Sons and Lovers
D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)
“Look how little she is!” he said to himself. “She’s lost like a grain of sand in the beach—just a concentrated speck blown along, a tiny white foam-bubble, almost nothing among the morning. Why does she absorb me?” The morning was altogether uninterrupted: she was gone in the water. Far and wide the beach, the sandhills with their blue marrain, the shining water, glowed together in immense, unbroken solitude. “What is she, after all?” he said to himself. “Here’s the seacoast morning, big and permanent and beautiful; there is she, fretting, always unsatisfied, and temporary as a bubble of foam. What does she mean to me, after all? She represents something, like a bubble of foam represents the sea. But what is she? It’s not her I care for.” Then, startled by his own unconscious thoughts, that seemed to speak so distinctly that all the morning could hear, he undressed and ran quickly down the sands. She was watching for him. Her arm flashed up to him, she heaved on a wave, subsided, her shoulders in a pool of liquid silver. He jumped through the breakers, and in a moment her hand was on his shoulder. He was a poor swimmer, and could not stay long in the water. She played round him in triumph, sporting with her superiority, which he begrudged her. The sunshine stood deep and fine on the water. They laughed in the sea for a minute or two, then raced each other back to the sandhills.
When they were drying themselves, panting heavily, he watched her laughing, breathless face, her bright shoulders, her breasts that swayed and made him frightened as she rubbed them, and he thought again: “But she is magnificent, and even bigger than the morning and the sea. Is she—? Is she—?” She, seeing his dark eyes fixed on her, broke off from her drying with a laugh. “What are you looking at?” she said. “You,” he answered, laughing. Her eyes met his, and in a moment he was kissing her white “goose-fleshed” shoulder, and thinking: “What is she? What is she?” She loved him in the morning. There was something detached, hard, and elemental about his kisses then, as if he were only conscious of his own will, not in the least of her and her wanting him. Later in the day he went out sketching. “You,” he said to her, “go with your mother to Sutton. I am so dull.” She stood and looked at him. He knew she wanted to come with him, but he preferred to be alone. She made him feel imprisoned when she was there, as if he could not get a free deep breath, as if there were something on top of him. She felt his desire to be free of her. In the evening he came back to her. They walked down the shore in the darkness, then sat for a while in the shelter of the sandhills.
“It seems,” she said, as they stared over the darkness of the sea, where no light was to be seen—“it seemed as if you only loved me at night—as if you didn’t love me in the daytime.” He ran the cold sand through his fingers, feeling guilty under the accusation. “The night is free to you,” he replied. “In the daytime I want to be by myself.” “But why?” she said. “Why, even now, when we are on this short holiday?” “I don’t know. Love-making stifles me in the daytime.” “But it needn’t be always love-making,” she said. “It always is,” he answered, “when you and I are together.” She sat feeling very bitter. “Do you ever want to marry me?” he asked curiously. “Do you me?” she replied. “Yes, yes; I should like us to have children,” he answered slowly. She sat with her head bent, fingering the sand. “But you don’t really want a divorce from Baxter, do you?” he said. It was some minutes before she replied. “No,” she said, very deliberately; “I don’t think I do.” “Why?” “I don’t know.” “Do you feel as if you belonged to him?” “No; I don’t think so.” “What, then?” “I think he belongs to me,” she replied. He was silent for some minutes, listening to the wind blowing over the hoarse, dark sea. “And you never really intended to belong to me?” he said. “Yes, I do belong to you,” she answered. “No,” he said; “because you don’t want to be divorced.”
It was a knot they could not untie, so they left it, took what they could get, and what they could not attain they ignored. “I consider you treated Baxter rottenly,” he said another time. He half-expected Clara to answer him, as his mother would: “You consider your own affairs, and don’t know so much about other people’s.” But she took him seriously, almost to his own surprise. “Why?” she said. “I suppose you thought he was a lily of the valley, and so you put him in an appropriate pot, and tended him according. You made up your mind he was a lily of the valley and it was no good his being a cow-parsnip. You wouldn’t have it.” “I certainly never imagined him a lily of the valley.” “You imagined him something he wasn’t. That’s just what a woman is. She thinks she knows what’s good for a man, and she’s going to see he gets it; and no matter if he’s starving, he may sit and whistle for what he needs, while she’s got him, and is giving him what’s good for him.” “And what are you doing?” she asked. “I’m thinking what tune I shall whistle,” he laughed. And instead of boxing his ears, she considered him in earnest. “You think I want to give you what’s good for you?” she asked.
