Skip to content
BookLens

The Return of the Native

Thomas Hardy (1840–1928)

Yeobright placed his hand upon her arm. “Now, don’t you suppose, my inexperienced girl, that I cannot rebel, in high Promethean fashion, against the gods and fate as well as you. I have felt more steam and smoke of that sort than you have ever heard of. But the more I see of life the more do I perceive that there is nothing particularly great in its greatest walks, and therefore nothing particularly small in mine of furze-cutting. If I feel that the greatest blessings vouchsafed to us are not very valuable, how can I feel it to be any great hardship when they are taken away? So I sing to pass the time. Have you indeed lost all tenderness for me, that you begrudge me a few cheerful moments?” “I have still some tenderness left for you.” “Your words have no longer their old flavour. And so love dies with good fortune!” “I cannot listen to this, Clym—it will end bitterly,” she said in a broken voice. “I will go home.”

A few days later, before the month of August had expired, Eustacia and Yeobright sat together at their early dinner. Eustacia’s manner had become of late almost apathetic. There was a forlorn look about her beautiful eyes which, whether she deserved it or not, would have excited pity in the breast of anyone who had known her during the full flush of her love for Clym. The feelings of husband and wife varied, in some measure, inversely with their positions. Clym, the afflicted man, was cheerful; and he even tried to comfort her, who had never felt a moment of physical suffering in her whole life. “Come, brighten up, dearest; we shall be all right again. Some day perhaps I shall see as well as ever. And I solemnly promise that I’ll leave off cutting furze as soon as I have the power to do anything better. You cannot seriously wish me to stay idling at home all day?” “But it is so dreadful—a furze-cutter! and you a man who have lived about the world, and speak French, and German, and who are fit for what is so much better than this.” “I suppose when you first saw me and heard about me I was wrapped in a sort of golden halo to your eyes—a man who knew glorious things, and had mixed in brilliant scenes—in short, an adorable, delightful, distracting hero?” “Yes,” she said, sobbing. “And now I am a poor fellow in brown leather.”

“Don’t taunt me. But enough of this. I will not be depressed any more. I am going from home this afternoon, unless you greatly object. There is to be a village picnic—a gipsying, they call it—at East Egdon, and I shall go.” “To dance?” “Why not? You can sing.” “Well, well, as you will. Must I come to fetch you?” “If you return soon enough from your work. But do not inconvenience yourself about it. I know the way home, and the heath has no terror for me.” “And can you cling to gaiety so eagerly as to walk all the way to a village festival in search of it?” “Now, you don’t like my going alone! Clym, you are not jealous?” “No. But I would come with you if it could give you any pleasure; though, as things stand, perhaps you have too much of me already. Still, I somehow wish that you did not want to go. Yes, perhaps I am jealous; and who could be jealous with more reason than I, a half-blind man, over such a woman as you?” “Don’t think like it. Let me go, and don’t take all my spirits away!”

“I would rather lose all my own, my sweet wife. Go and do whatever you like. Who can forbid your indulgence in any whim? You have all my heart yet, I believe; and because you bear with me, who am in truth a drag upon you, I owe you thanks. Yes, go alone and shine. As for me, I will stick to my doom. At that kind of meeting people would shun me. My hook and gloves are like the St. Lazarus rattle of the leper, warning the world to get out of the way of a sight that would sadden them.” He kissed her, put on his leggings, and went out. When he was gone she rested her head upon her hands and said to herself, “Two wasted lives—his and mine. And I am come to this! Will it drive me out of my mind?” She cast about for any possible course which offered the least improvement on the existing state of things, and could find none. She imagined how all those Budmouth ones who should learn what had become of her would say, “Look at the girl for whom nobody was good enough!” To Eustacia the situation seemed such a mockery of her hopes that death appeared the only door of relief if the satire of Heaven should go much further.

