Women in Love
D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)
“Yes, it does. At the very last, one is alone, beyond the influence of love. There is a real impersonal me, that is beyond love, beyond any emotional relationship. So it is with you. But we want to delude ourselves that love is the root. It isn’t. It is only the branches. The root is beyond love, a naked kind of isolation, an isolated me, that does not meet and mingle, and never can.” She watched him with wide, troubled eyes. His face was incandescent in its abstract earnestness. “And you mean you can’t love?” she asked, in trepidation. “Yes, if you like. I have loved. But there is a beyond, where there is not love.” She could not submit to this. She felt it swooning over her. But she could not submit. “But how do you know—if you have never really loved?” she asked. “It is true, what I say; there is a beyond, in you, in me, which is further than love, beyond the scope, as stars are beyond the scope of vision, some of them.” “Then there is no love,” cried Ursula. “Ultimately, no, there is something else. But, ultimately, there is no love.” Ursula was given over to this statement for some moments. Then she half rose from her chair, saying, in a final, repellent voice: “Then let me go home—what am I doing here?” “There is the door,” he said. “You are a free agent.” He was suspended finely and perfectly in this extremity. She hung motionless for some seconds, then she sat down again.
“If there is no love, what is there?” she cried, almost jeering. “Something,” he said, looking at her, battling with his soul, with all his might. “What?” He was silent for a long time, unable to be in communication with her while she was in this state of opposition. “There is,” he said, in a voice of pure abstraction; “a final me which is stark and impersonal and beyond responsibility. So there is a final you. And it is there I would want to meet you—not in the emotional, loving plane—but there beyond, where there is no speech and no terms of agreement. There we are two stark, unknown beings, two utterly strange creatures, I would want to approach you, and you me. And there could be no obligation, because there is no standard for action there, because no understanding has been reaped from that plane. It is quite inhuman,—so there can be no calling to book, in any form whatsoever—because one is outside the pale of all that is accepted, and nothing known applies. One can only follow the impulse, taking that which lies in front, and responsible for nothing, asked for nothing, giving nothing, only each taking according to the primal desire.” Ursula listened to this speech, her mind dumb and almost senseless, what he said was so unexpected and so untoward. “It is just purely selfish,” she said.
“If it is pure, yes. But it isn’t selfish at all. Because I don’t know what I want of you. I deliver myself over to the unknown, in coming to you, I am without reserves or defences, stripped entirely, into the unknown. Only there needs the pledge between us, that we will both cast off everything, cast off ourselves even, and cease to be, so that that which is perfectly ourselves can take place in us.” She pondered along her own line of thought. “But it is because you love me, that you want me?” she persisted. “No it isn’t. It is because I believe in you—if I do believe in you.” “Aren’t you sure?” she laughed, suddenly hurt. He was looking at her steadfastly, scarcely heeding what she said. “Yes, I must believe in you, or else I shouldn’t be here saying this,” he replied. “But that is all the proof I have. I don’t feel any very strong belief at this particular moment.” She disliked him for this sudden relapse into weariness and faithlessness. “But don’t you think me good-looking?” she persisted, in a mocking voice. He looked at her, to see if he felt that she was good-looking. “I don’t feel that you’re good-looking,” he said. “Not even attractive?” she mocked, bitingly. He knitted his brows in sudden exasperation.
“Don’t you see that it’s not a question of visual appreciation in the least,” he cried. “I don’t want to see you. I’ve seen plenty of women, I’m sick and weary of seeing them. I want a woman I don’t see.” “I’m sorry I can’t oblige you by being invisible,” she laughed. “Yes,” he said, “you are invisible to me, if you don’t force me to be visually aware of you. But I don’t want to see you or hear you.” “What did you ask me to tea for, then?” she mocked. But he would take no notice of her. He was talking to himself. “I want to find you, where you don’t know your own existence, the you that your common self denies utterly. But I don’t want your good looks, and I don’t want your womanly feelings, and I don’t want your thoughts nor opinions nor your ideas—they are all bagatelles to me.” “You are very conceited, Monsieur,” she mocked. “How do you know what my womanly feelings are, or my thoughts or my ideas? You don’t even know what I think of you now.” “Nor do I care in the slightest.” “I think you are very silly. I think you want to tell me you love me, and you go all this way round to do it.” “All right,” he said, looking up with sudden exasperation. “Now go away then, and leave me alone. I don’t want any more of your meretricious persiflage.”
