Skip to content
BookLens

Women in Love

D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)

“Yes, it was horrible, really. Why should you hate the moon? It hasn’t done you any harm, has it?” “Was it hate?” he said. And they were silent for a few minutes. “When did you come back?” she said. “Today.” “Why did you never write?” “I could find nothing to say.” “Why was there nothing to say?” “I don’t know. Why are there no daffodils now?” “No.” Again there was a space of silence. Ursula looked at the moon. It had gathered itself together, and was quivering slightly. “Was it good for you, to be alone?” she asked. “Perhaps. Not that I know much. But I got over a good deal. Did you do anything important?” “No. I looked at England, and thought I’d done with it.” “Why England?” he asked in surprise. “I don’t know, it came like that.” “It isn’t a question of nations,” he said. “France is far worse.” “Yes, I know. I felt I’d done with it all.” They went and sat down on the roots of the trees, in the shadow. And being silent, he remembered the beauty of her eyes, which were sometimes filled with light, like spring, suffused with wonderful promise. So he said to her, slowly, with difficulty: “There is a golden light in you, which I wish you would give me.” It was as if he had been thinking of this for some time. She was startled, she seemed to leap clear of him. Yet also she was pleased. “What kind of a light,” she asked.

But he was shy, and did not say any more. So the moment passed for this time. And gradually a feeling of sorrow came over her. “My life is unfulfilled,” she said. “Yes,” he answered briefly, not wanting to hear this. “And I feel as if nobody could ever really love me,” she said. But he did not answer. “You think, don’t you,” she said slowly, “that I only want physical things? It isn’t true. I want you to serve my spirit.” “I know you do. I know you don’t want physical things by themselves. But, I want you to give me—to give your spirit to me—that golden light which is you—which you don’t know—give it me—” After a moment’s silence she replied: “But how can I, you don’t love me! You only want your own ends. You don’t want to serve me, and yet you want me to serve you. It is so one-sided!” It was a great effort to him to maintain this conversation, and to press for the thing he wanted from her, the surrender of her spirit. “It is different,” he said. “The two kinds of service are so different. I serve you in another way—not through yourself—somewhere else. But I want us to be together without bothering about ourselves—to be really together because we are together, as if it were a phenomenon, not a thing we have to maintain by our own effort.”

“No,” she said, pondering. “You are just egocentric. You never have any enthusiasm, you never come out with any spark towards me. You want yourself, really, and your own affairs. And you want me just to be there, to serve you.” But this only made him shut off from her. “Ah well,” he said, “words make no matter, any way. The thing is between us, or it isn’t.” “You don’t even love me,” she cried. “I do,” he said angrily. “But I want—” His mind saw again the lovely golden light of spring transfused through her eyes, as through some wonderful window. And he wanted her to be with him there, in this world of proud indifference. But what was the good of telling her he wanted this company in proud indifference. What was the good of talking, any way? It must happen beyond the sound of words. It was merely ruinous to try to work her by conviction. This was a paradisal bird that could never be netted, it must fly by itself to the heart. “I always think I am going to be loved—and then I am let down. You don’t love me, you know. You don’t want to serve me. You only want yourself.” A shiver of rage went over his veins, at this repeated: “You don’t want to serve me.” All the paradisal disappeared from him.

“No,” he said, irritated, “I don’t want to serve you, because there is nothing there to serve. What you want me to serve, is nothing, mere nothing. It isn’t even you, it is your mere female quality. And I wouldn’t give a straw for your female ego—it’s a rag doll.” “Ha!” she laughed in mockery. “That’s all you think of me, is it? And then you have the impudence to say you love me.” She rose in anger, to go home. You want the paradisal unknowing,” she said, turning round on him as he still sat half-visible in the shadow. “I know what that means, thank you. You want me to be your thing, never to criticise you or to have anything to say for myself. You want me to be a mere thing for you! No thank you! If you want that, there are plenty of women who will give it to you. There are plenty of women who will lie down for you to walk over them—go to them then, if that’s what you want—go to them.” “No,” he said, outspoken with anger. “I want you to drop your assertive will, your frightened apprehensive self-insistence, that is what I want. I want you to trust yourself so implicitly, that you can let yourself go.” “Let myself go!” she re-echoed in mockery. “I can let myself go, easily enough. It is you who can’t let yourself go, it is you who hang on to yourself as if it were your only treasure. You—you are the Sunday school teacher—You—you preacher.”

