was something more in him, something deeper! She could trust to it, in spite of all desires. He said that possession was a great moment in life. All strong emotions concentrated there. Perhaps it was so. There was something divine in it; then she would submit, religiously, to the sacrifice. He should have her. And at the thought her whole body clenched itself involuntarily, hard, as if against something; but Life forced her through this gate of suffering, too, and she would submit. At any rate, it would give him what he wanted, which was her deepest wish. She brooded and brooded and brooded herself towards accepting him.

    Read in context