Skip to content
BookLens

Sons and Lovers

D. H. (David Herbert) Lawrence (1885–1930)

“Shall we go through the wood a little way?” she asked him, knowing he never refused a direct request. They went down to the warren. On the middle path they passed a trap, a narrow horseshoe hedge of small fir-boughs, baited with the guts of a rabbit. Paul glanced at it frowning. She caught his eye. “Isn’t it dreadful?” she asked. “I don’t know! Is it worse than a weasel with its teeth in a rabbit’s throat? One weasel or many rabbits? One or the other must go!” He was taking the bitterness of life badly. She was rather sorry for him. “We will go back to the house,” he said. “I don’t want to walk out.” They went past the lilac-tree, whose bronze leaf-buds were coming unfastened. Just a fragment remained of the haystack, a monument squared and brown, like a pillar of stone. There was a little bed of hay from the last cutting. “Let us sit here a minute,” said Miriam. He sat down against his will, resting his back against the hard wall of hay. They faced the amphitheatre of round hills that glowed with sunset, tiny white farms standing out, the meadows golden, the woods dark and yet luminous, tree-tops folded over tree-tops, distinct in the distance. The evening had cleared, and the east was tender with a magenta flush under which the land lay still and rich. “Isn’t it beautiful?” she pleaded. But he only scowled. He would rather have had it ugly just then.

At that moment a big bull-terrier came rushing up, open-mouthed, pranced his two paws on the youth’s shoulders, licking his face. Paul drew back, laughing. Bill was a great relief to him. He pushed the dog aside, but it came leaping back. “Get out,” said the lad, “or I’ll dot thee one.” But the dog was not to be pushed away. So Paul had a little battle with the creature, pitching poor Bill away from him, who, however, only floundered tumultuously back again, wild with joy. The two fought together, the man laughing grudgingly, the dog grinning all over. Miriam watched them. There was something pathetic about the man. He wanted so badly to love, to be tender. The rough way he bowled the dog over was really loving. Bill got up, panting with happiness, his brown eyes rolling in his white face, and lumbered back again. He adored Paul. The lad frowned. “Bill, I’ve had enough o’ thee,” he said. But the dog only stood with two heavy paws, that quivered with love, upon his thigh, and flickered a red tongue at him. He drew back. “No,” he said—“no—I’ve had enough.” And in a minute the dog trotted off happily, to vary the fun. He remained staring miserably across at the hills, whose still beauty he begrudged. He wanted to go and cycle with Edgar. Yet he had not the courage to leave Miriam. “Why are you sad?” she asked humbly. “I’m not sad; why should I be,” he answered. “I’m only normal.”

She wondered why he always claimed to be normal when he was disagreeable. “But what is the matter?” she pleaded, coaxing him soothingly. “Nothing!” “Nay!” she murmured. He picked up a stick and began to stab the earth with it. “You’d far better not talk,” he said. “But I wish to know—” she replied. He laughed resentfully. “You always do,” he said. “It’s not fair to me,” she murmured. He thrust, thrust, thrust at the ground with the pointed stick, digging up little clods of earth as if he were in a fever of irritation. She gently and firmly laid her band on his wrist. “Don’t!” she said. “Put it away.” He flung the stick into the currant-bushes, and leaned back. Now he was bottled up. “What is it?” she pleaded softly. He lay perfectly still, only his eyes alive, and they full of torment. “You know,” he said at length, rather wearily—“you know—we’d better break off.” It was what she dreaded. Swiftly everything seemed to darken before her eyes. “Why!” she murmured. “What has happened?” “Nothing has happened. We only realise where we are. It’s no good—” She waited in silence, sadly, patiently. It was no good being impatient with him. At any rate, he would tell her now what ailed him. “We agreed on friendship,” he went on in a dull, monotonous voice. “How often have we agreed for friendship! And yet—it neither stops there, nor gets anywhere else.”