“I hope so; but love should give a sense of freedom, not of prison. Miriam made me feel tied up like a donkey to a stake. I must feed on her patch, and nowhere else. It’s sickening!” “And would you let a woman do as she likes?” “Yes; I’ll see that she likes to love me. If she doesn’t—well, I don’t hold her.” “If you were as wonderful as you say—,” replied Clara. “I should be the marvel I am,” he laughed. There was a silence in which they hated each other, though they laughed. “Love’s a dog in a manger,” he said. “And which of us is the dog?” she asked. “Oh well, you, of course.”
Passages expressing a similar idea
The Voyage Out · Virginia Woolf (1882–1941) · CHAPTER XVIII
Supposing he went to her and said (he slackened his pace and began to speak aloud, as if he were speaking to Rachel): “I worship you, but I loathe marriage, I hate its smugness, its safety, its compromise, and the thought of you interfering in my work, hindering me; what would you answer?” He stopped, leant against the trunk of a tree, and gazed without seeing them at some stones scattered on the bank of the dry river-bed. He saw Rachel’s face distinctly, the grey eyes, the hair, the mouth; the face that could look so many things—plain, vacant, almost insignificant, or wild, passionate, almost beautiful, yet in his eyes was always the same because of the extraordinary freedom with which she looked at him, and spoke as she felt. What would she answer? What did she feel? Did she love him, or did she feel nothing at all for him or for any other man, being, as she had said that afternoon, free, like the wind or the sea? “Oh, you’re free!” he exclaimed, in exultation at the thought of her, “and I’d keep you free. We’d be free together. We’d share everything together. No happiness would be like ours. No lives would compare with ours.” He opened his arms wide as if to hold her and the world in one embrace. No longer able to consider marriage, or to weigh coolly what her nature was, or how it would be if they lived together, he dropped to the ground and sat absorbed in the thought of her, and soon tormented by the desire to be in her presence again.
Read in contextJude the Obscure · Thomas Hardy (1840–1928) · VI
“Does it really seem so to you?” said she, smiling with quick curiosity. “Well, that’s strange; but I feel just the same about you, Jude. When you are gone away I seem such a coldhearted—” As she knew his sentiment towards her Jude saw that they were getting upon dangerous ground. It was now, he thought, that he must speak as an honest man. But he did not speak, and she continued: “It was that which made me write and say—I didn’t mind your loving me—if you wanted to, much!” The exultation he might have felt at what that implied, or seemed to imply, was nullified by his intention, and he rested rigid till he began: “I have never told you—” “Yes you have,” murmured she. “I mean, I have never told you my history—all of it.” “But I guess it. I know nearly.” Jude looked up. Could she possibly know of that morning performance of his with Arabella; which in a few months had ceased to be a marriage more completely than by death? He saw that she did not. “I can’t quite tell you here in the street,” he went on with a gloomy tongue. “And you had better not come to my lodgings. Let us go in here.”
Read in contextAdam Bede · George Eliot (1819–1880) · Chapter III After the Preaching
I believe what you say, Seth, that you would try to be a help and not a hindrance to my work; but I see that our marriage is not God’s will—He draws my heart another way. I desire to live and die without husband or children. I seem to have no room in my soul for wants and fears of my own, it has pleased God to fill my heart so full with the wants and sufferings of his poor people.” Seth was unable to reply, and they walked on in silence. At last, as they were nearly at the yard-gate, he said, “Well, Dinah, I must seek for strength to bear it, and to endure as seeing Him who is invisible. But I feel now how weak my faith is. It seems as if, when you are gone, I could never joy in anything any more. I think it’s something passing the love of women as I feel for you, for I could be content without your marrying me if I could go and live at Snowfield and be near you. I trusted as the strong love God has given me towards you was a leading for us both; but it seems it was only meant for my trial. Perhaps I feel more for you than I ought to feel for any creature, for I often can’t help saying of you what the hymn says— In darkest shades if she appear, My dawning is begun; She is my soul’s bright morning-star, And she my rising sun.