The amount of truth that was in this made him stiff and unheeding of her. “I don’t mean let yourself go in the Dionysic ecstatic way,” he said. “I know you can do that. But I hate ecstasy, Dionysic or any other. It’s like going round in a squirrel cage. I want you not to care about yourself, just to be there and not to care about yourself, not to insist—be glad and sure and indifferent.” “Who insists?” she mocked. “Who is it that keeps on insisting? It isn’t me!” There was a weary, mocking bitterness in her voice. He was silent for some time. “I know,” he said. “While ever either of us insists to the other, we are all wrong. But there we are, the accord doesn’t come.” They sat in stillness under the shadow of the trees by the bank. The night was white around them, they were in the darkness, barely conscious. Gradually, the stillness and peace came over them. She put her hand tentatively on his. Their hands clasped softly and silently, in peace. “Do you really love me?” she said. He laughed. “I call that your war-cry,” he replied, amused. “Why!” she cried, amused and really wondering. “Your insistence—Your war-cry—“A Brangwen, A Brangwen”—an old battle-cry. Yours is, ‘Do you love me? Yield knave, or die.’” “No,” she said, pleading, “not like that. Not like that. But I must know that you love me, mustn’t I?” “Well then, know it and have done with it.” “But do you?”

Passages expressing a similar idea

  • The Tenant of Wildfell Hall · Anne Brontë (1820–1849) · CHAPTER XXXVII

    “There need be no disgrace, no misery or sacrifice in any quarter,” persisted he. “I do not ask you to leave your home or defy the world’s opinion.” But I need not repeat all his arguments. I refuted them to the best of my power; but that power was provokingly small, at the moment, for I was too much flurried with indignation—and even shame—that he should thus dare to address me, to retain sufficient command of thought and language to enable me adequately to contend against his powerful sophistries. Finding, however, that he could not be silenced by reason, and even covertly exulted in his seeming advantage, and ventured to deride those assertions I had not the coolness to prove, I changed my course and tried another plan. “Do you really love me?” said I, seriously, pausing and looking him calmly in the face. “Do I love you!” cried he. “Truly?” I demanded. His countenance brightened; he thought his triumph was at hand. He commenced a passionate protestation of the truth and fervour of his attachment, which I cut short by another question:— “But is it not a selfish love? Have you enough disinterested affection to enable you to sacrifice your own pleasure to mine?” “I would give my life to serve you.” “I don’t want your life; but have you enough real sympathy for my afflictions to induce you to make an effort to relieve them, at the risk of a little discomfort to yourself?” “Try me, and see.”

    Read in context
  • The House of Mirth · Edith Wharton (1862–1937) · Chapter 6

    Her face brightened at this, but she drew her hand away, not with a gesture of coquetry, but as though renouncing something to which she had no claim. “But you belittle ME, don’t you,” she returned gently, “in being so sure they are the only things I care for?” Selden felt an inner start; but it was only the last quiver of his egoism. Almost at once he answered quite simply: “But you do care for them, don’t you? And no wishing of mine can alter that.” He had so completely ceased to consider how far this might carry him, that he had a distinct sense of disappointment when she turned on him a face sparkling with derision. “Ah,” she cried, “for all your fine phrases you’re really as great a coward as I am, for you wouldn’t have made one of them if you hadn’t been so sure of my answer.” The shock of this retort had the effect of crystallizing Selden’s wavering intentions. “I am not so sure of your answer,” he said quietly. “And I do you the justice to believe that you are not either.” It was her turn to look at him with surprise; and after a moment—“Do you want to marry me?” she asked. He broke into a laugh. “No, I don’t want to—but perhaps I should if you did!” “That’s what I told you—you’re so sure of me that you can amuse yourself with experiments.” She drew back the hand he had regained, and sat looking down on him sadly.