“Is it really persiflage?” she mocked, her face really relaxing into laughter. She interpreted it, that he had made a deep confession of love to her. But he was so absurd in his words, also. They were silent for many minutes, she was pleased and elated like a child. His concentration broke, he began to look at her simply and naturally. “What I want is a strange conjunction with you—” he said quietly; “not meeting and mingling—you are quite right—but an equilibrium, a pure balance of two single beings—as the stars balance each other.” She looked at him. He was very earnest, and earnestness was always rather ridiculous, commonplace, to her. It made her feel unfree and uncomfortable. Yet she liked him so much. But why drag in the stars. “Isn’t this rather sudden?” she mocked. He began to laugh. “Best to read the terms of the contract, before we sign,” he said. A young grey cat that had been sleeping on the sofa jumped down and stretched, rising on its long legs, and arching its slim back. Then it sat considering for a moment, erect and kingly. And then, like a dart, it had shot out of the room, through the open window-doors, and into the garden. “What’s he after?” said Birkin, rising.
Passages expressing a similar idea
The Tenant of Wildfell Hall · Anne Brontë (1820–1849) · CHAPTER XXXVII
“There need be no disgrace, no misery or sacrifice in any quarter,” persisted he. “I do not ask you to leave your home or defy the world’s opinion.” But I need not repeat all his arguments. I refuted them to the best of my power; but that power was provokingly small, at the moment, for I was too much flurried with indignation—and even shame—that he should thus dare to address me, to retain sufficient command of thought and language to enable me adequately to contend against his powerful sophistries. Finding, however, that he could not be silenced by reason, and even covertly exulted in his seeming advantage, and ventured to deride those assertions I had not the coolness to prove, I changed my course and tried another plan. “Do you really love me?” said I, seriously, pausing and looking him calmly in the face. “Do I love you!” cried he. “Truly?” I demanded. His countenance brightened; he thought his triumph was at hand. He commenced a passionate protestation of the truth and fervour of his attachment, which I cut short by another question:— “But is it not a selfish love? Have you enough disinterested affection to enable you to sacrifice your own pleasure to mine?” “I would give my life to serve you.” “I don’t want your life; but have you enough real sympathy for my afflictions to induce you to make an effort to relieve them, at the risk of a little discomfort to yourself?” “Try me, and see.”
Read in contextThe Mill on the Floss · George Eliot (1819–1880) · Chapter III. Showing That Old Acquaintances Are Capable of Surprising Us
But perhaps I am wrong; perhaps I feel about you as the artist does about the scene over which his soul has brooded with love; he would tremble to see it confided to other hands; he would never believe that it could bear for another all the meaning and the beauty it bears for him. “I dared not trust myself to see you that morning; I was filled with selfish passion; I was shattered by a night of conscious delirium. I told you long ago that I had never been resigned even to the mediocrity of my powers; how could I be resigned to the loss of the one thing which had ever come to me on earth with the promise of such deep joy as would give a new and blessed meaning to the foregoing pain,—the promise of another self that would lift my aching affection into the divine rapture of an ever-springing, ever-satisfied want? “But the miseries of that night had prepared me for what came before the next. It was no surprise to me. I was certain that he had prevailed on you to sacrifice everything to him, and I waited with equal certainty to hear of your marriage. I measured your love and his by my own. But I was wrong, Maggie. There is something stronger in you than your love for him. “I will not tell you what I went through in that interval.