Read in contextNight and Day · Virginia Woolf (1882–1941) · CHAPTER V
“I’m sure one can smell the sea, with the wind blowing this way,” she said. They stood silent for a few moments while the river shifted in its bed, and the silver and red lights which were laid upon it were torn by the current and joined together again. Very far off up the river a steamer hooted with its hollow voice of unspeakable melancholy, as if from the heart of lonely mist-shrouded voyagings. “Ah!” Rodney cried, striking his hand once more upon the balustrade, “why can’t one say how beautiful it all is? Why am I condemned for ever, Katharine, to feel what I can’t express? And the things I can give there’s no use in my giving. Trust me, Katharine,” he added hastily, “I won’t speak of it again. But in the presence of beauty—look at the iridescence round the moon!—one feels—one feels—Perhaps if you married me—I’m half a poet, you see, and I can’t pretend not to feel what I do feel. If I could write—ah, that would be another matter. I shouldn’t bother you to marry me then, Katharine.” He spoke these disconnected sentences rather abruptly, with his eyes alternately upon the moon and upon the stream. “But for me I suppose you would recommend marriage?” said Katharine, with her eyes fixed on the moon.
Read in contextAnna Karenina · Leo Tolstoy (1828–1910) · Chapter 22
“I’m with child,” she said, softly and deliberately. The leaf in her hand shook more violently, but she did not take her eyes off him, watching how he would take it. He turned white, would have said something, but stopped; he dropped her hand, and his head sank on his breast. “Yes, he realizes all the gravity of it,” she thought, and gratefully she pressed his hand. But she was mistaken in thinking he realized the gravity of the fact as she, a woman, realized it. On hearing it, he felt come upon him with tenfold intensity that strange feeling of loathing of someone. But at the same time, he felt that the turning-point he had been longing for had come now; that it was impossible to go on concealing things from her husband, and it was inevitable in one way or another that they should soon put an end to their unnatural position. But, besides that, her emotion physically affected him in the same way. He looked at her with a look of submissive tenderness, kissed her hand, got up, and, in silence, paced up and down the terrace. “Yes,” he said, going up to her resolutely. “Neither you nor I have looked on our relations as a passing amusement, and now our fate is sealed. It is absolutely necessary to put an end”—he looked round as he spoke—“to the deception in which we are living.” “Put an end? How put an end, Alexey?” she said softly.
Read in contextNight and Day · Virginia Woolf (1882–1941) · CHAPTER XVIII
“I love you; I shall never love anybody else. Marry me or leave me; think what you like of me—I don’t care a straw.” At the moment, however, speech or silence seemed immaterial, and she merely clapped her hands together, and looked at the distant woods with the rust-like bloom on their brown, and the green and blue landscape through the steam of her own breath. It seemed a mere toss-up whether she said, “I love you,” or whether she said, “I love the beech-trees,” or only “I love—I love.” “Do you know, Mary,” Ralph suddenly interrupted her, “I’ve made up my mind.” Her indifference must have been superficial, for it disappeared at once. Indeed, she lost sight of the trees, and saw her own hand upon the topmost bar of the gate with extreme distinctness, while he went on: “I’ve made up my mind to chuck my work and live down here. I want you to tell me about that cottage you spoke of. However, I suppose there’ll be no difficulty about getting a cottage, will there?” He spoke with an assumption of carelessness as if expecting her to dissuade him. She still waited, as if for him to continue; she was convinced that in some roundabout way he approached the subject of their marriage. “I can’t stand the office any longer,” he proceeded. “I don’t know what my family will say; but I’m sure I’m right. Don’t you think so?” “Live down here by yourself?” she asked.
Read in context