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER XI THE TEST ON MIRIAM

    Miriam plunged home over the meadows. She was not afraid of people, what they might say; but she dreaded the issue with him. Yes, she would let him have her if he insisted; and then, when she thought of it afterwards, her heart went down. He would be disappointed, he would find no satisfaction, and then he would go away. Yet he was so insistent; and over this, which did not seem so all-important to her, was their love to break down. After all, he was only like other men, seeking his satisfaction. Oh, but there was something more in him, something deeper! She could trust to it, in spite of all desires. He said that possession was a great moment in life. All strong emotions concentrated there. Perhaps it was so. There was something divine in it; then she would submit, religiously, to the sacrifice. He should have her. And at the thought her whole body clenched itself involuntarily, hard, as if against something; but Life forced her through this gate of suffering, too, and she would submit. At any rate, it would give him what he wanted, which was her deepest wish. She brooded and brooded and brooded herself towards accepting him.

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER IX DEFEAT OF MIRIAM

    Paul was dissatisfied with himself and with everything. The deepest of his love belonged to his mother. When he felt he had hurt her, or wounded his love for her, he could not bear it. Now it was spring, and there was battle between him and Miriam. This year he had a good deal against her. She was vaguely aware of it. The old feeling that she was to be a sacrifice to this love, which she had had when she prayed, was mingled in all her emotions. She did not at the bottom believe she ever would have him. She did not believe in herself primarily: doubted whether she could ever be what he would demand of her. Certainly she never saw herself living happily through a lifetime with him. She saw tragedy, sorrow, and sacrifice ahead. And in sacrifice she was proud, in renunciation she was strong, for she did not trust herself to support everyday life. She was prepared for the big things and the deep things, like tragedy. It was the sufficiency of the small day-life she could not trust. The Easter holidays began happily. Paul was his own frank self. Yet she felt it would go wrong. On the Sunday afternoon she stood at her bedroom window, looking across at the oak-trees of the wood, in whose branches a twilight was tangled, below the bright sky of the afternoon. Grey-green rosettes of honeysuckle leaves hung before the window, some already, she fancied, showing bud. It was spring, which she loved and dreaded.

    Read in context
  • Sons and Lovers · D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930) · CHAPTER IX DEFEAT OF MIRIAM

    He was silent again. She brooded. What did he mean? He was so wearying. There was something he would not yield. Yet she must be patient with him. “I can only give friendship—it’s all I’m capable of—it’s a flaw in my make-up. The thing overbalances to one side—I hate a toppling balance. Let us have done.” There was warmth of fury in his last phrases. He meant she loved him more than he her. Perhaps he could not love her. Perhaps she had not in herself that which he wanted. It was the deepest motive of her soul, this self-mistrust. It was so deep she dared neither realise nor acknowledge. Perhaps she was deficient. Like an infinitely subtle shame, it kept her always back. If it were so, she would do without him. She would never let herself want him. She would merely see. “But what has happened?” she said. “Nothing—it’s all in myself—it only comes out just now. We’re always like this towards Easter-time.” He grovelled so helplessly, she pitied him. At least she never floundered in such a pitiable way. After all, it was he who was chiefly humiliated. “What do you want?” she asked him. “Why—I mustn’t come often—that’s all. Why should I monopolise you when I’m not—You see, I’m deficient in something with regard to you—”

    Read in context
  • A Room with a View · E. M. (Edward Morgan) Forster (1879–1970) · Chapter XIX Lying to Mr. Emerson

    “But you do,” he went on, not waiting for contradiction. “You love the boy body and soul, plainly, directly, as he loves you, and no other word expresses it. You won’t marry the other man for his sake.” “How dare you!” gasped Lucy, with the roaring of waters in her ears. “Oh, how like a man!—I mean, to suppose that a woman is always thinking about a man.” “But you are.” She summoned physical disgust. “You’re shocked, but I mean to shock you. It’s the only hope at times. I can reach you no other way. You must marry, or your life will be wasted. You have gone too far to retreat. I have no time for the tenderness, and the comradeship, and the poetry, and the things that really matter, and for which you marry. I know that, with George, you will find them, and that you love him. Then be his wife. He is already part of you. Though you fly to Greece, and never see him again, or forget his very name, George will work in your thoughts till you die. It isn’t possible to love and to part. You will wish that it was. You can transmute love, ignore it, muddle it, but you can never pull it out of you. I know by experience that the poets are right: love is eternal.” Lucy began to cry with anger, and though her anger passed away soon, her tears remained.

    Read in context