The Return of the Native
Thomas Hardy (1840–1928)
“But I am not worth receiving further proof even of Heaven’s reprobation. Do you think, Thomasin, that she knew me—that she did not die in that horrid mistaken notion about my not forgiving her, which I can’t tell you how she acquired? If you could only assure me of that! Do you think so, Eustacia? Do speak to me.” “I think I can assure you that she knew better at last,” said Thomasin. The pallid Eustacia said nothing. “Why didn’t she come to my house? I would have taken her in and showed her how I loved her in spite of all. But she never came; and I didn’t go to her, and she died on the heath like an animal kicked out, nobody to help her till it was too late. If you could have seen her, Thomasin, as I saw her—a poor dying woman, lying in the dark upon the bare ground, moaning, nobody near, believing she was utterly deserted by all the world, it would have moved you to anguish, it would have moved a brute. And this poor woman my mother! No wonder she said to the child, ‘You have seen a broken-hearted woman.’ What a state she must have been brought to, to say that! and who can have done it but I? It is too dreadful to think of, and I wish I could be punished more heavily than I am. How long was I what they called out of my senses?” “A week, I think.” “And then I became calm.”
“Yes, for four days.” “And now I have left off being calm.” “But try to be quiet—please do, and you will soon be strong. If you could remove that impression from your mind—” “Yes, yes,” he said impatiently. “But I don’t want to get strong. What’s the use of my getting well? It would be better for me if I die, and it would certainly be better for Eustacia. Is Eustacia there?” “Yes.” “It would be better for you, Eustacia, if I were to die?” “Don’t press such a question, dear Clym.” “Well, it really is but a shadowy supposition; for unfortunately I am going to live. I feel myself getting better. Thomasin, how long are you going to stay at the inn, now that all this money has come to your husband?” “Another month or two, probably; until my illness is over. We cannot get off till then. I think it will be a month or more.” “Yes, yes. Of course. Ah, Cousin Tamsie, you will get over your trouble—one little month will take you through it, and bring something to console you; but I shall never get over mine, and no consolation will come!” “Clym, you are unjust to yourself. Depend upon it, Aunt thought kindly of you. I know that, if she had lived, you would have been reconciled with her.”
“But she didn’t come to see me, though I asked her, before I married, if she would come. Had she come, or had I gone there, she would never have died saying, ‘I am a broken-hearted woman, cast off by my son.’ My door has always been open to her—a welcome here has always awaited her. But that she never came to see.” “You had better not talk any more now, Clym,” said Eustacia faintly from the other part of the room, for the scene was growing intolerable to her. “Let me talk to you instead for the little time I shall be here,” Thomasin said soothingly. “Consider what a one-sided way you have of looking at the matter, Clym. When she said that to the little boy you had not found her and taken her into your arms; and it might have been uttered in a moment of bitterness. It was rather like Aunt to say things in haste. She sometimes used to speak so to me. Though she did not come I am convinced that she thought of coming to see you. Do you suppose a man’s mother could live two or three months without one forgiving thought? She forgave me; and why should she not have forgiven you?” “You laboured to win her round; I did nothing. I, who was going to teach people the higher secrets of happiness, did not know how to keep out of that gross misery which the most untaught are wise enough to avoid.”
“How did you get here tonight, Thomasin?” said Eustacia. “Damon set me down at the end of the lane. He has driven into East Egdon on business, and he will come and pick me up by-and-by.” Accordingly they soon after heard the noise of wheels. Wildeve had come, and was waiting outside with his horse and gig. “Send out and tell him I will be down in two minutes,” said Thomasin. “I will run down myself,” said Eustacia. She went down. Wildeve had alighted, and was standing before the horse’s head when Eustacia opened the door. He did not turn for a moment, thinking the comer Thomasin. Then he looked, startled ever so little, and said one word: “Well?” “I have not yet told him,” she replied in a whisper. “Then don’t do so till he is well—it will be fatal. You are ill yourself.” “I am wretched.... O Damon,” she said, bursting into tears, “I—I can’t tell you how unhappy I am! I can hardly bear this. I can tell nobody of my trouble—nobody knows of it but you.” “Poor girl!” said Wildeve, visibly affected at her distress, and at last led on so far as to take her hand. “It is hard, when you have done nothing to deserve it, that you should have got involved in such a web as this. You were not made for these sad scenes. I am to blame most. If I could only have saved you from it all!”