He was silent again. She brooded. What did he mean? He was so wearying. There was something he would not yield. Yet she must be patient with him. “I can only give friendship—it’s all I’m capable of—it’s a flaw in my make-up. The thing overbalances to one side—I hate a toppling balance. Let us have done.” There was warmth of fury in his last phrases. He meant she loved him more than he her. Perhaps he could not love her. Perhaps she had not in herself that which he wanted. It was the deepest motive of her soul, this self-mistrust. It was so deep she dared neither realise nor acknowledge. Perhaps she was deficient. Like an infinitely subtle shame, it kept her always back. If it were so, she would do without him. She would never let herself want him. She would merely see. “But what has happened?” she said. “Nothing—it’s all in myself—it only comes out just now. We’re always like this towards Easter-time.” He grovelled so helplessly, she pitied him. At least she never floundered in such a pitiable way. After all, it was he who was chiefly humiliated. “What do you want?” she asked him. “Why—I mustn’t come often—that’s all. Why should I monopolise you when I’m not—You see, I’m deficient in something with regard to you—”

He was telling her he did not love her, and so ought to leave her a chance with another man. How foolish and blind and shamefully clumsy he was! What were other men to her! What were men to her at all! But he, ah! she loved his soul. Was he deficient in something? Perhaps he was. “But I don’t understand,” she said huskily. “Yesterday—” The night was turning jangled and hateful to him as the twilight faded. And she bowed under her suffering. “I know,” he cried, “you never will! You’ll never believe that I can’t—can’t physically, any more than I can fly up like a skylark—” “What?” she murmured. Now she dreaded. “Love you.” He hated her bitterly at that moment because he made her suffer. Love her! She knew he loved her. He really belonged to her. This about not loving her, physically, bodily, was a mere perversity on his part, because he knew she loved him. He was stupid like a child. He belonged to her. His soul wanted her. She guessed somebody had been influencing him. She felt upon him the hardness, the foreignness of another influence. “What have they been saying at home?” she asked. “It’s not that,” he answered. And then she knew it was. She despised them for their commonness, his people. They did not know what things were really worth. He and she talked very little more that night. After all he left her to cycle with Edgar.

Passages expressing a similar idea

  • Night and Day · Virginia Woolf (1882–1941) · CHAPTER XXVI

    “It’s not a question of friendship,” Mary exclaimed, her anger rising, to her own surprise. “You know it’s not. How can it be? I’ve no right to interfere—” She stopped. “Only I’d rather Ralph wasn’t hurt,” she concluded. “I think he seems able to take care of himself,” Katharine observed. Without either of them wishing it, a feeling of hostility had risen between them. “Do you really think it’s worth it?” said Mary, after a pause. “How can one tell?” Katharine asked. “Have you ever cared for any one?” Mary demanded rashly and foolishly. “I can’t wander about London discussing my feelings—Here’s a cab—no, there’s some one in it.” “We don’t want to quarrel,” said Mary. “Ought I to have told him that I wouldn’t be his friend?” Katharine asked. “Shall I tell him that? If so, what reason shall I give him?” “Of course you can’t tell him that,” said Mary, controlling herself. “I believe I shall, though,” said Katharine suddenly. “I lost my temper, Katharine; I shouldn’t have said what I did.” “The whole thing’s foolish,” said Katharine, peremptorily. “That’s what I say. It’s not worth it.” She spoke with unnecessary vehemence, but it was not directed against Mary Datchet. Their animosity had completely disappeared, and upon both of them a cloud of difficulty and darkness rested, obscuring the future, in which they had both to find a way.

    Read in context
  • Victory: An Island Tale · Joseph Conrad (1857–1924) · CHAPTER EIGHT

    Heyst looked into the dim aisles of the forest. Everything was so still now that the very ground on which they stood seemed to exhale silence into the shade. “Why be indignant?” he remonstrated. “It has not happened. I gave up pleading with Wang. Here we are, repulsed! Not only without power to resist the evil, but unable to make terms for ourselves with the worthy envoys, the envoys extraordinary of the world we thought we had done with for years and years. And that's bad, Lena, very bad.” “It's funny,” she said thoughtfully. “Bad? I suppose it is. I don't know that it is. But do you? Do you? You talk as if you didn't believe in it.” She gazed at him earnestly. “Do I? Ah! That's it. I don't know how to talk. I have managed to refine everything away. I've said to the Earth that bore me: 'I am I and you are a shadow.' And, by Jove, it is so! But it appears that such words cannot be uttered with impunity. Here I am on a Shadow inhabited by Shades. How helpless a man is against the Shades! How is one to intimidate, persuade, resist, assert oneself against them? I have lost all belief in realities . . . Lena, give me your hand.” She looked at him surprised, uncomprehending. “Your hand,” he cried. She obeyed; he seized it with avidity as if eager to raise it to his lips, but halfway up released his grasp. They looked at each other for a time.