Read in contextAdam Bede · George Eliot (1819–1880) · Chapter XXVIII A Dilemma
“Well, then, if you feel it,” Adam rejoined, eagerly; “if you feel as you may ha’ put false notions into her mind, and made her believe as you loved her, when all the while you meant nothing, I’ve this demand to make of you—I’m not speaking for myself, but for her. I ask you t’ undeceive her before you go away. Y’aren’t going away for ever, and if you leave her behind with a notion in her head o’ your feeling about her the same as she feels about you, she’ll be hankering after you, and the mischief may get worse. It may be a smart to her now, but it’ll save her pain i’ th’ end. I ask you to write a letter—you may trust to my seeing as she gets it. Tell her the truth, and take blame to yourself for behaving as you’d no right to do to a young woman as isn’t your equal. I speak plain, sir, but I can’t speak any other way. There’s nobody can take care o’ Hetty in this thing but me.” “I can do what I think needful in the matter,” said Arthur, more and more irritated by mingled distress and perplexity, “without giving promises to you. I shall take what measures I think proper.”
Read in contextNight and Day · Virginia Woolf (1882–1941) · CHAPTER XXIII
“I deny that I should cease to feel this if I knew you,” he went on. “I should feel it more reasonably—that’s all. I shouldn’t talk the kind of nonsense I’ve talked to-night.... But it wasn’t nonsense. It was the truth,” he said doggedly. “It’s the important thing. You can force me to talk as if this feeling for you were an hallucination, but all our feelings are that. The best of them are half illusions. Still,” he added, as if arguing to himself, “if it weren’t as real a feeling as I’m capable of, I shouldn’t be changing my life on your account.” “What do you mean?” she inquired. “I told you. I’m taking a cottage. I’m giving up my profession.” “On my account?” she asked, in amazement. “Yes, on your account,” he replied. He explained his meaning no further. “But I don’t know you or your circumstances,” she said at last, as he remained silent. “You have no opinion about me one way or the other?” “Yes, I suppose I have an opinion—” she hesitated. He controlled his wish to ask her to explain herself, and much to his pleasure she went on, appearing to search her mind. “I thought that you criticized me—perhaps disliked me. I thought of you as a person who judges—” “No; I’m a person who feels,” he said, in a low voice. “Tell me, then, what has made you do this?” she asked, after a break.
Read in contextAnna Karenina · Leo Tolstoy (1828–1910) · Chapter 30
“My love keeps growing more passionate and egoistic, while his is waning and waning, and that’s why we’re drifting apart.” She went on musing. “And there’s no help for it. He is everything for me, and I want him more and more to give himself up to me entirely. And he wants more and more to get away from me. We walked to meet each other up to the time of our love, and then we have been irresistibly drifting in different directions. And there’s no altering that. He tells me I’m insanely jealous, and I have told myself that I am insanely jealous; but it’s not true. I’m not jealous, but I’m unsatisfied. But....” she opened her lips, and shifted her place in the carriage in the excitement, aroused by the thought that suddenly struck her. “If I could be anything but a mistress, passionately caring for nothing but his caresses; but I can’t and I don’t care to be anything else. And by that desire I rouse aversion in him, and he rouses fury in me, and it cannot be different. Don’t I know that he wouldn’t deceive me, that he has no schemes about Princess Sorokina, that he’s not in love with Kitty, that he won’t desert me! I know all that, but it makes it no better for me. If without loving me, from duty he’ll be good and kind to me, without what I want, that’s a thousand times worse than unkindness! That’s—hell! And that’s just how it is.
Read in contextVillette · Charlotte Brontë (1816–1855) · CHAPTER IX. ISIDORE.
“No. I danced with a young officer the other night, whom I love a thousand times more than he. I often wonder why I feel so very cold to Isidore, for everybody says he is handsome, and other ladies admire him; but, somehow, he bores me: let me see now how it is….” And she seemed to make an effort to reflect. In this I encouraged her. “Yes!” I said, “try to get a clear idea of the state of your mind. To me it seems in a great mess—chaotic as a rag-bag.” “It is something in this fashion,” she cried out ere long: “the man is too romantic and devoted, and he expects something more of me than I find it convenient to be. He thinks I am perfect: furnished with all sorts of sterling qualities and solid virtues, such as I never had, nor intend to have. Now, one can’t help, in his presence, rather trying to justify his good opinion; and it does so tire one to be goody, and to talk sense,—for he really thinks I am sensible. I am far more at my ease with you, old lady—you, you dear crosspatch—who take me at my lowest, and know me to be coquettish, and ignorant, and flirting, and fickle, and silly, and selfish, and all the other sweet things you and I have agreed to be a part of my character.”
Read in context