“But, Damon, please pray tell me what I must do? To sit by him hour after hour, and hear him reproach himself as being the cause of her death, and to know that I am the sinner, if any human being is at all, drives me into cold despair. I don’t know what to do. Should I tell him or should I not tell him? I always am asking myself that. O, I want to tell him; and yet I am afraid. If he finds it out he must surely kill me, for nothing else will be in proportion to his feelings now. ‘Beware the fury of a patient man’ sounds day by day in my ears as I watch him.” “Well, wait till he is better, and trust to chance. And when you tell, you must only tell part—for his own sake.” “Which part should I keep back?” Wildeve paused. “That I was in the house at the time,” he said in a low tone. “Yes; it must be concealed, seeing what has been whispered. How much easier are hasty actions than speeches that will excuse them!” “If he were only to die—” Wildeve murmured. “Do not think of it! I would not buy hope of immunity by so cowardly a desire even if I hated him. Now I am going up to him again. Thomasin bade me tell you she would be down in a few minutes. Good-bye.” She returned, and Thomasin soon appeared. When she was seated in the gig with her husband, and the horse was turning to go off, Wildeve lifted his eyes to the bedroom windows. Looking from one of them he could discern a pale, tragic face watching him drive away. It was Eustacia’s.
Passages expressing a similar idea
The Return of the Native · Thomas Hardy (1840–1928) · II. He Is Set upon by Adversities but He Sings a Song
“Well, there are things which are placed beyond the pale of discussion; and I thought this was specially so, and by mutual agreement.” “Clym, I am unhappy at what I hear,” she said in a low voice; and her eyes drooped, and she turned away. This indication of an unexpected mine of hope in Eustacia’s bosom disconcerted her husband. It was the first time that he had confronted the fact of the indirectness of a woman’s movement towards her desire. But his intention was unshaken, though he loved Eustacia well. All the effect that her remark had upon him was a resolve to chain himself more closely than ever to his books, so as to be the sooner enabled to appeal to substantial results from another course in arguing against her whim. Next day the mystery of the guineas was explained. Thomasin paid them a hurried visit, and Clym’s share was delivered up to him by her own hands. Eustacia was not present at the time. “Then this is what my mother meant,” exclaimed Clym. “Thomasin, do you know that they have had a bitter quarrel?” There was a little more reticence now than formerly in Thomasin’s manner towards her cousin. It is the effect of marriage to engender in several directions some of the reserve it annihilates in one. “Your mother told me,” she said quietly. “She came back to my house after seeing Eustacia.” “The worst thing I dreaded has come to pass. Was Mother much disturbed when she came to you, Thomasin?” “Yes.” “Very much indeed?” “Yes.”
Read in contextThe Return of the Native · Thomas Hardy (1840–1928) · VI. A Conjuncture, and Its Result upon the Pedestrian
“No,” she said, “we won’t have any of this. If she comes in she must see you—and think if she likes there’s something wrong! But how can I open the door to her, when she dislikes me—wishes to see not me, but her son? I won’t open the door!” Mrs. Yeobright knocked again more loudly. “Her knocking will, in all likelihood, awaken him,” continued Eustacia, “and then he will let her in himself. Ah—listen.” They could hear Clym moving in the other room, as if disturbed by the knocking, and he uttered the word “Mother.” “Yes—he is awake—he will go to the door,” she said, with a breath of relief. “Come this way. I have a bad name with her, and you must not be seen. Thus I am obliged to act by stealth, not because I do ill, but because others are pleased to say so.” By this time she had taken him to the back door, which was open, disclosing a path leading down the garden. “Now, one word, Damon,” she remarked as he stepped forth. “This is your first visit here; let it be your last. We have been hot lovers in our time, but it won’t do now. Good-bye.” “Good-bye,” said Wildeve. “I have had all I came for, and I am satisfied.” “What was it?” “A sight of you. Upon my eternal honour I came for no more.”