Suddenly she aroused herself and exclaimed, “But I’ll shake it off. Yes, I will shake it off! No one shall know my suffering. I’ll be bitterly merry, and ironically gay, and I’ll laugh in derision. And I’ll begin by going to this dance on the green.” She ascended to her bedroom and dressed herself with scrupulous care. To an onlooker her beauty would have made her feelings almost seem reasonable. The gloomy corner into which accident as much as indiscretion had brought this woman might have led even a moderate partisan to feel that she had cogent reasons for asking the Supreme Power by what right a being of such exquisite finish had been placed in circumstances calculated to make of her charms a curse rather than a blessing.

Passages expressing a similar idea

  • The Return of the Native · Thomas Hardy (1840–1928) · IX. Love Leads a Shrewd Man into Strategy

    DEAR DIGGORY VENN,—The question you put when you overtook me coming home from Pond-close gave me such a surprise that I am afraid I did not make you exactly understand what I meant. Of course, if my aunt had not met me I could have explained all then at once, but as it was there was no chance. I have been quite uneasy since, as you know I do not wish to pain you, yet I fear I shall be doing so now in contradicting what I seemed to say then. I cannot, Diggory, marry you, or think of letting you call me your sweetheart. I could not, indeed, Diggory. I hope you will not much mind my saying this, and feel in a great pain. It makes me very sad when I think it may, for I like you very much, and I always put you next to my cousin Clym in my mind. There are so many reasons why we cannot be married that I can hardly name them all in a letter. I did not in the least expect that you were going to speak on such a thing when you followed me, because I had never thought of you in the sense of a lover at all. You must not becall me for laughing when you spoke; you mistook when you thought I laughed at you as a foolish man. I laughed because the idea was so odd, and not at you at all. The great reason with my own personal self for not letting you court me is, that I do not feel the things a woman ought to feel who consents to walk with you with the meaning of being your wife. It is not as you think, that I have another in my mind, for I do not encourage anybody, and never have in my life. Another reason is my aunt. She would not, I know, agree to it, even if I wished to have you. She likes you very well, but she will want me to look a little higher than a small dairy-farmer, and marry a professional man. I hope you will not set your heart against me for writing plainly, but I felt you might try to see me again, and it is better that we should not meet. I shall always think of you as a good man, and be anxious for your well-doing. I send this by Jane Orchard’s little maid,—And remain Diggory, your faithful friend,

    Read in context
  • The Return of the Native · Thomas Hardy (1840–1928) · XI. The Dishonesty of an Honest Woman

    “Come—no taunts, Eustacia, or we shall quarrel. If you don’t agree to go with me, and agree shortly, I shall go by myself.” “Or try Thomasin again. Damon, how strange it seems that you could have married her or me indifferently, and only have come to me because I am—cheapest! Yes, yes—it is true. There was a time when I should have exclaimed against a man of that sort, and been quite wild; but it is all past now.” “Will you go, dearest? Come secretly with me to Bristol, marry me, and turn our backs upon this dog-hole of England for ever? Say Yes.” “I want to get away from here at almost any cost,” she said with weariness, “but I don’t like to go with you. Give me more time to decide.” “I have already,” said Wildeve. “Well, I give you one more week.” “A little longer, so that I may tell you decisively. I have to consider so many things. Fancy Thomasin being anxious to get rid of you! I cannot forget it.” “Never mind that. Say Monday week. I will be here precisely at this time.” “Let it be at Rainbarrow,” said she. “This is too near home; my grandfather may be walking out.” “Thank you, dear. On Monday week at this time I will be at the Barrow. Till then good-bye.” “Good-bye. No, no, you must not touch me now. Shaking hands is enough till I have made up my mind.”

    Read in context
  • The Return of the Native · Thomas Hardy (1840–1928) · VI. The Two Stand Face to Face

    “To get excitement and shake off depression,” she said in low tones. “What depressed you?” “Life.” “That’s a cause of depression a good many have to put up with.” “Yes.” A long silence. “And do you find excitement?” asked Clym at last. “At this moment, perhaps.” “Then you are vexed at being discovered?” “Yes; though I thought I might be.” “I would gladly have asked you to our party had I known you wished to come. Have I ever been acquainted with you in my youth?” “Never.” “Won’t you come in again, and stay as long as you like?” “No. I wish not to be further recognized.” “Well, you are safe with me.” After remaining in thought a minute he added gently, “I will not intrude upon you longer. It is a strange way of meeting, and I will not ask why I find a cultivated woman playing such a part as this.” She did not volunteer the reason which he seemed to hope for, and he wished her good night, going thence round to the back of the house, where he walked up and down by himself for some time before re-entering.