    Read in context
  • Wuthering Heights · Emily Brontë (1818–1848) · CHAPTER XXIII

    “I can’t speak to you,” he murmured; “you’ve hurt me so that I shall lie awake all night choking with this cough. If you had it you’d know what it was; but you’ll be comfortably asleep while I’m in agony, and nobody near me. I wonder how you would like to pass those fearful nights!” And he began to wail aloud, for very pity of himself. “Since you are in the habit of passing dreadful nights,” I said, “it won’t be Miss who spoils your ease: you’d be the same had she never come. However, she shall not disturb you again; and perhaps you’ll get quieter when we leave you.” “Must I go?” asked Catherine dolefully, bending over him. “Do you want me to go, Linton?” “You can’t alter what you’ve done,” he replied pettishly, shrinking from her, “unless you alter it for the worse by teasing me into a fever.” “Well, then, I must go?” she repeated. “Let me alone, at least,” said he; “I can’t bear your talking.”

    Read in context
  • Victory: An Island Tale · Joseph Conrad (1857–1924) · CHAPTER EIGHT

    “What's the matter, dear?” she whispered timidly. “Neither force nor conviction,” Heyst muttered wearily to himself. “How am I to meet this charmingly simple problem?” “I am sorry,” she murmured. “And so am I,” he confessed quickly. “And the bitterest of this humiliation is its complete uselessness—which I feel, I feel!” She had never before seen him give such signs of feeling. Across his ghastly face the long moustaches flamed in the shade. He spoke suddenly: “I wonder if I could find enough courage to creep among them in the night, with a knife, and cut their throats one after another, as they slept! I wonder—” She was frightened by his unwonted appearance more than by the words in his mouth, and said earnestly: “Don't you try to do such a thing! Don't you think of it!” “I don't possess anything bigger than a penknife. As to thinking of it, Lena, there's no saying what one may think of. I don't think. Something in me thinks—something foreign to my nature. What is the matter?” He noticed her parted lips, and the peculiar stare in her eyes, which had wandered from his face. “There's somebody after us. I saw something white moving,” she cried. Heyst did not turn his head; he only glanced at her out-stretched arm. “No doubt we are followed; we are watched.” “I don't see anything now,” she said.

    Read in context
  • Villette · Charlotte Brontë (1816–1855) · CHAPTER III. THE PLAYMATES.

    Graham forgot his impatience the same evening, and would have accosted her as usual when his friends were gone, but she wrenched herself from his hand; her eye quite flashed; she would not bid him good-night; she would not look in his face. The next day he treated her with indifference, and she grew like a bit of marble. The day after, he teased her to know what was the matter; her lips would not unclose. Of course he could not feel real anger on his side: the match was too unequal in every way; he tried soothing and coaxing. “Why was she so angry? What had he done?” By-and-by tears answered him; he petted her, and they were friends. But she was one on whom such incidents were not lost: I remarked that never after this rebuff did she seek him, or follow him, or in any way solicit his notice. I told her once to carry a book or some other article to Graham when he was shut up in his study. “I shall wait till he comes out,” said she, proudly; “I don’t choose to give him the trouble of rising to open the door.”

    Read in context
  • Hard Times · Charles Dickens (1812–1870) · BOOK THE THIRD GARNERING / CHAPTER I ANOTHER THING NEEDFUL

    She made him no reply. ‘I am not too proud to believe it, Louisa. How could I be arrogant, and you before me! Can it be so? Is it so, my dear?’ He looked upon her once more, lying cast away there; and without another word went out of the room. He had not been long gone, when she heard a light tread near the door, and knew that some one stood beside her. She did not raise her head. A dull anger that she should be seen in her distress, and that the involuntary look she had so resented should come to this fulfilment, smouldered within her like an unwholesome fire. All closely imprisoned forces rend and destroy. The air that would be healthful to the earth, the water that would enrich it, the heat that would ripen it, tear it when caged up. So in her bosom even now; the strongest qualities she possessed, long turned upon themselves, became a heap of obduracy, that rose against a friend. It was well that soft touch came upon her neck, and that she understood herself to be supposed to have fallen asleep. The sympathetic hand did not claim her resentment. Let it lie there, let it lie.

    Read in context