Read in contextThe Return of the Native · Thomas Hardy (1840–1928) · BOOK FIFTH—THE DISCOVERY / I. “Wherefore Is Light Given to Him That Is in Misery”
Eustacia was always anxious to avoid the sight of her husband in such a state as this, which had become as dreadful to her as the trial scene was to Judas Iscariot. It brought before her eyes the spectre of a worn-out woman knocking at a door which she would not open; and she shrank from contemplating it. Yet it was better for Yeobright himself when he spoke openly of his sharp regret, for in silence he endured infinitely more, and would sometimes remain so long in a tense, brooding mood, consuming himself by the gnawing of his thought, that it was imperatively necessary to make him talk aloud, that his grief might in some degree expend itself in the effort. Eustacia had not been long indoors after her look at the moonlight when a soft footstep came up to the house, and Thomasin was announced by the woman downstairs. “Ah, Thomasin! Thank you for coming tonight,” said Clym when she entered the room. “Here am I, you see. Such a wretched spectacle am I, that I shrink from being seen by a single friend, and almost from you.” “You must not shrink from me, dear Clym,” said Thomasin earnestly, in that sweet voice of hers which came to a sufferer like fresh air into a Black Hole. “Nothing in you can ever shock me or drive me away. I have been here before, but you don’t remember it.”
Read in contextTess of the d'Urbervilles: A Pure Woman · Thomas Hardy (1840–1928) · XXXIX
“I don’t mind telling you, dear mother,” he said, “that I always meant to keep her away from this house till I should feel she could come with credit to you. But this idea of Brazil is quite a recent one. If I do go it will be unadvisable for me to take her on this my first journey. She will remain at her mother’s till I come back.” “And I shall not see her before you start?” He was afraid they would not. His original plan had been, as he had said, to refrain from bringing her there for some little while—not to wound their prejudices—feelings—in any way; and for other reasons he had adhered to it. He would have to visit home in the course of a year, if he went out at once; and it would be possible for them to see her before he started a second time—with her. A hastily prepared supper was brought in, and Clare made further exposition of his plans. His mother’s disappointment at not seeing the bride still remained with her. Clare’s late enthusiasm for Tess had infected her through her maternal sympathies, till she had almost fancied that a good thing could come out of Nazareth—a charming woman out of Talbothays Dairy. She watched her son as he ate. “Cannot you describe her? I am sure she is very pretty, Angel.” “Of that there can be no question!” he said, with a zest which covered its bitterness. “And that she is pure and virtuous goes without question?”
Read in contextThe Return of the Native · Thomas Hardy (1840–1928) · Letter
“She says herself that she did not. But the fact remains that keep her out she did.” “Believe her sorry, and send for her.” “How if she will not come?” “It will prove her guilty, by showing that it is her habit to nourish enmity. But I do not think that for a moment.” “I will do this. I will wait for a day or two longer—not longer than two days certainly; and if she does not send to me in that time I will indeed send to her. I thought to have seen Wildeve here tonight. Is he from home?” Thomasin blushed a little. “No,” she said. “He is merely gone out for a walk.” “Why didn’t he take you with him? The evening is fine. You want fresh air as well as he.” “Oh, I don’t care for going anywhere; besides, there is baby.” “Yes, yes. Well, I have been thinking whether I should not consult your husband about this as well as you,” said Clym steadily. “I fancy I would not,” she quickly answered. “It can do no good.” Her cousin looked her in the face. No doubt Thomasin was ignorant that her husband had any share in the events of that tragic afternoon; but her countenance seemed to signify that she concealed some suspicion or thought of the reputed tender relations between Wildeve and Eustacia in days gone by. Clym, however, could make nothing of it, and he rose to depart, more in doubt than when he came.
Read in contextThe Return of the Native · Thomas Hardy (1840–1928) · BOOK FOURTH—THE CLOSED DOOR / I. The Rencounter by the Pool
“You spoke of me within it, to Clym, and you could not do worse.” “I did my duty.” “And I’ll do mine.” “A part of which will possibly be to set him against his mother. It is always so. But why should I not bear it as others have borne it before me!” “I understand you,” said Eustacia, breathless with emotion. “You think me capable of every bad thing. Who can be worse than a wife who encourages a lover, and poisons her husband’s mind against his relative? Yet that is now the character given to me. Will you not come and drag him out of my hands?” Mrs. Yeobright gave back heat for heat. “Don’t rage at me, madam! It ill becomes your beauty, and I am not worth the injury you may do it on my account, I assure you. I am only a poor old woman who has lost a son.” “If you had treated me honourably you would have had him still.” Eustacia said, while scalding tears trickled from her eyes. “You have brought yourself to folly; you have caused a division which can never be healed!” “I have done nothing. This audacity from a young woman is more than I can bear.” “It was asked for; you have suspected me, and you have made me speak of my husband in a way I would not have done. You will let him know that I have spoken thus, and it will cause misery between us. Will you go away from me? You are no friend!”
Read in context