    Read in context
  • The Return of the Native · Thomas Hardy (1840–1928) · II. He Is Set upon by Adversities but He Sings a Song

    During the whole of Yeobright’s walk home to Alderworth he was lost in reflections which were not of an unpleasant kind. On his coming up to the house Eustacia spoke to him from the open window, and he went across to her. “Darling,” he said, “I am much happier. And if my mother were reconciled to me and to you I should, I think, be happy quite.” “I fear that will never be,” she said, looking afar with her beautiful stormy eyes. “How can you say ‘I am happier,’ and nothing changed?” “It arises from my having at last discovered something I can do, and get a living at, in this time of misfortune.” “Yes?” “I am going to be a furze- and turf-cutter.” “No, Clym!” she said, the slight hopefulness previously apparent in her face going off again, and leaving her worse than before. “Surely I shall. Is it not very unwise in us to go on spending the little money we’ve got when I can keep down expenditures by an honest occupation? The outdoor exercise will do me good, and who knows but that in a few months I shall be able to go on with my reading again?” “But my grandfather offers to assist us, if we require assistance.” “We don’t require it. If I go furze-cutting we shall be fairly well off.”

    Read in context
  • The Return of the Native · Thomas Hardy (1840–1928) · Act in a Timeworn Drama

    “Yes, it frightened me. I had not been to church for a long time. And now I shall not go again for ever so long—perhaps never. I cannot face their eyes after this. Don’t you think it dreadfully humiliating? I wished I was dead for hours after, but I don’t mind now.” “I have come to clean away these cobwebs,” said Yeobright. “Would you like to help me—by high-class teaching? We might benefit them much.” “I don’t quite feel anxious to. I have not much love for my fellow-creatures. Sometimes I quite hate them.” “Still I think that if you were to hear my scheme you might take an interest in it. There is no use in hating people—if you hate anything, you should hate what produced them.” “Do you mean Nature? I hate her already. But I shall be glad to hear your scheme at any time.” The situation had now worked itself out, and the next natural thing was for them to part. Clym knew this well enough, and Eustacia made a move of conclusion; yet he looked at her as if he had one word more to say. Perhaps if he had not lived in Paris it would never have been uttered. “We have met before,” he said, regarding her with rather more interest than was necessary. “I do not own it,” said Eustacia, with a repressed, still look. “But I may think what I like.” “Yes.” “You are lonely here.”

    Read in context
  • The Return of the Native · Thomas Hardy (1840–1928) · IV. The Ministrations of a Half-forgotten One

    “You refuse?” “I do. I care too much for you to give ’em up.” She turned aside, her face for the first time softening from the stony immobility of the earlier day, and the corners of her mouth resuming something of that delicacy of cut which was always lost in her moments of despair. At last she confronted him again. “Why should I not die if I wish?” she said tremulously. “I have made a bad bargain with life, and I am weary of it—weary. And now you have hindered my escape. O, why did you, Charley! What makes death painful except the thought of others’ grief?—and that is absent in my case, for not a sigh would follow me!” “Ah, it is trouble that has done this! I wish in my very soul that he who brought it about might die and rot, even if ’tis transportation to say it!” “Charley, no more of that. What do you mean to do about this you have seen?” “Keep it close as night, if you promise not to think of it again.” “You need not fear. The moment has passed. I promise.” She then went away, entered the house, and lay down. Later in the afternoon her grandfather returned. He was about to question her categorically, but on looking at her he withheld his words. “Yes, it is too bad to talk of,” she slowly returned in answer to his glance. “Can my old room be got ready for me tonight, Grandfather? I shall want to occupy it again.” He did not ask what it all meant, or why she had left her husband, but ordered the room to be prepared.

    Read in context